Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “edge instability”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 235 records · Page 13
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

First simultaneous observation of co- and counter-current fast-ion losses in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak

In ITER and future fusion power plants, the source of the fusion born alpha particles is almost isotropic in pitch angle, thus having co- and counter-current populations. For trapped ions, the co-current side of the orbit corresponds to its outer leg, while the counter-current side corresponds to the inner leg. Understanding the mechanisms responsible for the fast-ion losses (FILs) is critical for future magnetically confined fusion power plants. To further study the interplay of fast ions with plasma instabilities, a double pinhole collimator has been developed for a Fast-Ion Loss Detector (FILD) in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak (AUG). This new FILD opens the operational window to simultaneous measurements of the co- and counter-current ion velocity-space. In this paper, the first results for the AUG double collimator FILD detector are shown. The commissioning of this new probe is carried out in H-mode plasmas with an on-axis magnetic field $B_0 = -2.5$ T, and a plasma current $I_{\textrm{p}} = 0.7$ MA. Simultaneous co- and counter-current FILs have been measured. Both have shown a similar dependence on Ion Cyclotron Resonance Heating (ICRH) power, where the main difference is the intensity of the losses, with the co-losses being an order of magnitude larger. Toroidal Alfvén eigenmode-coherent ICRH-only losses have been identified for the co-current ions. Additionally, the presence of Edge Localized Modes during the discharge were shown to increment Neutral Beam Injection prompt losses, while partially mitigating ICRH-driven losses on both co- and counter- sides of the velocity-space. Finally, a very trapped and high gyroradius losses, with an unclear origin, have been measured in the co- and counter-current velocity-space. The computed ion trajectories show that these ions remain permanently near the vessel wall, suggesting that they are accelerated within the scrape-off layer.

ELM↗
DOE OSTI2022

Homologous Alkali Metal Copper Rare-Earth Chalcogenides A 2 Cu 2 n Ln 4 Q 7+ n ( n = 1, 2, 3)

Twenty-seven new members of the A 2 Cu 2n Ln 4 Q 7+n (A = Cs, Rb; Ln = La-Nd, Sm, Gd-Yb; Q = S, Se) homologous series were synthesized in one of three structural types (indicated by n = 1, 2, 3). All the compounds contained 3D frameworks with alkali-metal-containing tunnels. For each increment in n, one Cu 2 Q was added, which was incorporated into the framework as an edge-sharing tetrahedron by replacing a square planar chalcogenide site. High-throughput DFT calculations predicted many of the phases to be thermodynamically stable. These predictions were compared with the synthesis results for the phases formed in each composition space. In the syntheses, heavier lanthanides showed a preference to start forming the n = 3 ACu 3 Ln 2 Q 5 , which is consistent with the predictions. RbCuNd 2 Se 4 and RbCuTb 2 Se 4 were found to be thermally stable under vacuum at temperatures up to 1000 °C. Optical measurements revealed band gaps of 1.55(5) and 1.62(5) eV for CsCuCe 2 Se 4 and RbCuTb 2 Se 4 , respectively, and a work function of 4.83(5) eV for CsCuPr 2 Se 4 . Additionally, some n = 3 ACu 3 Ln 2 Qs compounds exhibit a negative phonon mode because of a copper atom coordination, which may distort to a trigonal planar geometry at sufficiently low temperatures. The dynamic instabilities and the predicted distortion in the copper tetrahedra for the n = 3 ACu 3 Ln 2 Q 5 compounds were found to have a linear relationship with the atomic number of the lanthanides and the electronegativity of the lanthanides. In conclusion, the A 2 Cu 2 n Ln 4 Q 7+n compounds can potentially find application as high-temperature thermoelectric materials and other semiconductors.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Local step-flow dynamics in thin film growth with desorption

Desorption of deposited species plays a role in determining the evolution of surface morphology during crystal growth when the desorption time constant is short compared with the time to diffuse to a defect site, step edge, or kink. However, experiments to directly test the predictions of these effects are lacking. Novel techniques such as in situ coherent x-ray scattering can provide significant new information. Herein we present x-ray photon correlation spectroscopy (XPCS) measurements during diindenoperylene (DIP) vapor deposition on thermally oxidized silicon surfaces. DIP forms a nearly complete two-dimensional first layer over the range of temperatures studied (40–120 ⁢°C), followed by mounded growth during subsequent deposition. Local step flow within mounds was observed, and we find that there was a terrace-length-dependent behavior of the step edge dynamics. This led to unstable growth with rapid roughening (β>0.5) and deviation from a symmetric error-function-like height profile. At high temperatures, the grooves between the mounds tend to close up leading to nearly flat polycrystalline films. In conclusion, numerical analysis based on a (1+1)-dimensional model suggests that terrace-length dependent desorption of deposited ad-molecules is an essential cause of the step dynamics, and it influences the morphology evolution.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

X-point effects on the ideal MHD modes in tokamaks in the description of dual-poloidal-region safety factor

The flux coordinates with dual-region safety factor (q) in the poloidal direction are developed in this work. The X-point effects on the ideal MHD modes in tokamaks are then analyzed using this coordinate system. Since the X-point effects mainly affect the edge region, the modes localized at the tokamak edge are particularly examined. Two types of modes are studied. The first is related to the conventional peeling or peeling-ballooning modes. The mode existence aligned with the local magnetic field in the poloidally core region as observed experimentally is confirmed. The X points are shown to contribute to a stabilizing effect for the conventionally treated modes with the surface-averaged q and with the tokamak edge portion truncated. The other is the axisymmetric modes localized in the vicinity of X points, which can affect the cross-field-line transport near the X points. The existence of axisymmetric modes points to the possibility of applying a toroidally axisymmetric resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) in the X-point area for mitigating the edge localized modes, which can be an alternative to the current RMP design. The dual q description also has important implications for the existing non-axisymmetric RMP concept. It helps to understand why the RMP suppression of edge localized modes is difficult to achieve in the double-null tokamak configurations and points to the possibility of further improving the current RMP concept by considering the alignment to the local q.

Fourier analysis↗
DOE OSTI2025

Nanoscale Strain and Octahedral Tilting Removes Structural and Nonradiative Defects in 2D-Templated FAPbI 3

The halide perovskite formamidinium lead iodide (FAPbI 3 ) is a prime candidate for photovoltaics due to its excellent optoelectronic properties, but its application has been limited due to its structural instability. The large size of the FA cation results in metastability of the photoactive cubic phase and a facile degradation into thermodynamically stable hexagonal phases at room temperature. Recently, the incorporation of two-dimensional (2D) Ruddlesden-Popper halide perovskite seeds into a FAPbI 3 precursor solution was shown to template the growth of and stabilize cubic FAPbI 3 . Here, in this study, we investigate the nanoscale structural and optoelectronic mechanisms behind the observed bulk stabilization using synchrotron-based X-ray microscopies. Nanoprobe X-ray diffraction reveals 2D-templated FAPbI 3 films exhibit an average compressive strain normal to the substrate of -3.3%, 2-fold larger than that of MACl-stabilized FAPbI 3 . This compression creates locally templated regions composed of tetragonal-phase FAPbI 3 distributed nonuniformly throughout the film with fewer crystalline defects than purely cubic regions. Scanning X-ray excited optical luminescence (X-ray analog of photoluminescence) reveals that this local templating results in increased radiative recombination and red-shifted band edge and emission. Our results provide insight into the microscopic mechanism for the phase stabilization of FAPbI 3 using 2D perovskites as templates.

X-ray diffraction↗
DOE OSTI2025

Propagation of ion cyclotron emission in the DIII-D tokamak

Experiments in L- and H-mode plasmas performed on the DIII-D tokamak explored ion cyclotron emission (ICE) propagation via the recently upgraded ICE diagnostic. The distance between the plasma and the outer wall was scanned to alter the evanescent region, which was seen to impact the detection of runaway electron-driven whistler modes in a comparable frequency range to typical ICE harmonics (f≳10fci) [Heidbrink et al., Plasma Phys. Controlled Fusion 61, 014007 (2018)]. In L-mode plasmas, core ICE did not exhibit clear trends as the plasma-wall distance was altered. Instead, inadvertent changes to the fast ion density correlated with different ICE fine structures; the most spectral bands (spaced ∼150–200 kHz apart) were observed at the highest fast ion density, and a just single band when nfast decreased by ∼ 40%. The full-wave Petra-M code simulated core ICE propagation through the plasma and to ICE probes, agreeing with experimental findings that these are likely compressional fast waves, which propagate to probe locations with no dependence on plasma-wall gap. Edge ICE in H-mode plasmas was similarly unaffected by plasma-wall distance. Unlike in core ICE cases, there were negligible changes to the edge fast ion distribution and edge bulk plasma profiles. However, changes in ELM frequency seemed most closely tied to ICE behavior. Ultimately, core and edge ICE did not exhibit clear dependencies on the plasma-wall distance, and ICE harmonics were observed with even the largest plasma-wall gaps. This independence bodes well for similar diagnostics in future tokamaks, which might be placed further from high radiation areas without adversely impacting measurement capabilities.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2021

Resistive wall mode stability and resonant field amplification in MAST high beta plasma

The n=1 (n is the toroidal mode number) resistive wall mode (RWM) instability and the resonant field amplification (RFA) due to a stable RWM response are numerically investigated for a MAST high-pressure plasma scenario, utilizing the MARS-F (Liu Y.Q. et al 2000 Phys. Plasmas 7 3681) and MARS-K (Liu Y.Q. et al 2008 Phys. Plasmas 15 112503) codes, for the purpose of understanding the potential RWM behavior in MAST-U plasmas. Ideal kink stability analysis identifies a target plasma, with parameters similar to that of the reference equilibrium reconstructed from a MAST high-pressure discharge, that accesses the RWM regime. The unstable n=1 RWM for the target equilibrium is subject to strong damping by the plasma toroidal flow and/or the drift kinetic effects from thermal particles. As a result, the mode is found to be stable under the experimental flow conditions, or even without flow stabilization if drift kinetic stabilization is included. The stability prediction is robust against variation of the assumed resistive wall minor radius. Active magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) spectroscopy modeling, using the magnetic coils designed for controlling the edge localized modes (ELMs) in MAST-U as the antenna, shows strong resonant field amplification due to a stable RWM response in the target plasma. Maximal amplification, of 6-7 times larger than the applied vacuum field within the plasma, is obtained assuming a coil phasing of 120-180 degrees between the upper and lower rows of the ELM control coils. The MHD-kinetic hybrid model predicts generally higher RFA than the fluid model, in particular near the low-field and high-field sides of the plasma boundary surface. Furthermore, the MARS-F/K modeling thus shows that the RWM in MAST-U is subject to strong flow and kinetic stabilization, but can nevertheless be detected by active MHD spectroscopy.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2024

Experimental investigation of PDI bifurcation of lower hybrid waves during electron density ramp-up in EAST

Abstract The effect of parametric decay instability (PDI) on the current drive efficiency of 4.6 GHz lower hybrid (LH) waves in EAST is investigated experimentally, showing the PDI channel bifurcation of LH waves for the first time in EAST. First, experiments with three platforms of LH power were performed, achieving the LH power required for the PDI occurrence. Second, PDI bifurcation experiments were further carried out by ramping up the plasma electron density. The loop voltage increases with an increase in density, implying a decrease in the current driven by the LH wave. PDI bifurcation during electron density ramp-up was studied by analyzing the parallel refractive index ( n ∥ ) and the frequency spectrum broadening, which is measured with a radio frequency magnetic probe array recently installed close to the LH antenna. It is observed for the first time that they both first increase with density, then there is not much variation and a clear sideband in the frequency spectrum is also observed when the density is up to 4 × 10 19 m − 3 , suggesting a change in the PDI channel. Calculation of the mode growth rate driven by PDI shows that when the edge electron density is up to 1.9 × 10 18 m − 3 , the growth rate of the ion cyclotron quasi-mode (ICQM) will exceed that of the ion sound quasi-mode (ISQM), quantitively explaining that with an increase in density, the PDI channel partly transits from the ISQM to the ICQM channel. Studies provide a possible way to reduce the power deposition in the edge region and improve drive capability by means of mitigating PDI behavior.

Physics↗
DOE OSTI2022

Simulation study of particle transport by weakly coherent mode in the Alcator C-Mod tokamak

A simulation study has been conducted of the physical mechanisms behind the weakly coherent mode (WCM) and its produced particle transport in the I-mode edge plasmas by using the BOUT++ code. The WCM is identified in our simulations by its poloidal and radial distributions as well as its frequency and wavenumber spectra. Its produced radial particle flux is calculated and compared with the experimental value. The good agreement indicates that the WCM is an important particle transport channel in the I-mode pedestal. It is found that the WCM can transport particles across the strong outer shear layer of the Er well established in the formation of I-mode, based on which a possible explanation is provided why I-mode does not feature a density pedestal. The key point lies in the change of the cross-phase between the electric potential and density fluctuations induced by the E × B Doppler shift. In the strong shear layer, although the electric potential fluctuation is significantly suppressed, the cross-phase is close to π/2, resulting in a strong drive of the density fluctuation and particle transport. To identify the physical nature of the WCM, a linear dispersion relation for drift Alfvén modes is derived in the slab geometry. A drift Alfvén wave instability is found to have similar dependence to the simulated linear instability behind the WCM on the resistivity and the parallel electron pressure gradient and thermal force terms in the parallel Ohm's law.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2021

Resolving ECRH deposition broadening due to edge turbulence in DIII-D

Microwave heat pulse propagation experiments have demonstrated a correlation between millimeter-scale turbulence and deposition profile broadening of electron cyclotron (EC) waves on the DIII-D tokamak. In a set of discharges in DIII-D, a variation in edge density fluctuations on the mm-scale is associated with 40%–150% broader deposition profiles, expressed in terms of normalized minor radius, as compared with equilibrium ray tracing. The 1D power profile is determined from transport analysis of the electron temperature response to EC power modulation using perturbative analysis with a square wave power modulation at 20–70 Hz, producing a series of Fourier harmonics that are fit collectively to resolve transport. Fitting an integrated heat flux expressed in the Fourier basis of the modulation to diffusive, convective, and coupled transport terms in a linear model can resolve the broadened EC deposition width from the power perturbation to resolve a broadening in each case. The best fit degree of beam broadening observed scales approximately linearly with the Doppler backscattering measured fluctuation level in the steep gradient region. Quantifying the effect of edge fluctuation broadening on EC current drive power needs of future devices will require 3D full-wave codes that can be validated on the current generation of machines. These DIII-D experiments provide a quantitative measure of fluctuation effects and a dataset to benchmark full-wave simulations that can model and eventually predict nonlinear effects neglected by 1D equilibrium beam and ray tracing.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2023

Drift kinetic effects on plasma response to resonant magnetic perturbation for EU DEMO design

Abstract A systematic investigation of the plasma response to an externally applied resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) field, for the purpose of controlling edge localized modes, is carried out for an EU DEMO reference plasma. Particular emphasis is placed on the role of kinetic effects associated with both thermal particles and fusion-born alphas. The single fluid, resistive model predicts a large peak amplification of the n = 1 ( n is the toroidal mode number) plasma response to the target equilibrium, which is found to be close to the Troyon no-wall limit. A more advanced response model, including kinetic resonances between the RMP perturbation and drift motions of thermal and energetic particles, on the other hand, finds a strong suppression of the n = 1 field amplification. A major role is played by the precessional drift resonance of fusion-born alphas. A strong parallel sound wave damping model is found to well reproduce the full kinetic response results for the DEMO plasma, in terms of both the resonant field response amplitude and the plasma displacement. Finally, both fluid and kinetic models produce similar responses for the n = 2 and 3 RMP fields for the considered DEMO plasma, whilst kinetic effects again become important for the n = 4 RMP due to proximity of the reference plasma to the no-wall limit for the n = 4 ideal kink instability.

Physics↗
DOE OSTI2026

Evidence of nonlinear coupling in the edge harmonic oscillation sustaining quiescent high confinement in a tokamak plasma

In a tokamak plasma, we measure nonlinear coupling between harmonics comprising a saturated edge oscillation, as predicted by nonlinear magnetohydrodynamic simulations. The coherent structure formed by this coupling suppresses bursty edge-localized modes that cause energy and particle loss. We also measure nonlinear coupling of the edge harmonic oscillation to core-resonant magnetic tearing modes. When tearing modes are present, the edge oscillation harmonics decouple, and edge-localized modes return. In this article, we conclude that nonlinear interaction with tearing modes interrupts the formation of the edge harmonic oscillation.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2024

Kinetic-ballooning-bifurcation in tokamak pedestals across shaping and aspect-ratio

We use a new gyrokinetic threshold model to predict a bifurcation in tokamak pedestal width-height scalings that depends strongly on plasma shaping and aspect-ratio. The bifurcation arises from the first and second stability properties of kinetic-ballooning-modes that yields wide and narrow pedestal branches, expanding the space of accessible pedestal widths and heights. The wide branch offers potential for edge-localized-mode-free pedestals with high core pressure. For negative triangularity, low-aspect-ratio configurations are predicted to give steeper pedestals than conventional-aspect-ratio. Both wide and narrow branches have been attained in tokamak experiments.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2026

Edge fluctuation measurements in EDA H-mode and QCE plasmas in ASDEX Upgrade using the correlation electron cyclotron emission diagnostic

The requirement of a plasma solution without large edge-localized modes (ELMs) for future fusion devices motivates the study of plasmas without Type I ELMs. The enhanced D–α (EDA) and quasi-continuous exhaust (QCE) scenarios are two such Type I ELM free plasmas, but their underlying physics principles are not fully understood. A database of EDA and QCE plasmas from ASDEX Upgrade was compiled and analyzed using the correlation electron cyclotron emission diagnostic in order to study differences between properties of the quasi-coherent mode (QCM) between these two regimes. Investigations into measured spectral properties of the QCM, radiated temperature fluctuations δT rad /T rad , and radial correlation lengths L c showed no differences between the two regimes. Spectral properties using the cross-power spectral density, G xy were similar between regimes, with the values measured to be a central frequency, $f$ $QCM$ ≈ 20 - 50 kHz; spectral width, Δ $f$ ≈ 5 - 40 kHz; δT rad /T rad ≈ 4-6%; and L c ≈ 1-2 cm. Investigations into a quantity representing the relative bandwidth Δ$f$/$f$ $QCM$ revealed differences between EDA and QCE plasmas when plotted radially, suggesting some type of interaction between the QCM in QCE plasmas with the surrounding broadband turbulence that is not present in EDA phases. Additionally, investigations into various drive terms for hypothesized instability drivers for the QCM are performed showing no difference in the parameter spaces of collisionality and the ion temperature, electron temperature, or electron pressure scale lengths between each regime indicating that there is no observable difference between the drive behind the QCM in each regime.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

Achieving a robust grassy-ELM operation regime in CFETR

We have identified a robust grassy-edge localized mode (ELM) operation regime for future tokamak reactors. The regime exists within a pedestal top electron collisionality (ν*) window at high global poloidal beta (β p ). The existence of an upper ν* limit for grassy-ELMs is consistent with results previously reported in experiments (Oyama et al 2010 Nucl. Fusion 50 064014), while the existence of a lower ν* limit has not been reported previously. Using EPED and BOUT++, a theoretical model that quantitatively explains the physics of the grassy-ELMs within the window, which distinguishes them from the small mixed-ELMs at lower ν*, is presented for the first time. A peeling-ballooning stability boundary is obtained by scanning the operating density space. The change in density corresponds to a change in ν* that affects the pedestal bootstrap current. High β p leads to a strong Shafranov shift, which affects the flux surface averaged pressure drive. The two effects combine to create a peeling-dominated window in intermediate ν* buffered by ballooning-dominated regimes. Only the peeling-dominated regime shows a cyclic behavior in the perturbed pressure during the nonlinear simulation of an ELM crash, reminiscent of grassy-ELM dynamics. Similarly, the energy released across the separatrix is demonstrated to be significantly smaller. The quick recovery of the ELM crash is explainable by the rapid rise of a low n kink-peeling instability when the pedestal current I ped exceeds a threshold at high β p . It minimizes the excursion beyond marginal stability and is absent in the ballooning-dominated regime. Comparison with recent experiments over a range of β p and ν* strongly supports the physical picture proposed by the modeling.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

Toroidal modeling of runaway electron loss due to 3-D fields in DIII-D and COMPASS

The 3-D field induced relativistic runaway electron (RE) loss has been simulated for DIII-D, COMPASS and ITER plasmas, utilizing the MARS-F code incorporated with the recently developed and updated RE orbit module (REORBIT). Modeling shows effectively 100% loss of a post-disruption, high-current runaway beam in DIII-D, due to the 1 kG level of magnetic field perturbation produced by a fast growing n = 1 resistive kink instability. The RE loss is shown to be independent of the particle energy or the initial location of particles in the configuration space. Applied resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) fields from in-vessel coils are not effective for RE beam mitigation in DIII-D, but do produce finite (>10%) RE loss in COMPASS, consistent with experimental observations in above two devices. The major reasons for this difference in RE control by RMP between these two devices are (i) the coil proximity to the RE beam and (ii) the effective coil current scaling versus the machine size and the toroidal magnetic field. About 10% RE loss fraction is also predicted for an ITER 15 MA scenario with pre-disruption plasma, highlighting the role of the plasma response. Up to 30% loss is computed, however, by artificially scaling the equilibrium pressure to zero. This is due to the more resistive plasma response and stronger resulting field line stochasticity. Distributions of the lost REs to the limiting surface show poloidally peaked profile near the high-field-side in both DIII-D and COMPASS, covering about 100o poloidal angle. Higher perturbation field level and/or higher particle energy also result in REs being lost to the low-field-side of the limiting surface of these two devices, increasing the effective wetted area. Finally, for the modeled ITER plasmas, the applied RMP field, with optimal poloidal spectrum that maximizes the edge localized mode control, leads to REs being lost to the lower divertor region of the limiting surface within a narrow poloidal band.

3-D field↗
DOE OSTI2020

Phonon spectrum of underdoped HgBa 2 CuO 4+δ investigated by neutron scattering

The cuprates exhibit a prominent charge-density-wave (CDW) instability with a wave vector along [100], i.e., the Cu-O bond direction. Whereas CDW order is most prominent at moderate doping and low temperature, there exists increasing evidence for dynamic charge correlations throughout a large portion of the temperature-doping phase diagram. In particular, the signatures of incipient charge order have been observed as phonon softening and/or broadening near the CDW wave vector approximately halfway through the Brillouin zone. Most of this work is focused on moderately doped cuprates, for which the CDW order is robust, or on optimally doped samples, for which the superconducting transition temperature (T c ) attains its maximum. Here we present a time-of-flight neutron scattering study of phonons in simple-tetragonal HgBa 2 CuO 4+δ (T c = 55 K) at a low doping level where prior work showed the CDW order to be weak. We employ and showcase a new software-based technique that mines a large number of measured Brillouin zones for useful data in order to improve accuracy and counting statistics. Density-functional theory has not provided an accurate description of phonons in HgBa2CuO4+δ, yet we find the right set of parameters to qualitatively reproduce the data. The notable exception is a dispersion minimum in the longitudinal Cu-O bond-stretching branch along [100]. Here, this discrepancy suggests that, while CDW order is weak, there exist significant dynamic charge correlations in the optic phonon range at low doping, near the edge of the superconducting dome.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2021

3D simulations of vertical displacement events in tokamaks: A benchmark of M3D-C 1 , NIMROD, and JOREK

In recent years, the nonlinear 3D magnetohydrodynamic codes JOREK, M3D-C1, and NIMROD developed the capability of modeling realistic 3D vertical displacement events (VDEs) including resistive walls. In this paper, a comprehensive 3D VDE benchmark is presented between these state-of-the-art codes. The simulated case is based on an experimental NSTX plasma but with a simplified rectangular wall. There are differences between the physics models and numerical methods, and the VDE evolution leads to sensitivities on the initial conditions that cannot be avoided as can be done in edge localized modes (ELM) and sawtooth simulations (due to the non-cyclical nature of VDEs). Nonetheless, the comparison serves to quantify the level of agreement in the relevant quantities used to characterize disruptions, such as the 3D wall forces and energy decay. The results bring confidence regarding the use of the mentioned codes for disruption studies, and they distinguish aspects that are specific to the models used (e.g., reduced vs full MHD models). Here, the simulations show important 3D fea- tures for a NSTX plasma, such as the self-consistent evolution of the halo current and the origin of the wall forces. In contrast to other reduced MHD models based on an ordering in the aspect ratio, the ansatz-based JOREK reduced MHD model allows capturing many aspects of the 3D dynamics even in the spherical tokamak limit considered here.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗