Comment on 'Magnetospheric origin of energetic (E greater than or equal to 50 keV) ions upstream of the bow shock: The October 31, 1977, event' by G. C. Anagnostopoulos, E. T. Sarris, and S. M. Krimigis
Observational data on the effects of the solar burst event of October 31, 1977 on the earth bow shock are reassessed in a critical examination of the hypothesis of Anagnostopoulos et al. (1986), that energetic ions detected upstream of the shock originated in the magnetosphere and then leaked into the upstream region. The upstream and magnetospheric observations are compared, and consideration is given to the proton energy spectrum, anisotropies, and connection time. It is found that the event in question can best be explained in terms of Fermi shock acceleration. In a reply by Anagnostopoulos et al., additional data on this and similar events are presented in extensive graphs and analyzed. It is argued that there are many observed phenomena which cannot be explained by Fermi acceleration but are consistent with upstream leakage.