Cassini Titan flyby environment thermal acceptability evaluation
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The heat shield of the Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) was equipped with thermocouplestacks to measure in-depth heating of the thermal protection system during atmosphericentry. The heat load derived from the thermocouples in the stagnation region was found tobe 33 lower than corresponding post-flight predictions of convective heating alone. It washypothesized that this difference could be attributed to radiation from the shock-heated gas,a mechanism not considered in post-flight analyses of flow fields. In order to test thehypothesis and quantify the contribution of shock-layer radiation to total surface heating,ground tests and simulations (both flow and radiation) were performed at several pointsalong the best-estimated entry trajectory of MSL. The present paper provides anassessment of the quality of the radiation model and its impact to stagnation point heating.Although the impact of radiative heating is shown to be significant, it only accounts for 43of the discrepancy. Additional factors behind the remaining discrepancy are discussed.
This paper introduces a method for assessing similarity between available shock-layer radiation measurements and the radiative heating to a vehicle of interest. This method will be referred to as the flowfield property binning (FPB) approach. The challenge in developing this approach is that radiometer measurements from a surface normal line of sight, observed radiation measurements of the entire shock-layer from a distance, or measured shock-tube nonequilibrium profiles are notably different geometrically than the radiative flux to a vehicle surface. Therefore, the relative contributions of various regions of the shock-layer to the measurement, and how these relative contributions compare with the radiative heating to a vehicle of interest, are unclear. By tracking the radiation contribution from each flowfield location, and then grouping this contribution based on two local flowfield properties, these geometric differences are removed. This provide a two dimensional group, or bin, distribution that represents the radiation environment in the same format for various types of radiation simulations, such as observed radiation or radiative flux to a vehicle surface. In the limits of optically-thin radiation transport and thermochemical equilibrium flow, the choice of pressure and temperature as the binning flowfield properties is shown to provide a bin distribution that uniquely defines the radiation simulation. This concept is found to be sufficient for establishing similarity between two cases even when the optically-thin radiation transport and thermochemical equilibrium assumptions are not satisfied. A simple metric of comparison between bin distributions from different cases is provided by the histogram intersection algorithm. This algorithm results in a histogram intersection factor (H) between 0 and 1, which represents the fraction of the radiation that is similar between the two cases. Therefore, if H evaluated between bin distributions for two completely different radiation problems is near 1, then they represent essentially the same radiation problem. This means that they depend on the same weighting of various radiation modeling parameters evaluated at the same pressure and temperature. If one of these cases agrees well with a radiation measurement, then the matching bin distributions provide justification for applying this experimental validation to the other case. Even for H values as low as 0.2, the measurement case could be considered relevant if there are no other useful measurements. This approach allows observed radiation measurements to directly inform radiative heating simulations, which allows NASA’s past and future investments in observed radiation measurements to directly inform the radiative heating uncertainty or margins for future vehicle design. This FPB approach is also used to determine shock-tube conditions for informing backshell radiative heating simulations, where the normal shock velocity and Lagrangian time from the shock is used for the binning variables instead of pressure and temperature.
Past Mars entry missions have made extensive use of 70° sphere-cone forebody heatshields. This shape was chosen for its aerodynamic stability during direct entry, either ballistic or low L/D trajectories. Historic missions, including Viking in 1976, Pathfinder in1997, and Mars Rover in 2004, have provided a large aerodynamic and aerothermodynamic database for the70° sphere-cone shape that perpetuates continued use for future Mars missions. Using 3D Real-Gas Navier-Stokes simulations, we show that once turbulent heating occupies a significant portion of the mission trajectory, undesirable aerothermodynamic properties arise associated with the 70° sphere-cone heatshield geometry. As an additional consideration, the pitch angle to achieve high L/D of a Mars aerocapture trajectory mitigates the stability justification for the 70° sphere-cone. This suggests that alternative forebody geometries should be considered for future Mars missions.
Several different thermochemical models for H2/He mixtures are used to simulate a 1-D shock in a viscous CFD code at conditions relevant for hypersonic entry into the ice and gas giants. These models range from a 6-species, 1-temperature (1-T) model, to more complex 17 and 25-species state-to-state (StS) models. Corresponding radiance profiles for each of these models are then computed using a radiation code, and results are compared to experimental data from the NASA Ames Electric Arc Shock Tube (EAST) facility. Overall, the 6-species model with a quasi-steady state (QSS) solver for atomic H and modified ionization rates, along with the 17 and 25-species StS models, are found to reproduce the magnitude of the radiance seen in the EAST experiments reasonably accurately. Two additional changes to the modeling of species diffusion fluxes are also investigated: the exclusion of a ∇W term, as well as the inclusion of Soret/ Dufour effects. It is determined that these changes to the transport modeling have a negligible impact on the flowfield and therefore the radiance predictions for the H2/He shock conditions considered in this study.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.