Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “throughput”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 325 records · Page 18

Adaptive Sample Preparation and Target Fabrication for High-Throughput Materials Science

High-repetition-rate brilliant and coherent light sources are significantly increasing the rate at which scientific experiments can be performed. An investment in transformative technologies to make samples of condensed matter could enable a paradigm shift for that field or open new exciting frontiers in high-energy density science (HEDS). This will especially be true for dynamic materials in extremes research or HEDS, where the repetition rate for placing samples into extreme environments is increasing and the samples or targets are irreversibly destroyed in each experiment. Research teams that are able to implement solutions to all aspects of the experimental process and enable a paradigm of high-throughput science will have the greatest success and impact. There are two different directions for adaptive samples. One is research when the number of experiments can be greatly increased with increased volume, such as in high energy density science. The other is when flexibility and agility can aid Bayesian optimization computational methods and speed up the discovery process, as with materials science. Conducting a similar equation-of-state (EOS) experiment took three years on the OMEGA laser facility, compared to five days of shifts at the LCLS XFEL. New materials with improved properties have been found by guided optimization of experimental science. Adaptive sample preparation and target fabrication can create a tremendous return on scientific investment. High-throughput enabling precision science is also a desirable goal. To address these issues, we sought a diverse set of innovative participants who had ideas of how to achieve this paradigm shift. We invited 42 researchers from a variety of disciplines and fields to attend a workshop in College Station, Texas, May 14–16, 2019. Many of the participants had never been in the same room before, and most found it very exciting to hear about new and different research. The goal was twofold: to define the challenges, i.e., “what would we like to be able to do and why it is difficult to do so,” and to describe the progress, approaches and capabilities, as well as the vision, “what we could do if we had more support.”

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Development and Operation of a High Throughput Computer Hard Disk Drive Recycling Enterprise (CRADA NFE-16-05989)

The aim of this collaborative effort is to develop, construct and operate a high throughput computer hard disc drive (HDD) recycling system. Research conducted as part of the Critical Materials Institute (CMI), a Department of Energy (DOE) Energy Innovation Hub, has revealed the economic rationale and the necessary technology for a potentially viable HDD recycling enterprise. Moreover, the very notion of CMI is the development of replacement sources of rare earth critical materials that enable the U.S. to become less dependent on single source supplies. Focused on end-of-life (EOL) consumer products containing rare earth permanent magnets, this cooperative endeavor will develop, construct and operate a highly automated recycling process. Demonstrating economically viable recycling of high value products is largely an untapped resource in the U.S. Recycling HDDs to recover rare earth magnets and other valuable materials (e.g. aluminum, steel, printed circuit boards, copper, etc.) presents a new opportunity to satisfy U.S. demand for highly desirable commodities. The goal of this cooperative research and development agreement (CRADA) project is to create a commercial HDD recycling enterprise that changes the landscape of rare earth magnet material and magnet availability for U.S. manufacturers. Underpinning this primary goal is the development and demonstration of an economic HDD recycling process that provides a significant and alternative supply of rare earth magnets that is not dependent upon foreign sourcing. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) has researched the technology options and down selected specific sub-process technologies based upon throughput and economic potential. The participant, however, brings significant process design, development and operational experience that may result in process improvement or optimization strategies that will be explored in collaboration with the contractor. The final outcome of this CRADA is a system/process for recycling large quantities of HDDs. The technology is available for commercial scale-up.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Higher Throughput, Lower Cost Processing of Flexible Perovskite Solar Cells by Photonic Curing

The objectives of this SETO project are to explore whether photonic curing can be used to perform annealing in perovskite solar cell (PSC) fabrication, and if so, whether it can enable high-throughput PSC manufacturing. The successful outcome of the project will reduce manufacturing cost towards realizing the SETO goal of the Levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) $0.03/kWh by 2030. The project is a collaboration between Hsu’s group at the University of Texas at Dallas (UTD) and NovaCentrix, an Austin TX based company that pioneered the PulseForge® photonic curing tools and has expertise in applying this technology to printed electronics. Thin-film synthesis typically involves a thermal annealing step to convert from precursors to final material phases, to obtain the desired crystalline phase, or to improve materials structural or electrical properties. However, thermal annealing typically requires high temperatures that are incompatible with inexpensive plastic substrates and annealing times lasting tens-to-hundreds of minutes, making it incompatible with roll-to-roll (R2R) manufacturing at a desirable web speed. Photonic curing uses a flash Xe lamp to deliver short (20 µs to 100 ms) but high intensity (up to 50 kW/cm 2 ) pulses of broadband light (200 – 1500 nm) to the sample. It has been successfully applied to sinter printed metal nanoparticle inks into conductive patterns. This project aimed to extend the applications of photonic curing to convert halide perovskite films and transparent metal oxide transport layers. Despite the interruption by COVID-19, we have achieved significant accomplishments to establish photonic curing as a viable technology for the high-throughput manufacturing of PSCs. (1) We demonstrated that photonic curing can convert both metal oxide transport layer and halide perovskite absorber in the PSCs and successfully made flexible PSCs on Corning Willow glass® (WG)/ indium tin oxide (ITO) substrates without any thermal annealing steps. These photonically cured devices achieve performance comparable to conventional thermally annealed devices but were fabricated with a total processing time reduced by six orders of magnitude. We also show that photonic curing can achieve desirable web speed (up to 26 m/min) and large-area uniformity. (2) By establishing photonic curing processing phase spaces for the perovskite, we show that the longer pulses are more forgiving in small variation in the photonic curing conditions, making it more suitable for R2R manufacturing. (3) Our results clearly illustrated the importance of improving mechanical and optical properties of transparent electrodes on flexible substrates. (4) We also performed fundamental studies that elucidate the interactions between perovskite absorber and metal oxide transport layer that can undermine the PSC stability. Five refereed journal papers in top journals (ACS Energy Letters, npj Flexible Electronics, ACS Applied Energy Materials, Materials Advances, and Frontiers in Energy Research), one conference proceeding (PVSC-47), six conference presentations (PVSC and Materials Research Society meetings), and a Ph.D. dissertation (Trey B. Daunis) were produced under this project. Energy Materials Corporation (EMC) has forecast that with a 1.5 m wide web moving at a web speed of 30 m/min, R2R processing of PSC could provide up to 4 GW/year for a single R2R assembly line. Replacing thermal annealing with photonic curing, as demonstrated by the accomplishments of this project, is necessary to realize such an energy production goal.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

High Throughput In-Line Coating Metrology Development for Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Manufacturing

Coatings play key roles in solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) stack durability. For example, diffusion barrier coatings on Cr-containing interconnect and balance of plant (BOP) components protect electrodes from Cr poisoning over the long operational lifetimes (>10,000 hours) of the fuel cell stack. Common defects in coatings, such as cracks, pinholes, and porosity, result in a failure to protect the electrodes, resulting in shorter operational lifetime and thus higher cost. It is very unlikely, even in the best coating process, that all these defects can be mitigated, hence identifying critical defects in parts, and removing defective parts from production before they can damage the stack, becomes paramount. Furthermore, these quality control techniques must be operational in the production/assembly line (in-line), i.e., high throughput and non-destructive, and cost effective. Redox Power Systems, LLC (Redox) together with the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) developed much needed high throughput, in-line metrology techniques for protective coatings. The overall goal of the project is to lower cost while increasing robustness, reliability, and endurance of SOFC stacks. To accomplish this, we had several objectives, including: to identify key coating and substrate defects that lead to coating failure through the use of detailed characterization methods (e.g., microscopy, XRD, EDS, electrochemistry); to assess capabilities of in-line metrology techniques, e.g., optical profilometry (Redox) and thermography (NREL), to probe these defects, or evidence thereof; demonstrate long-term performance of “defect-free” protective coatings, as identified by in-line metrology, in solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) stack operation. In the first part of this project, the ability to identify key defects expected to lead to coating and SOFC degradation using in-line metrology tools were evaluated. Coated interconnect samples with controlled defect types and populations were tested under conditions similar to SOFC operation, followed by detailed post-test analysis to reveal the defects responsible for observed degradation. In the second part of the project, the optimal in-line metrology techniques and methodologies were used to map the defect distribution in full-size interconnects with critical defects intentionally allowed to exist in some cases. These interconnects underwent SOFC testing for extended periods (up to ~3,000 hours) followed by post-test analysis to evaluate the effectiveness of in-line metrology techniques in mitigating MCO coating related degradation. Key accomplishments in this project included the following: Demonstrated ASR of < 0.05 ohm-cm 2 at 650 °C for 1,000 hours with low defect (determined by in-line metrology) interconnect samples (average ASR=37 milliohms-cm 2 after over 1,000 hours). Demonstrated that low defect coatings on interconnects (as screened using in-line metrology) have low volatilization of chromium at ~650 °C for 1,000 hours as detected using Cr-getter material (< 5 at% increase above baseline); 1022 hour duration tests under humidified, elevated temperature (750 °C rather than 650 °C) compared a base case against different coating thicknesses. Demonstrated capability to identify initial key defects of interest with in-line metrology techniques using up to 8 cm by 10 cm having coatings with and without intentional defects of interest using thermal imaging and optical profilometry. Correlated key defects identified using metrology techniques with observed coating performance (e.g., ASR and Cr volatility). Conducted several 4 cm by 4 cm cell tests using MCO-interconnects that were pre-screened using some of the metrology techniques developed in the project (e.g., optical profilometry). An analysis of ASR measurements were able to show that defect-free coatings resulted in the anticipated performance in the cell tests.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

High-throughput native mass spectrometry as experimental validation for in silico drug design

In this project, we developed automated workflows for both experimental validation and computational prediction of protein-ligand interactions. The ultimate goal is to establish an integrated pipeline for high throughput design of inhibitors to enzymes relevant to all areas of biological research. Our experimental approach is based on native mass spectrometry (native MS), which measures accurate masses and quantify the relative abundance of protein-ligand complexes to define binding affinity. We set up an in-house built autosampler with highly flexible configurations to minimize the manual steps for high throughput native MS. In parallel, we also performed manual native MS to characterize the binding of substrates and inhibitors of SARS-Cov-2 nonstructural protein nsp10/16 in order to optimize the experimental parameters for future automation. On the computational side, we streamlined the pipeline to achieve minimal manual intervention for predicting enzyme inhibitors via simulation, using the same nsp10/16 system as an example. Using the native MS method we examined 8 top-ranked designed compounds, 2 of which showed weak binding of ~50 µM. The information from native MS experiment provided critical insights and the foundation for a fully integrated workflow for enzyme inhibitor design.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

A Platform Technology for High-throughput Atomically Precise Manufacturing: Mechatronics at the Atomic Scale

The main objective of this project is to invent the necessary enabling technologies for high throughput atomically precise manufacturing (APM). APM is an emerging technology that refers to any manufacturing capability that enables fabrication of atomically precise structures, components, and devices under programmable control. APM will require positional assembly at the atomic and/or molecular scale, as well as at the nano and microscales using hierarchical assembly to create products ranging from nanoscale and quantum devices to macroscale systems and materials. This project builds on the expectation that commercial viability of APM will depend on a high level of parallelism to achieve the required throughput, a capability that currently does not exist. This project is the first attempt to address this key technological bottleneck.

77 NANOSCIENCE AND NANOTECHNOLOGY↗

High Throughput Source-less Plasma Deposition of Structured Silicon Anodes for Lithium-Ion Batteries

Amprius developed a manufacturing solution for silicon nanowire anode that relies on an inexpensive, high throughput, and high gas precursor utilization plasma deposition method that uses the anode foils as electrodes for plasma generation. The capacitively couple plasma (CCP) method is used in semiconductor and photovoltaic industry and Amprius modified existing high throughput equipment to use anode foils and to deposit amorphous silicon. The equipment was installed ahead of the program at Amprius site. The rest of the tasks included foil handling and process development. The equipment passed site acceptance tests (SAT) and the process parameter mapping was completed, indicating that the target process window limits produce output materials at the rate and with yield and specifications that meet the manufacturing target criteria. Amprius has hired supporting personnel to optimize processes and run the equipment. A parallel task verified the baseline performance of the silicon anode material, to be used as reference for the new manufacturing method.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

High Throughput Genome Releaser

In this study, we present the development of a High Throughput Genome Releaser, an innovative device addressing common challenges in screening PCR. This genome DNA releaser is designed for rapid, cost-effective, and efficient DNA extraction, optimized for subsequent PCR reactions. Our experimentation with various synthetic materials led us to select a particular type of plastic that mirrors the properties of glass cover slides, providing a smooth surface and effective compression capabilities. We engineered a 96-well device equipped with a 96-well plate and a top rod, operable both manually and automatically, which is compatible with widely used liquid-handling robot decks. This compatibility enhances ease of use in high-throughput PCR setups. Additionally, we developed software to support its automatic functions. The genome releaser facilitates the extraction of PCR-amplifiable genomic DNA from 96 samples within minutes, eliminates the need for extraction buffers, and is adaptable to a wide range of microorganisms and cells. This versatility could significantly advance biomanufacturing processes.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Characterization of Performance Degradation Mechanisms in Low-Cost High Throughput DI-O3 Layer for Passivated Contact Silicon Solar Cells

Characterization and mitigating performance limiting defects in Silicon (Si) PV is one of key areas to be addressed to improve PV hardware costs and energy yield in order to lower the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) of installed PV cost to $0.02/kWh. As Si PV cells efficiencies have surpassed 22% and approaching 23%, the recombination at the metal contacts have become the focus point to be addressed. Passivated contact technologies—having a heterojunction with a band-gap larger than silicon between the metal and silicon—have emerged as a great potential for future highand ultrahigh-efficiency solar cells, as it concurrently reduces recombination and increases carrier selectivity, by incorporating thin films within the contact structure. Passivated contact Si solar cell technologies use a wide variety of tunnel layers—playing a crucial role to passivate metal contacts and tunnel charge carriers—including stoichiometric silicon oxide (SiO 2 ) grown by thermal oxidation and Low-Pressure Chemical Vapor Deposition (LPCVD) technique and silicon oxide (SiO x ) by hot nitric acid. However, thorough investigations on understanding the failure and performance degradation mechanisms associated with tunnel layers are still limited to date. Unlocking those degradation characteristics in crucial tunnel layers could improve the reliability and energy yield of passivated contact Si solar cells. Besides, the technique of growing aforementioned tunneling layers are low throughput, and requires high temperature processes and/or a vacuum environment. In this project, we investigated the performance degradation mechanisms of a low-cost high-throughput ozonated oxide (DI-O 3 ) tunnel layer for the passivated contact Si solar cells.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Micro-Mechanically Guided High-Throughput Alloy Design Exploration Towards Metastability-Induced H Embrittlement Resistance

We develop a high-throughput approach for studying H embrittlement (HE)-resistance in alloys, which is based on combinatorial compositional screening of metastability effects by in situ scanning electron microscopy H-analyses. The project objective included: (i) technique development of high-throughput screening (HTS) for HE-resistance, (ii) discovery of new metallic materials with superior HE-resistance, (iii) Multiscale verification of HE-resistance of the new alloys and H-barrier layers, from atomic scale to an engineering scale. The investigation focused on a model system that enables exploration of different metastable states in Fe-based complex-concentrated alloys. Composition spread islands with hundreds of varying compositions are fabricated on a single substrate using a combinatorial co-sputtering technique. To screen these alloys, we developed and employed a home-built SEM-based integrated analysis system capable of characterizing H-permeability, H-trapping, H-influence on mechanical properties, and other material properties, as well as atomistic to continuum simulations to study the underlying physics.

08 HYDROGEN↗

High Throughput Solvent-free Manufacturing of Battery Electrodes

The project goal is to develop and demonstrate an advanced solvent-free lithium-ion battery electrode process through proposed Advanced Dry Electrode Process (ADEP) equipment, which is expected to exhibit a better binder fibrillization and high throughput and suitable for high performance electrode manufacturing, and commonize the anode and cathode dry processing equipment, supply chain and operation for lithium-ion battery OEMs for replacing the solvent-based slurry casting. Our proposed approach will facilitate low-cost battery production by addressing the following gaps in present dry electrode processing: • Extend the dry electrode fabrication process to lithium-ion battery anode manufacturing • Increase the active material content for anodes and cathodes • Intensify the process through improved mixing, powder rheology and surface modifications • Enable processing of next-generation electrode materials that are not stable to solvent or ambient air exposure. The project objectives include the development of anode-compatible binder and binder fibrillization promoter for low irreversible capacity loss, low electrode binder content yet higher film mechanical strength, and the optimization of solvent-free anode and cathode process for low cost (>60% electrode cost reduction), high performance (10% increase in energy density without sacrificing cycle life) and high throughput to enable next generation lithium-ion battery electrode production. Solvent-free electrode manufacturing will also enable next-generation cell designs based on prelithiated anodes or solid-state electrolytes.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Development of high throughput light-sheet fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy for 3D functional imaging of metabolic pathways in plant and microorganisms (Final Technical Report)

This research program will enable new biochemical contrast in the nanosecond lifetime domain through use of the recently demonstrated electro-optic fluorescence lifetime imaging technique (EO-FLIM) for wide-field lifetime imaging. The Stanford/Stanford Linear Accelerator Center multidisciplinary collaboration -- physics, applied physics, and structural biology -- will develop a light-sheet fluorescence lifetime imaging microscope for functional studies of microbial and plant metabolic pathways and dynamic interactions between plants and microorganisms in the rhizosphere. The proposed approach overcomes the imaging time bottleneck associated with existing fluorescence lifetime imaging methods. Initial demonstrations have shown a factor of 100,000 improvement in photon throughput compared to existing methods. High photon efficiency allowed the first wide-field fluorescence lifetime imaging of single molecules. Recent work has improved the technique’s repetition rate to enable compatibility with mode-locked lasers and demonstrated the combination of wide-field fluorescence lifetime imaging with super-resolution localization microscopy, observations of single molecule dynamics, and observation of donor lifetime quenching in single-molecule imaging. These results were achieved on standard camera sensors and would not have been possible with other wide-field approaches. The throughput and photon economy of the EO-FLIM method enables new BER-relevant imaging opportunities. In particular, scanned single- and two-photon light-sheet excitation will be used to achieve volumetric imaging with time-domain contrast.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Evaluation of a New Remote Handling Design for High Throughput Annular Centrifugal Contactors

Advanced designs of nuclear fuel recycling plants are expected to include more ambitious goals for aqueous based separations including; higher separations efficiency, high-level waste minimization, and a greater focus on continuous processes to minimize cost and footprint. Therefore, Annular Centrifugal Contactors (ACCs) are destined to play a more important role for such future processing schemes. Previous efforts defined and characterized the performance of commercial 5 cm and 12.5 cm single-stage ACCs in a “cold” environment. The next logical step, the design and evaluation of remote capable pilot scale ACCs in a “hot” or radioactive environment was reported earlier. This report includes the development of remote designs for ACCs that can process the large throughput rates needed in future nuclear fuel recycling plants. Novel designs were developed for the remote interconnection of contactor units, clean-in-place and drain connections, and a new solids removal collection chamber. A three stage, 12.5 cm diameter rotor module has been constructed and evaluated for operational function and remote handling in highly radioactive environments. This design is scalable to commercial CINC ACC models from V-05 to V-20 with total throughput rates ranging from 20 to 650 liters per minute. The V-05R three stage prototype was manufactured by the commercial vendor for ACCs in the U.S., CINC mfg. It employs three standard V-05 clean-in-place (CIP) units modified for remote service and replacement via new methods of connection for solution inlets, outlets, drain and CIP. Hydraulic testing and functional checks were successfully conducted and then the prototype was evaluated for remote handling and maintenance suitability. Removal and replacement of the center position V-05R ACC unit in the three stage prototype was demonstrated using an overhead rail mounted PaR manipulator. This evaluation confirmed the efficacy of this innovative design for interconnecting and cleaning individual stages while retaining the benefits of commercially reliable ACC equipment for remote applications in the nuclear industry. Minor modifications and suggestions for improved manual remote servicing by the remote handling specialists were provided but successful removal and replacement was demonstrated in the first prototype.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

High Throughput Screening of Nanostructured Hydrogen Storage Materials

Hydrogen storage is the most challenging task for the hydrogen economy. We established a multidisciplinary research program for high throughput combinatorial synthesis and characterization of novel nanoporous and metastable complex hydrides, coupled to fundamental material studies including electronic, structural and kinetic transport modeling, and pump-probe experiments. Our research is based the concept of hybrid nanostructures that store hydrogen by a combination of chemi- and physorption: atomic hydrogen is stored in metastable hydrides while molecule hydrogen is stored in the nanometer pores of the hydrides. Metastable nanostructured hydride has been achieved by introducing structural and compositional disorders through high throughput elemental substitution/doping, catalyst addition, and nonequilibrium processing. Fast screening compatible with the combinatorial synthesis was achieved by combining X-ray structural characterization with the development of a laser-based microbalance. Manufacturing of nanoporous metahydrides that are identified as promising by the combinatorial synthesis has been explored along with the materials search.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

RESULTS OF THE FY09 ENHANCED DOE HIGH LEVEL WASTE MELTER THROUGHPUT STUDIES AT SRNL

High-level waste (HLW) throughput (i.e., the amount of waste processed per unit time) is a function of two critical parameters: waste loading (WL) and melt rate. For the Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant (WTP) at the Hanford Site and the Defense Waste Processing Facility (DWPF) at the Savannah River Site (SRS), increasing HLW throughput would significantly reduce the overall mission life cycle costs for the Department of Energy (DOE). The objective of this task is to develop data, assess property models, and refine or develop the necessary models to support increased WL of HLW at SRS. It is a continuation of the studies initiated in FY07, but is under the specific guidance of a Task Change Request (TCR)/Work Authorization received from DOE headquarters (Project Number RV071301). Using the data generated in FY07, FY08 and historical data, two test matrices (60 glasses total) were developed at the Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL) in order to generate data in broader compositional regions. These glasses were fabricated and characterized using chemical composition analysis, X-ray Diffraction (XRD), viscosity, liquidus temperature (TL) measurement and durability as defined by the Product Consistency Test (PCT). The results of this study are summarized below: (1) In general, the current durability model predicts the durabilities of higher waste loading glasses quite well. A few of the glasses exhibited poorer durability than predicted. (2) Some of the glasses exhibited anomalous behavior with respect to durability (normalized leachate for boron (NL [B])). The quenched samples of FY09EM21-02, -07 and -21 contained no nepheline or other wasteform affecting crystals, but have unacceptable NL [B] values (> 10 g/L). The ccc sample of FY09EM21-07 has a NL [B] value that is more than one half the value of the quenched sample. These glasses also have lower concentrations of Al{sub 2}O{sub 3} and SiO{sub 2}. (3) Five of the ccc samples (EM-13, -14, -15, -29 and -30) completely crystallized with both magnetite and nepheline, and still had extremely low NL [B] values. These particular glasses have more CaO present than any of the other glasses in the matrix. It appears that while all of the glasses contain nepheline, the NL [B] values decrease as the CaO concentration increases from 2.3 wt% to 4.3 wt%. A different form of nepheline may be created at higher concentrations of CaO that does not significantly reduce glass durability. (4) The T{sub L} model appears to be under-predicting the measured values of higher waste loading glasses. Trends in T{sub L} with composition are not evident in the data from these studies. (5) A small number of glasses in the FY09 matrix have measured viscosities that are much lower than the viscosity range over which the current model was developed. The decrease in viscosity is due to a higher concentration of non-bridging oxygens (NBO). A high iron concentration is the cause of the increase in NBO. Durability, viscosity and T{sub L} data collected during FY07 and FY09 that specifically targeted higher waste loading glasses was compiled and assessed. It appears that additional data may be required to expand the coverage of the T{sub L} and viscosity models for higher waste loading glasses. In general, the compositional regions of the higher waste loading glasses are very different than those used to develop these models. On the other hand, the current durability model seems to be applicable to the new data. At this time, there is no evidence to modify this model; however additional experimental studies should be conducted to determine the cause of the anomalous durability data.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

To have value, comparisons of high-throughput phenotyping methods need statistical tests of bias and variance

The gap between genomics and phenomics is narrowing. The rate at which it is narrowing, however, is being slowed by improper statistical comparison of methods. Quantification using Pearson’s correlation coefficient ( r ) is commonly used to assess method quality, but it is an often misleading statistic for this purpose as it is unable to provide information about the relative quality of two methods. Using r can both erroneously discount methods that are inherently more precise and validate methods that are less accurate. These errors occur because of logical flaws inherent in the use of r when comparing methods, not as a problem of limited sample size or the unavoidable possibility of a type I error. A popular alternative to using r is to measure the limits of agreement (LOA). However both r and LOA fail to identify which instrument is more or less variable than the other and can lead to incorrect conclusions about method quality. An alternative approach, comparing variances of methods, requires repeated measurements of the same subject, but avoids incorrect conclusions. Variance comparison is arguably the most important component of method validation and, thus, when repeated measurements are possible, variance comparison provides considerable value to these studies. Statistical tests to compare variances presented here are well established, easy to interpret and ubiquitously available. The widespread use of r has potentially led to numerous incorrect conclusions about method quality, hampering development, and the approach described here would be useful to advance high throughput phenotyping methods but can also extend into any branch of science. The adoption of the statistical techniques outlined in this paper will help speed the adoption of new high throughput phenotyping techniques by indicating when one should reject a new method, outright replace an old method or conditionally use a new method.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

Robust High-Throughput Phenotyping with Deep Segmentation Enabled by a Web-Based Annotator

The abilities of plant biologists and breeders to characterize the genetic basis of physiological traits are limited by their abilities to obtain quantitative data representing precise details of trait variation, and particularly to collect this data at a high-throughput scale with low cost. Although deep learning methods have demonstrated unprecedented potential to automate plant phenotyping, these methods commonly rely on large training sets that can be time-consuming to generate. Intelligent algorithms have therefore been proposed to enhance the productivity of these annotations and reduce human efforts. We propose a high-throughput phenotyping system which features a Graphical User Interface (GUI) and a novel interactive segmentation algorithm: Semantic-Guided Interactive Object Segmentation (SGIOS). By providing a user-friendly interface and intelligent assistance with annotation, this system offers potential to streamline and accelerate the generation of training sets, reducing the effort required by the user. Our evaluation shows that our proposed SGIOS model requires fewer user inputs compared to the state-of-art models for interactive segmentation. As a case study of the use of the GUI applied for genetic discovery in plants, we present an example of results from a preliminary genome-wide association study (GWAS) of in planta regeneration in Populus trichocarpa (poplar). We further demonstrate that the inclusion of a semantic prior map with SGIOS can accelerate the training process for future GWAS, using a sample of a dataset extracted from a poplar GWAS of in vitro regeneration. The capabilities of our phenotyping system surpass those of unassisted humans to rapidly and precisely phenotype our traits of interest. The scalability of this system enables large-scale phenomic screens that would otherwise be time-prohibitive, thereby providing increased power for GWAS, mutant screens, and other studies relying on large sample sizes to characterize the genetic basis of trait variation. Our user-friendly system can be used by researchers lacking a computational background, thus helping to democratize the use of deep segmentation as a tool for plant phenotyping.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

High-Throughput Field Plant Phenotyping: A Self-Supervised Sequential CNN Method to Segment Overlapping Plants

High-throughput plant phenotyping—the use of imaging and remote sensing to record plant growth dynamics—is becoming more widely used. The first step in this process is typically plant segmentation, which requires a well-labeled training dataset to enable accurate segmentation of overlapping plants. However, preparing such training data is both time and labor intensive. To solve this problem, we propose a plant image processing pipeline using a self-supervised sequential convolutional neural network method for in-field phenotyping systems. This first step uses plant pixels from greenhouse images to segment nonoverlapping in-field plants in an early growth stage and then applies the segmentation results from those early-stage images as training data for the separation of plants at later growth stages. The proposed pipeline is efficient and self-supervising in the sense that no human-labeled data are needed. We then combine this approach with functional principal components analysis to reveal the relationship between the growth dynamics of plants and genotypes. We show that the proposed pipeline can accurately separate the pixels of foreground plants and estimate their heights when foreground and background plants overlap and can thus be used to efficiently assess the impact of treatments and genotypes on plant growth in a field environment by computer vision techniques. This approach should be useful for answering important scientific questions in the area of high-throughput phenotyping.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗