Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Reactor Structure”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 307 records · Page 17
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2024

3D printed optimized electrodes for electrochemical flow reactors

Recent advances in 3D printing have enabled the manufacture of porous electrodes which cannot be machined using traditional methods. With micron-scale precision, the pore structure of an electrode can now be designed for optimal energy efficiency, and a 3D printed electrode is not limited to a single uniform porosity. As these electrodes scale in size, however, the total number of possible pore designs can be intractable; choosing an appropriate pore distribution manually can be a complex task. To address this challenge, we adopt an inverse design approach. Using physics-based models, the electrode structure is optimized to minimize power losses in a flow reactor. The computer-generated structure is then printed and benchmarked against homogeneous porosity electrodes. We show how an optimized electrode decreases the power requirements by 16% compared to the best-case homogeneous porosity. Future work could apply this approach to flow batteries, electrolyzers, and fuel cells to accelerate their design and implementation.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Neutronic design and fuel cycle analysis of a fluoride salt-cooled High Temperature Reactor (FHR)

The Fluoride salt-cooled High temperature Reactor (FHR) is a new Gen IV reactor concept that can operate under near atmospheric pressure circumstances and further enhance the inherent safety. In this study, an FHR core design with 165 megawatts of thermal output (MWth) is proposed. The reactor core employs tri-structural-isotropic (TRISO) particle fuel within prismatic graphite blocks as the basic fuel form, FLiBe (2 {sup 7}LiF-BeF{sub 2}) as the primary coolant, and a three-batch fuel cycle scheme. Sensitivity analyses on various parameters were performed to optimize the cycle length and neutronic parameters. The fuel cycle of this core design was evaluated in detail from 4 aspects: cycle length, power peaking factor (PPF), discharge burnup, and temperature coefficient. It was found that larger fuel channel pitch (FCP) would have a relatively harder neutron spectrum, and yield relatively longer cycle length, lower, better fuel temperature coefficient (FTC), and moderator temperature coefficient (MTC). In addition, burnable poison (BP), Er{sub 2}O{sub 3}, can effectively reduce PPF, hold down the multiplication factor, and more importantly it can improve the MTC. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗
DOE OSTI2022

Cluster dynamics modeling of Mn-Ni-Si precipitates coupled with radiation-induced segregation in low-Cu reactor pressure vessel steels

Formation of precipitates enhanced or induced by irradiation causes hardening and embrittlement of nuclear structural materials. Post-irradiation microstructure characterization of reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels has shown that precipitation can be strongly associated with radiation-induced segregation (RIS) of solutes on dislocations. However, RIS and precipitation have not been coupled in previous precipitation modeling of RPV steels. Here in this study, a new hybrid and spatially-dependent precipitation model is developed that couples cluster dynamics with RIS, providing an unique way to account for concurrent evolution of heterogeneous cluster densities as well as solute and point defect concentration profiles. The model is applied to study the segregation of Mn, Ni, and Si on dislocations and heterogeneous nucleation of Mn-Ni-Si rich precipitates (MNSPs) in a low-Cu RPV steel. The result shows that the onset of MNSP nucleation on dislocations occurs at the fluence of 2 x 10 23 n.m -2 . The number density and mean radius can reach ~ 10 24 m -3 and 1-2 nm at high fluence, respectively. These observations suggest that the role of RIS and heterogeneous nucleation can be significant for RPV steels under a high fluence of irradiation. Results of simulations adopting various dose rates and dislocation densities show an increased fraction of MNSPs on dislocations at the condition of low dose rate, high dislocation density, and high fluence.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Modeling Nondestructive Defect Detection in Additively Manufactured Metallic Structures for Nuclear Applications

The future of quickly, economically produced metallic nuclear reactor parts with minimal supply-chain dependence lies in Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) Additive Manufacturing (AM): a 3D printing method involving laser melting and net shaping stainless steel and Inconel metallic powder into a solid structure. However, intrinsic features in LPBF frequently leads to the formation of materials defects, such as pores, within 3D printed structures. As safe long-term use in energy applications requires knowledge of all relevant defects before deployment in a reactor, we must develop methods for nondestructive detection of these defects. We are investigating Pulsed Thermal Tomography (PTT), which is a non-contact nondestructive imaging method scalable to arbitrary structure size. Thermal tomography (TT) is a computational method for 3D spatial reconstruction of material thermal effusivity from flash or pulsed thermography temperature data cube. Thermography data cube consists of 2D surface temperature measurements at different times. The objective of the present work is to investigate limits on defect detection in AM metallic structures with PTT. To this effect, we modeled PTT with COMSOL heat transfer computer simulations. We developed a layered media COMSOL simulation consisting of a Stainless Steel 316 (SS316) plate with an internal layer of un-sintered SS316 powder. Thermophysical properties of the powder layer were modeled with equivalent volume mixing model. To account for partial sintering at the boundary of the defect, the transition between solid and powder layers was modeled as a Gaussian. Using data from COMSOL simulations, we reconstructed depth-dependent thermal effusivity, which allowed defect visibility estimation. A series of parametric studies determined that at 1mm depth, 50µm is the smallest detectable defect. In addition, classification of the defects which can lead to early fatigue of the metallic structure in a reactor is briefly discussed.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2024

Environmentally Assisted Fatigue in Light Water Reactor Environment

This report summarizes the Environmentally Assisted Fatigue (EAF) research conducted at ANL under the US DOE Light Water Reactor Sustainability (LWRS) program. Starting from a rich background in theoretical and experimental EAF, ANL previously developed an approach to evaluate fatigue performance of reactor materials in light water reactor environments with the correction factor F en . The approach was based on a large body of experimental work performed at ANL and elsewhere, and was consistent with American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME)’s methodology governing the design and construction of reactor components. In recent years, the program was focused on component fatigue prediction and made several major and fundamental contributions in this area. These accomplishments help meet the needs identified by the industry concerning component level fatigue predictions in complex, transient conditions. The main contribution of the ANL program involved the development of a system-level model for estimating residual strain and life of nuclear reactor coolant system components under connected-system-thermal-mechanical boundary conditions. The goal was to predict the stress hotspots, strain residuals, strain amplitudes and the resulting fatigue lives. Thermal-mechanical stress analysis was performed considering thermal stratification and a design-basis reactor loading cycle. Based on the finite element (FE) model results, the strain residuals, strain amplitudes and resulting fatigue lives of reactor coolant system (RCS) components were predicted. The results show that some of the RCS components can have significantly different strain amplitudes, residual strain, and fatigue lives, despite having similar geometry and material. In addition, the simulated component-level strain profile can guide the selection of appropriate test inputs for conducting laboratory-scale EAF tests. Building upon the system-level model, ANL developed a digital twin (DT) framework to predict the structural states and associated fatigue life of components in real-time. This framework is a comprehensive system designed to predict the structural states and fatigue lives of reactor components. It includes multiple models and integrates artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML), and FE based modeling tools to evaluate the structural states and fatigue lives.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Graphite Licensing (ASME) and Testing (ASTM) Technical Assistance

DOE ART Graphite R&D program is currently involved in developing the structural code for licensing the new High Temperature Reactor (HTR) designs through the ASME Boiler Pressure Vessel Code (BPVC). The basic structural design code for graphite core components has been written, approved, and within the BPVC since 2012. However, several areas within the graphite code remain to be improved, specifically the addition of material property changes resulting from environmental degradation (neutron flux and oxidation). The incorporation of this data, which can significantly affect the graphite components and alter the structural integrity of the core during operation, is proving to be an important activity. How this data will be incorporated within the code and how it will be used for license applications will be critical to a number of HTR applicants in the future. These modifications to the code must take into account the unique irradiation and oxidation response of the wide spectrum of available nuclear graphite grades currently under consideration for HTR applications. Additionally, the ASME BPVC requires material property testing within the expected operational conditions of the HTR core including neutron radiation flux, elevated temperatures, and after chronic/acute oxidation of the graphite components. Currently, no standardized graphite testing methods are approved for these environmental conditions. New American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standardized tests for elevated temperature testing, small sample testing, and testing after oxidation must be developed to support the requirements within the ASME code.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Development of MOSCATO: A CFD-Level Electrochemistry and Corrosion Simulator for Molten Salt Systems

For both coolant and fueled variants of molten salt reactors (MSRs), the corrosion of structural materials is a significant challenge. The corrosion stems from chemical and electrochemical reactions initiated by fissile material, fission products, and impurities in the salt. Lower-fidelity models rely on empirical correlations for mass transfer, simplified lumped temperature profiles, and similar assumptions. They do not capture detailed spatial variations in complex geometries, creating the need for high-fidelity modeling to bridge this gap.As we approach the demonstration and possible deployment of MSRs in this decade, the development of a high-fidelity, high-performance simulator becomes imperative. To simulate the complex electrochemical environment and corrosion within molten salt systems, we have developed the Molten Salt Chemistry And TranspOrt (MOSCATO) code. This endeavor is comprised of three essential components. First, mass transfer equations are coupled with the Navier-Stokes equations in order to account for the transport of species in the salt. Second, the diffusion of alloy constituents, such as Cr, Fe, Ni, etc. is simulated within the structural metals. Third, the alloy and salt domains are coupled to account for the heterogeneous chemical and electrochemical reactions that occur at the salt-alloy interface.MOSCATO manages all three components within the framework of the highly scalable, open-source spectral element method computational fluid dynamics code Nek5000/NekRS. This integration enables MOSCATO to harness the immense computational power of modern high-performance computing resources, ensuring both high fidelity and computational speed.In addition to code development, we have initiated a comprehensive verification and validation campaign, utilizing data from diverse sources. First, MOSCATO's electrochemical solver was verified with reference numerical data. Then validation occurred against experiments: one of a thermal galvanic cell and the other for corrosion in flowing molten salt of FLiNaK (LiF-NaF-KF). This campaign verified and validated MOSCATO as a reliable tool for simulating electrochemical environments and corrosion in molten salt systems.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Modular high temperature gas reactor core modeling with RELAP5-3D/PHISICS – Optimization schemes for load following

The objective of this study is to develop a 3D/NK model to study the load following operation of a Modular High-Temperature Gas-Cooled Reactor (MHTGR). The selected design is the 350 MW prismatic, graphite moderated, helium cooled thermal reactor based on the MHTGR-350 transient benchmark led by the High-Temperature Gas-Cooled Reactor (HTGR) Methods Core Simulation Group at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) in the framework of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development Nuclear Energy Agency (OECD/NEA). This kind of reactor usually reacts very slowly to the perturbation of the core parameters due to the large amount of graphite in the core. This kind of behavior promotes the reactor stability but on the other hand limits the reactor load-following operability. Recently advances in gas reactor designs have made load-following in gas reactors a feasible and achievable goal. Modern nuclear reactors (such as the MHTGR-350) are designed to withstand the structural stresses associated with load-following. Operating the reactor in load-following mode will inevitably reduce the load factor. Although a higher load factor means more revenue and the best usage of the fuel, following the variable energy demand will increase the maximum achievable fraction of generated nuclear power, being no more limited to the base load power generation. In general, if low impact on material aging and the safe operability are demonstrated the plant economics will be minimally affected. In order to ensure that the system can be safely operated in a load-following mode an extensively study has been carried out. Some tests with linear coolant mass flow rate change demonstrated that the reactor behavior is suitable for operation in load following mode. This assumption has been confirmed by a 4 days load following transient test in which the reactor supplied the requested power with a negligible error.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
NASA NTRS2013

Deleterious Thermal Effects Due To Randomized Flow Paths in Pebble Bed, and Particle Bed Style Reactors

A review of literature associated with Pebble Bed and Particle Bed reactor core research has revealed a systemic problem inherent to reactor core concepts which utilize randomized rather than structured coolant channel flow paths. For both the Pebble Bed and Particle Bed Reactor designs; case studies reveal that for indeterminate reasons, regions within the core would suffer from excessive heating leading to thermal runaway and localized fuel melting. A thermal Computational Fluid Dynamics model was utilized to verify that In both the Pebble Bed and Particle Bed Reactor concepts randomized coolant channel pathways combined with localized high temperature regions would work together to resist the flow of coolant diverting it away from where it is needed the most to cooler less resistive pathways where it is needed the least. In other words given the choice via randomized coolant pathways the reactor coolant will take the path of least resistance, and hot zones offer the highest resistance. Having identified the relationship between randomized coolant channel pathways and localized fuel melting it is now safe to assume that other reactor concepts that utilize randomized coolant pathways such as the foam core reactor are also susceptible to this phenomenon.

Moran, Robert P.↗
DOE OSTI2025

High Radiation Resistance in the Binary W‐Ta System Through Small V Additions: A New Paradigm for Nuclear Fusion Materials

Abstract Refractory High‐Entropy Alloys (RHEAs) are promising candidates for structural materials in nuclear fusion reactors, where W‐based alloys are currently leading. Fusion materials must withstand extreme conditions, including i) severe radiation damage from energetic neutrons, ii) embrittlement due to H and He ion implantation, and iii) exposure to high temperatures and thermal gradients. Recent RHEAs, such as WTaCrV and WTaCrVHf, have shown superior radiation tolerance and microstructural stability compared to pure W, but their multi‐element compositions complicate bulk fabrication and limit practical use. In this study, it is demonstrated that reducing alloying elements in RHEAs is feasible without compromising radiation tolerance. Herein, two Highly Concentrated Refractory Alloys (HCRAs) − W 53 Ta 44 V 3 and W 53 Ta 42 V 5 (at.%) − were synthesized and investigated. We found that small V additions significantly influence the radiation response of the binary W–Ta system. Experimental results, supported by ab‐initio Monte Carlo simulations and machine‐learning‐driven molecular dynamics, reveal that minor variations in V content enhance Ta–V chemical short‐range order (CSRO), improving radiation resistance in the W 53 Ta 42 V 5 HCRA. By focusing on reducing chemical complexity and the number of alloying elements, the conventional high‐entropy alloy paradigm is challenged, suggesting a new approach to designing simplified multi‐component alloys with refractory properties for thermonuclear fusion applications.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2021

Dynamic observation of dual-beam irradiated Fe and Fe-10Cr alloys at 435 °C

The attractive mechanical properties and superior resistance to void-swelling make ferritic/martensitic alloys a promising structural material for advanced nuclear reactors. However, one anomaly that has intrigued researchers for more than 50 years is the proportion of two types of dislocation loops in Fe and Fe-Cr alloys with Burger vectors b=½<111> and b=<100>. Although the possible mechanisms responsible for the presence of <100> loops continue to be the subject of intense modeling studies, there remains incomplete experimental understanding of fundamental irradiation processes in Fe(Cr) alloys. Here, the dose dependence of the irradiation-induced microstructural evolution was examined from 0 to 20 displacement per atom (dpa) in high purity Fe and Fe-10Cr during simultaneous dual-beam (1 MeV Kr + 10 appm He/dpa) irradiation at 435 °C. We experimentally revealed that the mechanism for the formation of <100> loops may not follow the conventional simple dislocation reaction between two 1½<111> loops. Real-time dynamic formation and evolution of defects including black dot loops, loop coarsening, loop decoration, network dislocations, and cavities were demonstrated. Several results indicated that the addition of Cr and He could impede dislocation loop motion. The evolution of the defect size/density and relative fraction of ½<111> vs <100> loops were quantitatively summarized. With increasing dose, ½<111> loops became the dominant type of loop in both materials. Notably, <100> loops were predominantly observed near grain boundaries only for pure Fe, while arrays of nanoscale black dot defects composing the <100> loop strings were observed in plenty in Fe-10Cr.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Thermal Stability and Ion Irradiation Response of Refined Grained V – 4Cr – 4Ti

Since the 1960’s, there has been interest in V-4Cr-4Ti and similar alloys as candidates for low activation structural materials for advanced nuclear reactors. V-4Cr-4Ti was produced using arc melting and subsequently subjected to large strain extrusion machining to produce a multimodal microstructure largely composed of nanocrystalline and ultrafine grain sizes. In-situ thermal stability of the multimodal V-4Cr-4Ti to 800 °C shows the formation of vanadium carbides with negligible grain growth. In-situ dual-beam 16 KeV He+ and 1 MeV Kr2+ ion irradiation performed at 700 °C to a final dose of ~5 displacements per atom show the formation of small He cavities well distributed throughout the system, with preferential clustering at grain boundaries. This work provides insight into how the increased fraction of grain boundaries affect the simultaneous dual beam ion irradiation response of multimodal V – 4 wt.% Cr – 4 wt.% Ti at elevated temperatures. Analysis of the cavities reveal an areal density of 0.024±0.007 cavities/nm2 and swelling of 0.236% after the dual-beam ion irradiation. Nanoindentation shows a ~50% increase in hardening after the ion irradiation at 700 °C.

TEM↗
DOE OSTI2022

Anisotropic temperature-dependent elastic constants and thermal conductivities of TRISO particle coatings

Tristructural isotropic (TRISO) particles show great promise as a candidate fuel for use in several next-generation high-temperature nuclear reactor designs due to their structural integrity and fuel performance at high temperatures and burnups. Computational codes exist that can simulate TRISO fuel performance characteristics and failure probabilities under extreme conditions which require knowledge of the TRISO coatings’ thermophysical properties. The thermophysical descriptions of the TRISO particle's layers (i.e., buffer, pyrolytic carbon, and silicon carbide) currently used in fuel performance codes, however, assume that many of these properties are constant with respect to temperature or texture. In this paper, we obtain the full elastic stiffness tensors of the carbon and silicon carbide layers, which have transversely isotropic symmetry. Additionally, the calculated elastic properties of each of the coating layers are in remarkable agreement with the current models at room temperature and correct orientations. Additionally, the textured 3C-SiC layer was found to exhibit novel auxetic behavior above 1500 °C. The anisotropic temperature-dependent thermal conductivities of the carbon layers were calculated using acoustical Grüneisen-Debye theory which are in excellent agreement with current models at room temperature and correct orientations. These texture- and temperature-dependent relationships can be incorporated into the thermophysical description of TRISO particles in order to more accurately model fuel performance and failure probabilities under extreme conditions in forthcoming high-fidelity computational simulations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

No ball milling needed: Alternative ODS steel manufacturing with gas atomization reaction synthesis (GARS) and friction-based processing

Oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) steels are promising structural materials for future fusion reactors. The high-density (~10 23 /m 3 ) of highly stable Y-(Ti)-O nano-oxides provide high sink strength for radiation resistance and high-temperature (> 650 °C) creep strength. Concomitantly, helium management is enabled by trapping high density (~10 23 /m 3 ) of small (< 3 nm) helium bubbles in the vicinity of nano-oxides. However, conventional route of making ODS steels involves prolonged ball milling, canning, degassing, and laborious thermo-mechanical processing (TMP). Such route, especially the batch-by-batch ball milling step, faces persistent challenge with scalability and high costs. Gas atomization reaction synthesis (GARS) method has demonstrated the potential of making precursor ODS steel powders without ball milling, but the nano-oxide density was around 10 21 /m 3 in the final consolidated form by conventional TMP. Taking advantage of GARS precursor powder, we use friction-based processing, including friction consolidation and extrusion, to manufacture ODS steel with further improved nano-oxide characteristics. Here, preliminary results showed that Y/Ti/O species were intimately mixed and rapidly reacted to form nano-oxides with a number density of ~10 22 /m 3 .

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Accurate Fe–He machine learning potential for studying He effects in BCC-Fe

Nanostructured Ferritic Alloys (NFAs) containing oxide nanoparticles are prospective advanced structural materials in future fusion reactors. Lacking fusion neutron sources with an adequate flux, modeling is critical to understand radiation damage in the NFAs, including helium effects. Machine learning interatomic potentials (MLPs) have been demonstrated to be capable of describing atomic interactions in chemically complex systems with comparable accuracy to density functional theory (DFT) but with much less computational costs. Hence, MLPs are chosen to study He bubble accumulation in chemically complex NFAs. As a preliminary step, we develop a Fe–He potential, based on ~10,000 atomic configurations. The developed MLP accurately predicts the bulk properties of BCC-Fe compared to DFT, including the lattice constant (2.832 Å), elastic constants (c 11 = 271 GPa, c 12 = 141, c 44 = 93), and phonon frequencies (maximum error < 3.5%). The MLP predicts He binding energies in He n V bubbles and He n clusters with a mean absolute error (MAE) of only ~70 meV, which is ~3 to ~5 times smaller than the MAE of binding energies estimated using empirical potentials. The MLP also accurately predicts the migration barrier of interstitial He (64 meV). Furthermore, the MLP correctly predicts the maximum number of He atoms (critical size) at which a He n V bubble (He n cluster) can kick-out a self-interstitial atom (SIA), forming a bigger He n V 2 bubble (He n V bubble). Subsequently, we use the MLP to perform molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the effect of temperature on the critical size of He n V bubbles and He n clusters. We find that the critical size decreases with increasing temperature — indicating that smaller bubbles and clusters can kick-out an SIA at higher temperatures, thereby escalating the He bubble growth. We report the current Fe–He MLP can be further developed to include all chemical interactions in NFAs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Length scale effects of micro- and meso-scale tensile tests of unirradiated and irradiated Zircaloy-4 cladding

Zircaloy-4 is an essential material for cladding structures within fission-based reactors. To explore the changes in properties measured on differing length scales, FIB-machined micro-scale tensile tests were performed on both irradiated and control groups of Zircaloy-4. This was correlated with tensile testing on femtosecond laser-machined meso-scale specimens. Pronounced size effects were found when varying specimen geometry. Increases in tensile geometry size were associated with a reduction in measured yield stress for both irradiated and unirradiated samples. Here, meso-scale testing found strength and strain values similar to that of bulk-scale testing.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Understanding the effect of minor alloying elements on helium bubble formation in ferritic-martensitic steels

Ferritic-martensitic steels are promising structural materials for advanced nuclear reactors. To minimize long-term radioactivity, reduced-activation ferritic-martensitic steels have been developed by substituting high-activation elements like Ni and Mo with low-activation elements such as W. However, the impact of these alloying modifications on helium bubble formation, which plays a key role in material swelling, remains unclear. Here, in this study, we compared helium bubble formation in ferritic-martensitic steel T91 and reduced-activation ferritic-martensitic steel F82H. Both materials were irradiated with sequential 100 keV, 150 keV, and 200 keV helium ions to a dose of 0.5 dpa and a helium concentration of 9,000 appm at 500°C. The helium bubbles in F82H exhibited a larger average size and a lower density than those in T91, suggesting differences in minor alloying elements may influence the bubble growth. Here, to investigate the effects of these alloying elements, we characterized radiation-induced segregation near bubbles and grain boundaries. Prominent Ni-Mn-Si enriched clusters were found near bubbles in T91, while only Mn-Si enriched clusters were found near bubbles in F82H. In addition, the obvious Cr enrichment near grain boundaries was absent around bubbles in both steels. The different segregation trends among elements revealed the variations in element diffusion mechanisms and the different sink biases between bubbles and grain boundaries. Cr enrichment near grain boundaries is mostly driven by interstitial-mediated diffusion. However, since bubble growth relies on net vacancy flux, vacancy-mediated diffusion plays a dominant role in controlling element segregation near bubbles. Therefore, Cr enrichment was not found near bubbles. Because of preferential vacancy-drag diffusion for Ni, Si and Mn, these elements were enriched near bubbles. Due to the strong binding energies of vacancies with these solute atoms, the vacancy diffusivity can be reduced near these solutes. Therefore, the more prominent Ni-Si-Mn clustered near helium bubbles in T91 lead to stronger suppression of helium bubble growth compared to F82H.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗