Abundances of the group IVB elements, Ti, Zr, and Hf and implications of their ratios in lunar materials
New data on Zr and Hf abundances in samples from recent Apollo missions and a few from earlier missions are presented. The data confirm our previous suggestion of a modest Zr-Hf fractionation among lunar rock types. The four major lunar rock types can be readily distinguished, based on Zr and Hf abundances and Zr/Hf mass ratios. Mare basalts exhibit mean Zr abundances ranging from 111 ppm for Apollo 15 to 534 ppm for Apollo 11 and low Zr/Hf mass ratios ranging from 34 to 39. KREEP basalts are characterized by very high Zr contents (mean = 1380 ppm Zr) and high Zr/Hf ratio of 47. Anorthosites exhibit extremely low Zr and Hf contents and possibly very low Zr/Hf ratios. Arguments that the fractionation may be partly due to the presence of Zr(3+) in lunar magmas while Hf remains as Hf(4+) are presented. These data for Zr and Hf together with data for Ti recently obtained on the same samples in our laboratory are discussed in support of a modified two-stage lunar crustal evolution model.