Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “intercomparison”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 289 records · Page 16
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS1981

Characteristics of space and ground based total ozone observing systems investigated by intercomparison of Nimbus 4 Backscattered Ultraviolet /BUV/ data with Dobson and M-83 results

The Nimbus 4 Backscattered Ultraviolet (BUV) experiment data has been reprocessed to provide a near global data set covering the seven years from 1970 to 1977. The data set is the result of a three year effort by the Ozone Processing Team which included review and correction of the spacecraft ephemeris, instrument calibration, and processing algorithms. The accuracy of the resulting total ozone determinations compares well with that of ground based data. An important application of the global BUV data set is to use it in determining long term trends in global total ozone. However, in order to identify long term trends in ozone, it is necessary to eliminate first long-term drift in the instrument calibration. A follow on experiment, the Solar Backscattered Ultraviolet/Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer, (SBUV/TOMS), was flown on Nimbus 7 launched in October 1978. The SBUV provides information about both total ozone and vertical ozone profiles for a 200 km square field of view.

Fleig, A. J.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Intercomparison of lunar laser and traditional determinations of earth rotation

Since August, 1969, ranges to one or more retroreflector arrays on the lunar surface have been measured by means of a laser procedure. Analysis of these measurements improves determination, not only of the orbit and librations of the moon, but also of the rotational parameters of the earth, including the X and Y coordinates of the terrestrial pole, and the true rotational angle of the earth with respect to atomic or to broadcast time. The considered approach for deriving the Universal Time 1 (UT1) involves two steps. During the first step the parameters of the lunar orbit and librations are solved along with the coordinates of the retroreflectors on the moon and of the observatory. Improved values of the Universal Time 0 (UT0) and range corrections at the observatory are obtained in the second step. Attention is given to lunar laser ranging (LLR), raw data in UT1, an harmonic analysis of the LLR UT1 data, and data obtained in 1980. The results provide UT1 with an accuracy of a factor of 2 or more better than was previously available from conventional astrometric data.

Fliegel, H. F.↗
NASA NTRS1983

An intercomparison of NEL and DHL water flow facilities using a twin orifice plate flowmeter assembly

A 205 mm transfer standard orifice plate meter assembly, consisting of two orifice plates in series separated by a length of pipe containing a flow straightener, was calibrated in two water flow facilities. Results show that the agreement in the characteristics of such a differential pressure transfer standard package is within 0.17% over a 10:1 range from flow rates of approximately 8 to 80 l/sec. When the range over which the comparison was made was limited to that for which the calibration graphs gave straight lines, the agreement is 0.1% in 3 of the 4 calibrations (0.17% in the fourth).

Dejong, J.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Satellite-in situ measurement intercomparisons at Wallops Island, Virginia

A field program was carried out at Wallops Island, Virginia in which a number of in situ soundings were made during February to May 1980 in conjunction with near overpasses of NOAA-6. A comparison of NOAA-6 measured and derived quantities with those of in situ instruments was made. Positive temperature biases (satellite warmer) were found to appear in the lower troposphere and tropopause regions; negative differences generally were found to appear in the middle and upper stratosphere. Average geopotential height differences were relatively small at all levels, but increasing rms errors showed decreasing reliability with height of satellite geopotential heights. Satellite-derived geostrophic winds were found to have less shear than in situ determined winds. Bias in the directional differences was found to range from less than 5 deg to about 20 deg, with rms differences apparently decreasing near the level of wind speed.

Nestler, M. S.↗
NASA NTRS1984

Intercomparison of NIMBUS 7 solar backscattered ultraviolet ozone profiles with rocket, balloon, and Umkehr profiles

A global ozone data set covering the two years from November 1978 until October 1980, with an average of 1200 profiles per day, has been produced and archived from the solar backscattered ultraviolet (SBUV) instrument flown on the NIMBUS 7 spacecraft. The SBUV ozone profiles are compared with measurements from chemical and optical sensors launched on balloons and rockets and with ozone profiles obtained from the ground-based Dobson spectrophotometers using the Umkehr method. The biases between the SBUV results and the balloon and Umkehr results are generally less than 10 percent. These biases are functions of layer height and latitude and are believed to be largely due to inconsistencies in the ozone absorption cross sections used for the various measurement systems. The precision of the SBUV measurements is found to be better than 8 percent for pressures between 1 and 64 mbar and better than 15 percent from 64 to 253 mbar.

Bhartia, P. K.↗
NASA NTRS1984

Intercomparison of the Nimbus 7 SBUV/TOMS total ozone data sets with Dobson and M83 results

Two years of SBUV/TOMS (Solar Backscattered Ultraviolet/Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer) data spanning the period November 1978 to October 1980 have been processed and compared with ground-based ozone measurements made at 62 Dobson spectrophotometer and 18 M83 filter photometer ozone stations. Results show that the satellite ozone values are consistently smaller than those measured by the stations; most of this difference is probably due to an error in the currently accepted ozone absorption cross sections at ultraviolet wavelengths. Dobson-derived ozone amounts agree extremely well with those derived from each of the satellite instruments. Long-term stability of the ozone derived by the two instruments is expected to be better than 0.5 percent per year.

Bhartia, P. K.↗
NASA NTRS1984

An intercomparison of SAGE and SBUV ozone observations for March and April 1979

Thirty-eight latitudinal cross sections of stratospheric ozone observed by the SAGE (Stratospheric Aerosol and Gas Experiment) and SBUV (Solar Backscattered Ultraviolet) satellite instruments on the same days in March and April 1979 and at approximately the same latitude are compared. Differences in the zonal-mean mixing ratios are found. At pressures less than 5 mbar, SAGE gives approximately 20 percent larger mixing ratios at tropical latitudes (after a correction has been applied for the expected diurnal variation of ozone). The uncorrelated portion of the SBUV variances are smaller than the SAGE noise variances at altitudes above 10 mbar, which indicates that the SBUV experiment should provide excellent detectability of longitudinal ozone variations.

Cunnold, D. M.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Report on the Workshop on Intercomparison of Solar UV Irradiance Measurements and Related Instrument Calibration

The knowledge of the absolute value of the solar ultraviolet irradiance did not improve very much during the rising phase of the solar cycle 21. The variations associated with the solar rotation period were observed by means of three satellites, namely, the Atmospheric Explorer E (AE-E), Nimbus 7 and the Solar Mesospheric Explorer (SME). Long-term variations related to the solar activity cycle are not well known. Values were deduced during the solar cycle 21 from the AE-E satellite and the rocket program performed by the Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics leading to variations of about a factor of 2 around 150 nm but definitely less than 20 percent beyond 175 nm. Such low level of variation is still masked by the current uncertainties and reproducibility of the observations performed since 1976. The uncertainties of recent observations are reported with their discrepancies. The gaps between the current accuracy goals and the achievements are still very important. The challenge for the next three years is to improve both the accuracy and the precision of future observations at the level of the available irradiance standards and to measure quantitatively long-term variations of the order of a few percent. The main causes of these gaps are identified.

Simon, P. C.↗
NASA NTRS1985

Intercomparison of Sea-surface Temperature Anomaly Fields

Sea-surface temperature anomaly fields produced from analysis of HIRS2/MSU data at GLAS for the months November 1979, December 1981, March 1982, and July 1982 were compared to those produced from data from ships, AVHRR, and SMMR in a series of NASA sponsored sea-surface temperature workshops. The methods used by GLAS to analyze the HIRS2/MSU data were made to the algorithm used to retrieve sea and land surface temperatures and in the cloud filtering algorithm. One of the improvements involved generating weights for a given sounding, which decreased with increasing cloudiness and increasing humidity. These weights should be used in generating monthly mean fields. The workshop generated statistics for the weighted HIRS2/MSU field only for the month of July 1982.

Susskind, J.↗
NASA NTRS1984

ACARS wind measurements - An intercomparison with radiosonde, cloud motion and VAS thermally derived winds

Statistical comparisons between winds measured by ACARS and winds obtained from radiosondes, geostationary satellite image cloud motions, and VAS are presented. Observations from three separate comparisons reveal over 60 percent of wind vector magnitude differences are within 9 m/s, and 70 percent of the directional differences are within 15 deg. The comparisons indicate that the ACARS system provides an independent source of wind data that complements other sources of wind data for constructing composite wind field analyses.

Lord, R. J.↗
NASA NTRS1984

Intercomparison of planetary-scale diagnostics derived from separate satellite and radiosonde time-mean temperature fields

The planetary-scale components of the extratropical Northern Hemisphere troposphere-stratosphere 1973-74 winter circulation are diagnosed using separate time-mean temperature fields based on radiosonde and satellite observations. Meridional cross-sections of zonal wind together with, for zonal wavenumbers 1, 2 and 3, the streamfunction amplitude, phase and Eliassen-Palm flux are displayed, with the relative accuracy of the satellite-derived diagnostics assessed through comparison with the 'ground-truth' radiosonde information. The satellite and radiosonde diagnostics compare most favourably in terms of zonal wind speed and shear, direction of wave propagation and meridional wave structure - all of which are closely related to the differential properties of the atmospheric temperature field. The intensity of the satellite-derived patterns of tropospheric wave propagation is underestimated due to the effects of spatial smoothing and residual cloud contamination present in the satellite radiance measurements.

Miles, T.↗
NASA NTRS1983

The absolute amplitude calibration of the SEASAT synthetic aperture radar - An intercomparison with other L-band radar systems

The absolute amplitude calibration of the spaceborne Seasat SAR data set is presented based on previous relative calibration studies. A scale factor making it possible to express the perceived radar brightness of a scene in units of sigma-zero is established. The system components are analyzed for error contribution, and the calibration techniques are introduced for each stage. These include: A/D converter saturation tests; prevention of clipping in the processing step; and converting the digital image into the units of received power. Experimental verification was performed by screening and processing the data of the lava flow surrounding the Pisgah Crater in Southern California, for which previous C-130 airborne scatterometer data were available. The average backscatter difference between the two data sets is estimated to be 2 dB in the brighter, and 4 dB in the dimmer regions. For the SAR a calculated uncertainty of 3 dB is expected.

Held, D.↗
NASA NTRS1984

Intercomparison of stratospheric/mesospheric data; Proceedings of the Topical Meeting, Graz, Austria, June 25-July 7, 1984

Comparative analyses of various stratospheric and mesospheric species, including aerosols, ions, ozone, and some minor species, are presented, based on measurements obtained from rocket, balloon, aircraft, and satellite missions. In addition, studies concerning temperature and density characteristics of the stratosphere and mesosphere are included, as well as discussions on the various sensing and measurement techniques. Finally, dynamics and turbulence measurements are examined; consideration is given to radar winds, solar X-ray and HF radiowave absorption, and ionization irregularities.

Ghazi, A.↗
NASA NTRS1984

Intercomparisons of temperature, density and wind measurements from in situ and satellite techniques

Atmospheric temperature, density, and wind data retrieved by various means are intercompared, covering the 1980-1984 period. The study encompasses such data sources as radiosonde, rocketsonde, in situ measurements, remote measurements, satellites, and NOAA-6 and 7 TOVS data. Larger temperature differences (up to 7-8 K) are noted for the rocketsonde/satellite comparison than for the radiosonde/satellite comparison (less than 1 K). The rocketsonde measurements were found to be internally consistent to less than 1 K up to 50 km and to less than 3 K up to 60 km. A general agreement of the density data obtained from small rocketsondes and large sounding rocket systems is suggested to be within 15 percent up to 85 km of altitude. The usefulness of intermixing the measurements of the various atmospheric parameters obtained from different instruments is emphasized, and some suggestions are made concerning the approaches to such intermixing.

Schmidlin, F. J.↗
NASA NTRS1983

An intercomparison of ozone profile measurements from LIMS, SAGE, and SBUV

Ozone profile measurements by the Limb IR Monitor of Stratosphere (LIMS) and the Solar Backscatter UV (SBUV) aboard the Nimbus satellite, and the Stratospheric Aerosol and Gas Experiment (SAGE) aboard the AEM-2 satellite are intercompared in an effort to assess the quality of satellite ozone retrieval techniques. Good correlation between LIMS and SBUV observations is noted in the ozone layer bounded by pressures of 31.2-15.6 mb; absolute differences are generally less than 10 percent, with similar zonal variations. Above 35 km SAGE values are systematically larger than SBUV or LIMS. The differences generally increase with height and are largest in the tropics. Finally, excellent agreement is noted to exist among the three data sets between 10 and 35 km of altitude with respect to the latitude dependence of the ozone profiles.

Fleig, A. J.↗
NASA NTRS1985

Intercomparison of global SST fields derived from satellite sensors and ship observations

Near global comparisons were made between binned forms of SST obtained from different instruments, ship meteorological observations, and the output of a meteorological model. Binning hereinafter means gridding by simple summation of data values in a bin, which in this study was a 2 deg. x 2 deg. box or a 10 deg. x 10 box surrounding a grid node. In the binned comparisons, the question is asked: are the binned data from two instruments drawn from the same population? The first two measures of statistical moments of the populations are used to test the hypothesis that they are. Comparisons were also attempted between raw forms of the various SST retrievals, using a structure function analysis. The results of this analysis were relatively uninteresting and are therefore omitted.

Pazan, S. E.↗
NASA NTRS1985

Analysis and forecast intercomparisons using the FGGE SOP-1 data base

The First GARP Global Experiment (FGGE) data base has provided the research community with the most complete global coverage of meteorological informaiton since measurements were first taken. It is important to understand the characteristics of the FGGE data base in terms of its accuracy and representativeness compared to the true state of the atmosphere. The uncertainty associated with the initial conditions used in a numerical model plays a significant role in subsequent error growth as shown by predictability theory. The ultimate limit of forecast skill is directly related to the initial uncertainty. The accuracy of analyses using FGGE data base coupled with the errors due to modeling imperfections determines the present skill of numerical models. An estimte of initial uncertainty is determined by examining differences in several FGGE analyses. The estimate is then used to determine an ultimate limit of forecast skill from derived predictability error growth rates. Several different calculations of predictability error growth are also compared. Finally, present-day forecast skill using FGGE analyses is contrasted to the estimates of ultimate skill, and the partition of model error versus initial uncertainty is discussed.

Baumhefner, D. P.↗