Design Guidelines for Predicting Stress in Cemented Doublets Undergoing Temperature Change
This work explores quick predictive methods for calculating potentially risky stresses in cemented doublets underdoing temperature change that agree well with finite element analysis. We also provide guidelines for avoiding stress concentrations. Cemented doublets are ubiquitous in the optics world, but it is not always clear if they will perform as intended in a specific thermal environment due to excessive stress. The stress in the optic can cause debonding or even fracture. Yoder addressed this problem using analytical results from Chen and Nelson but also expressed some skepticism as to the accuracy and usefulness of those results. Closed-form analytical solutions are extremely useful when doing trade-off studies to see if a particular geometry or glass choice will cause stress problems. The problem of bonded materials undergoing temperature change is of great interest in the electronics industry, and improved analytical solutions are now available that address the issues raised by Yoder, and they have been validated using finite element analysis (FEA). But the newer solutions still have limitations. The analytical solutions presented here cannot predict stresses due to stress concentrations or singularities at the edge of the bondline—this still has to be done using FEA—although some advanced methods are available. Also, the existing analytical methods assume a flat interface between adjoining elements; they do not account for the effect of curvature. We find that most doublet failures start at the edges and involve debonding of the glass. Glass fracture is rare for doublets, accounting for less than 10% of the failures. This paper provides the reader with a general introduction to a large and dense body of literature in order to demystify the subject of temperature-induced glass bonding failures.