Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Vibrational”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 325 records · Page 18
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2022

In-process, layer-by-layer non-destructive testing of additive manufactured components using linear and nonlinear vibrational resonance

Provided is an additive manufacturing system capable of performing in-process, layer-by-layer non-destructive testing, the additive manufacturing system including: a plate for producing a part thereon; a transducer attached to the plate and configured to induce vibrations in the part; and a laser vibrometer configured to detect a vibrational response of the part to determine whether defect and/or anisotropy exists within the part.

Remillieux, Marcel↗
DOE OSTI2020

Vibrational metrics for the evaluation of internal conditions in a scaled nuclear dry storage cask

In many countries, permanent repositories for high burnup spent nuclear fuel assemblies have yet to be established. As a result, much of the spent fuel from nuclear reactors is contained within dry storage casks, with many being beyond their designed service life. The assessment of the internal structural integrity of these casks and the fuel assemblies contained therein is of critical importance for both extended storage and transport to permanent repositories. The large size, structural complexity, and inaccessibility of the interior of the casks make this task challenging. To address these difficulties, a 1:6 scaled model based closely on the design of a Transnuclear (TN-32) dry storage cask was fabricated to facilitate controlled studies of these structures in the laboratory. Vibrational spectroscopy was used to evaluate the state of the cargo and internal structures within the cask utilizing only measurements on the outer surface. Using modes identified through Finite Element modeling corresponding to those previously measured on a full-scale TN-32 cask, we report on the development of amplitude- and phase-based metrics that are sensitive to internal conditions in the lab cask. Steel rod bundles and steel shot were used as surrogates for intact and damaged fuel assemblies, and various internal configurations of these materials were investigated. Finally, the metrics were based on acquired spectra involving the (1, 2) global bending mode and the (2, 1) radial-with-shearing mode. The results show that the metrics are sensitive to the condition of a single assembly and have some ability to determine the locations of damaged and empty slots.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗
DOE OSTI2019

Adaptive harnessing damping in hydrokinetic energy conversion by two rough tandem-cylinders using flow-induced vibrations

Alternating lift technology (ALT) harnesses hydrokinetic energy from currents and tides and is different from conventional steady lift technologies (turbines). ALT is still under development with an important research issue being the mitigation of wake effect on downstream cylinders in Flow Induced Oscillations (FIO) of multi-cylinder Current Energy Converters (CEC). Rather than adjust the configuration/parameters of the converter, a more direct and effective way is to actively adjust the harnessed power. In this paper, a hydrokinetic energy converter using FIO of two cylinders in tandem in one-degree-of-freedom oscillators, with nonlinear adaptive damping and linear spring stiffness, is tested experimentally. FIO include Vortex Induced Vibrations (VIV), galloping, and their coexistence. Introducing adaptive damping into the tandem cylinders overcomes the shielding effect, which previous research on two tandem cylinders has shown to reduce power output by the downstream cylinder. Shielding along with fixed damping result either in ceasing motion due to excessive damping, or in low harnessed energy due to insufficient damping. In this experimental study, damping-to-velocity rate, linear spring-stiffness, cylinder spacing, and flow-velocity are the parameters with Reynolds number 30,000 ≤ Re ≤ 120,000. Comparison to linear-oscillators in FIO shows that this nonlinear converter, with velocity-proportional damping coefficient, is more effective over the entire FIO range but especially in galloping, where both flow and cylinder speeds are higher. Experimental results for energy harvesting, efficiency and instantaneous energy of the converter are presented and discussed supported by amplitude and frequency response data. Here the results show that the nonlinear, adaptive, velocity-proportional damping coefficient is an effective way to increase the overall harnessed power and the power of downstream cylinder. The harnessed power in the VIV to galloping transition increases by up to 94%. The most significant improvement is in the galloping region, where the increase in harnessed power and efficiency is around 33%.

13 HYDRO ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2021

A comprehensive review of nonlinear oscillators in hydrokinetic energy harnessing using flow-induced vibrations

A comprehensive review of hydrokinetic energy converters based on alternating lift technology (ALT) is provided. Emphasis is on nonlinear oscillators based on Flow Induced Vibration (FIV) or Oscillation (FIO). Due to strong coupling in Fluid-Structure Interaction (FSI), and in order to maximize the hydrokinetic harnessed energy, design of nonlinear oscillators and analysis by model tests or computational fluid dynamics dominates this area. Research confirmed that the nonlinear oscillator can harvest energy from a stochastic excitation modeled by a generic wide spectrum, and overcome the most severe oscillator limitations: specifically, the need for continuous frequency tuning due to the narrow bandwidth response, and low efficiency outside the narrow bandwidth oscillator response. This review covers the following aspects of nonlinear oscillators in ALT converters: (1) Geometric changes in oscillator cross-section; e.g., circular, square, rectangular, or trilateral shapes. (2) Passive turbulence control of FIV/FIO. (3) Position based nonlinear stiffness. (4) Multi-cylinder synergistic FIV/FIO. (5) Mechanically linked oscillators. (6) Velocity-based, nonlinear, adaptive harnessing damping.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2020

The role of rotation-vibration coupling in symmetric and asymmetric isotopomers of ozone

A theoretical framework and a computer code (SpectrumSDT) are developed for accurate calculations of coupled rotational–vibrational states in triatomic molecules using hyper-spherical coordinates and taking into account the Coriolis coupling effect. Concise final formulas are derived for the construction of the Hamiltonian matrix using an efficient combination of the variational basis representation and discrete variable representation methods with locally optimized basis sets and grids. First, the new code is tested by comparing its results with those of the APH3D program of Kendrick et al. [Kendrick, Pack, Walker, and Hayes, J. Chem. Phys. 110, 6673 (1999)]. Then, accurate calculations of the rovibrational spectra are carried out for doubly substituted symmetric ( 18 O 16 O 18 O) and asymmetric ( 18 O 18 O 16 O) ozone isotopomers for the total angular momentum up to J = 5. Together with similar data recently reported for the singly substituted symmetric ( 16 O 18 O 16 O) and asymmetric ( 16 O 16 O 18 O) ozone isotopomers, these calculations quantify the role of the Coriolis coupling effect in the large mass-independent isotopic enrichment of ozone, observed in both laboratory experiments and the atmosphere of the Earth. It is found that the Coriolis effect in ozone is relatively small, as evidenced by deviations of its rotational constants from the symmetric-top-rotor behavior, magnitudes of parity splittings (Λ-doubling), and ratios of rovibrational partition functions for asymmetric vs symmetric ozone molecules. It is concluded that all of these characteristics are influenced by the isotopic masses as much as they are influenced by the overall symmetry of the molecule. It is therefore unlikely that the Coriolis coupling effect could be responsible for symmetry-driven mass-independent fractionation of oxygen isotopes in ozone.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Cyclically symmetric radially self-similar phononic pseudocrystal isolator for broadband, ultrasonic vibration bandstop filtering

A 2D phononic pseudocrystal isolator exhibiting cyclic symmetry and radial self-similarity is measured and demonstrated to block a wide range of ultrasonic vibration. Measurements of longitudinal and shear wave blocking effects are made and compared with computational results. The use of the bandgap edge ratio is recommended for quantifying suppression in very-wide-bandgap materials. In conclusion, the upper-to-lower suppression edge frequency ratios of 3–4 are remarkably large for shear waves and even larger for longitudinal waves upper-to-lower suppression ratio (13 at 5 dB), such that 92.5% of frequencies in that range experience ≥ 5 dB of suppression.

Acoustic metamaterial↗
DOE OSTI2025

Isomers and band assignments in the cryogenic vibrational spectrum of the binary complex between water and protonated formic acid using two color, IR–IR photobleaching and H/D isotopic substitution

Protonated formic acid (PFA) is purported to be the active species in the catalytic activation of condensation reactions at the acidic interface of microdroplets. Here, we investigate the fundamental interaction between PFA and water with cryogenic ion vibrational spectroscopy of the binary PFA–H 2 O complexes generated via electrospray ionization followed by buffer gas cooling to about 20 K. The patterns displayed by the isomer-specific IR spectra of D 2 -tagged PFA–H 2 O indicate that two distinct, non-interconverting rotamers are present at low temperatures based on the cis and trans structures of the HCO 2 $H$$^{+}_{2}$ core ion. Both of these occur with the water molecule attached to the OH that is in a cis-configuration relative to the CH group (denoted E), but differ in the E vs Z (cis vs trans relative to the CH group) orientation of the spectator OH. This assignment scheme corrects a previous theoretical analysis that invoked a scenario in which structures with E- and Z-bound water molecules interconvert at low (20 K) temperatures. Isomer-specific bands arising from the OH stretches and water bending modes are deconvoluted using isotopomer-specific spectroscopy of the complexes with partial H/D exchange. The dependence of the nominal shared proton OH stretch frequency on the deuteration of the tethered water confirms strong coupling between this mode and the water bending fundamental.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Structural Trends and Vibrational Analysis of N,N,N′,N′−Tetramethylmalonamide Complexes Across the Lanthanide Series

Fundamental understanding of coordination chemistry across the lanthanide series is essential for explaining chemical behavior of rare-earth metals in complex liquid-liquid extraction processes, which in turn affects the distribution ratios and efficacy of separations as a whole. In this work, we explore the structural trends between the lanthanides and a neutral N,N,N',N'-tetramethylmalonamide (TMMA) ligand within four isolated families of solid-state compounds: Ln(trans-TMMA) 2 (NO 3 ) 3 Ln=La-Nd, Sm; Ln(cis-TMMA) 2 (NO 3 ) 3 Ln=Eu-Tb, Er; [Ln(TMMA) 3 (NO 3 ) 2 ][Ln(TMMA)(NO 3 ) 4 ] Ln=Dy-Tm; Ln(Κ 2 -TMMA)(iPrOH)(NO 3 ) 3 and Ln(Κ 1 -TMMA)(Κ 2 -TMMA)(NO 3 ) 3 Ln=Yb, Lu. Moving across the lanthanide series, we note the formation of both discrete charge-neutral complexes, as well as charged molecular anion-cation pairs, with variations in spatial ligand arrangement, coordination numbers, and ligand denticities. IR and Raman spectroscopy paired with DFT frequency calculations were used for an in-depth investigation of vibrational modes unique to each structural family. The collection of isolated model compounds was also discussed in the context of liquid-liquid separations based on reported distribution ratios from malonamide extraction.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2021

A fast multi-fidelity method with uncertainty quantification for complex data correlations: Application to vortex-induced vibrations of marine risers

Here we develop a fast multi-fidelity modeling method for very complex correlations between high- and low-fidelity data by working in modal space to extract the proper correlation function. We apply this method to infer the amplitude of motion of a flexible marine riser in cross-flow, subject to vortex-induced vibrations (VIV). VIV are driven by an absolute instability in the flow, which imposes a frequency (Strouhal) law that requires a matching with the impedance of the structure; this matching is easily achieved because of the rapid parametric variation of the added mass force. As a result, the wavenumber of the riser spatial response is within narrow bands of uncertainty. Hence, an error in wavenumber prediction can cause significant phase-related errors in the shape of the amplitude of response along the riser, rendering correlation between low- and high-fidelity data very complex. Working in modal space as outlined herein, dense data from low-fidelity data, provided by the semi-empirical computer code VIVA, can correlate in modal space with few high-fidelity data, obtained from experiments or fully-resolved CFD simulations, to correct both phase and amplitude and provide predictions that agree very well overall with the correct shape of the amplitude response. We also quantify the uncertainty in the prediction using Bayesian modeling and exploit this uncertainty to formulate an active learning strategy for the best possible location of the sensors providing the high fidelity measurements.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2025

Probing air-water interfaces of dibutyl phosphoric acid (HDBP) aqueous solutions using vibrational sum frequency generation (vSFG) spectroscopy

Liquid-liquid extraction is a separation technique implemented in a wide variety of areas, achieving particular success in both the nuclear and biomedical fields. In this work, vibrational sum frequency generation spectroscopy (VSFG) and surface tension measurements were used to investigate the adsorption of dibutyl phosphate (DBP) at air-aqueous interfaces to simulate liquid-liquid systems relevant to the Plutonium Uranium Redox Extraction (PUREX) Process. The objective of this work is to establish qualitative relationships between changes in the bulk aqueous phase concentrations of DBP and its concentration and structure at air-liquid interface as probed with VSFG. Nitric acid concentration and solution ionic strength were varied to examine their effect on the interfacial DBP.. Introduction of DBP into neat water resulted in reduction of the VSFG spectral intensity in the dangling O-H region (3680 – 3800 cm -1 ) but large increase in the H-bonded O-H stretch frequency region (3000 – 3500 cm-1) and the appearance of the CH 3 symmetric stretch and CH 3 Fermi resonance peaks at ~ 2880 and 2945 cm -1 , respectively, indicating DBP at the air-water interface. The intensity of the C-H strecth peaks increased as DBP concentration increased from 0.24 to 32 mM, accompanied by a decreasing surface tension values. At fixed DBP concentration, the addition of either or both of HNO 3 and NaNO 3 to an ionic strength of 1 M or 3 M led to significant reduction of the O-H VSFG peaks and enhancement of the C-H peaks. The origins of these experimental observations are attributed to both the increased HDBP molecules partitioning and adsorption to the interface and the protonation of the interfacial DBP- molecules.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Numerical simulation of vortex-induced vibration response of a single IEA 10-MW wind turbine blade

Three-dimensional simulation of vortex-induced vibration (VIV) of a single International Energy Agency (IEA) 10-MW reference wind turbine blade with a length of 97.325 m is performed using the ExaWind stack, an open-source suite of codes. This study aims to illustrate the spanwise VIV response characteristics and cross-validate the results with an existing commercial framework. Five near-body meshes and three time steps are selected for the convergence study. To improve computational efficiency, several VIV triggering methods are also compared to shorten the VIV development period. The ExaWind-based VIV simulation strategy for a single IEA 10-MW blade is determined. First, the modal shape is validated against published results. Then, spanwise VIV responses of four blade configurations under a fixed and varied incoming flow velocity are analyzed. Results show that the VIV response is dominated by the first edgewise (second overall) mode. Little first-mode contributions appear near the second-mode node, producing a pi phase jump, and a higher harmonics response occurs near the blade root. Rotational degrees of freedom are minor compared with translational motion. The response versus reduced velocity is analyzed, showing a two-branch behavior similar to that of VIV for a bluff cylinder. Across all tested cases, the dominant frequency remains locked to the natural frequency of the second mode with no observed desynchronization. A mild deviation is observed for the case of 90-degree pitch and 310-degree azimuth rotation near a reduced velocity of 6, which will be examined with additional cases in future work. These findings indicate that severe VIV responses can arise under specific configurations and flow conditions, thereby increasing the potential for VIV fatigue damage and requiring greater attention during operation.

17 WIND ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2026

Time-Domain Vortex Induced Vibration Modeling of Reference Dynamic Power Cable for the Gulf of Maine

Vortex-induced vibration (VIV) is a phenomenon known to decrease the fatigue life of dynamic power cables used in floating offshore wind systems through increased bending loading cycles. A variety of modeling solutions have been proposed to study this, but none enable fully-coupled simulations leveraging open-source tools. To address this, a time-domain VIV model has been successfully implemented into the open-source mooring dynamics model MoorDyn. The semi-empirical VIV model describes a lift force acting on segments of a flexible cylinder, making it well suited for implementation into MoorDyn. The new capability successfully predicted the frequencies and magnitudes of strain in both steady and oscillating flows when compared to the original validation results and matched peak spectral response when compared to experimental results, verifying successful implementation. MoorDyn with VIV was then leveraged to simulate a 15 MW floating turbine with a dynamic power cable in the Gulf of Maine using OpenFAST for six return periods of combined wind, wave, and current conditions. Increased curvature and tension fluctuations in higher flow speeds were observed when simulating VIV. Maximum tensions and curvatures also increased, with the 500 year conditions violating the curvature factor of safety of 2.0. These results highlight the importance of considering VIV when designing dynamic power cables for the Gulf of Maine, and indicate that cost effective mitigation strategies should be explored for the area. They also demonstrate the utility of this new modeling capability, which provides the first open-source tool for fully coupled time-domain floating offshore wind simulations with dynamic power cable VIV.

17 WIND ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

A systematic exploration of the hydrolysis products of the uranium trioxide polymorphs and their optical vibrational spectra

Study of the uranium trioxide (UO 3 )-water system is complex with inconclusive results and limited details in the literature. The UO 3 system is home to at least seven structural polymorphs and an amorphous phase. The proposed hydrolysis products of UO 3 are just as numerous, yet investigations of these alteration products are sporadic and generally antiquated, thus requiring systematic investigations. Recent developments in the understanding of UO 3 phase space, aided by improvements in analytical and computational techniques, necessitate more modern investigations into the uranyl hydroxide family and their naturally occurring mineral counterparts. We present findings from a systematic investigation of the products formed via hydrothermal reactions of common UO 3 polymorphs and discuss how the equatorial coordination of the uranyl/uranyl-like ions within the UO 3 precursors leads to differences in the optical vibrational spectra of the resulting hydrolysis products. The hypo-stochiometric nature of α-UO 2 (OH) 2 allows for the formation of multiple unique uranyl sites and a distortion of the unit cell to a lower symmetry. This study provides, for the first time, an analysis of β-UO 2 (OH) 2 using modern techniques and instrumentation (Raman/infrared spectroscopy and powder x-ray diffraction) and lays a foundation for future time-dependent investigations into the structural dependence of the hydrolysis kinetics of the UO 3 phases. In conclusion, given the prevalence of UO 3 at both ends of the nuclear fuel cycle, an understanding of its behavior with water has applications ranging from nuclear forensics to waste management and environmental transport.

Uranium trioxide↗
DOE OSTI2020

Edge-cloud computing performance benchmarking for IoT based machinery vibration monitoring

Advances in low cost and reliable sensing, connectivity (Internet of Things), computational power, and advanced analytics, are leading to a new wave of innovation in machinery status sensing and condition monitoring. Significant research efforts are directed towards cloud computing architectures. However, given the latency, bandwidth, cost, security, and privacy concerns, further supported by the ever-increasing capabilities of edge computing devices, there is a need to consider both edge and cloud computing together to make informed decisions based upon context and performance. In this work, we present an edge-cloud performance evaluation for IoT based machinery vibration monitoring, to foster deployment for the contexts considered.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2021

Resonance-Enhanced Excitation of Interlayer Vibrations in Atomically Thin Black Phosphorus

The strength of interlayer coupling critically affects the physical properties of 2D materials such as black phosphorus (BP), where the electronic structure depends sensitively on layer thickness. Rigid-layer vibrations reflect directly the interlayer coupling strength in 2D van der Waals solids, but measurement of these characteristic frequencies is made difficult by sample instability and small Raman scattering cross sections in atomically thin elemental crystals. Here, we overcome these challenges in BP by performing resonance-enhanced low-frequency Raman scattering under an argon-protective environment. Interlayer breathing modes for atomically thin BP were previously unobservable under conventional (nonresonant) excitation but became strongly enhanced when the excitation energy matched the sub-band electronic transitions of few-layer BP, down to bilayer thicknesses. The measured out-of-plane interlayer force constant was found to be 10.1 × 10 19 N/m 3 in BP, which is comparable to graphene. Accurate characterization of the interlayer coupling strength lays the foundation for future exploration of BP twisted structures and heterostructures.

interlayer interaction↗
DOE OSTI2023

Analytical harmonic vibrational frequencies with VV10-containing density functionals: Theory, efficient implementation, and benchmark assessments

VV10 is a powerful nonlocal density functional for long-range correlation that is used to include dispersion effects in many modern density functionals, such as the meta-generalized gradient approximation (mGGA), B97M-V, the hybrid GGA, ωB97X-V, and the hybrid mGGA, ωB97M-V. While energies and analytical gradients for VV10 are already widely available, this study reports the first derivation and efficient implementation of the analytical second derivatives of the VV10 energy. The additional compute cost of the VV10 contributions to analytical frequencies is shown to be small in all but the smallest basis sets for recommended grid sizes. Here, this study also reports the assessment of VV10-containing functionals for predicting harmonic frequencies using the analytical second derivative code. The contribution of VV10 to simulating harmonic frequencies is shown to be small for small molecules but important for systems where weak interactions are important, such as water clusters. In the latter cases, B97M-V, ωB97M-V, and ωB97X-V perform very well. The convergence of frequencies with respect to the grid size and atomic orbital basis set size is studied, and recommendations are reported. Finally, scaling factors to allow comparison of scaled harmonic frequencies with experimental fundamental frequencies and to predict zero-point vibrational energy are presented for some recently developed functionals (including r2SCAN, B97M-V, ωB97X-V, M06-SX, and ωB97M-V).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2022

Vibrational properties of CuInP 2 S 6 across the ferroelectric transition

In order to explore the properties of a two-sublattice ferroelectric, we measured the infrared and Raman scattering response of CuInP 2 S 6 across the ferroelectric and glassy transitions and compared our findings to a symmetry analysis, calculations of phase stability, and lattice dynamics. In addition to uncovering displacive character and a large hysteresis region surrounding the ferroelectric transition temperature T C , we identify the vibrational modes that stabilize the polar phase and confirm the presence of two ferroelectric variants with opposite polarizations. Below T C , a poorly understood relaxational or glassy transition at T g is characterized by local structure changes in the form of subtle peak shifting and activation of low frequency out-of-plane Cu- and In-containing modes. Here, the latter are due to changes in the Cu/In coordination environments and associated order-disorder processes. Moreover, T g takes place in two steps with another large hysteresis region and significant underlying scattering. Combined with imaging of the room temperature phase separation, this effort lays the groundwork for studying CuInP 2 S 6 under external stimuli and in the ultrathin limit.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2020

Searching for correlations between vibrational spectral features and structural parameters of silicate glass network

Infrared (IR) and Raman spectroscopic features of silicate glasses are usually interpreted based on the analogy with those of smaller molecules, molecular clusters, or crystalline counterparts; this study tests the accuracy and validity of these widely cited peak assignment schemes by comparing vibrational spectral features with bond parameters of the glass network created by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. A series of sodium silicate glasses with compositions of [Na 2 O] x [Al 2 O 3 ] 2 [SiO 2 ] 98- x with x = 7, 12, 17, and 22 were synthesized and analyzed with IR and Raman. A silica glass substrate and a crystalline quartz were also analyzed for comparison. Glass structures with the same compositions were generated with MD simulations using three types of potentials: fixed partial charge pairwise (Teter), partial diffuse charge potential (MGFF), and bond order-based charge transfer potential (ReaxFF). The comparison of simulated and experimental IR spectra showed that, among these three potentials tested, ReaxFF reproduces the concentration dependence of spectral features closest to the experimentally observed trend. Hence, the bond length and angle distributions as well as Si– Q n species and ring size distributions of silica and sodium silicate glasses were obtained from ReaxFF-MD simulations and further compared with the peak assignment or deconvolution schemes—which have been widely used since 1970s and 1980s—(a) correlation between the IR peak position in the Si–O stretch region (1050-1120 cm -1 ) and the Si–O–Si bond angle; (b) deconvolution of the Raman bands in the Si–O stretch region with the Q n speciation; and (c) assignment of the Raman bands in the 420-600 cm -1 region to the bending modes of (SiO) n rings with different sizes (typically, n = 3-6). The comparisons showed that none of these widely used methods is congruent with the bond parameters or structures of silicate glass networks produced via ReaxFF-MD simulations. This result invokes that the adequacy of these spectral interpretation methods must be questioned. Alternative interpretations are proposed, which are to be tested independently in future studies.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗