Validation of CTF Droplet Entrainment and Annular/Mist Closure Models using Riso Steam/Water Experiments
This report summarizes the work done to validate the droplet entrainment and de-entrainment models as well as two-phase closure models in the CTF code by comparison with experimental data obtained at Riso National Laboratory. The Riso data included a series of over 250 steam/water experiments that were performed in both tube and annulus geometries over a range of various pressures and outlet qualities. Experimental conditions were set so that the majority of cases were in the annular/mist ow regime. Measurements included liquid lm ow rate, droplet ow rate, lm thickness, and two-phase pressure drop. CTF was used to model 180 of the tubular geometry cases, matching experimental geometry, outlet pressure, and outlet ow quality to experimental values. CTF results were compared to the experimental data at the outlet of the test section in terms of vapor and entrained liquid ow fractions, pressure drop per unit length, and liquid lm thickness. The entire process of generating CTF input decks, running cases, extracting data, and generating comparison plots was scripted using Python and Matplotlib for a completely automated validation process. All test cases and scripting tools have been committed to the COBRA-TF master repository and selected cases have been added to the continuous testing system to serve as regression tests. The dierences between the CTF- and experimentally-calculated ow fraction values were con- sistent with previous calculations by Wurtz, who applied the same entrainment correlation to the same data. It has been found that CTF's entrainment/de-entrainment predictive capability in the annular/mist ow regime for this particular facility is comparable to the licensed industry code, COBRAG. While lm and droplet predictions are generally good, it has been found that accuracy is diminished at lower ow qualities. This nding is consistent with the noted deciencies in the Wurtz entrainment model employed by CTF. The CTF predicted two-phase pressure drop in the annular/mist ow regime has been found to be highly inaccurate, exhibiting a clear bias with respect to the experimental data. This inaccuracy led to an investigation that revealed deciencies in the implementation of the annular/mist interfacial friction model, which should be investigated further in the future. Looking to published COBRAG results for this same facility reveal it exhibits no bias with regard to experimental pressure drop results. In addition to the problems with pressure drop prediction, the lm thickness was also signicantly under-predicted by CTF compared to both experimental data and Wurtz's analytical calculations. Film thickness is calculated using a simple geometric relationship and lm void fraction in CTF, which is dependent on slip ratio and interfacial friction. It is possible that the issues aecting the pressure drop and lm void prediction are related.