Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “initial guess”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 271 records · Page 15

End-to-End Performance Optimization of a Crewed Lunar Landing Mission Staged from a Near Rectilinear Halo Orbit

A crewed lunar landing mission staged from a Near Rectilinear Halo Orbit (NRHO) presents a unique set of challenges not considered before for the Apollo-type direct missions. The NRHO does not have a fixed orbital plane and its period also changes with time, due to which the mission performance is very sensitive to the timing and location of the NRHO departure and arrival burns for a near-polar surface landing site. For such type of mission staged from the NRHO, an end-to-end optimization approach for the entire mission, from the NRHO departure to surface landing and from surface lift-off to the NRHO insertion, is well-suited for extracting the maximum performance out of this design. In this paper, an integrated approach for performing end-to-end optimization of a NRHO-staged crewed lunar landing mission is proposed that optimizes the in-space and powered flight segments simultaneously using Copernicus trajectory optimization tool. Copernicus is augmented with analytical approximations for the in-space, powered descent, and powered ascent segments in this work to improve the convergence of its multiple-shooting based direct optimization method. New analytical solutions are derived for the different phases of the powered flight segments by solving associated guidance problems. These analytical solutions act as initial guesses for starting the numerical optimization of the integrated mission in Copernicus. An example lunar landing mission is simulated to validate the proposed end-to-end optimization approach and the results are compared with the conventional patched trajectory approach.

Bharat Mahajan↗

Phase-Free Orbital Element Model Designed to Enable Rapid Assessment of Eclipse and Radiation Profiles for Low-Thrust Spiral Transfers Around the Earth

The Gateway Power and Propulsion Element (PPE) will be the first low-thrust solar electric ion propulsion mission to transfer from a highly elliptical Earth-bound orbit to a southern near-rectilinear halo orbit (NRHO) at the Earth-Moon L2 point. Due to the low thrust nature of the transfer orbit, it is desirable to locate viable trajectories that minimize the time spent in the Van Allen radiation belts to reduce solar array degradation and keep radiation dosages below design limits. In addition to radiation, low thrust trajectories which spiral around the Earth will pass through at least one or more seasons of Earth eclipses. The solar electric propulsion system relies on sunlight to generate the power necessary to operate the ion thrusters. Therefore, it is advantageous to find trajectories which also minimize the amount of time spent in eclipse and avoid excessive battery draw-down periods. We present an analytical method which rapidly approximates low-thrust spiral trajectories, fit to high-fidelity simulated data and parameterized to allow for changes in vehicle thrust characteristics, that is post-processed to determine eclipse profiles and time spent in the belts using a novel approach that estimates the geometry of the belts using a first-order dipole approximation of the Earth’s magnetic field. This method can be used to find satisfactory launch dates and orbit orientations that can serve as initial guesses when optimizing such missions in high-fidelity software.

low thrust trajectory design↗

Electric Sail Design Sensitivities

Electric Sails (E-Sails) are a promising propulsion technology that seek to enable high characteristic propellentless acceleration for spacecraft to reach distant and/or difficult to reach orbits such as rapid transit to heliopause. The E-Sail system exchanges momentum by using positively charged electrostatic tethers to repel solar wind photons to push it through space. This concept was first theorized by Pekka Janhunen in 2004 with further developments occurring including a NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts Phase 1 and Phase 2 hosted out of NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC). These developments led to further maturation of the overall system, and this paper is designed to help identify different design sensitivities of an integrated Electric Sail system. To approach this, a small team at MSFC took an in-house developed three degrees of freedom (3DoF) simulation tool and a trajectory modelling tool to look at different design parameters and to determine a potential ideal E-Sail configuration. An E-Sail system has different design architectures including a barbell design, hub and spoke design, and a potential hybrid solution. The barbell design features two equally massed satellites that spin around a central point in the tether system. The hub and spoke design features a large central spacecraft with small end spacecraft to aid in formation control of the overall E-Sail system. Leveraging elements from both the hub and spoke, and barbell design, a hybrid option exists where one could have a larger central mass and one or two tethers extended to a smaller end mass [2]. In summary, the hub and spoke design is the ideal configuration for E-Sail with tethers spanning kilometers to achieve the designed design characteristic acceleration of at least one mm/s2 with this architecture being the focus of this study. Different key design parameters were varied as part of this study. These parameters include the total number of tethers, the length of the tethers, spin rate, relative spacecraft mass, tether voltage, inertia per tether, and impact of slew rate changes. These results started from an internal MSFC technology demonstration mission design and then the parameters were varied with engineering judgement to ensure that the results were consistent with expected results. These were varied in the MSFC 3DoF tool and compared to baseline results to generate a candidate ideal E-Sail design system. These results were then used to help inform the mission analysis design for the system. The 3DoF trajectory optimization was performed in the Astrodynamics and Space Science Enabling Toolbox (ASSET) and utilized collocation optimization of control vector pointing with the objective function being transfer duration. A representative model of the E-Sail force was derived as a function of the Sun-pointing vector direction. This model was initialized with a zero Sun Incidence Angle (SIA) trajectory for the initial guess generation, then with a portion of the mission optimized SIA time history for fast outbound transfers. After the trajectory is hyperbolic relative to a heliocentric frame, the SIA is maintained at 0 degrees except for any needed trajectory correction maneuvers. This trajectory optimization looked at different characteristic acceleration values to analyze the impact it had on mission performance. As a result of this study, the team can best inform mission designers and technology development efforts to mature the E-Sail system. This study will allow mission designers to have defined rules-of-thumb to design an E-Sail system to meet desired mission needs as well as providing several sample mission profiles. These design drivers will inform maturation efforts on which design requirements to consider for an integrated E-Sail design.

E-Sail↗

Phase-Free Orbital Element Model Designed to Enable Rapid Assessment of Eclipse and Radiation Profiles for Low-Thrust Spiral Transfers Around the Earth

The Gateway Power and Propulsion Element (PPE) will be the first low-thrust solar electric ion propulsion mission to transfer from a highly elliptical Earth-bound orbit to a southern near-rectilinear halo orbit (NRHO) at the Earth-Moon L2 point. Due to the low thrust nature of the transfer orbit, it is desirable to locate viable trajectories that minimize the time spent in the Van Allen radiation belts to reduce solar array degradation and keep radiation dosages below design limits. In addition to radiation, low thrust trajectories which spiral around the Earth will pass through at least one or more seasons of Earth eclipses. The solar electric propulsion system relies on sunlight to generate the power necessary to operate the ion thrusters. Therefore, it is advantageous to find trajectories which also minimize the amount of time spent in eclipse and avoid excessive battery draw-down periods. We present an analytical method which rapidly approximates low-thrust spiral trajectories, fit to high-fidelity simulated data and parameterized to allow for changes in vehicle thrust characteristics, that is post-processed to determine eclipse profiles and time spent in the belts using a novel approach that estimates the geometry of the belts using a first-order dipole approximation of the Earth’s magnetic field. This method can be used to find satisfactory launch dates and orbit orientations that can serve as initial guesses when optimizing such missions in high-fidelity software.

low thrust trajectory design↗

Mission Design Strategies for Rendezvous and Servicing of Sun-Earth Libration Point Missions

With the launch of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) and future launches of the Roman Space Telescope (RST) and larger telescopes such as the proposed Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO), the questions of where and how to rendezvous to enable servicing of these telescope missions arise. To aid in determining the allowable locations to rendezvous for servicing from a trajectory design approach, our previous research and analysis has shown feasible transfer trajectories between the Sun-Earth Libration L2 region (Quasi-Halo orbit) and the Earth Moon vicinity (Distant Retrograde Orbit (DRO), Quasi-Halo Orbit, Halo Orbit, and Near Rectilinear Halo Orbit (NRHO)), along with the related transfer constraints and the corresponding total fuel mass costs. We now focus on operational-like optimal scenarios for these transfers to complete a rendezvous to permit servicing at various Libration orbit locations. In this paper, we address how operational navigation and maneuver execution uncertainties impact the rendezvous timing and fuel mass (via ΔV). While optimization techniques are applied to ensure minimal ΔVs, we also analyze various transfer trajectory durations and rendezvous arrival geometries. The analysis presented includes dynamical system approaches and applies optimization through several tools including the Adaptive Trajectory Design (ATD) module as an initial guess, numerical computation using the General Mission Analysis Tool (GMAT) and Systems Tool Kit (STK) with higher fidelity perturbation modeling, and recently developed optimization tools that incorporate dynamical systems directly into the optimization process. Transfer trajectory options examined include a direct transfer from Earth versus departures from the previously examined Earth-Moon regime orbits, e.g. NRHOs and DROs. A return from Sun-Earth to lunar vicinity for a complete servicing after a rendezvous in Sun-Earth orbit is also considered. The resultant ΔV’s for each scenario is provided with discussions on various transfer trades, rendezvous considerations, and orbital limitations from the dynamical systems. A Poincare-like mapping of trajectory and rendezvous conditions categorize feasible and optimum transfer approaches, dependent on Sun-Earth orbit mission parameters. The focus of this research addresses questions for upcoming trades regarding servicing options for current and future Sun-Earth L1 and L2 missions. By doing a comprehensive analysis approach (dynamical systems + high fidelity optimization with true operational constraints), this paper will serve as a guide for mission architecture and operational trade considerations.

Maneuver Design↗

Relative Motion for Short-Term Loitering in the Gateway NRHO

Numerous vehicles will visit Gateway throughout the expected mission lifetime, and much like Gateway, these vehicles will operate in a Near Rectilinear Halo Orbit (NRHO). Short-term loitering strategies are explored for these vehicles. The objective of this analysis is to illuminate concepts that enable safe loitering, while considering the operational limitations to the design process. To highlight relative motion, a linear sensitivity analysis is applied. The linear approach offers an initial guess strategy for generating loiter architectures in the high-fidelity gravity model. Methods of constructing transfers between loitering regimes are explored.

Stephen T Scheuerle↗

Q-Law for Rapid Assessment of Low Thrust Cislunar Trajectories Via Automatic Differentiation

Q-Law is a Lyapunov-based control law used to determine optimal controls for a low thrust trajectory. One major issue with its use is the difficult derivatives re-quired for calculating optimal controls at a given time. In this paper, an implementation of Q-Law with automatic differentiation via a Python package called JAX is applied. With automatic differentiation, the difficult derivatives for Q-Law’s optimal controls are calculated with ease, and derivatives of final states with respect to Q-Law’s weights are found enabling gradient-based optimization of Q-Law for the first time. Different search and optimization methods for finding optimal weights are then compared using the LEO to GEO problem, and it was found that gradient-free methods like design of experiments and genetic algorithm produced the best results, but they took the longest time to get a solution, while the gradient-based method found a locally optimal result in a much faster time. Overall, the run time for a single propagation is manageable and well-suited for a mission designer to use as an initial guess generator for trajectory optimization, or for simple orbit transfer analysis.

Nathan Steffen↗

Predicting Operational Performance of xEMU Boot at Lunar South Pole Temperatures using Thermal Desktop ®

The spacesuit boots that will be used on Artemis lunar south pole surface missions will be exposed to extremely cold temperatures (down to ~50 K). To assess the performance of the government’s Exploration Extravehicular Mobility Unit (xEMU) lunar boot in these permanently shadowed regions, testing was performed at the Jet Propulsion Lab (JPL) in the Cryogenic Ice Transfer, Acquisition Development, and Excavation Laboratory (CITADEL) thermal vacuum (TVAC) chamber. This paper documents the data analysis, thermal boot model correlation, and operational predictions conducted using data from the xEMU CITADEL TVAC test. Expected thermal conductances within the boot and between the boot and environment were calculated from test data, which was then used as an initial guess for conductances within a Thermal Desktop (TD) model. Correlation of the TD model using the internal SOLVER feature was performed across 10 different test points which varied external temperature, internal boot ventilation flowrate, and contact pressure. Operational performance at the lunar south pole was then predicted using results from the correlated model. While the predictions provide evidence for acceptable performance of the boots at the 100K environment test point, there is still substantial uncertainty in performance, especially at the 48K test point. This uncertainty is due in part to testing limitations such as contacting the foot to a hard metal plate rather than granular regolith, and model limitations such as the lack of a realistic foot model. These limitations and their impacts are addressed in detail in this paper. The results of this test series and model correlation underscore the importance of additional improved testing and modeling for characterizing the expected thermal resistance between the outside of the boot and the lunar surface.

Spacesuit↗

Adding linear kinetic effects to existing finite-difference simulations

We present the proof-of-principle KINETIC-J module for iterative addition of all-order kinetic effects (parallel and perpendicular) in both the IC and EC frequency ranges, to any existing FD or FE frequency-domain full-wave RF simulation. The module calculates the linear, kinetic plasma current, such that given f 0 (r,v) and the cold plasma solution as an initial guess at the wave electric field, iterating the KINETIC-J module and the existing code (its internal plasma current replaced with the output of the module) converges to the kinetic solution. Since KINETIC-J does not use the k-space representation of the hot plasma dielectric, in favor of data parallel numeric integrals, implementing the module requires minimal code changes.

Green, David L↗

Impact of Flux Wire Selection on Neutron Spectrum Adjustment

In reactor dosimetry, spectrum unfolding methods are used to assess the energy-dependent neutron flux following the irradiation of flux wires or foils. For some spectrum unfolding methods, an a priori, or initial guess, spectrum is necessary. However, if the a priori spectrum is not representative of the irradiation spectrum experienced by the flux wires, the spectrum unfolding method may fail or create a nonphysical adjusted spectrum. The unfolded spectrum is dependent on flux wire reaction rates, and therefore cross section. As a result, each selection or combination of flux wires will have a different sensitivity to the group-wise fluence difference between the a priori spectrum and the irradiation spectrum. Therefore, a selection of flux wires that are insensitive to errors in the a priori spectrum would be considered robust choices for reactor dosimetry. In this work, flux wire reaction rates are calculated using a simulated neutron spectrum from the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) and spectrum unfolding methods are used in each flux wire combinations. The flux wire combinations are compared against a traditional flux wire set of Ti, Fe, and Co, with a summary table of the deemed “good” wire combinations that are insensitive to number of a priori neutron energy groups, group-wise difference between the a priori and irradiation, and magnitude of difference.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Accelerated Coupled Monte Carlo-Thermal Hydraulic Calculations using a Hybrid GTF-Diffusion-based Prediction Block: First Results

Accurate predictions of spatial power and temperature distributions require the coupling of a neutron transport solver with a thermal-hydraulic (TH) feedback. Nowadays, Monte Carlo (MC) codes are widely coupled to TH solvers, typically via a Picard iteration (PI) method, due to the higher fidelity that such frameworks can produce. To speed up a PI, a prediction step can produce an improved initial guess for a source distribution and feed it to the MC code. Recent work [1, 2] investigated a prediction step that uses generalized transfer functions (GTFs) to predict the macroscopic cross sections’ variations following a perturbation in TH properties, such as coolant density. The previous method also relied on first order perturbation (FOP) theory to predict perturbed power profiles, rather than using an expensive MC iterate. The implemented FOP method relied on generating a fission matrix from which the forward and adjoint eigenmodes were extracted and later used to for power calculations. The generation of the fission matrix can introduce a significant computational overhead, therefore undermining the performance of the proposed hybrid technique when applied to high-dimensional problems, e.g., full core calculations. This work attempts to improve the GTF-FOP prediction step by replacing the FOP solver with a nodal diffusion solver, thus eliminating the need to calculate a fission matrix. The GTF-diffusion step was tested for various moderator density perturbations. In each case, the predicted power distribution showed good agreement with the reference case. The latter is attributed to the generally good prediction of most spatially distributed macroscopic cross sections, except the transport cross section, which will become the focus of future work.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Convergence analysis of a CMFD method based on generalized equivalence theory

CMFD acceleration methods have been successful in reducing the computational burden for steady-state and transient reactor calculations. However, recent work on a complex coupled code BWR ATWS event has exposed possible issues with the stability of the CMFD method when standard CMFD methods are used. During the simulation of the ATWS boron injection event in the BWR, the PARCS code failed to converge with the existing CMFD method. A new CMFD method based on generalized equivalence theory was developed and the PARCS solution converged for the same ATWS event. This paper presents the new method and a detailed analytic and numerical convergence analysis. The results show that the new CMFD converges for all possible cross sections combinations anticipated in Light Water Reactor simulation and unlike existing CMFD methods, it is very robust even when the initial guess is far from final true solution. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Convergence analysis of a CMFD method based on generalized equivalence theory

CMFD acceleration methods have been successful in reducing the computational burden for steady-state and transient reactor calculations. However, recent work on a complex coupled code BWR ATWS event has exposed possible issues with the stability of the CMFD method when standard CMFD methods are used. During the simulation of the ATWS boron injection event in the BWR, the PARCS code failed to converge with the existing CMFD method. A new CMFD method based on generalized equivalence theory was developed and the PARCS solution converged for the same ATWS event. This paper presents the new method and a detailed analytic and numerical convergence analysis. The results show that the new CMFD converges for all possible cross sections combinations anticipated in Light Water Reactor simulation and unlike existing CMFD methods, it is very robust even when the initial guess is far from final true solution. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Thermal hydraulic method for whole core design analysis of an HTGR

A new thermal hydraulic method and initial results are presented for core-wide steady state analysis of prismatic High Temperature Gas-Cooled Reactors (HTGR). The method allows for the complete solution of temperature and coolant mass flow distribution by solving quasi-steady energy balances for the discretized core. Assembly blocks are discretized into unit cells for which the average temperature of each unit cell is determined. Convective heat removal is coupled to the unit cell energy balances by a 1-D axial flow model. The flow model uses established correlations for friction factor and Nusselt number. Bypass flow is explicitly calculated by using an initial guess for mass flow distribution and determining the exit pressure of each flow channel. The mass flow distribution is updated until a uniform core exit pressure condition is reached. Results are obtained for the MHTGR-350 with emphasis on the change in thermal hydraulic parameters due to various steady state power profiles and bypass gap widths. Steady state temperature distribution and its variations are discussed. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Characterizing the Thermal Column Beam in the University of Massachusetts Lowell Research Reactor

The University of Massachusetts Lowell operates a 1 MW, light water cooled and moderated Research Reactor (UMLRR) fueled by low-enriched uranium to generate neutron flux that is used at a variety of in-core and beam port facilities within the reactor to perform irradiation experiments for academic and industrial research. One of the irradiation sites is a graphite-moderated thermal column designed to deliver a collimated beam of thermal neutrons to a neutron radiography imaging system. A detailed characterization of the neutron beam is essential for the design and interpretation of experiments at the facility and for radiation safety. This work aimed to characterize the neutron flux and energy spectrum in the UMLRR thermal column beam by employing experimental and computational methods known as the foil activation and spectrum unfolding technique. A previously existing Monte Carlo N-Particle transport (MCNP) model of the UMLRR reactor core has been extended to the thermal column where the neutron flux and energy spectrum have been computed and experimentally validated. This work employed the foil activation and spectrum unfolding technique along with neutron transport computation to extend the knowledge of the neutron fluence and energy spectrum from the UMLRR core to the adjacent thermal column beam. Radiography systems are used for materials characterization, studying dynamic behavior of engineering systems, and for nuclear forensics applications. Foil activation is an experimental method where thin foils of highly pure materials are placed in the beam where interactions between the neutrons and the foil material activate radioisotopes in the foils whose activities can be measured after the irradiation. Downstream computation with MCNP and the spectrum unfolding code SAND can deconvolute the neutron fluence and energy spectrum that must have been necessary to induce the production rates of radioisotopes that were obtained through foil activation. The necessary ingredients for successful spectrum unfolding are the experimentally measured production rates and some a priori (initial guess) knowledge of the flux spectrum. The thermal column is equipped with a neutron radiography imaging system, so any experimenters who desire to use neutron radiography at UMass Lowell will benefit significantly from knowing the characteristics of the neutron beam. Comprehensive knowledge of these characteristics of the beam is essential to compare and benchmark results obtained for similar experiments at other facilities. The Integrated Nuclear Security and Safeguards Laboratory (INSSL) is pursuing the investigation of the performance of self-healing materials under stress-strain environments and the characterization of radiation detectors and special containers for storing and transporting nuclear material. This work contributes to the improvement of the current radiography system, expands the utility of the system for nuclear safeguards and security application and provides information that will enhance the general safety of the UMLRR experimental facilities. The main objective of this work has been achieved; an appropriate neutron flux spectrum for the UMLRR thermal column beam has been determined using the foil activation method followed by spectrum unfolding. There now exists an experimentally validated computational model of the neutron flux spectrum and the thermal column's neutron environment is characterized. We can conclude that the thermal column is well characterized; an appropriate neutron flux spectrum has been determined through an experimentally validated computational model. Future experimenters interested in the thermal column may now expand on the computational model or use the spectral information for their own purposes. The knowledge gained herein will be helpful for the INSSL's future work using neutron radiography to analyze the effectiveness of self-healing materials and special containers. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Calculation of Higher Eigenpairs of the Transport Equation Using IRAM Based on Domain Decomposition

The higher eigenpairs of the neutron transport (or diffusion) equation are useful in core flux distribution reconstruction, transient analysis, stability analysis, and loading pattern optimization. There are various methods for the calculation of higher eigenpairs, such as the power iteration method with filtering technique, the Generalized Modified Power Method (GMPM), the power iteration method with innovative boundary conditions for symmetric cores, and Krylov subspace methods. In regard to Krylov subspace methods, the Implicitly Restarted Arnoldi Method (IRAM) and ORTHOMIN were implemented to calculate higher eigenpairs for both transport and diffusion equations. In Warsa's work, however, there was a significant drawback that problems with energy upscatter could not be treated efficiently. In Modak's work, the mode to which his method was likely to converge depended on the shape of initial guess flux, and only one mode could be computed each time, making it impractical for real use. Furthermore, the computational burden for higher eigenpairs is generally much larger than for only the first eigenpair, especially for neutron transport equations. Therefore, the implementation of parallel computation for higher eigenpairs is essential to improve the efficiency, and no such work has been reported in literature so far. In this summary, we propose an innovative method to calculate higher eigenpairs of the neutron transport equation based on high performance computation. In this method, 2D Matrix Method of Characteristic (MMOC) is used to discretize the neutron transport equation; IRAM is used to evaluate higher eigenpairs; spatial domain decomposition is used to realize parallel computation. The highlight of this method is using the MGMD PGMRES (Multi-Group and Multi-Domain coupled Parallel Generalized Minimal Residual Method) algorithm to simultaneously accelerate the upscatter iterations and the inner interface angular fluxes iterations, avoiding the drawback in Warsa's method and the efficiency problem of conventional Jacobi iteration. To the best of our knowledge, our work represents the first application of IRAM based on domain decomposition for higher eigenpairs.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Anderson acceleration stability in NDA-accelerated k-eigenvalue problems

Anderson acceleration (AA) has been used to improve the stability and convergence rate of multiphysics iterative methods for reactor analysis. Most applications studied assume a tightly converged solution for the different physics problems, and AA is usually applied to state variables like temperature, density, and heat generation rate. In this paper, we study the theoretical performance of AA in NDA-accelerated k-eigenvalue problems. The problems and algorithms studied are simplified from the coupled iteration scheme adopted by MPACT and many other high-fidelity whole-core reactor codes. Compared to previous analyses of AA for these iteration schemes, we study the case with a partially converged neutronics solution and possibly partially converged nonlinear diffusion acceleration (NDA)/coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) solutions. We observe that the performance of the iteration scheme with AA is very sensitive to the initial guess and is affected by the partially converged CMFD solutions. When the NDA solution is fully converged, using AA cannot achieve the optimal convergence rate in large-sized problems. Conversely, if the NDA solution is partially converged, the iteration scheme with AA can diverge or converge extremely slowly. It is found that the loss of robustness for AA is due to the fact that it is applied to the iterative subspace of state variables rather than the fundamental unknowns of the governing equations. To improve the robustness, the scalar flux should also be considered in the implementation of AA. After considering the residuals of flux, we observe that the stability is regardless of the partial convergence of NDA solutions. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

LOCO with Constraints and Improved Fitting Technique

LOCO has been a powerful beam-based diagnostics and optics control method for storage rings and synchrotrons worldwide ever since it was established at NSLS by J. Safranek. This method measures the orbit response matrix and optionally the dispersion function of the machine. The data are then fitted to a lattice model by adjusting parameters such as quadrupole and skew quadrupole strengths in the model, BPM gains and rolls, corrector gains and rolls of the measurement system. Any abnormality of the machine that affects the machine optics can then be identified. The resulting lattice model is equivalent to the real machine lattice as seen by the BPMs. Since there are usually two or more BPMs per betatron period in modern circular accelerators, the model is often a very accurate representation of the real machine. According to the fitting result, one can correct the machine lattice to the design lattice by changing the quadrupole and skew quadrupole strengths. LOCO is so important that it is routinely performed at many electron storage rings to guarantee machine performance, especially after the Matlab-based LOCO code became available. However, for some machines, LOCO is not easy to carry out. In some cases, LOCO fitting converges to an unrealistic solution with large changes to the quadrupole strengths {Delta}K. The quadrupole gradient changes can be so large that the resulting lattice model fails to find a closed orbit and subsequent iterations become impossible. In cases when LOCO converges, the solution can have {Delta}K that is larger than realistic and often along with a spurious zigzag pattern between adjacent quadrupoles. This degeneracy behavior of LOCO is due to the correlation between the fitting parameters - usually between neighboring quadrupoles. The fitting scheme is therefore less restrictive over certain patterns of changes to these quadrupoles with which the correlated quadrupoles fight each other and the net effect is very inefficient {chi}{sup 2} reduction, i.e., small {chi}{sup 2} reduction with large changes of {Delta}K. Under effects of random noise, the fitting solution tends to crawl toward these patterns and ends up with unrealistically large {Delta}K. Such a solution is not very useful in optics correction because after the solution is dialed in, the quadrupoles will not respond as predicted by the lattice model due to magnet hysteresis. We will show that adding constraints to the fitting parameters is an effective way to combat this problem of LOCO. In fact, it improves optics calibration precision even for machines that don't show severe degeneracy behavior. LOCO fitting is essentially to solve a nonlinear least square problem with an iterative approach. The linear least square technique is applied in each iteration to move the solution toward the minimum. This approach is commonly referred to as the Gauss-Newton method. By using singular value decomposition (SVD) to invert the Jacobian matrix, this method has generally been very successful for LOCO. However, this method is based on a linear expansion of the residual vector over the fitting parameters which is valid only when the starting solution is sufficiently close to the real minimum. The fitting algorithm can have difficulties to converge when the initial guess is too far off. For example, it's possible for the {chi}{sup 2} merit function to increase after an iteration instead of decrease. This situation can be improved by using more robust nonlinear least square fitting algorithms, such as the Levenberg-Marquardt method. We will discuss the degeneracy problem in section 2 and then show how the constrained fitting can help in section 3. The application of Levenberg-Marquadt method to LOCO is shown in section 4. A summary is given in section 5.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗