Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “dynamic fracture”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 307 records · Page 17

Impact Testing of Heat Source Exemplars

This report details the heat source impact testing performed at the Shock Thermodynamics Applied Research Facility (STAR). The purpose of these tests were to measure the impact behavior of a heated Ta-10W tantalum/tungsten alloy heat source exemplar. Each exemplar resembled a cylinder with a rectangular through-hole orthogonal to the cylinder axis-of-symmetry. In each test, the exemplar was impacted by a hardened steel impactor accelerated using the STAR air gun. The exemplars were impacted perpendicular to the through-hole and at an an angle to the cylindrical axis-of-symmetry. The exemplar bar stock source, impact angle, and impact velocity were varied throughout the testing series. High-speed video was used to measure dynamic impact behavior while photon doppler velocimetry (PDV) and shorting pins were used to measure the impact velocity. Foam support structures were used to thermally isolate the exemplar and provide a support structure which was non-perturbative to the impact event. Soft-catch techniques were used to minimize secondary impacts and enable recovery for detailed post-shot analysis. Results indicate positive correlation between exemplar fracture and the variables of impact velocity and impact angle. Exemplar fracture occurred consistently along a single corner of the through-hole.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Understanding the effect of friction stir processing on electrical steel: Microstructural changes and mechanical transformations

Raising Si beyond 3.5 wt% reduces core loss but embrittles electrical steels, constraining processing and application. Here we assess friction stir processing (FSP) as a solid‑state route to enable Fe–4.0 wt% Si with improved mechanical performance. Temperature‑controlled FSP with a PcBN tool produced a defect‑free processed zone. SEM/EBSD revealed dynamic recrystallization and grain refinement from an average 110 μm in the base material to ∼20 μm in the processed region, with ∼ 80% of grains < 40 μm and a reduction in high‑angle boundary fraction to ∼65% (vs >85% in the base). Comparative mechanical property analysis shows a moderate increase in yield strength in FSP samples relative to the base material, with a significant improvement in ductility (∼35–50%). Post‑fracture EBSD identified 60° twin boundaries in the base while sub-grain formation with elevated KAM in the FSP sample. Fractography revealed a shift from quasi‑cleavage in the Base-faceted planes with river patterns, steps, and occasional secondary cracks—to ductile micro void coalescence after FSP. Following FSP, the material retains soft‑magnetic behavior, with modest shifts in saturation magnetization consistent with grain refinement and stored strain, accompanied by a clear gain in formability. These results indicate that FSP provides a viable route to deploy higher‑Si electrical steels with concurrent gains in strength and ductility.

Electrical steel↗

Dynamic Bottlebrush Polymer Networks: Self-Healing in Super-Soft Materials

Here, we introduce a design strategy to expand the range of accessible mechanical properties in covalent adaptable networks (CANs) using bottlebrush polymer building blocks. Well-defined bottlebrush polymers with rubbery poly(4-methylcaprolactone) side-chains were crosslinked in formulations that include a bislactone and strong Lewis acid (tin ethylhexanoate). The resulting materials exhibit tunable stress relaxation rates at elevated temperatures (160–180 °C) due to dynamic ester crosslinks that undergo transesterification with residual hydroxy groups. Varying the crosslinker loading or bottlebrush backbone degree of polymerization yields predictable low-frequency shear moduli ca. 10–100 kPa, well below values typical of linear polymer CANs (1 MPa). These extensible networks can be stretched to strains as large as 350% before failure and undergo efficient self-healing to recover >85% of their original toughness upon repeated fracture and melt processing. In summary, molecular architecture creates new opportunities to tailor the mechanical properties of CANs in ways that are otherwise difficult to achieve.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Report Summarizing the Mechanical Properties of a Large ODS Ferritic Alloy Ingot by Forging at High Temperatures for Future Mother Tube Production

Oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) ferritic alloys are considered the benchmark fuel cladding and core structural material in advanced nuclear energy reactors that require high-temperature strength and creep properties and resistance to radiation damage. The ODS ferritic alloys including 14YWT are produced by mechanical alloying (MA), which is time-consuming and is associated with high manufacturing costs that are not beneficial to being used in advanced nuclear energy reactors. This report summarizes the accomplishments in FY24 in the INM program for producing an ODS ferritic alloy by high-deformation, high-temperature processing of reactive and ferritic alloy powders for advanced reactor fuel cladding applications. Following four hot forging experiments, it was concluded that several significant challenges were encountered that were difficult to overcome. These challenges were related to using high annealing temperatures for pressure assisted sintering processes to produce dense microstructures, but the high annealing temperatures result in long range diffusion of Ti through the bcc Fe lattice and react with the YIG particles that are distributed on the prior surfaces of the ferritic alloy powders. In addition, it was determined that the high deformations induced by forging at high temperatures were not very effective for fracturing the reactive YIG particles into smaller particles and distributing them into the interior of the ferritic alloy powders. Spark plasma sintering was attempted for shortening the time at high temperatures, which led to full densification but the microstructure characterization results still showed that Ti atoms diffused over long distances in the bcc Fe lattice and reacted with the YIG particles. Finally, a short 30 minute high intensity ball milling experiment was conducted on blended 14WT and YIG powders for inducing severe deformations that caused the initially spherical powders of 14WT decorated with the YIG particles on the surfaces to transform to flakes and fracturing of YIG particles into smaller particles that were incorporated into the bcc Fe lattice. Two forgings were performed with the high intensity milled powders: first annealing for 20 minutes at 850ºC followed by forging and second annealing for 20 minutes at 1,100ºC followed by forging. At 850ºC, Ti atoms are effectively immobile, thus allowing for densification albeit incomplete. The deformation by forging after annealing for 20 minutes at 1,100ºC favored dynamic recrystallization processes that led to nano-size grains with very high stored energy due to high dislocation density. The corresponding VH data showed significant hardening that correlated with estimated strengthening of ~1650 MPa. This hybrid processing approach combining high intensity ball milling of powder with annealing and forging showed the most promise for producing an oxide dispersing strengthened ferritic alloy.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Inertia-induced mixing and reaction maximization in laminar porous media flows

Solute transport and biogeochemical reactions in porous and fractured media flows are controlled by mixing, as are subsurface engineering operations such as contaminant remediation, geothermal energy production, and carbon sequestration. Porous media flows are generally regarded as slow, so the effects of fluid inertia on mixing and reaction are typically ignored. Here, we demonstrate through microfluidic experiments and numerical simulations of mixing-induced reaction that inertial recirculating flows readily emerge in laminar porous media flows and dramatically alter mixing and reaction dynamics. An optimal Reynolds number that maximizes the reaction rate is observed for individual pore throats of different sizes. This reaction maximization is attributed to the effects of recirculation flows on reactant availability, mixing, and reaction completion, which depend on the topology of recirculation relative to the boundary of the reactants or mixing interface. Recirculation enhances mixing and reactant availability, but a further increase in flow velocity reduces the residence time in recirculation, leading to a decrease in reaction rate. The reaction maximization is also confirmed in a flow channel with grain inclusions and randomized porous media. Interestingly, the domain-wide reaction rate shows a dramatic increase with increasing Re in the randomized porous media case. This is because fluid inertia induces complex three-dimensional flows in randomized porous media, which significantly increases transverse spreading and mixing. This study shows how inertial flows control reaction dynamics at the pore scale and beyond, thus having major implications for a wide range of environmental systems.

Chen, Michael A. (ORCID:0000000294614710)↗

Accelerated Self-Healing and Property Recovery in Brush Particle Solids Featuring Brush Dispersity

Brush particles, hybrid materials consisting of polymer chains tethered to particle surfaces, offer tunable properties that make them promising candidates for advanced functional materials. This study investigated the role of chain dispersity in the viscoelastic self-healing of poly (methyl acrylate) (PMA)-based brush particle solids. Increasing the molecular weight dispersity of grafted chains significantly enhanced both strain-to-fracture and toughness of brush particle solids, while the elastic modulus and glass transition temperature were independent of chain dispersity. Cut-and-adhere testing revealed a significant acceleration of the rate of toughness recovery in high-dispersity systems as compared to low-dispersity analogs for which toughness recovery markedly lagged the recovery of Young’s modulus. The results suggest that structure and property recovery in brush particle solids are sensitive to the dynamical heterogeneity of brush canopies and highlight the role of molecular weight dispersity as a design parameter to enable hybrid materials with advanced self-healing ability.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Brittle-to-Ductile Transition Temperature Decreases at the Microscale in Muscovite Mica

Characterizing the structural and chemical transitions of muscovite mica across various scales and thermal profiles is essential for ensuring the reliability of high-voltage power insulation, aerospace thermal barriers, and nanoscale semiconductor substrates under extreme operational stress. Here, we investigate notch fracture toughness $K^{n}_{Ic}$ of muscovite mica as a function of feature size w and temperature T with microscale shear testing. $K^{n}_{Ic}$ decreased and then stayed constant as w increased, likely from fabrication-induced changes to the microstructure and roughness. Moreover, $K^{n}_{Ic}$ initially decreased and then increased as temperature T increased, with the reversal in trend indicative of a brittle-to-ductile transition. Complementary Raman spectroscopy and molecular dynamics showed that the observed trends were due to an increase in bond lengths and a decrease in critical stresses/strains. In comparing the microscale results to macroscale counterparts, it was surmised that the decrease in brittle-to-ductile transition temperature was due to an increase in the dehydroxylation rate.

DelRio, Frank W. [Sandia National Laboratories (SN↗

Effects of Interactions Between Produced Formation Fluid and Rock Matrix on Pore Structure of Caney Shale, Southern Oklahoma

ABSTRACT: Rock-fluid interactions change properties of shales during exploitation. To investigate effects of rock-fluid interactions on pore structure of shales matrix after hydraulic fracturing, powder samples from two late Mississippian Caney Shale cores in the Ardmore Basin, southern Oklahoma, were used to react with formation produced fluid from the field in the batch reactor analysis. X-ray diffraction for mineralogy and Low-pressure nitrogen adsorption isotherms for pore structure were measured for original, after-7days, and after-30days samples. Results show that the samples consist mainly of quartz, followed by clay minerals, carbonates, and feldspar. The pore sizes of micropore (<2 nm) and mesopore (2-50 nm) increase 14%-233% due to dissolution of pyrite, feldspar, and carbonates after 7 days. Due to the transformation from smectite to illite and the increase of pore size, the specific surface area (SSA) decreases after 7-days interactions. After 30-days interactions, the micropore volume slightly increases and the mesopore and macropore volume decreases. Due to the decrease of pore size, the SSA of 30-days reacted samples increases correspondingly and is lower (for the clay-rich sample) or higher (for the calcareous sample) than that of the unreacted samples. Findings improve our understanding of dynamic alteration of shale properties during production. 1. INTRODUCTION Energy demand will continuously grow owing to the increasing global population as well as energy consumption (EIA, 2023). On the other hand, shale gas and oil reshaped the energy market in the United States, enabling the United States to become a net-export of natural gas country in 2017 (EIA, 2023). However, shale reservoirs are challenging tight formations that are still poorly understood in the extraction and production of hydrocarbons (Ross and Bustin, 2009; Curtis et al., 2012; Xiong et al., 2015, 2021a; Li Y. et al., 2016; Gong et al., 2019a; Benge et al., 2021; Awejori et al., 2022; Huang et al., 2022). One of the most challenging topics is the rock-fluid interactions post hydraulic fracturing and its subsequent impacts on the pore structures of fractured formation matrix.

Xiong, Fengyang↗

Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Insights into Stress Corrosion Cracking and Dissolution of Metal Oxides

Oxide phases such as α-Fe2O3 (hematite) and α-Al2O3 (corundum) are highly insoluble in water; however, subcritical crack growth has been observed in humidity nonetheless. Chemically induced bond breaking at the crack tip appears unlikely due to sterically hindered molecular transport. The molecular mechanics of a crack in corundum with a reactive force field reveal minimal lattice trapping, leading to bond breaking before sufficient space opens for water transport. To address this, we model a pre-built blunt crack with space for H2O molecule adsorption at the tip and show that it reduces fracture toughness by lowering the critical J-integral. Then, we explore stress-enhanced dissolution to understand the mechanism of crack tip blunting in the oxide/water system. Density functional theory combined with metadynamics was employed to describe atomic dissolution from flat hematite and corundum surfaces in pure water. Strain accelerates dissolution, stabilizing intermediate states with broken bonds before full atom detachment, while the free energy profile of unstrained surfaces is almost monotonic. The atomistic calculations provided input for a kinetic model, predicting the shape evolution of a blunt crack tip, which displays three distinct regimes: (i) dissolution primarily away from the tip, (ii) enhanced blunting near but not at the apex, and (iii) sharpening near the apex. The transition between regimes occurs at a low strain, highlighting the critical role of water in the subcritical crack growth of oxide scales, with dissolution as the fundamental microscopic mechanism behind this process.

Chemistry↗

Precambrian Crystalline Basement Properties From Pressure History Matching and Implications for Induced Seismicity in the US Midcontinent

Injection-induced seismicity across the US midcontinent has almost exclusively occurred in the crystalline basement that underlies the Arbuckle Group aquifer and its equivalents, the primary wastewater disposal zone in this region. However, the properties of the basement are not well known. Newly compiled data, from Class I wells in Kansas, provide a unique record of pressures in the Arbuckle and an opportunity to constrain the reservoir-scale properties of the basement such as permeability, diffusivity, and specific storage. Constraints on these parameters are critical for modeling fluid flow and pressures across the entire Arbuckle-basement system, and are necessary for accurate evaluation and prediction of injection-induced earthquakes. Here, we present a detailed, three-dimensional geological and pressure history-matched numerical model for the Arbuckle and basement, based on data from >400 wells covering a large region in south-central Kansas, where injection-induced seismicity has been concentrated since 2014. Simulations of dynamic data from 319 wells indicate that Arbuckle pressures have increased by 1.1 MPa in high injection rate areas and an overpressure of <0.1 MPa may be the cause of seismicity in the basement. Pressure-history matching also yields the likely range in porosity (0.3%–7%), permeability (0.1–0.7 mD), and diffusivity (0.004–0.07 m2 /s) for the basement. The resulting estimates suggest reservoir-scale properties of the basement are enhanced by faults and fractures. Importantly, the diffusivities determined in this study are lower than estimates derived from Kansas earthquake triggering fronts, and suggest that such seismicity-based techniques may have limitations, particularly where spacetime patterns between injection and seismicity are complex.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

DNA Strand Displacement Driven Molecular Additive Manufacturing (DSD-MAM)

The goal of this project was to validate two-dimensional molecular printers, initially selfassembled from DNA and then actuated by externally driven cycles of DNA strand displacement, as prototype integrated nanosystems for molecular additive manufacturing. Novel functionalities of these nanomachines were explored during this project, including the following: nanometer-precision positioning mechanisms based on DNA strand displacement with multivalent interactions for discrete stepping or else diffusive capture; integration of independently moving layers of DNA origami to achieve 2D controllable motion; integration of spatial positioning with deposition functionality. The principal importance of this project was to provide an essential step in the development of a new technology for atomically precise manufacturing. Our first generation molecular 2D printer offers several advantages over conventional DNA-origami patterning, such as faster prototyping, faster dynamic rearrangement of patterns, and the ability to respond with feedback. We anticipate that our first-generation molecular printers may inspire future generations of molecular printers with iterative improvements in robustness and throughput. Potential applications of atomically precise manufacturing include the following: photovoltaics; photosynthetic and fuel cells; thermoelectrics and anisotropic heat spreaders; solid-state lighting; molecular electronic and plasmonic circuits; selectively preamble membranes; self-repairing materials with high strength-to-weight and fracture resistance.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Modal Analysis of Ultrasonic Spot Welding for Lightweight Metals Joining

Ultrasonic spot welding (USW) represents one of the unique solid-state joining methods for lightweight materials such as magnesium alloy and aluminum alloy. However, the sonotrode vibration may have a detrimental impact on the sheet material and the existing welds, depending on the component geometry and vibration frequency. In this study, a modal analysis tool based on steady-state dynamics was developed for ultrasonic spot welding which features a cyclic load applied to the sheets during the joining process. Through predicting relative motion and shear stress at the faying surfaces, coupon geometry and weld spacing are identified as two major factors that affect the welding reliability and joint quality in USW. The model was validated via welding experiments on aluminum alloy and magnesium alloy and relevant characterization of temperature distribution, joint strength as well as fracture location.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Understanding poromechanical response of a biogenic coalbed methane reservoir

Abstract Biogenic coalbed methane (BCBM) reservoirs aim to produce methane from in situ coal deposits following microbial conversion of coal. Success of BCBM reservoirs requires economic methane production within an acceptable timeframe. The work reported here quantifies the findings of previously published qualitative work, where it was found that bioconversion induces strains in the pore, matrix and bulk scales. Using imaging and dynamic strain monitoring techniques, the bioconversion induced strain is quantified here. To understand the effect of these strains from a reservoir geomechanics perspective, a corresponding poromechanical model is developed. Furthermore, findings of imaging experiments are validated using core-flooding flow experiments. Finally, expected field-scale behavior of the permeability response of a BCBM operation is modeled and analyzed. The results of the study indicated that, for Illinois coals, bioconversion induced strains result in a decrease in fracture porosity, resulting in a detrimental permeability drop in excess of 60% during bioconversion, which festers itself exponentially throughout its producing life. Results indicate that reservoirs with high initial permeability that will support higher Darcian flowrates, would be better suited for coal bioconversion, thereby providing a site-selection criteria for BCBM operations.

Pandey, Rohit (ORCID:0009000415483436)↗

Effect of lot microstructure variations on detonation performance of the triaminotrinitrobenzene (TATB)-Based insensitive high explosive PBX 9502

PBX 9502 is an important insensitive high explosive due to its combination of safety properties and detonation performance. It is a polymer-bonded formulation consisting of 95 wt.% 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-trinitrobenzene (TATB) as the high explosive crystal, bound with Kel F-800 (FK-800), a co-polymer of chlorotrifluoroethylene and vinylidene-fluoride. Two different types are used, one known as virgin that uses only pristine manufactured TATB, and a second known as recycled that has 50 wt.% of its TATB reclaimed from machining scraps of previously pressed virgin PBX 9502. Recycled lots have a higher percentage of fine particles compared to virgin lots, due to the fracturing and damage sustained by TATB crystals during pressing. We examine the influence that this TATB microstructure difference between virgin and recycled PBX 9502 has on detonation performance properties. New rate-stick geometry diameter effect, detonation front shape and cylinder expansion test data are obtained for two previously uncharacterized virgin lots and one recycled lot of PBX 9502. This is combined with previously published data for one virgin and one recycled lot for evaluation purposes. Detonation shock dynamics model calibrations are conducted on each of the five lots to provide an assessment of the detonation timing characteristics of virgin versus recycled PBX 9502 lots. For two of the virgin lots, detonations propagate slower in the rate-stick geometry than those in the two recycled lots. However, the other virgin lot tested has propagation rates comparable to that of the recycled lots for larger diameter rate-sticks. The latter result, though, is shown to be geometry dependent and depends on the range of detonation curvatures accessed in different geometries. New copper-confined, cylinder expansion tests are conducted on each of the three virgin and two recycled lots to obtain detonation product Jones-Wilkins-Lee equations of state, enabling an assessment of the metal push capabilities for each of the five lots. We find that the metal push capabilities, characterized by the evolution of the heat of detonation with volume, are similar between the virgin and recycled lots. Thus, changes in microstructure between different PBX 9502 lots seemingly affect the rate of reaction, but not the overall energy content.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Hybrid Nanocrystals of Small Molecules and Chemically Disordered Polymers

Organic crystals formed by small molecules can be highly functional but are often brittle or insoluble structures with limited possibilities for use or processing from a liquid phase. A possible solution is the nanoscale integration of polymers into organic crystals without sacrificing long-range order and therefore function. This enables the organic crystals to benefit from the advantageous mechanical and chemical properties of the polymeric component. We report here on a strategy in which small molecules co-crystallize with side chains of chemically disordered polymers to create hybrid nanostructures containing a highly ordered lattice. Synchrotron X-ray scattering, absorption spectroscopy, and coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations reveal that the polymer backbones form an “exo-crystalline” layer of disordered chains that wrap around the nanostructures becoming a handle for interesting properties. The morphology of this “hybrid bonding polymer” nanostructure is dictated by the competition between the polymers’ entropy and the enthalpy of the lattice allowing for control over the aspect ratio of the nanocrystal by changing the degree of polymer integration. Further, we observed that nanostructures with an exo-crystalline layer of polymer exhibit enhanced fracture strength, self-healing capacity, and dispersion in water, which benefits their use as light-harvesting assemblies in photocatalysis. Guided by computation, future work could also explore these hybrid nanostructures as building blocks for functional materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Review of High‐Speed Digital Image Correlation: Advancements and Good Practices

This paper reviews the current state of the art in high‐speed (HS) and ultrahigh‐speed (UHS) digital image correlation (DIC) techniques, emphasizing their critical role in experimental research across various scientific domains. HS and UHS DIC have evolved significantly, driven by advancements in camera systems, image processing algorithms and experimental methodologies. These developments have opened new avenues for capturing and analysing dynamic events with unprecedented temporal and spatial detail, but not without introducing challenges such as optical distortions, motion blur and lighting issues that can affect measurement quality. This review advocates for standardized reporting practices in HS/UHS DIC methodologies to improve reproducibility and reliability across studies, drawing on guidelines from the International Digital Image Correlation Society (iDICs). Through a comprehensive analysis of over 150 articles, this review identifies key advancements in imaging technology and their application in six research domains: material characterization, test development, fracture mechanics, model validation, ballistic and explosive phenomena assessment and measurement uncertainties. Distinctions between two‐dimensional (2D) and stereo‐DIC applications are explored, offering insights into their practical implementation and trade‐offs. Good practices for HS/UHS DIC applications are proposed along with suggestions for future directions for this evolving field, highlighting the indispensable role of technological innovation in expanding the capabilities of optical metrology.

experimental mechanics↗

Friction-based riveting technique for AZ31 magnesium alloy

Rivet materials used in the aerospace and automotive industries are typically alloys of aluminum (Al) or steel. Magnesium (Mg) is an attractive alternative because it is 33% and 75% lighter than Al and steel, respectively. However, a primary barrier for using Mg as rivet material is its poor formability at room temperature, resulting in brittle fracture of the rivet head during cold riveting. Hot riveting is possible but suffers from high cycle time due to the need for pre-heating. A new friction-based riveting technique, Rotating Hammer Riveting (RHR), is reported to fully form AZ31 Mg rivet heads in a mere 0.23 seconds cycle time. Heat and pressure generated through severe plastic deformation during the process was sufficient to form the Mg rivet head without the need for a separate pre-heating operation. Due to dynamic recrystallization, AZ31 Mg grains in the rivet head were significantly refined from about 15 to 2.6 µm during RHR, which favors the formability of Mg rivet by triggering grain boundary sliding and reducing plastic anisotropy of Mg. In addition, RHR joints showed a metallurgical bond between the rivet head and top sheet, which eliminates a significant pathway for corrosion.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Microstructural Changes to Thermally Sprayed Materials Subjected to Dynamic Compression

Dynamic compression of materials can induce a variety of microstructural changes. As thermally-sprayed materials have highly complex microstructures, the expected pressure at which changes occur cannot be predicted a priori. In addition, typical in-situ measurements such as velocimetry are unable to adequately diagnose microstructural changes such as failure or pore collapse. Quasi-isentropic compression experiments with sample recovery were conducted to examine microstructural changes in thermally sprayed tantalum and tantalum-niobium blends up to 8 GPa pressure. Spall fracture was observed in all tests, and post-shot pore volume decreased relative to the initial state. The blended material exhibited larger spall planes with fracture occurring at interphase boundaries. An estimate of the pressure at which pore collapse is complete was determined to be ~26 GPa for pure tantalum and ~19 GPa for the tantalumniobium blend under these loading conditions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗