Search NASASearch

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Defect engineering”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 271 records · Page 15

Modulating charge transport via 2 MeV He + irradiation in VO 2

Vanadium dioxide (VO 2 ) is of interest for adaptive electronic applications such as neuromorphic neuristor devices and variable emissivity or tunable thermal control materials, thanks to its key property—a metal–insulator transition (MIT) at 68 °C that is accompanied by a dramatic change in electrical and optical properties. To improve performance in these roles, it is critical to develop approaches to engineer transport properties and the MIT behavior. While many documented techniques exist to modulate the MIT and film resistivities via lattice strain and chemical doping, less is known about the effects of ion irradiation on the intrinsic properties of VO 2 , despite the ability to control the spatial distribution of irradiation beams and the prevalence of high energy ion implantation in the semiconductor industry. The impact of irradiation of different acceleration energies on the responses of VO 2 is of specific interest, as charged particle energy generally impacts both the resulting defect profile and corresponding transport behavior. Here, we demonstrate that 2 MeV He ions at equivalent calculated displacements per atom, in two different types of films, can create remarkable changes to the nature of charge transport in VO 2 , especially in the low-temperature insulating phase. Simulation of resulting changes in electrical conductivity reveals that He ion irradiation offers a strategy to increase both oscillation frequency and the signal transmission. These results provide insights into the intentional design of defect populations to modulate transport for neuromorphic VO 2 devices.

Gurrola, Rebeca M. [Texas A & M Univ., College Sta

Engineering long-lived entanglement through dissipation in quantum hybrid solid-state platforms

Spin squeezing, a form of many-body entanglement, is a crucial resource in quantum metrology and information processing. While experimentally viable protocols for generating stable spin squeezing have been proposed in quantum optics setups, there is growing interest in quantum hybrid solid-state systems as alternative platforms for both engineering and exploring many-body quantum phenomena. In this work, we propose a scheme to generate long-lived spin squeezing in an ensemble of solid-state qubits interacting with electromagnetic noise emitted by a squeezed solid-state bath. We identify the conditions under which quantum correlations within the bath can be transferred to the qubit array, driving it into an entangled state independently of its initial configuration. To assess the experimental feasibility of our approach, we analyze the dynamics of an array of solid-state spin defects coupled to a common ferromagnetic bath, which is driven into a non-equilibrium squeezed state through its interaction with a surface acoustic wave mode. Our results demonstrate that the ensemble can exhibit steady-state spin squeezing under suitable conditions, opening new pathways for the generation of robust many-body entanglement in solid-state spin ensembles.

NV centers

Ab Initio Design of High-Entropy Thermal/ Environmental Barrier Coatings

Next generation thermal/environmental barrier coatings (TEBC) require carefully balancing various properties including phase stability, thermal conductivity, coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE), mechanical properties, and resistance against hot corrosion and water vapor recession. This work mainly focuses on rapid design of cost-effective high entropy rare-earth disilicates and aluminum garnets to protect SiC-based ceramic matrix composites and nickel-based superalloys in the hot section of gas turbine engines using density functional theory methods. Our calculations identify several low-cost high entropy TEBC exhibiting ultralow thermal conductivity at 1500 K and desirable CTE while maintaining good mechanical properties, including Er1/2Y3/4Yb3/4Si2O7, Gd1/4Er1/4Y3/4Yb3/4Si2O7, Eu1/4Er1/4Y3/4Yb3/4Si2O7, and (Y1/4Gd1/4Er1/4Yb1/4)3Al5O12. This work also aims to gain fundamental understanding of oxygen diffusion in model disilicates. Minimizing oxidizer (such as water vapor and oxygen) permeability through the EBC layer can significantly decrease the growth rate of thermally grown oxide and extend the service life of the coating system. Oxygen diffusion mechanisms including formation energy of defects under varying oxygen conditions and defect migration energy barriers will be presented.

coefficient of thermal expansion

Overcoming the Conductance versus Crossover Trade-off in State-of-the-Art Proton Exchange Fuel-Cell Membranes by Incorporating Atomically Thin Chemical Vapor Deposition Graphene

Permeance–selectivity trade-offs are inherent to polymeric membranes. In fuel cells, thinner proton exchange membranes (PEMs) could enable higher proton conductance and increased power density with lower area-specific resistance (ASR), smaller ohmic losses, and lower ionomer cost. However, reducing thickness is accompanied by an increase in undesired species crossover harming performance and long-term efficiency. Here, we show that incorporating atomically thin monolayer graphene synthesized via scalable chemical vapor deposition (CVD) and tunable defect density into PEMs (Nafion, ~5–25 μm thick) can allow for reduced H 2 crossover (~34–78% of Nafion of a similar thickness) while maintaining adequate areal proton conductance for applications (>4 S cm –2 ). In contrast to most prior work using >50 μm symmetric Nafion sandwich structures, we elucidate the interplay of graphene defect density and Nafion proton transport resistance on the performance of Nafion|graphene composite membranes and find high-quality low-defect density CVD graphene (G) supported on Nafion 211 (~25 μm); i.e., N211|G has a high areal proton conductance (~6.1 S cm –2 ) and the lowest H 2 crossover (~0.7 mA cm –2 ). Fully functional centimeter-scale N211|G fuel-cell membranes demonstrate performance comparable to that of state-of-the-art Nafion N211 at room temperature as well as standard operating conditions (~80 °C, ~150–250 kPa-abs) with H 2 /air (power density ~0.57–0.63 W cm –2 ) and H 2 /O 2 feed (power density ~1.4–1.62 W cm –2 ) and markedly reduced H 2 crossover (~53–57%).

25 ENERGY STORAGE

LPBF Processability of NiTiHf Alloys: Systematic Modeling and Single-Track Studies

Research into the processability of NiTiHf high-temperature shape memory alloys (HTSMAs) via laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) is limited; nevertheless, these alloys show promise for applications in extreme environments. This study aims to address this limitation by investigating the printability of four NiTiHf alloys with varying Hf content (1, 2, 15, and 20 at. %) to assess their suitability for LPBF applications. Solidification cracking is one of the main limiting factors in LPBF processes, which occurs during the final stage of solidification. To investigate the effect of alloy composition on printability, this study focuses on this defect via a combination of computational modeling and experimental validation. To this end, solidification cracking susceptibility is calculated as Kou’s index and Scheil–Gulliver model, implemented in Thermo-Calc/2022a software. An innovative powder-free experimental method through laser remelting was conducted on bare NiTiHf ingots to validate the parameter impacts of the LPBF process. The result is the processability window with no cracking likelihood under diverse LPBF conditions, including laser power and scan speed. This comprehensive investigation enhances our understanding of the processability challenges and opportunities for NiTiHf HTSMAs in advanced engineering applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Machine Learning for Additive Manufacturing of Functionally Graded Materials

Additive Manufacturing (AM) is a transformative manufacturing technology enabling direct fabrication of complex parts layer-by-layer from 3D modeling data. Among AM applications, the fabrication of Functionally Graded Materials (FGMs) has significant importance due to the potential to enhance component performance across several industries. FGMs are manufactured with a gradient composition transition between dissimilar materials, enabling the design of new materials with location-dependent mechanical and physical properties. This study presents a comprehensive review of published literature pertaining to the implementation of Machine Learning (ML) techniques in AM, with an emphasis on ML-based methods for optimizing FGMs fabrication processes. Through an extensive survey of the literature, this review article explores the role of ML in addressing the inherent challenges in FGMs fabrication and encompasses parameter optimization, defect detection, and real-time monitoring. The article also provides a discussion of future research directions and challenges in employing ML-based methods in the AM fabrication of FGMs.

36 - MATERIALS SCIENCE

L-PBF High-Throughput Data Pipeline Approach for Multi-modal Integration

Abstract Metal-based additive manufacturing requires active monitoring solutions for assessing part quality. Multiple sensors and data streams, however, generate large heterogeneous data sets that are impractical for manual assessment and characterization. In this work, an automated pipeline is developed that enables feature extraction from high-speed camera video and multi-modal data analysis. The framework removes the need for manual assessment through the utilization of deep learning techniques and training models in a weakly supervised paradigm. We demonstrate this pipeline’s capability over 700,000 high-speed camera frames. The pipeline successfully extracts melt pool and spatter geometries and links them to corresponding pyrometry, radiography, and processparameter information. 715 individual prints are examined to reveal melt pool areas that exceeds 0.07 mm 2 and pyrometry signal over a threshold (375 pyrometry units) were more likely to have defects. These automated processes enable massive throughput of characterization techniques.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Probing the limits of genetic recoding using multi-omics-guided evolution

Engineering the genetic code—by reassigning multiple of the 64 natural codons—enables making organisms resistant to all viruses, preventing genetic information exchange, and allowing the biosynthesis of genetically encoded unnatural polymers. However, synonymous codon replacement—recoding—is frequently lethal, and how recoding impacts fitness remains poorly explored. Here, we explore these effects using genome synthesis, directed evolution, and genome-transcriptome-translatome-proteome co-profiling on multiple synthetic Escherichia coli genomes. We construct six partially recoded E. coli strains bearing up to 45.8% of a synthetic genome with a deleterious 57-codon genetic code. As our analyses revealed widespread defects—including unassigned codons in Syn61 and Syn57—we apply multi-omics to revise our genome design and mitigate defects. Using multi-omics, we show that recoding induces transcriptional and translational changes leading to fitness defects under hundreds of conditions. Finally, we develop a multi-omics-guided evolution strategy that rapidly restores fitness, enabling genome synthesis with radical changes.

Nyerges, Akos [Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA

Measuring 3D Profilometry of SAVY-4000 Nuclear Material Storage Containers: Novacam TubeInspect Capabilities Report

The SAVY-4000 container series is a general-purpose interim storage container for nuclear materials, developed and maintained by Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL). It is the first vented, general-use nuclear material container to be demonstrated as meeting the requirements outlined in DOE M 441.1-1, the Nuclear Material Packaging Manual. Due to the challenging radiation, thermal, and corrosive storage conditions that the SAVY containers must endure, continuous surveillance techniques are employed to ensure the containers meet all safety standards and specifications. These inspections are typically performed by human operators, who check for issues such as corrosion, O-ring deterioration, corrosion, filter integrity, and potential manufacturing defects. However, human inspections alone are not sufficient, and automated inspection technologies, such as the ATIS system, as well as other automated systems are also utilized. The MicroCam TubeInspect, developed by Novacam Technologies Inc., is designed to address the challenges of understanding how manufacturing variations in the SAVY-4000 container series may affect performance. It is a 3D profilometry measurement system that enables detailed analysis of surface features, including defects, surface roughness, and manufacturing variations. This advanced tool significantly enhances rapid surveillance techniques for both pristine and used containers. In this study, container properties such as surface roughness, thickness, and geometric attributes like circularity are measured for SAVY-4000 containers. Artificially corroded or dented containers are examined to demonstrate the MicroCam's ability to quantify defects. A sensitivity analysis is also conducted, comparing the MicroCam results to those obtained using more precise instruments such as confocal microscopy. This comparison aims to provide valuable insights into container quality, durability, and potential improvements in manufacturing processes.

42 ENGINEERING

Electric Drive Technologies Consortium (EDTC)/ Cost competitive, high-Performance, highly Reliable (CPR) Power Devices on 4H-SiC (Final Report)

4H-Silicon carbide (4H-SiC) is a wide bandgap semiconductor that offers superior material properties over silicon, including higher critical electric field, thermal conductivity, and electron saturation velocity. These advantages make 4H-SiC highly attractive for high-voltage, high-efficiency power electronics. However, realizing the full potential of SiC requires device technologies that are not only high-performing but also manufacturable and reliable under real-world operating conditions. This report summarizes the outcomes of a five-year R&D effort funded by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) under the Electric Drive Technologies Consortium (EDTC), focused on developing cost-competitive, high-performance, and highly reliable (CPR) power devices on 4H-SiC substrates. The program targeted scalable and manufacturable 1.2 kV-class SiC MOSFETs optimized for next-generation electric vehicles, renewable energy systems, and industrial power conversion. The project delivered transformative advancements in SiC power device performance and ruggedness. Particularly, Specific on-resistance (R on,sp ) was reduced by up to 37%, from ~4.0 m$\Omega \cdot$cm 2 in earlier designs to an industry-leading 2.40 m$\Omega \cdot$cm 2 , driven by optimized doping, refined JFET widths, and layout engineering. Breakdown voltages (BV) exceeded 1600 V, marking improvement over legacy baselines, and demonstrating the robustness of newly implemented junction profiles and edge terminations. Short-circuit withstand time (SCWT) saw a remarkable 4$\times$ increase, from ~2 $\mu$s to over 8 $\mu$s, achieved through the successful deployment of deep P-well structures (~1.8–2.0 $\mu$m) via channeling implantation. This innovative process breakthrough enabled precise junction formation without MeV-class implantation tools, reduced leakage under high field stress, and allowed even the shortest-channel devices (down to 0.3 $\mu$m) to achieve both high BV and excellent ruggedness—breaking the traditional trade-off between conduction efficiency and blocking capability. Several novel architectures pushed the performance envelope further. JBSFETs—featuring embedded Schottky portions—eliminated bipolar degradation and drastically reduced third-quadrant leakage, while Ladder MOSFETs introduced a clever orthogonal conduction path that achieved a 15.4% reduction in R on,sp over standard linear designs. Switching performance reached new benchmarks: short-channel devices showed a 31% reduction in total switching energy compared to 0.5 $\mu$m counterparts, while maintaining manageable gate drive requirements. Layout-optimized structures not only improved transconductance but also accelerated switching transitions, pointing to real-world benefits in converter-level efficiency. The devices also passed rigorous reliability validation. Stress-tested across TDDB, HTGB, HTRB, HVP, and burn-in, the devices screened under 30 V/10 hr and 43 V/1 s protocols consistently exhibited tighter lifetime distributions and long-term oxide robustness. These screening techniques proved effective in identifying latent defects and ensuring deployment-grade reliability. Meanwhile, advanced 3D TCAD simulations revealed and resolved electric field hotspots—particularly in HEXFET corners—where fields exceeding 4.8 MV/cm were mitigated through geometry-aware layout corrections. Overall, the results of this project demonstrate a manufacturable and scalable SiC power device platform that addresses key DOE performance targets for efficient, robust, and reliable 1.2kV 4H-SiC Power Devices. The developed technologies represent a meaningful step forward in the commercial readiness of high-voltage SiC solutions and provide a strong foundation for continued advancement in wide bandgap power electronics.

42 ENGINEERING

Characterizations of two-photon absorption process induced by defects in aluminum nitride using Z-scan method

Abstract In this work, we reported two-photon absorption (TPA) measurements for aluminum vacancies in Aluminum nitride single crystals. We measured the linear transmission and identified the defect levels. Using the Z-scan method, we measured the TPA coefficients of the transitions between defect levels from 380 nm to 735 nm. The transition occurs between the aluminum vacancies defect levels. Furthermore, the power dependence shows good linear fitting, confirming the TPA mechanism. These results will be helpful for the design and fabrication of ultra-low loss waveguides and integrated photonics in the ultraviolet spectral range.

Engineering

A critical review on additive manufacturing of refractory alloys from a data analytics perspective- beyond nickel-based superalloys

Refractory alloys (RAs) are promising materials due to their exceptional physicochemical properties, but most research remains at the laboratory scale. For broader adoption, advancements in manufacturing are essential. Because their high stability makes conventional methods like machining and casting difficult, additive manufacturing (AM) is emerging as an effective approach for fabricating refractory alloy components. However, AM's repeated non-equilibrium thermal cycles introduce undesired features (e.g. defects, anisotropic microstructures, and residual stresses), which are magnified due to RAs’ unique properties. This paper comprehensively reviews the state-of-the-art methods of AM for refractory alloys. It explores data analytics techniques to establish design rules based on multi-fidelity experimental and computational methods. Furthermore, it investigates integrated, collaborative efforts to harmonise standalone databases, information, knowledge, and predictive models at multi-physics, multi-stage, and multi-scale. Unlike the existing literature that focuses primarily on material systems or process fundamentals, this work provides an integrated perspective on AM of refractory alloys from a data analytics standpoint, highlighting the roles of integrated computational materials engineering (ICME), verification, validation, and uncertainty quantification (VV&UQ), and digital twin-driven qualification in overcoming data scarcity and accelerating rapid qualification.

Additive manufacturing

An engineering perspective on evaluating mechanisms governing ductility in pure molybdenum

The United States lacks a stable domestic supply of 99 mTc, a critical medical imaging isotope generated from 99 Mo. Accelerator-based production using 100 Mo targets (aMo) introduces mechanical concerns due to the ductile-to-brittle transition temperature inherent to refractory metals like Mo. This study evaluates the tensile behavior of aMo targets from 25 to 1000 °C, compared to powder-metallurgy-processed natural Mo (PMo) and cast-and-rolled Mo (RMo), both as-received and after 5 ppm O 2 exposure in flowing He. RMo showed superior ductility (7.3% at 25 °C, 48% at 1000 °C) and strength, attributed to its fine, elongated grains and high geometrically necessary dislocation density. PMo exhibited variable ductility (up to 33%), while aMo remained brittle, with a maximum elongation of 10.4% at 600 °C. EBSD analysis revealed weak texture in PMo and aMo, but high defect density in aMo limited dislocation mobility. This work links processing, microstructure, and deformation mechanisms to guide fabrication of ductile refractory targets.

Hyer, Holden C. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (OR

Self-consistent solution of the Frank–Bilby equation for interfaces containing disconnections

The quantized Frank–Bilby equation can be used to identify interfacial line defect array configurations which relax the misorientation and/or misfit of a coherent crystalline interface. These line defect arrays may be comprised of dislocations and/or disconnections, which are interfacial steps with dislocation character. When an interface contains disconnections, solution of the quantized Frank–Bilby equation is complicated by the fact that the habit plane orientation is not known in advance because it depends on the unknown spacing of the disconnection array. We present a root-finding-based method for addressing this issue, enabling a self-consistent solution for arbitrary defect content. Our method has been implemented in an open-source code which enumerates all possible solutions given a list of candidate line defects. Two cases are presented employing the code: a misoriented FCC twin boundary and an FCC/BCC phase boundary with the Nishiyama-Wasserman orientation relationship. Both cases exhibit more than 10,000 solutions to the Frank–Bilby equation, with several hundred solutions categorized as ‘‘low energy’’ and thus plausible configurations for the actual interface. The resulting set of solutions can be utilized to predict and understand the properties of a given interface.

42 ENGINEERING

SAGA1 and MITH1 produce matrix-traversing membranes in the CO2-fixing pyrenoid

Abstract Approximately one-third of global CO 2 assimilation is performed by the pyrenoid, a liquid-like organelle found in most algae and some plants. Specialized pyrenoid-traversing membranes are hypothesized to drive CO 2 assimilation in the pyrenoid by delivering concentrated CO 2 , but how these membranes are made to traverse the pyrenoid matrix remains unknown. Here we show that proteins SAGA1 and MITH1 cause membranes to traverse the pyrenoid matrix in the model alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii . Mutants deficient in SAGA1 or MITH1 lack matrix-traversing membranes and exhibit growth defects under CO 2 -limiting conditions. Expression of SAGA1 and MITH1 together in a heterologous system, the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana , produces matrix-traversing membranes. Both proteins localize to matrix-traversing membranes. SAGA1 binds to the major matrix component, Rubisco, and is necessary to initiate matrix-traversing membranes. MITH1 binds to SAGA1 and is necessary for extension of membranes through the matrix. Our data suggest that SAGA1 and MITH1 cause membranes to traverse the matrix by creating an adhesive interaction between the membrane and matrix. Our study identifies and characterizes key factors in the biogenesis of pyrenoid matrix-traversing membranes, demonstrates the importance of these membranes to pyrenoid function and marks a key milestone toward pyrenoid engineering into crops for improving yields.

Hennacy, Jessica H.

Functional analysis of the methylerythritol phosphate pathway terminal enzymes IspG and IspH from Zymomonas mobilis

ABSTRACT Isoprenoids are a diverse family of compounds that are synthesized from two isomeric compounds, isopentenyl diphosphate and dimethylallyl diphosphate. In most bacteria, isoprenoids are produced from the essential methylerythritol phosphate (MEP) pathway. The terminal enzymes of the MEP pathway IspG and IspH are [4Fe-4S] cluster proteins, and in Zymomonas mobilis, the substrates of IspG and IspH accumulate in cells in response to O 2 , suggesting possible lability of their [4Fe-4S] clusters. Here, we show using complementation assays in Escherichia coli that even under anaerobic conditions, Z. mobilis IspG and IspH are not as functional as their E. coli counterparts, requiring higher levels of expression to rescue viability. A deficit of the sulfur utilization factor (SUF) Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathway did not explain the reduced function of Z. mobilis IspG and IspH since no improvement in viability was observed in E. coli expressing the Z. mobilis SUF pathway or having increased expression of the E. coli SUF pathway. Complementation of single and double mutants with various combinations of Z. mobilis and E. coli IspG and IspH indicated that optimal growth required the pairing of IspG and IspH from the same species. Furthermore, Z. mobilis IspH conferred an O 2 -sensitive growth defect to E. coli that could be partially rescued by co-expression of Z. mobilis IspG. In vitro analysis showed O 2 sensitivity of the [4Fe-4S] cluster of both Z. mobilis IspG and IspH. Altogether, our data indicate an important role of the cognate protein IspG in Z. mobilis IspH function under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions. IMPORTANCE Isoprenoids are one of the largest classes of natural products, exhibiting diversity in structure and function. They also include compounds that are essential for cellular life across the biological world. In bacteria, isoprenoids are derived from two precursors, isopentenyl diphosphate and dimethylallyl diphosphate, synthesized primarily by the methylerythritol phosphate pathway. The aerotolerant Z. mobilis has the potential for methylerythritol phosphate pathway engineering by diverting some of the glucose that is typically efficiently converted into ethanol to produce isoprenoid precursors to make bioproducts and biofuels. Our data revealed the surprising finding that Z. mobilis IspG and IspH need to be co-optimized to improve flux via the methyl erythritol phosphate pathway in part to evade the oxygen sensitivity of IspH.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Elucidating the Role of InGaAs and InAlAs Buffers on Carrier Dynamics of Tensile-Strained Ge Double Heterostructures

Extensive research efforts of strained germanium (Ge) are currently underway due to its unique properties, namely, (i) possibility of band gap and strain engineering to achieve a direct band gap, thus exhibiting superior radiative properties, and (ii) higher electron and hole mobilities than Si for upcoming technology nodes. Realizing lasing structures is vital to leveraging the benefits of tensile-strained Ge (ε-Ge). Here, we use a combination of different analytical tools to elucidate the effect of the underlying InGaAs/InAlAs and InGaAs overlaying heterostructures on the material quality and strain state of ε-Ge grown by molecular beam epitaxy. Using X-ray analysis, we show the constancy of tensile strain in sub-50 nm ε-Ge in a quantum-well (QW) heterostructure. Further, effective carrier lifetime using photoconductive decay as a function of buffer type exhibited a high (low) defect-limited carrier lifetime of ~68 ns (~13 ns) in 0.61% (0.66%) ε-Ge grown on an InGaAs (InAlAs) buffer. These results correspond well with the measured surface roughness of 1.289 nm (6.303 nm), consistent with the surface effect of the ε-Ge/III–V heterointerface. Furthermore, a reasonably high effective lifetime of ~78 ns is demonstrated in a QW of ~30 nm 1.6% ε-Ge, a moderate reduction from ~99 ns in uncapped ε-Ge, alluding to the surface effect of the overlying heterointerface. Thus, the above results highlight the prime quality of ε-Ge that can be achieved via III–V heteroepitaxy and paves a path for integrated Ge photonics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

How transparent is graphene? A surface science perspective on remote epitaxy

Remote epitaxy is the synthesis of a single crystalline film on a graphene-covered substrate, where the film adopts epitaxial registry to the substrate as if the graphene is transparent. Despite many exciting applications for flexible electronics, strain engineering, and heterogeneous integration, an understanding of the fundamental synthesis mechanisms remains elusive. Here we offer a perspective on the synthesis mechanisms, focusing on the foundational assumption of graphene transparency. We identify challenges for quantifying the strength of the remote substrate potential that permeates through graphene, and propose Fourier and beating analysis as a bias-free method for decomposing the lattice potential contributions from the substrate, from graphene, and from surface reconstructions, each at different frequencies. We highlight the importance of graphene-induced reconstructions on epitaxial templating, drawing comparison to moiré epitaxy. We highlight the role of the remote potential in tuning surface diffusion and adatom kinetics on graphene, which are crucial for navigating the competition between remote epitaxy and defect-seeded mechanisms like pinhole epitaxy. In light of this weak remote potential, we re-evaluate the current state-of-the-art experimental evidence, highlighting why it remains challenging to experimentally validate a ‘remote’ epitaxy mechanism that cannot be explained by alternatives, such as pinhole-seeded epitaxy or serial van der Waals epitaxy. We end with one experimental example that, to out knowledge, cannot be explained by competing mechanisms: a different long-range epitaxial relationship for GdPtSb films grown on graphene/sapphire, compared to direct epitaxy on sapphire. We suggest for future experiments that directly measure the remote potential and impact of tuneable growth kinetics.

epitaxy