Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “FILM”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 253 records · Page 14

Dynamic asymmetric strain imprinted into substrates by an oxide thin film

In film-substrate systems, the substrate role is often considered to be limited to providing static mechanical constraints. Dynamic film-substrate interactions when a structural change in the film modifies the substrate are generally disregarded. Here, using combined x-ray and electron microscopies, we observed that an electrically induced filament in a vanadium dioxide film created strong asymmetric strain in an underlying sapphire substrate. This asymmetric substrate strain fed back into the film and defined the filament expansion direction, revealing the importance of film-substrate dynamic interactions in determining film functionality. Furthermore, the strain imprint propagated at least tens of micrometers deep into the substrate, exceeding the film thickness by more than 200-fold, potentially enabling substrate functionalization as an active mechanical coupling media in three-dimensional integrated microelectronic architectures.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Factors Controlling Electrochemistry-Induced Deposition of a Zeolitic Imidazolate Framework-8 Film on Underlying Substrates

This paper discusses factors controlling electrochemistry-induced deposition of a zeolitic imidazolate framework-8 (ZIF-8) film on a planar substrate that is placed under an electrode. This method, which was recently demonstrated by us [T. Ito, et al. Cryst. Growth Des., 23, 6369 (2023)], provides a simple means to form a ZIF-8 film having lateral dimensions replicating those of a working electrode on an underlying substrate. We reported the effects of applied cathodic potential, electrode–substrate distance, and deposition time on the film formation, and proposed a mechanism involving cathodic base generation at a working electrode that promoted ligand deprotonation to form intermediate species, followed by their diffusion toward an underlying substrate. Here, we discuss details on the deposition mechanism by investigating the influences of other factors on the film deposition. We have investigated the effects of precursor concentration on film formation, and clarified that O 2 is a probase, rather than H 2 O. We have also shown the influences of substrate surface properties controlled by self-assembled monolayers on film thickness and morphology. Most notably, we successfully demonstrated the formation of microscale ZIF-8 films using an ultramicroelectrode, revealing the applicability of the electrochemistry-induced method for micropatterned film deposition on an underlying substrate.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Confocal Raman Microscopy for Measuring In Situ Temperature-Dependent Structural Changes in Poly(Ethylene Oxide) Thin Films

Crystallization from the melt is a critical process governing the properties of semi-crystalline polymeric materials. While structural analyses of melting and crystallization transitions in bulk polymers have been widely reported, in contrast, those in thin polymer films on solid supports have been underexplored. Herein, in situ Raman microscopy and self-modeling curve resolution (SMCR) analysis are applied to investigate the temperature-dependent structural changes in poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) films during melting and crystallization phase transitions. By resolving complex overlapping sets of spectra, SMCR analysis reveals that the thermal transitions of 50 µm thick PEO films comprise two structural phases: an ordered crystalline phase and a disordered amorphous phase. The ordered structure of the crystalline PEO film entirely disappears as the polymer is heated; conversely, the disordered structure of the amorphous PEO film reverts to the ordered structure as the polymer is cooled. Broadening of the Raman bands was observed in PEO films above the melting temperature (67 °C), while sharpening of bands was observed below the crystallization temperature (45 °C). The temperatures at which these spectral changes occurred were in good agreement with differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) measurements, especially during the melting transition. The results illustrate that in situ Raman microscopy coupled with SMCR analysis is a powerful approach for unraveling complex structural changes in thin polymer films during melting and crystallization processes. Furthermore, we show that confocal Raman microscopy opens opportunities to apply the methodology to interrogate the structural features of PEO or other surface-supported polymer films as thin as 2 µm, a thickness regime beyond the reach of conventional thermal analysis techniques.

Koh, Miharu [Department of Chemistry, University o↗

MOCVD Growth and Characterization of Wide Bandgap ZnGeN 2 Thin Films

ZnGeN 2 is a wide bandgap material having less than 0.1% lattice mismatch with GaN and bandgap within few percent of that of GaN. Based on the first principle calculations, the valence band of ZnGeN 2 is situated ~1.4 eV above that of GaN at the heterointerface. Such a staggered band alignment between two closely lattice matched materials has already been demonstrated promising for novel optoelectronic device designs, for example, high efficiency blue and green light emitting diodes. However, the research on ZnGeN 2 is yet to pass the inceptive period. We report on the growth of single crystalline ZnGeN 2 films using metalorganic chemical vapor deposition and investigation on the crystalline, optical, electrical properties. Diethylzinc (DEZn), germane (GeH 4 ) and ammonia were used as the precursors for Zn, Ge and N, respectively. Films were grown on GaN and sapphire substrates. The Zn/Ge atomic ratio in the films determined from energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy was found to decrease with increase in growth temperature but to increase with increase in pressure and DEZn/GeH 4 molar flow rate ratio. The X-ray diffraction (XRD) 2θ-ω spectra of the single crystalline ZnGeN 2 films resembled those of orthorhombic (perfectly ordered cations) or distorted wurtzite (disordered cations) polymorphs. High resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy imaging was used to further investigate the crystalline quality and crystalline structure of the films. The single crystalline films on c-sapphire or GaN substrates were found to have planar surface from scanning electron micrographs while those on r-sapphire substrate had stepped surface. No near band edge peak but a broad peak at ~2.05 eV was observed in the photoluminescence (PL) spectra, which was attributed to the transitions involving deep level defects. The PL excitation spectra peaked around 3.4 eV, which is due to the enhanced absorption of photons having energy close to the band gap. The as grown films were found to be n-type with 10 18 – 10 19 cm -3 carrier densities and mobility up to 17 cm 2 /V·s. In the end, the advancement made in this work regarding the growth of ZnGeN 2 thin films is a footstep towards the understanding of the material itself and in turn, towards the implementation of ZnGeN 2 based novel device designs.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Investigation of the impact of supplemental reflective films to improve micro-light climate within tomato plant canopy in solar greenhouses

The non-uniform growth and development of crops within Chinese Solar Greenhouses (CSG) is directly related to the micro-light climate within canopy. In practice, reflective films are used to improve micro-light climate within plant canopy by homogenizing light distribution and so increasing total plant light interception. However, as to our knowledge, the contributions to light distribution within canopy have not been investigated for passive reflector like reflective films. Field experiments dealing with light conditions and growth behavior over time, are complicated to carry out, time-consuming and hard to control, while however, accurate measurements of how reflective films influence the micro-light climate of canopy are an essential step to improve the growth conditions for any crop. Here, we propose a supplementary light strategy using reflective films to improve light distribution within plant canopy. Based on the example of CSG, a 3D greenhouse model including a detailed 3D tomato canopy structure was constructed to simulate the influence of supplementary reflective films to improve micro-light climate. Comparison of measured solar radiation intensity with predicted model data demonstrated that the model could precisely predict light radiation intensity over time with different time points and positions in the greenhouse. A series of reflective film configurations were investigated based on features analysis of light distribution in the tomato canopy on sunny days using the proposed model. The reflective film configuration scheme with the highest impact significantly improved the evenness of horizontal and vertical light distribution in tomato canopy. The strategy provided here can be used to configure reflective films that will enhance light conditions in CSG, which can be applied and extended in different scenarios.

Liu, Anhua↗

Triple Layer Tungsten Trioxide, Graphene, and Polyaniline Composite Films for Combined Energy Storage and Electrochromic Applications

Different polyaniline (PANI)-based hybrid films were successfully prepared by electro-polymerizing aniline monomers onto pre-spin-coated indium tin oxide (ITO) glass slides with WO 3 , graphene, or WO 3 /graphene films. Comparing with pristine PANI, the shifts of the characteristic peaks of PANI-based nanocomposites in UV-visible absorption spectra (UV-vis) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR) indicate the chemical interaction between the PANI matrix and the nanofillers, which is also confirmed by the scanning electron microscope (SEM) images. Corresponding coloration efficiencies were obtained for the WO 3 /PANI (40.42 cm 2 C -1 ), graphene/PANI (78.64 cm 2 C -1 ), and WO 3 /graphene/PANI (67.47 cm 2 C -1 ) films, higher than that of the pristine PANI film (29.4 cm 2 C -1 ), suggesting positive effects of the introduced nanofillers on the electrochromic performance. The areal capacitances of the films were observed to increase following the order as bare WO 3 < WO 3 /graphene < pristine PANI < WO 3 /PANI < graphene/PANI < WO 3 /graphene/PANI films from both the cyclic voltammogram (CV) and galvanostatic charge-discharge (GCD) results. The enhanced energy storage and electrochromic performances of the PANI-based nanocomposite films can be attributed to the capacitance contributions of the introduced nanofillers, increased PANI amount, and the rougher morphology due to the embedment of the nanofillers into the PANI matrix. This extraordinary energy storage and electrochromic performances of the WO 3 /graphene/PANI film make it a promising candidate for combined electrochromic and energy storage applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Effect of metal encapsulation on bulk superconducting properties of niobium thin films used in qubits

Niobium metal occupies nearly 100% of the volume of a typical 2D transmon device. While the aluminum Josephson junction is of utmost importance, maintaining quantum coherence across the entire device means that pair-breaking in Nb leads, capacitive pads, and readout resonators can be a major source of decoherence. The established contributors are surface oxides and hydroxides, as well as absorbed hydrogen and oxygen. Metal encapsulation of freshly grown surfaces with non-oxidizing metals, preferably without breaking the vacuum, is a successful strategy to mitigate these issues. While the positive effects of encapsulation are undeniable, it is important to understand its impact on the macroscopic behavior of niobium films. We present a comprehensive study of the bulk superconducting properties of Nb thin films encapsulated with gold and palladium/gold, and compare them to those of bare Nb films. Magneto-optical imaging, magnetization, resistivity, and London and Campbell penetration depth measurements reveal significant differences in encapsulated samples. Both sputtered, and epitaxial Au-capped films exhibit the highest residual resistivity ratio and superconducting transition temperature, as well as the lowest upper critical field, London penetration depth, and critical current. These results are in good agreement with the microscopic theory of anisotropic normal and superconducting states of Nb. We conclude that pair-breaking in the bulk of niobium films, driven by disorder throughout the film rather than just at the surface, is a significant source of quantum decoherence in transmons. We also conclude that gold capping not only passivates the surface but also affects the properties of the entire film, significantly reducing the scattering rate due to defects likely induced by surface diffusion if the film is not protected immediately after fabrication.

Datta, Amlan [Ames Lab; Iowa State U.]↗

Effect of substrate tilt on sputter-deposited AuTa films

Gold-tantalum alloy films are of interest for biomedical and magnetically-assisted inertial confinement fusion applications. However, growth mechanisms of such Au-Ta alloy films are not well understood. Here, we systematically study the effect of substrate tilt on properties of films deposited by direct current magnetron sputtering from a AuTa alloy target. Experimental data is correlated with distributions of landing energies and incident angles of sputtered and backscattered species calculated by Monte Carlo simulations of ballistic collisions and gas phase atomic transport. Results reveal that the deposition rate and film density monotonically decrease with increasing substrate tilt. Properties are similar for films with a tilt of 40° and below: films are amorphous, with an average compressive stress of 0.5 GPa, a density of 16 g/cm 3 , and electrical resistivity of 200 μΩ cm. The critical substrate tilt angle for the onset of porosity, a transition to a reduced stress state, and an increase in electrical resistivity lies between 40 and 60°. Based on Monte Carlo simulations, these changes in film properties are correlated with an increase in the average impact angle of the ballistic component of atomic flux. Implications of these results to deposition onto non-planar substrates are discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Pulsed laser deposition and structural evolution of BaF 2 nanolayers in Eu-doped BaF 2 /Al 2 O 3 layered optical nanocomposite thin films

Here, we have developed a pulsed laser deposition (PLD) geometry for the growth of uniform BaF 2 nanoscale thin films, through control of the deposition conditions. Our goal is to use the BaF 2 layers with controllable structure as component layers in layered optical nanocomposites. The structure of the BaF 2 nanolayer evolves as a function of the layer thickness: BaF 2 grows via a layer-by-layer growth mode on Al 2 O 3 ; the layers are amorphous for a thickness < 3 nm, and then become nanocrystalline as the layer thickness increases. The BaF 2 nanocrystals have an FCC crystal structure with a weak < 111 > texture that becomes stronger for thicker films. We then demonstrate that our BaF2 films can be introduced into layered Al 2 O 3 /BaF 2 /EuO x nanocomposite films, which allows for control of the relative position of the Eu ions and the BaF 2 layer. Cross-section samples of the multilayered films show interfacial intermixing between the layers, which is related to implantation during the PLD process. This intermixing enables the incorporation of Eu ions into BaF 2 layers and form a thin Eu-doped BaF 2 nanolayer at the interface. The layered nanocomposite films show photoluminescence (PL) emission from Eu 3+ ions, and the PL intensity changes can be correlated with the crystallinity and crystal size changes in the BaF 2 layer. Our results provide guidance for achieving thin film nanocomposite materials with controllable structure and photoluminescence behavior for light emitting diodes, photovoltaics and other optical applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Controlling T c of iridium films using the proximity effect

A superconducting Transition-Edge Sensor (TES) with low-$T_c$ is essential in a high resolution calorimetric detection. With a motivation of developing sensitive calorimeters for applications in cryogenic neutrinoless double beta decay searches, we have been investigating methods to reduce the $T_c$ of an Ir film down to 20 mK. Utilizing the proximity effect between a superconductor and a normal metal, we found two room temperature fabrication recipes of making Ir-based low-$T_c$ films. In the first approach, an Ir film sandwiched between two Au films, a Au/Ir/Au trilayer, has a tunable $T_c$ in the range of 20-100 mK depending on the relative thicknesses. In the second approach, a paramagnetic Pt thin film is used to create Ir/Pt bilayer with a tunable $T_c$ in the same range. We present detailed study of fabrication and characterization of Ir-based low-$T_c$ films, and compare the experimental results to theoretical models. We show that Ir-based films with predictable and reproducible critical temperature can be consistently fabricated for use in large scale detector applications.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Heterogeneous Structural Evolution of In–Zn–O Thin Films during Annealing

Amorphous In-Zn-O (a-IZO) thin films are among the most promising transparent conducting materials. Applications of a-IZO include thin film transistors for display technology and photovoltaic devices. However, the use of this material in practical devices has been impeded by limitations in our understanding of the relationship between a-IZO film structure and electrical properties. Here, we use in situ X-ray reflectivity to provide experimental evidence for a vertically heterogeneous, thermally induced structural relaxation that had been predicted for amorphous oxide films but not previously observed. The structural relaxation is shown to be dependent on the thermal annealing environment. Complementary in situ current-voltage curves and ex situ Van der Pauw measurements further show that thermal annealing also influences the electrical performance of the films. Here our results suggest that both oxygen uptake and structural relaxation contribute to the reduction in free carriers within a-IZO films during postdeposition processing. The structural heterogeneity and loss of carriers that occur during thermal annealing are only partly reversible. We anticipate that this insight into the structure-processing-property relationships within a-IZO will help to enable a-IZO-based devices.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Anion Exchange Ionomers: Impact of Chemistry on Thin-Film Properties

Ionomer thin-films (i.e., 20–100 nm) on supports serve as model systems to understand ionomer-catalyst interfacial behavior as well as the confinement-driven deviation in properties from bulk membranes. While ionomer thin-films have been examined for proton exchange ionomers, the thin-film properties of anion exchange ionomers (AEIs) remain largely unexplored. More importantly, delineating the convoluted impact of chemistry and confinement on thin-film morphology and hydration is of interest to advancing the field on functional ionic interfaces. In this work, these aspects are studied by using AEIs of different backbones (perfluorinated, aliphatic, and aromatic) and side chains (various lengths, and single versus dual functional groups). Quartz-crystal microbalance and spectroscopic ellipsometry are used to analyze density and coupled with calculated free volume fraction of thin-films to provide insights on their gas transport properties. AEI side-chain's chemical character plays a key role in how confinement modulates hydration (in thin-film versus bulk). Overall, the results elucidate the effects of backbone, side-chain chemistry versus anion/cation type in the confinement-driven changes in thin-film morphology and swelling. This study also provides new insights for tuning AEI transport functionalities at interfaces via chemistry, which can benefit the design and development of electrode-ionomers for alkaline membrane-based energy systems.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Water-Surface Drag Coating: A New Route Toward High-Quality Conjugated Small-Molecule Thin Films with Enhanced Charge Transport Properties

Electronic properties of organic semiconductor (OSC) thin films are largely determined by their morphologies and crystallinities. However, solution-processed conjugated small-molecule OSC thin films usually exhibit abundant grain boundaries and impure grain orientations because of complex fluid dynamics during solution coating. Here, a novel methodology, water-surface drag coating, is demonstrated to fabricate high-quality OSC thin films with greatly enhanced charge transport properties. This method utilizes the water surface to alter the evaporation dynamics of solution to enlarge the grain size, and a unique drag-coating process to achieve the unidirectional growth of organic crystals. Furthermore, using 2,8-difluoro-5,11-bis(triethylsilylethynyl)anthradithiophene (Dif-TES-ADT) as an example, thin films with millimeter-sized single-crystal domains and pure crystallographic orientations are achieved, revealing a significant enhancement (4.7 times) of carrier mobility. More importantly, the resulting film can be directly transferred onto any desired flexible substrates, and flexible transistors based on the Dif-TES-ADT thin films show a mobility as high as 16.1 cm 2 V -1 s -1 , which represents the highest mobility value for the flexible transistors reported thus far. The method is general for the growth of various high-quality OSC thin films, thus opening up opportunities for high-performance organic flexible electronics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Rational Regulation of Layer‐by‐Layer Processed Active Layer via Trimer‐Induced Pre‐Swelling Strategy for Efficient and Robust Thick‐Film Organic Solar Cells

Thick-film (>300 nm) organic solar cells (OSCs) have garnered intensifying attention due to their compatibility with commercial roll-to-roll printing technology for the large-scale continuous fabrication process. However, due to the uncontrollable donor/acceptor (D/A) arrangement in thick-film condition, the restricted exciton splitting and severe carrier traps significantly impede the photovoltaic performance and operability. For this work, combined with layer-by-layer deposition technology, a twisted 3D star-shaped trimer (BTT-Out) is synthesized to develop a trimer-induced pre-swelling (TIP) strategy, where the BTT-Out is incorporated into the buried D18 donor layer to enable the fabrication of thick-film OSCs. The integrated approach characterizations reveal that the exceptional configuration and spontaneous self-organization behavior of BTT-Out trimer could pre-swell the D18 network to facilitate the acceptor's infiltration and accelerate the formation of D/A interfaces. This enhancement triggers the elevated polarons formation with amplified hole-transfer kinetics, which is essential for the augmented exciton splitting efficiency. Furthermore, the regulated swelling process can initiate the favorable self-assembly of L8-BO acceptors, which would ameliorate carrier transport channels and mitigate carrier traps. As a result, the TIP-modified thin-film OSC devices achieve the champion performance of 20.3% (thin-film) and 18.8% (thick-film) with upgraded stability, among one of the highest performances reported of thick-film OSCs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

PFSA-Ionomer Dispersions to Thin-Films: Interplay Between Sidechain Chemistry and Dispersion Solvent

In fuel-cell catalyst layers (CLs), ionomers exists as nanoscale thin-films binding catalyst particles, wherein ionic and gaseous species transport to catalyst sites. To improve film function, ionomers have been designed based on the prototypical perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA). Since CLs are fabricated through solution-based processing of inks, understanding how ink/dispersion solvent impacts ionomer interactions and function is important to guide future ionomer design. Herein, PFSA and its chemical derivatives are characterized from dispersion (in solvent) to thin film (cast on support) to investigate the impact of solvent water content on ionomer dispersion (structure, acidity) and resulting film properties. Dispersion characterization reveals that secondary aggregate structure depends on the sidechain chemistry, but all PFSA-based ionomers evolve similarly as dispersion becomes water-rich. The differences in aggregation alter ionomer adsorption and thin film morphology. Further, hydrophilic domain spacing and orientation are affected primarily by sidechain chemistry, and modulated by solvent composition. Thin-film conductivity correlates with hydration and nanodomain alignment, signifying the role of morphology in properties. Overall, this work provides insights into how chemistry can be used to coarse-tune structure–property relationships, while processing solvent is for fine-tuning of dispersion-film interplay for controlling CL-ionomer function, which can be translated to other chemistries and ink formulations.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Time-Resolved Grazing Incidence X-Ray Absorption Spectroscopy for the In Situ Investigation of the Initial Stages of Sputter-Deposited Copper Thin Films

The sputter deposition and the growth of thin copper films on float glass substrates are in situ studied using grazing incidence, reflection mode X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy with subsecond time resolution. The experimental data are compared with model calculations, assuming the presence of crystalline, face-centered cubic metallic Cu nanostructures. From a detailed analysis of the measured spectra, the film thickness as well as the surface roughness is determined, leading to a detailed understanding of the films growth as a function of the sputter deposition time. In particular, different stages of film growth can clearly be distinguished from the fits of the experimental data. The results suggest the formation of isolated, approximately nm-sized copper clusters in the initial phase of the film deposition for the first few seconds, a coalescence phase with a nominal thickness of ≈1.5–2.8 nm, constant roughness of about 1.4 nm for the subsequent ≈5 s, and finally 3D growth of the Cu crystallites in the film for later stages of film growth. Further prospects of the methodology are given.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Fe Thin Film-Coated Optics for Corrosion Monitoring: Optical and Electrochemical Studies

Corrosion proxy materials integrated with an optical sensing platform enable a real-time optical corrosion sensor for natural gas pipelines to prevent methane leaks and catastrophic events. Effects of CO 2 , pH, and film thickness on corrosion of Fe thin films (25, 50, 100 nm) were studied using optical and electrochemical methods in 3.5%wt. NaCl solutions at 30 °C. An increase in light transmission (T%) corresponded to corrosion of Fe thin films. CO 2 accelerated corrosion of Fe thin films due to the lower pH and the promoted corrosion reactions, resulting in a faster increase of T% than without CO 2 or at higher pH. While the corrosion rate increased with increasing film thickness, electrochemical corrosion of Fe thin films was in good agreement with that of bulk carbon steel, verifying that Fe thin films can serve as a representative corrosion proxy when integrated with the optical sensing platform.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Sputter-Deposited Mo Thin Films: Multimodal Characterization of Structure, Surface Morphology, Density, Residual Stress, Electrical Resistivity, and Mechanical Response

Multimodal datasets of materials are rich sources of information which can be leveraged for expedited discovery of process–structure–property relationships and for designing materials with targeted structures and/or properties. For this data descriptor article, we provide a multimodal dataset of magnetron sputter-deposited molybdenum (Mo) thin films, which are used in a variety of industries including high temperature coatings, photovoltaics, and microelectronics. In this dataset we explored a process space consisting of 27 unique combinations of sputter power and Ar deposition pressure. Here, the phase, structure, surface morphology, and composition of the Mo thin films were characterized by x-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy, and Rutherford backscattering spectrometry. Physical properties—namely, thickness, film stress and sheet resistance—were also measured to provide additional film characteristics and behaviors. Additionally, nanoindentation was utilized to obtain mechanical load-displacement data. The entire dataset consists of 2072 measurements including scalar values (e.g., film stress values), 2D linescans (e.g., x-ray diffractograms), and 3D imagery (e.g., atomic force microscopy images). An additional 1889 quantities, including film hardness, modulus, electrical resistivity, density, and surface roughness, were derived from the experimental datasets using traditional methods. Minimal analysis and discussion of the results are provided in this data descriptor article to limit the authors’ preconceived interpretations of the data. Overall, the data modalities are consistent with previous reports of refractory metal thin films, ensuring that a high-quality dataset was generated. The entirety of this data is committed to a public repository in the Materials Data Facility.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗