Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “bottleneck analysis”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 325 records · Page 18

Evolution of Metastable Phases During Mg Metal Corrosion: An In Situ Cryogenic X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy Study

Magnesium and its alloys are potential structural materials candidates for a wide variety of applications due to their high strength-to-weight ratio. However, ductility and poor corrosion resistance under ambient environmental conditions are the bottleneck for industrial deployment. Designing passivation layers and/or corrosion resistant alloys requires fundamental understanding of the corrosion process. The traditional ex-situ spectroscopic measurements of polycrystalline metal surface with ubiquitous surface impurities and grain boundaries only provided an indistinct view of the corrosion process. To clearly distinguish the mechanism and sequence of corrosion process, we employed in-situ cryo-based x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements on Mg single crystal surface exposed to aqueous salt solution. Clean Mg (0001) surfaces were exposed to pure D2O and NaCl aqueous solution (5 wt% NaCl+95 wt% D2O). The interfacial reactions were studied using multimodal analysis including XPS, x-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). In contrast to previous studies, our experiments demonstrated the formation of magnesium chloride hydroxide hydrate during aqueous salt corrosion processes. Evidence of metastable ClO* radicals were also found during the initial aqueous salt solution exposure.

Shutthanandan, Vaithiyalingam↗

Ultrafast exciton many-body interactions and hot-phonon bottleneck in colloidal cesium lead halide perovskite nanocrystals

Defect-tolerant perovskite nanocrystals of the general formula Cs-Pb-X 3 (where X=Cl, Br, and I) have shown exceptional potential in fundamental physics as well as in novel optoelectronic applications as the next generation of solar cells. Although exciton many-body interactions such as biexciton Stark shift, state filling, and Auger recombination are studied extensively, other important correlated effects, such as band gap renormalization (BGR) and hot-phonon bottleneck, are not explored in these nanocrystals. Here we experimentally demonstrate the carrier density dependence of the BGR and an effective hot-phonon bottleneck in CsPb(Cl 0.20 Br 0.80 ) 3 mixed-halide nanocrystals. The results are compared with two other halide compositions, namely, CsPbBr 3 and CsPb(Br 0.55 I 0.45 ) 3 nanocrystals with varying band gaps. The optical response of the nanocrystals changes dramatically across the spectral range of many hundreds of meV at high carrier density due to large BGR. We have calculated the BGR constant ~(6.0+/-0.3) x 10 -8 eV cm for CsPb(Cl 0.20 Br 0.80 ) 3 nanocrystals that provides the amount of band gap shift as a function of carrier density. In these nanocrystals, an efficient hot-phonon bottleneck is observed at a carrier density of 3.1 x 10 17 cm -3 that slows down the thermalization by 1 order of magnitude. Our findings reveal that the complex kinetic profile of the exciton dynamics can be analyzed by the global target analysis using the sequential model with increasing lifetimes.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Two new SciDAC institutes promote mathematical tools and software technology for high-performance computing

Bigger is often said to be better, and the newest extreme-scale computers certainly are bigger, with millions of processing units. Moreover, the breadth of science performed on the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) computing facilities is expanding, with new technology such as artificial intelligence emerging. These advances are exciting, creating new opportunities for scientific discovery; however, they also raise new questions for scientists who want to exploit these advances for tackling more complex problems. Will my simulation code be able to utilize the accelerators in extreme-scale computing systems? Can I take advantage of the deepening memory hierarchy in heterogeneous processors? Is there a way around bottlenecks caused by the widening ratio of peak floating-point operations per second to I/0 bandwidth? How can I manage my huge amounts of data effectively? Can I analyze data in situ, or must I transfer it to offline storage for later analysis? To address such questions, DOE announced that it is providing $57.5 million over the next five years for two multidisciplinary teams — FASTMath and RAPIDS2 — to develop new tools and techniques to harness supercomputers for scientific discovery. The teams, called SciDAC Institutes, are part of the Scientific Discovery through Advanced Computing program.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes with Confined Chalcogens as the Catalysts and Electrodes for Oxygen Reduction Reaction in Fuel Cells

The goal of this project is to synthesize and characterize a new non-metal electro-catalyst for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) for fuel cell applications. The intended catalyst is a composite material composed of sulfur chains encapsulated in narrow diameter single-walled carbon nanotubes (S@SWNTs). S@SWNTs were successfully synthesized through sulfur vapor infusion method, and validated with Raman spectroscopy. However, the electrochemical analysis on the ORR catalytic activity of S@SWNTs indicated that it had low ORR catalytic activity. Our theoretical study based on density functional theory (DFT) revealed that the poor oxygen adsorption (low binding energy) on the surface of S@SWNTs was the bottleneck of the entire catalytic reaction. The focus of the project was subsequently pivoted to the development of a new non-noble metal ORR catalyst that could provide durability in acidic electrolyte. The hypothesis was to encapsulate small iron (Fe) clusters in SWNTs (Fe@SWNTs) can provide ORR electro-catalytic activity and long durability in acidic environment. DFT-based computational studies were carried out to explore the feasibility of the Fe@SWNTs catalyst. The theoretical study indicated that Fe@SWNTs indeed could catalyze the ORR with lower theoretical overpotential than platinum (Pt). However, its weaker bonding energy with oxygen was the bottleneck of the overall reaction. On the other hand, Fe clusters (composed of 7 Fe atoms) encapsulated in nitrogen-doped SWNTs (Fe 7 @N 4 WSNTs) showed proper oxygen adsorption by the Fe cluster and low theoretical overpotential of ORR. Comparing to the Fe single atom catalyst on N-doped SWNTs (Fe-N 4 SWNTs), which is one the best non-noble metal ORR catalysts reported in the literature, the Fe 7 @N 4 WSNTs showed lower overpotential and better resistance to acidic environment. Fe encapsulated N-doped SWNTs were synthesized with ferrocene as the Fe precursors through vapor infusion method, and experimental validate is underway. This study theoretically demonstrated the feasibility of a new type of non-noble metal electro-catalyst for ORR that could have high catalytic activity and long durability.

08 HYDROGEN↗

An Intelligent Distributed Ledger Construction Algorithm for IoT

Blockchain is the next generation of secure data management that creates near-immutable decentralized storage. Secure cryptography created a niche for blockchain to provide alternatives to well-known security compromises. However, design bottlenecks with traditional blockchain data structures scale poorly with increased network usage and are extremely computation-intensive. This made the technology difficult to combine with limited devices, like those in Internet of Things networks. In protocols like IOTA, replacement of blockchain's linked-list queue processing with a lightweight dynamic ledger showed remarkable throughput performance increase. However, current stochastic algorithms for ledger construction suffer distinct trade-offs between efficiency and security. This work proposed a machine-learning approach with a multi-arm bandit that resolved these issues and was designed for auditing on limited devices. This algorithm was tested in a reinforcement-learning environment simulating the IOTA ledger's construction with a decision tree. This study showed through regret analysis and experimentation that this approach was secure against impulse manipulation attacks while remaining energy-efficient. Although the IOTA protocol was a pioneer for lightweight distributed ledgers, it is expected that future blockchain protocols will adopt techniques similar to those presented in this work.

multi-arm bandit↗

Active Measurement of the Impact of Network SwitchUtilization on Application Performance

Inter-node networks are a key capability of High-Performance Computing (HPC) systems that differentiates them from less capable classes of machines. However, in spite of their very high performance, the increasing computational power of HPC compute nodes and the associated rise in application communication needs make network performance a common performance bottleneck. To achieve high performance in spite of network limitations application developers require tools to measure their applications’ network utilization and inform them about how the network’s communication capacity relates to the performance of their applications. This paper presents a new performance measurement and analysis methodology based on empirical measurements of network behavior. Our approach uses two benchmarks that inject extra network communication. The first probes the fraction of the network that is utilized by a software component (an application or an individual task) to determine the existence and severity of network contention. The second aggressively injects network traffic while a software component runs to evaluate its performance on less capable networks or when it shares the network with other software components. We then combine the information from the two types of experiment to predict the performance slowdown experienced by multiple software components (e.g. multiple processes of a single MPI application) when they share a single network. Our methodology is applied to individual network switches and demonstrated on two real systems with different types of switches and compute node architectures.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Development of a Sustainable Green Chemistry Platform for Production of Acetone and Downstream Drop-in Fuel and Commodity Products Directly From Biomass Syngas Via a Novel Energy Conserving Route in Engineered Acetogenic Bacteria

LanzaTech and Oak Ridge National Laboratory have developed and scaled up a process for sustainable production of acetone and downstream drop-in fuel and commodity products directly from biomass syngas via a novel energy conserving route in engineered acetogenic bacteria. This process offers a safer and more environmentally-friendly production method for acetone production than the current phenol-dependent method, and the product has significantly lower GHG emissions. The developed process offers a cost competitive route to Acetone and enables biofuels at or below DOE’s $3 gge target. In addition, it also provides an attractive biological alternative to traditional sugar-based ABE fermentation, by enabling utilization of non-food biomass resources as fermentation feedstocks. Challenges overcome: • By-products formation: Byproduct 2,3-butandiol and 3-hydroxybutyrate reduce yield and stability. Addressed by elimination of both pathways in our chassis acetone production strain. • Cost competitiveness: Addressed by developing an integrated acetone strain and eliminating by-products to increase yield and stability. Optimized co-selectivity and coproductivity of acetone and ethanol instead of titer, based on technoeconomic analysis. • Limited enzyme variety: Addressed by genome mining of over 300 industrial strains in LanzaTech collection, identifying unique enzyme sequences, and refactoring these unique enzyme variants through LanzaTech’s engineering platform. Resulted in over 10x improvement in acetone production from gas. • Continuous process (stability): Identified bottleneck through detailed omics studies, addressed by integration of the acetone pathway on the chromosome. • Novel process to scale up: Addressed by demonstrating stable acetone production in a 80- L pilot reactor, with acetone productivity and selectivity comparable to those observed under the same conditions in 2-L reactors. We have demonstrated stable acetone production for over 7 days at commercial target rate and selectivity in 2-L reactors and have piloted the process.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Porting HEP Parameterized Calorimeter Simulation Code to GPUs

The High Energy Physics (HEP) experiments, such as those at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), traditionally consume large amounts of CPU cycles for detector simulations and data analysis, but rarely use compute accelerators such as GPUs. As the LHC is upgraded to allow for higher luminosity, resulting in much higher data rates, purely relying on CPUs may not provide enough computing power to support the simulation and data analysis needs. As a proof of concept, we investigate the feasibility of porting a HEP parameterized calorimeter simulation code to GPUs. We have chosen to use FastCaloSim, the ATLAS fast parametrized calorimeter simulation. While FastCaloSim is sufficiently fast such that it does not impose a bottleneck in detector simulations overall, significant speed-ups in the processing of large samples can be achieved from GPU parallelization at both the particle (intra-event) and event levels; this is especially beneficial in conditions expected at the high-luminosity LHC, where extremely high per-event particle multiplicities will result from the many simultaneous proton-proton collisions. We report our experience with porting FastCaloSim to NVIDIA GPUs using CUDA. A preliminary Kokkos implementation of FastCaloSim for portability to other parallel architectures is also described.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Scalable Hyper-parameter Estimation for Gaussian Process Based Time Series Analysis

Gaussian process (GP) is increasingly becoming popular as a kernel machine learning tool for non-parametric data analysis. Recently, GP has been applied to model non-linear dependencies in time series data. GP based analysis can be used to solve problems of time series prediction, forecasting, missing data imputation, change point detection, anomaly detection, etc. But the use of GP to handle massive scientific time series data sets has been limited, owing to its expensive computational complexity. The primary bottleneck is the handling of the covariance matrix whose size is quadratic in the length of the time series. In this paper we propose a scalable method that exploit the special structure of the covariance matrix for hyper-parameter estimation in GP based learning. The proposed method allows estimation of hyper parameters associated with GP in quadratic time, which is an order of magnitude improvement over standard methods with cubic complexity. Moreover, the proposed method does not require explicit computation of the covariance matrix and hence has memory requirement linear to the length of the time series as opposed to the quadratic memory requirement of standard methods. To further improve the computational complexity of the proposed method, we provide a parallel version to concurrently estimate the log likelihood for a set of time series which is the key step in the hyper-parameter estimation. Performance results on a multi-core system show that our proposed method provides significant speedups as high as 1000, even when running in serial mode, while maintaining a small memory footprint. The parallel version exploits the natural parallelization potential of the serial algorithm and is shown to perform significantly better than the serial faster algorithm, with speedups as high as 10.

Chandola, Varun↗

High-performance mass storage system for workstations

Reduced Instruction Set Computer (RISC) workstations and Personnel Computers (PC) are very popular tools for office automation, command and control, scientific analysis, database management, and many other applications. However, when using Input/Output (I/O) intensive applications, the RISC workstations and PC's are often overburdened with the tasks of collecting, staging, storing, and distributing data. Also, by using standard high-performance peripherals and storage devices, the I/O function can still be a common bottleneck process. Therefore, the high-performance mass storage system, developed by Loral AeroSys' Independent Research and Development (IR&D) engineers, can offload a RISC workstation of I/O related functions and provide high-performance I/O functions and external interfaces. The high-performance mass storage system has the capabilities to ingest high-speed real-time data, perform signal or image processing, and stage, archive, and distribute the data. This mass storage system uses a hierarchical storage structure, thus reducing the total data storage cost, while maintaining high-I/O performance. The high-performance mass storage system is a network of low-cost parallel processors and storage devices. The nodes in the network have special I/O functions such as: SCSI controller, Ethernet controller, gateway controller, RS232 controller, IEEE488 controller, and digital/analog converter. The nodes are interconnected through high-speed direct memory access links to form a network. The topology of the network is easily reconfigurable to maximize system throughput for various applications. This high-performance mass storage system takes advantage of a 'busless' architecture for maximum expandability. The mass storage system consists of magnetic disks, a WORM optical disk jukebox, and an 8mm helical scan tape to form a hierarchical storage structure. Commonly used files are kept in the magnetic disk for fast retrieval. The optical disks are used as archive media, and the tapes are used as backup media. The storage system is managed by the IEEE mass storage reference model-based UniTree software package. UniTree software will keep track of all files in the system, will automatically migrate the lesser used files to archive media, and will stage the files when needed by the system. The user can access the files without knowledge of their physical location. The high-performance mass storage system developed by Loral AeroSys will significantly boost the system I/O performance and reduce the overall data storage cost. This storage system provides a highly flexible and cost-effective architecture for a variety of applications (e.g., realtime data acquisition with a signal and image processing requirement, long-term data archiving and distribution, and image analysis and enhancement).

Chiang, T.↗

Response of Pseudomonas putida to Complex, Aromatic-Rich Fractions from Biomass

There is strong interest in the valorization of lignin to produce valuable products; however, its structural complexity has been a conversion bottleneck. Chemical pretreatment liberates lignin-derived soluble fractions that may be upgraded by bioconversion. Here, cholinium ionic liquid pretreatment of sorghum produced soluble, aromatic-rich fractions that were converted by Pseudomonas putida (P. putida), a promising host for aromatic bioconversion. Growth studies and mutational analysis demonstrated that P. putida growth on these fractions was dependent on aromatic monomers but unknown factors also contributed. Proteomic and metabolomic analyses indicated that these unknown factors were amino acids and residual ionic liquid; the oligomeric aromatic fraction derived from lignin was not converted. A cholinium catabolic pathway was identified, and the deletion of the pathway stopped the ability of P. putida to grow on cholinium ionic liquid. This work demonstrates that aromatic-rich fractions obtained through pretreatment contain multiple substrates; conversion strategies should account for this complexity.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Demonstration of and future perspective on scaling ultrafast-laser-ablation microstructuring of Li-ion battery electrodes to roll-to-roll production and large-format cells

This work demonstrates integration of an ultrafast laser onto a roll-to-roll machine, the laser structuring of a double-sided, 700 m long roll of graphite battery anode and its subsequent manufacture into 27 Ah prismatic cells. The electrode was ablated with a novel hybrid-microstructure composed of both hexagonally arranged pores for enhanced rate performance and channels for fast electrolyte wetting. Subsequently, this anode and a non-ablated baseline anode are paired with an NMC111 cathode for cell building and electrochemical characterization. Compared to the baseline, laser ablated cells demonstrated a reduction in soaking time of at least 60%, an improvement in fast charge capability with >30% more capacity accepted during 6C charging, and an extension of cycle life of >40% during 0.5C cycling. Further, a perspective is provided on scaling ultrafast laser ablation of battery electrodes to industrial throughputs. Additionally, lessons learned from this pilot-scale demonstration are provided in regards to optical architecture, debris removal, and system control. A techno-economic analysis is used to demonstrate that laser ablation can be integrated into existing electrode manufacturing facilities with only ≈$\$$1.3 per kWh increase (≈2%) in manufacturing cost. Preemptive electrode design for laser ablation is discussed as a further method for enhancing performance. Finally, an analysis of available laser systems and beam-scanning architectures is used to determine design requirements to scale process throughput to a state-of-the-art speed of 50 m min −1 . This analysis demonstrates that laser ablating Li-ion battery electrodes has multiple benefits to manufacturing and battery performance, that the technology already exists to achieve high laser-ablation throughputs, and that integrating ultrafast laser ablation to electrode manufacturing will not create a cost or processing bottleneck.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Toward exascale whole-device modeling of fusion devices: Porting the GENE gyrokinetic microturbulence code to GPU

GENE solves the five-dimensional gyrokinetic equations to simulate the development and evolution of plasma microturbulence in magnetic fusion devices. The plasma model used is close to first principles and computationally very expensive to solve in the relevant physical regimes. In order to use the emerging computational capabilities to gain new physics insights, several new numerical and computational developments are required. Here, we focus on the fact that it is crucial to efficiently utilize GPUs (graphics processing units) that provide the vast majority of the computational power on such systems. In this paper, we describe the various porting approaches considered and given the constraints of the GENE code and its development model, justify the decisions made, and describe the path taken in porting GENE to GPUs. We introduce a novel library called gtensor that was developed along the way to support the process. Performance results are presented for the ported code, which in a single node of the Summit supercomputer achieves a speed-up of almost 15× compared to running on central processing unit (CPU) only. Typical GPU kernels are memory-bound, achieving about 90% of peak. Our analysis shows that there is still room for improvement if we can refactor/fuse kernels to achieve higher arithmetic intensity. We also performed a weak parallel scalability study, which shows that the code runs well on a massively parallel system, but communication costs start becoming a significant bottleneck.

Germaschewski, K. (ORCID:0000000284956354)↗

Development of a Sustainable Green Chemistry Platform for Production of Acetone and Downstream Drop-in Fuel and Commodity Products directly from Biomass Syngas via a Novel Energy Conserving Route in Engineered Acetogenic Bacteria

LanzaTech and Oak Ridge National Laboratory have developed and scaled up a process for sustainable production of acetone and downstream drop-in fuel and commodity products directly from biomass syngas via a novel energy conserving route in engineered acetogenic bacteria. This process offers a safer and more environmentally-friendly production method for acetone production than the current phenol-dependent method, and the product has significantly lower GHG emissions. The developed process offers a cost competitive route to Acetone and enables biofuels at or below DOE’s $3/gge target. In addition, it also provides an attractive biological alternative to traditional sugar-based ABE fermentation, by enabling utilization of non-food biomass resources as fermentation feedstocks. Challenges overcome: (1) By-products formation: Byproduct 2,3-butanediol and 3-hydroxybutyrate reduce yield and stability. Addressed by elimination of both pathways in the chassis acetone production strain. (2) Cost competitiveness: Addressed by developing an integrated acetone strain and eliminating by-products to increase yield and stability. Optimized co-selectivity and co-productivity of acetone and ethanol, based on technoeconomic analysis. (3) Limited enzyme variety: Addressed by genome mining of over 300 industrial strains in LanzaTech collection, identifying unique enzyme sequences, and refactoring these unique enzyme variants through LanzaTech’s engineering platform. Resulted in over 10x improvement in acetone production from gas. (4) Continuous process (stability): Identified bottleneck through detailed omics studies, addressed by integration of the acetone pathway on the chromosome. (5) Novel process to scale up: Addressed by demonstrating stable acetone production in an 80-L pilot reactor, with acetone productivity and selectivity comparable to those observed under the same conditions in 2-L reactors. LanzaTech has demonstrated stable acetone production for over 7 days at commercial target rate and selectivity in a 2-L reactor and have piloted the process.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Evaluating Retention Index Score Assumptions to Refine GC–MS Metabolite Identification

As metabolomics grows into a high-throughput and high demand research field, current metrics for the identification of small molecules in gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) still require manual verification. Though steps have been taken to improve scoring metrics by combining spectral similarity (SS) and retention index (RI), the problem persists. A large body of literature has analyzed and refined SS scores, but few studies have explicitly studied improvements to RI scores. Here, in this study, we examined whether uninvestigated assumptions of the RI score are valid and propose ways to improve them. Query RIs were matched to library RI with a generous window of ±35 to avoid unintentional removal of valid compound identifications. Each match was manually verified as a true positive (TP), true negative, or unknown. Metabolites with at least 30 TP identifications were included in downstream analyses, resulting in a total of 87 metabolites from samples of varying complexity and type (e.g., amino acid mixtures, human urine, fungal species, and so on.). Our results showed that the RI score assumptions of normality, consistent variance across metabolites, and a mean error centered at 0 are often violated. We demonstrated through a cross-validation analysis that modifying these underlying assumptions according to empirical metabolite-specific distributions improved the TP and negative rankings. Further, we statistically determined the minimum number of samples required to estimate distributional parameters for scoring metrics. Overall, this work proposes a robust statistical pipeline to reduce the time bottleneck of metabolite identification by improving RI scores and thus minimize the effort to complete manual verification.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Visualizing Hierarchical Performance Profiles of Parallel Codes Using CallFlow

Calling context trees (CCTs) couple performance metrics with call paths, helping understand the execution and performance of parallel programs. To identify performance bottlenecks, programmers and performance analysts visually explore CCTs to form and validate hypotheses regarding degraded performance. However, due to the complexity of parallel programs, existing visual representations do not scale to applications running on a large number of processors. In this work, we present CallFlow, an interactive visual analysis tool that provides a high-level overview of CCTs together with semantic refinement operations to progressively explore CCTs. Using a flow-based metaphor, we visualize a CCT by treating execution time as a resource spent during the call chain, and demonstrate the effectiveness of our design with case studies on large-scale, production simulation codes.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Functional characterization and regulatory modeling of lignocellulose deconstruction in the saprophytic bacterium Cellvibrio japonicus (Final Technical Report)

The goal of this project was to establish a fundamental systems-level model of lignocellulose deconstruction by saprophytic soil bacteria while simultaneously identifying and characterizing novel enzymes that can be used for applied bioenergy technologies. This project was significant because it elevated our mechanistic and regulatory understanding of bacterial plant biomass degradation and led to technologies to enable bottlenecks in biofuel production R&D. Furthermore, the completed work was novel because it integrated in vivo, in vitro, and in silico approaches with bioenergy-relevant substrates. We identified the required enzymes for lignocellulose degradation and mechanisms of regulation through a combination of transcriptomic profiling (RNAseq), enzymatic analysis, the functional characterization of mutants, and modeling of the regulatory networks used to detect and degrade lignocellulose. This project employed the lignocellulose-degrading bacterium Cellvibrio japonicus to dissect the functional properties and underlying regulatory networks saprophytic bacteria use to depolymerize and utilize lignocellulose. There were four Objectives to this project, the specific metrics of which are summarized in this report.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Efficient energy transfer in light-harvesting systems: Quantum-classical comparison, flux network, and robustness analysis

Following the calculation of optimal energy transfer in thermal environment in our first paper [J. L. Wu, F. Liu, Y. Shen, J. S. Cao, and R. J. Silbey, New J. Phys. 12, 105012 (2010)], full quantum dynamics and leading-order 'classical' hopping kinetics are compared in the seven-site Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) protein complex. The difference between these two dynamic descriptions is due to higher-order quantum corrections. Two thermal bath models, classical white noise (the Haken-Strobl-Reineker (HSR) model) and quantum Debye model, are considered. In the seven-site FMO model, we observe that higher-order corrections lead to negligible changes in the trapping time or in energy transfer efficiency around the optimal and physiological conditions (2% in the HSR model and 0.1% in the quantum Debye model for the initial site at BChl 1). However, using the concept of integrated flux, we can identify significant differences in branching probabilities of the energy transfer network between hopping kinetics and quantum dynamics (26% in the HSR model and 32% in the quantum Debye model for the initial site at BChl 1). This observation indicates that the quantum coherence can significantly change the distribution of energy transfer pathways in the flux network with the efficiency nearly the same. The quantum-classical comparison of the average trapping time with the removal of the bottleneck site, BChl 4, demonstrates the robustness of the efficient energy transfer by the mechanism of multi-site quantum coherence. To reconcile with the latest eight-site FMO model which is also investigated in the third paper [J. Moix, J. L. Wu, P. F. Huo, D. F. Coker, and J. S. Cao, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2, 3045 (2011)], the quantum-classical comparison with the flux network analysis is summarized in Appendix C. The eight-site FMO model yields similar trapping time and network structure as the seven-site FMO model but leads to a more disperse distribution of energy transfer pathways.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗