Fluorination Effect on Lithium- and Manganese-Rich Layered Oxide Cathodes
Not Available
25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “MANGANESE OXIDE”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Direct observation of Mn distribution/speciation within and surrounding a basidiomycete fungus in the production of Mn-oxides important in toxic element containment
Biogenic manganese (Mn) oxides occur ubiquitously in the environment including the uranium (U) mill tailings at the Ningyo-toge U mine in Okayama, Japan, being important in the sequestration of radioactive radium (Ra). To understand the nanoscale processes in Mn oxides formation at the U mill tailings site, Mn 2+ absorption by a basidiomycete fungus, Coprinopsis urticicola, isolated from Ningyo-toge mine water samples, was investigated in the laboratory under controlled conditions utilizing electron microscopy, synchrotron-based X-ray analysis, and fluorescence microscopy with molecular pH probe. The fungus’ growth was first investigated in an agar-solidified medium supplemented with 1.0 mmol/L of Mn 2+ , ± Cu 2+ (50 – 200 µM), ± Zn 2+ (50 – 200 µM), or ± diphenyleneiodonium chloride (DPI) (50 – 100 µM) at 25 °C. The results revealed that Zn 2+ has no significant effects on the Mn oxides formation, whereas Cu 2+ and DPI significantly inhibit both fungal growth and Mn oxidation, indicating superoxide-mediated Mn oxidation. During the interaction of Mn 2+ with the fungi in solution medium at the initial pH of 5.67, a small fraction of Mn 2+ infiltrated into the fungal hyphae within 8 h, forming a few tens nm-sized concentrates of soluble Mn2+ in the intracellular pH of ~6.5, which can be released back to solution within a day as shown in a subsequent releasing experiment. After 1 day of incubation, Mn oxides began to precipitate on the hyphae, which were characterized to be fibrous nanocrystals with a hexagonal birnessite-structure, these forming spherical aggregates with a diameter of ~1.5 µm. When the fungi were reacted using the Ningyo-toge mine water, the Mn concentration decreased at a rate of 1.0 mmol·day-1 per unit dry weight. The nanoscale processes associated with the fungi derived from the Ningyo-toge mine area provides additional insights into the existing mechanisms of Mn oxidation by filamentous fungi at other U mill tailings sites under circumneutral pH conditions. Such processes add to the class of reactions important to the sequestration of toxic elements.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Effect of iron substitution in cryptomelane on the heterogeneous reaction with isoprene
Biogenic isoprene is an important pollutant for regional air quality. Being ubiquitously distributed on the earth surface, manganese (hydr)oxides should play a vital role in the transformation of isoprene. Cryptomelane is a typical manganese oxide with isomorphous substitution of Fe for Mn, but less attention has been paid to its heterogeneous reaction with isoprene. When Fe 3+ replaces Mn 3+ , K + is depleted and Mn 3+ is oxidized to Mn 4+ . In contrast, oxygen vacancies are formed when Fe 3+ substitutes Mn 4+ . Fe substitution creates weak crystallites and abundant mesopores, resulting in the increase of isoprene adsorption. As found by theoretical calculations, the Mn 4+ –O 2- bonds at the cross sections of the tunnels is more active than that on the outer wall of the tunnels. After the adsorption of isoprene, bridging carboxylate species and hydrogen-bonding water are produced and the surface octahedra are distorted, i.e., Mn 4+ O 6 → Mn 3+ O 6-δ . As the heat facilitates the breakage of Mn 4+ –O 2- , the increase of environmental temperature enhances the oxidation of isoprene. Here the above findings shed light on the effect of Fe substitution in cryptomelane to enhance the oxidation of isoprene, and illustrates that heterogeneous reaction with isoprene impairs the transformation of other environmental substances on cryptomelane.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
A continuum model for heat and mass transfer in moving-bed reactors for thermochemical energy storage
In this work, a continuum heat and mass transfer model coupling transport phenomena and high-temperature thermochemical reactions is developed for stationary packed-bed and counter-flow moving-bed reactors. After presenting the general modeling framework, we focus on the 2D axisymmetric version of the model for which validation is conducted with experimental results for a packed-bed reactor in the literature for manganese-iron oxide reduction/oxidation and an in-house counter-flow moving-bed reactor for magnesium-manganese oxide reduction up to 1450 °C. Transient simulation results including the local distributions of gas/solid temperatures, oxygen concentration and the extent of reaction, as well as the various energy flow components and energy conversion efficiencies are reported. The results based on the 2D axisymmetric model are also compared with those obtained from a previous 1D model. The comparison shows that capturing the radial variation is critical in reactor modeling and the 2D results demonstrate improved agreement with experiments. Specifically, large temperature variations along the radial direction are observed especially in the reaction zone; this non-uniform radial temperature distribution has a significant effect on the chemical reaction extent due to its strong dependence on temperature; and the overall oxygen concentration at the reactor exit and the predicted system efficiency are slightly lower in the 2D model compared to the 1D model. Finally, the present heat and mass transfer model can provide valuable insights into reactor design, scale-up, and operating conditions selection to maximize system energy storage efficiency.
25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
The influence of manganese and silicon on the oxidation behavior of Co-20Cr
Manganese and silicon effects on oxidation and scale mechanisms of Co-Cr alloys, using thermogravimetric, metallographic and microprobe techniques
Armijo, J. S.↗
Nucleation-promoting and growth-limiting synthesis of disordered rock-salt Li-ion cathode materials
Disordered rock-salt oxides and oxyfluorides are promising positive electrode materials for high-performance lithium-ion batteries free of nickel and cobalt. However, conventional synthesis methods rely on post-synthesis pulverization to achieve cycling-appropriate particle sizes, offering limited control over particle microstructure and crystallinity. This accelerates degradation and complicates secondary particle processing. Here we present a synthesis strategy that enhances nucleation while suppressing particle growth and agglomeration across various disordered rock-salt compositions, including lithium–manganese–titanium oxide, lithium–manganese–niobium oxide, and lithium–nickel–titanium oxide systems. Applied to Li 1.2 Mn 0.4 Ti 0.4 O 2 , this method yields highly crystalline, well-dispersed sub-200 nm particles that form homogeneous electrode films with stable cycling behavior. Tested in cells with lithium metal as the counter electrode, these electrodes deliver ~200 mAh/g with 85% capacity retention relative to the first cycle after 100 cycles (20 mA/g, 1.5–4.8 V), and an average discharge voltage loss of 4.8 mV per cycle, compared to 38.6% retention and 7.5 mV loss per cycle for electrodes derived from pulverized solid-state particles. This approach suggests a route to enhance the performance and durability of disordered rock-salt electrodes for sustainable lithium-ion batteries.
Batteries↗
Sintered Cathodes for All-Solid-State Structural Lithium-Ion Batteries
All-solid-state structural lithium ion batteries serve as both structural load-bearing components and as electrical energy storage devices to achieve system level weight savings in aerospace and other transportation applications. This multifunctional design goal is critical for the realization of next generation hybrid or all-electric propulsion systems. Additionally, transitioning to solid state technology improves upon battery safety from previous volatile architectures. This research established baseline solid state processing conditions and performance benchmarks for intercalation-type layered oxide materials for multifunctional application. Under consideration were lithium cobalt oxide and lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide. Pertinent characteristics such as electrical conductivity, strength, chemical stability, and microstructure were characterized for future application in all-solid-state structural battery cathodes. The study includes characterization by XRD, ICP, SEM, ring-on-ring mechanical testing, and electrical impedance spectroscopy to elucidate optimal processing parameters, material characteristics, and multifunctional performance benchmarks. These findings provide initial conditions for implementing existing cathode materials in load bearing applications.
Ceramics↗
Mineral surface-catalyzed oxidation of Mn(II) by bromate: Implications for the occurrence of Mn oxides on Mars
The occurrence of manganese (Mn) oxides on Mars is believed to be an indicator of an O 2 -rich paleoenvironment of Mars because Mn oxides often form through the oxidation of Mn(II) by O 2 on the surface of Earth. An alternative formation pathway was recently proposed, in which Mn(II) is oxidized by bromate (BrO 3 - ), a common oxidant in contemporary Martian regolith. However, the oxidation of Mn(II) by bromate in solution is kinetically controlled and slow unless using very high concentrations (100 mM) of reactants that may be irrelevant to the conditions of Mars. We conducted laboratory simulations to determine whether iron (Fe) oxides (hematite and goethite) and a phyllosilicate (montmorillonite), abundant minerals on the surface of Mars, could catalyze the oxidation of Mn(II) by bromate. Hematite and goethite, but not montmorillonite, dramatically accelerated the oxidation with a low concentration (1 mM) of Mn(II) and bromate under various solution conditions. Further, the reaction system was autocatalytic with Fe oxides initiating the oxidation of Mn(II) at the early stage and the subsequent catalysis mainly provided by the Mn oxide products. In contrast to producing Mn(IV)O 2 only during the homogeneous oxidation of Mn(II) by bromate in solutions, the heterogeneous mineral-surface catalyzed oxidation resulted in a mixture of Mn(III)OOH and Mn(IV)O 2 phases. Mn(III)OOH was an intermediate product and can be further oxidized by bromate to Mn(IV)O 2 . The occurrence and accumulation of the intermediate product MnOOH can be attributed to its rapid formation due to surface-enhanced nucleation and growth on Fe oxide surfaces and to its higher resistance to oxidation by bromate than Mn(III) ions or clusters. Overall, mineralsurface catalyzed oxidation of Mn(II) by bromate is favorable from both thermodynamic and kinetic perspectives, and can be a major pathway for the occurrence of Mn oxides on Mars where microorganisms are lacking to catalyze the reaction. Our study further improves our understanding of the thermodynamic and kinetic controls on Mn(II) oxidation.
54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
A Cobalt– and Manganese–Free High–Nickel Layered Oxide Cathode for Long–Life, Safer Lithium–Ion Batteries
High-nickel LiNi 1–x–y Mn x Co y O 2 and LiNi 1–x–y Co x Al y O 2 cathodes are receiving growing attention due to the burgeoning demands on high-energy-density lithium-ion batteries. The presence of both cobalt and manganese in them, however, triggers multiple issues, including high cost, high toxicity, rapid surface deterioration, and severe transition-metal dissolution. Herein, a Co- and Mn-free ultrahigh-nickel LiNi 0.93 Al 0.05 Ti 0.01 Mg 0.01 O 2 (NATM) cathode that exhibits 82% capacity retention over 800 deep cycles in full cells, outperforming two representative high-Ni cathodes LiNi 0.94 Co 0.06 O 2 (NC, 52%) and LiNi 0.90 Mn 0.05 Co 0.05 O 2 (NMC, 60%) is presented. It is demonstrated that a titanium-enriched surface along with aluminum and magnesium as the stabilizing ions in NATM not only ameliorates unwanted side reactions with the electrolyte and structural disintegrity, but also mitigates transition-metal dissolution and active lithium loss on the graphite anode. As a result, the graphite anode paired with NATM displays an ultrathin (≈8 nm), monolayer anode-electrolyte interphase architecture after extensive cycling. Furthermore, NATM displays considerably enhanced thermal stability with an elevated exothermic temperature (213 °C for NATM vs 180 and 190 °C for NC and NMC, respectively) and remarkably reduced heat release. This work sheds light on rational compositional design to adopt ultrahigh-Ni cathodes in lithium-based batteries with low cost, long service life, and improved thermal stability.
25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
Three Distinctive Steps for Heterogeneous Nucleation of Tunnel-Structured Mn Oxide on Quartz under Light Exposure
Natural manganese (Mn) oxide coatings, resulting from the heterogeneous nucleation on foreign substances, have garnered interest based on their importance in the reaction with organic substances and in environmental systems. However, the heterogeneous nucleation of the natural Mn oxide coatings still remains elusive. Here, via fast photochemical oxidation of Mn 2+ (aq), we show that Mn(IV) oxide nuclei form and aggregate on quartz in three distinct successive stages: (i) a nanocrystalline film of unaligned grain forms, (ii) nanoislands develop on the film, and (iii) nanorods form on the nanoislands. Each stage has different crystalline structures and forms by aligned attachment of nanoscale precursors on the preceding surface. Crystal lattice analyses confirm the crystalline development, from the short-range order of the Mn oxide film to the long-range order of the nanorods. Also, the heterogeneous nucleation observed in this work produced groutellite-like tunnel structures of Mn oxide on quartz. Furthermore, this revealed pathway of the heterogeneous nucleation can offer a new perspective on the variety of poorly crystalline structures of natural Mn oxides found in the environment, which can affect elemental redox cycles, contaminant sequestration and removal, and soil carbon storage.
Aligned attachment↗
Sorption and Oxidative Degradation of Small Organic Molecules on Mn-Oxides-Effects of pH and Mineral Structures
Manganese (Mn)-oxides regulate carbon (C) cycling in soils by sorbing and oxidizing organic compounds. The composition of soil organic matter varies widely, and little is known about the reactivity of individual organic compounds with structurally diverse Mn-oxides under various environmentally relevant pH conditions. Here, in this study, we examined the affinity of six organic compounds for three Mn-oxides, comprised of layer (birnessite and hydrous Mn oxide HMO) or tunnel (cryptomelane) structures, at acidic (pH 4), slightly acidic (pH 6), and slightly alkaline (pH 8) conditions. Cryptomelane, with a higher specific surface area and point of zero charge, showed higher reactivity than that of HMO and birnessite. Interestingly, these Mn-oxides, although different in structures, decomposed each organic compound to form the same products. Citrate, pyruvate, ascorbate, and catechol induced reduction and dissolution of Mn-oxides. After the reaction, the average oxidation state of Mn in the solids was much lower at pH 4 than at pH 6 and 8, suggesting more reduction under more acidic conditions. Even when reacting with phthalate and propanol, which only sorbed to Mn-oxides but did not degrade, there was proton-promoted Mn dissolution under acidic conditions. These results suggest the significance of environmental pH and mineral structures in affecting the Mn–organic interactions and provide fundamental insights into a better understanding of the roles of Mn-oxides in regulating soil C cycling.
58 GEOSCIENCES↗
Manganese-Rich Sandstones as an Indicator of Ancient Oxic Lake Water Conditions in Gale Crater, Mars
Manganese has been observed on Mars by the NASA Curiosity rover in a variety of contexts and is an important indicator of redox processes in hydrologic systems on Earth. Within the Murray formation, an ancient primarily fine-grained lacustrine sedimentary deposit in Gale crater, Mars, have observed up to 45× enrichment in manganese and up to 1.5× enrichment in iron within coarser grained bedrock targets compared to the mean Murray sediment composition. This enrichment in manganese coincides with the transition between two stratigraphic units within the Murray: Sutton Island, interpreted as a lake margin environment, and Blunts Point, interpreted as a lake environment. On Earth, lacustrine environments are common locations of manganese precipitation due to highly oxidizing conditions in the lakes. Here, we explore three mechanisms for ferromanganese oxide precipitation at this location: authigenic precipitation from lake water along a lake shore, authigenic precipitation from reduced groundwater discharging through porous sands along a lake shore, and early diagenetic precipitation from groundwater through porous sands. All three scenarios require highly oxidizing conditions and we discuss oxidants that may be responsible for the oxidation and precipitation of manganese oxides. This work has important implications for the habitability of Mars to microbes that could have used Mn redox reactions, owing to its multiple redox states, as an energy source for metabolism.
58 GEOSCIENCES↗
Manganese-rich sandstones as an indicator of ancient oxic lake water conditions in Gale crater, Mars
Manganese has been observed on Mars by the NASA Curiosity rover in a variety of contexts and is an important indicator of redox processes in hydrologic systems on Earth. Within the Murray formation, an ancient primarily fine-grained lacustrine sedimentary deposit in Gale crater, Mars, have observed up to 45× enrichment in manganese and up to 1.5× enrichment in iron within coarser grained bedrock targets compared to the mean Murray sediment composition. This enrichment in manganese coincides with the transition between two stratigraphic units within the Murray: Sutton Island, interpreted as a lake margin environment, and Blunts Point, interpreted as a lake environment. On Earth, lacustrine environments are common locations of manganese precipitation due to highly oxidizing conditions in the lakes. Here, we explore three mechanisms for ferromanganese oxide precipitation at this location: authigenic precipitation from lake water along a lake shore, authigenic precipitation from reduced groundwater discharging through porous sands along a lake shore, and early diagenetic precipitation from groundwater through porous sands. All three scenarios require highly oxidizing conditions and we discuss oxidants that may be responsible for the oxidation and precipitation of manganese oxides. This work has important implications for the habitability of Mars to microbes that could have used Mn redox reactions, owing to its multiple redox states, as an energy source for metabolism.
58 GEOSCIENCES↗
Effect of Reverse Bias Stress on Leakage Currents and Breakdown Voltages of Solid Tantalum Capacitors
The majority of solid tantalum capacitors are produced by high-temperature sintering of a fine tantalum powder around a tantalum wire followed by electrolytic anodization that forms a thin amorphous Ta2O5 dielectric layer and pyrolysis of manganese nitrite on the oxide to create a conductive manganese dioxide electrode. A contact to tantalum wire is used as anode terminal and to the manganese layer as a cathode terminal of the device. This process results in formation of an asymmetric Ta -- Ta2O5 -- MnO2 capacitor that has different characteristics at forward (positive bias applied to tantalum) and reverse (positive bias applied to manganese cathode) voltages. Reverse bias currents might be several orders of magnitude larger than forward leakage currents so I-V characteristics of tantalum capacitors resemble characteristics of semiconductor rectifiers. Asymmetric I-V characteristics of Ta -- anodic Ta2O5 systems have been observed at different top electrode materials including metals, electrolytes, conductive polymers, and manganese oxide thus indicating that this phenomenon is likely related to the specifics of the Ta -- Ta2O5 interface. There have been multiple attempts to explain rectifying characteristics of capacitors employing anodic tantalum pentoxide dielectrics. A brief review of works related to reverse bias (RB) behavior of tantalum capacitors shows that the mechanism of conduction in Ta -- Ta2O5 systems is still not clear and more testing and analysis is necessary to understand the processes involved. If tantalum capacitors behave just as rectifiers, then the assessment of the safe reverse bias operating conditions would be a relatively simple task. Unfortunately, these parts can degrade with time under reverse bias significantly, and this further complicates analysis of the I-V characteristics and establishing safe operating areas of the parts. On other hand, time dependence of reverse currents might provide additional information for investigation of the processes under reverse bias conditions. In practice, there were instances when, due to unforeseen events, the system operated at conditions when capacitors experience periodically a relatively small reverse bias for some time followed by normal, forward bias conditions. In such a case an assessment should be made on the degree to which these capacitors are degraded by application of low-voltage reverse bias, and whether this degradation can be reversed by normal operating conditions. In this study, reverse currents in different types of tantalum capacitors were monitored at different reverse voltages below 15%VR and temperatures in the range from room to 145 C for up to 150 hours to get better understanding of the degradation process and determine conditions favorable to the unstable mode of operation. The reversibility of RB degradation has been evaluated after operation of the capacitors at forward bias conditions. The effect of reverse bias stress (RBS) on reliability at normal operating conditions was evaluated using highly accelerated life testing at voltages of 1.5VR and 2 VR and by analysis of changes in distributions of breakdown voltages. Possible mechanisms of RB degradation are discussed.
Teverovsky, Alexander A.↗
Stability of Mn-Doped TiO 2 Thin-Film Anodes during Water Oxidation Reactions
Incorporating manganese atoms into TiO 2 has been shown to improve its activity for water oxidation. However, its activity has been observed to steadily degrade under constant applied potential, especially at more oxidizing applied potentials. Here, the compositional profile and electrochemical stability of Mn-doped TiO 2 (Mn:TiO 2 ) thin-film electrodes precisely fabricated by atomic layer deposition (ALD) were evaluated to elucidate the mechanisms of electrode degradation. Although ALD enables the deposition of Mn dopants throughout the film thickness, only Mn within 1.5 nm of the surface was observed to be redox active. Annealing Mn:TiO 2 films in air leads to the diffusion of Mn toward the electrode surface and oxidation of the Mn and alters the redox behavior. Annealing endows greater stability to Mn redox behavior but does not fully stabilize the water oxidation current, suggesting that the two electrochemical processes are not precisely correlated. In situ inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry reveals that Mn is lost from Mn:TiO 2 films at potentials greater than 1.8 V vs RHE. However, the initial Mn loss is equivalent to less than a single ALD layer of MnO x . Longer-term constant potential experiments suggest that Mn is lost from up to 1 nm of the electrode surface but that this loss may account for only a portion of the diminished water oxidation activity.
atomic layer deposition↗
Tailoring P2/P3‐Intergrowth in Manganese‐Based Layered Transition Metal Oxide Positive Electrodes via Sodium Content for Na‐Ion Batteries
High-manganese content sodium-ion positive electrodes have received heightened interest as an alternative to contemporary Li-ion chemistries due to their high abundance, low toxicity, and even geographical distribution. However, these materials typically suffer from poor capacity, unstable cycling performance, and sluggish Na + kinetics. Herein, we explore a manganese-based layered transition metal oxide (Na x N 0.25 Mn 0.75 O 2 ) and show by X-ray diffraction (XRD) and high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (HAADF-STEM) that careful variation of the sodium content can instigate the formation of a biphasic intergrowth. This intergrown P2/P3 material offered a higher capacity than its monophasic P2 counterpart due to the P3 structure having greater low-voltage Mn 3+/4+ redox. Further, the intergrowth material offers greatly enhanced kinetics and cycling stability when compared to single-phase P3 material, due to the stabilizing nature of the P2 structure, elucidated by galvanostatic intermittent titration technique (GITT) and operando synchrotron X-ray diffraction. These results highlight the beneficial effect that the intergrowth structure has on the electrochemical performance of high-manganese content positive electrode for future sodium-ion batteries.
25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
Cobalt Dissolution from Metal Oxides and Battery Cathode Materials with Acetic Acid-Based Deep Eutectic Solvents
Recovery of critical metals with alternative solvents beyond those in traditional pyrometallurgy and hydrometallurgy is needed in consideration of environmental challenges and the growing demand for metals in energy technologies. Deep eutectic solvents (DESs) have emerged as sustainable alternatives for solvometallurgy in metal separation and recovery. In this study, DESs based on hydrogen bond acceptors (HBAs) including choline chloride (ChCl), acetylcholine chloride (AChCl), and betaine (Bet) were investigated for their effectiveness when paired with acetic acid (AA) as the hydrogen bond donor (HBD) for the dissolution of cobalt from cobalt oxide (CoO), lithium cobalt oxide (LiCoO 2 ), and lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide (LNMC). Based on the spectroscopic analysis of the metal dissolution and coordination, Bet:AA was found to provide the highest solubility for CoO (0.33 M) in the form of an octahedral complex. On the other hand, ChCl:AA solvent was more effective at dissolving LiCoO 2 with 0.04 M Co 2+ corresponding to 17% dissolution efficiency and LNMC with 0.06 M Co 2+ corresponding to 72% dissolution efficiency at 50 °C, compared to Bet:AA (9% for LiCoO 2 and 31% for LNMC). Although the solubilities of LiCoO 2 and LNMC have not significantly improved in ChCl:AA, this difference in effectiveness between the solvents clearly reveals the role of the HBA in solubilization. The coordination synergy between the chloride and the –OH moiety facilitates the breakdown of the LiCoO 2 driven by the alteration of the solvent polarity. Cobalt in these solutions was found dominantly as a tetrahedral [CoCl 4 ] 2– complex. A chemical separation of cobalt oxalate from a mixed-metal oxide system based on Co, Fe, and Ni was also demonstrated, confirming the potential of these solvents for practical metal recovery.
Cobalt separation↗
Electrolytes and electrochemical devices
Disclosed herein are electrolytes and electrochemical devices. The electrochemical devices comprise cathodes that include nickel-rich layered lithium transition metal oxides, lithium-rich layered transition-metal oxides, lithium manganese-based spinel oxides, lithium polyanion-based compounds, and combinations thereof. The electrolytes include a lithium imide salt, an aprotic acyclic carbonate solvent, and an additive, wherein the additive comprises a metal salt, an aprotic solvent, or a combination thereof. The electrolyte can be stable at a voltage of 4.3 V or above vs. Li/Li+.
Manthiram, Arumugam↗