Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Comparison study”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 37 records · Page 2
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2026

An International Laboratory Comparison Study on Approximating the Enthalpy of Adsorption via the Clausius‐Clapeyron Approach

Materials-based gas capture and storage is an increasingly important area of research. Robust and accurate determination of material properties is required for judicial selection of materials for specific applications and for engineering materials–based systems at scale. One key property is the strength of the adsorbate–adsorbent interaction often quantified via the isosteric enthalpy of adsorption. The heat of adsorption can be measured directly through calorimetry; however, a more widely used approach is to apply the Clausius-Clapeyron (CC) equation to adsorption isotherms collected at different temperatures. While this approach appears to be straightforward, there exist multiple variants in the application of the methodologies employed. This raises the question on how these variations may or may not affect the determined results. Presented here is a discussion of the most common methodologies and a comparison of indirect determinations (via CC) of the isosteric enthalpy of adsorption by different laboratories on identical material. Included in that comparison are discussions on the measurement and analysis reproducibility. Importantly, details of the methodologies are shown to be critical when comparing enthalpies among laboratories, and different methodologies contribute to significant discrepancies and artifacts in the results. Recommendations are provided to promote robust determination and the reporting thereof.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2018

A comparison study of the reporting systems for salivary gland fine needle aspirations: Are they really different?

Background Recently a new system for reporting salivary gland fine‐needle aspiration (FNA) cytology was proposed, the Milan System for Reporting Salivary Gland Cytopathology (MSRSGC). Herein, we evaluated diagnostic accuracy of salivary gland FNA, comparing the system previously used in our hospital with the Milan system. Methods Salivary gland specimens obtained between 2011 and 2017 were reclassified according to MSRSGC. Risk of malignancy for each diagnostic category was determined. Diagnostic yield of both classifications was evaluated. Results The cases ( n = 388) were classified according to the old system: nondiagnostic ( n = 28), benign ( n = 246), atypical ( n = 36), neoplastic ( n = 57), suspicious for malignancy ( n = 7) and malignant ( n = 14). The lesions were distributed according to the MSRSGC: nondiagnostic ( n = 28), non‐neoplastic ( n = 89), atypia of undetermined significance ( n = 39), benign neoplasm ( n = 156), neoplasm of uncertain malignant potential ( n = 55), suspicious for malignancy ( n = 7) and malignant ( n = 14). When considering only benign and malignant cases, both classifications showed the same sensitivity (62.5%), specificity (100%) and similar accuracy (95.8%). Comparison between the two systems showed no significant difference. Conclusions Salivary gland FNA has high diagnostic accuracy and assists clinical management independently of the reporting system used, however, in some cases, the use of Milan system could be beneficial, since it allows an enhanced category stratification.

Montezuma, Diana↗
DOE OSTI2019

Balloon-Expandable Biodegradable Stents Versus Self-Expandable Metallic Stents: A Comparison Study of Stent-Induced Tissue Hyperplasia in the Rat Urethra

Purpose: To compare the degrees of stent-induced tissue hyperplasia of balloon-expandable, biodegradable stents (BEBSs) with those of self-expandable metallic stents (SEMSs) in a rat urethral model. Materials and Methods: A total of 20 rats were randomized into two groups. The BEBS group (n = 10) received a poly-l-lactic acid (PLLA) biodegradable stent. The SEMS group (n = 10) received a nitinol bare stent. All rats were killed eight weeks after stent placement. The degree of stent-induced tissue hyperplasia was assessed by comparing the results of retrograde urethrography and histologic examination between the two groups. Results: Stent placement was technically successful in all rats. Two rats in the BEBS group were excluded due to procedure-related death. The mean luminal diameter of stented urethra on urethrograms was not significantly different at 4 and 8 weeks between the two groups. On histologic analysis, the percentage of granulation tissue area (p < 0.001) and the thickness of papillary projection (p < 0.001) were significantly higher in the BEBS group compared with the SEMS group. The inflammatory cell infiltration showed a clear tendency to significance (p = 0.050). There were no statistical differences in the number of epithelial layers and the thickness of submucosal fibrosis between the two groups. Conclusion: Formation of stent-induced tissue hyperplasia was significantly evident in the rat urethra with similar degrees between the BEBS and the SEMS. The BEBS was associated with a thicker papillary projection and larger granulation tissue area resulting from higher inflammation compared with the SEMS.

62 RADIOLOGY AND NUCLEAR MEDICINE↗
DOE OSTI2020

A comparison study on trading behavior and profit distribution in local energy transaction games

With the increasing integration of distributed energy resources, localized peer-to-peer energy transactions are receiving more attention since they could absorb more distributed renewables locally and stabilize the power grid. To better study the trading behavior and provide guidance for a viable local market design, different game-theoretical frameworks including cooperative and non-cooperative games are established and compared here. For the cooperative grand coalition, the maximum social welfare is guaranteed, the Shapley value and bargaining based approaches are implemented for further profit redistribution. It is shown that the asymmetrical bargaining power can be critical in the final payment clearing and it is equivalent to the Shapley value allocation if prosumers bargain based on their marginal contributions. Non-cooperative trading is formulated by using a Stackelberg bilevel model in which the upper level has the privilege in internal price setting. However, system optimum is not obtained due to competition, and the selfish leader could take away 89% of the collective benefit by price-gap based arbitraging. Aiming for a long-lasting trading market, a virtual benevolent leader and a uniform price structure in which purchase price equals selling price are tested. Experimental results indicate that maximum social welfare and a fairer profit allocation can be achieved with a uniform price structure, regardless of the selfish or benevolent attitude.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗
DOE OSTI2018

A comparison study of local lattice distortion in Ni 80 Pd 20 binary alloy and FeCoNiCrPd high-entropy alloy

In this paper, the effect of alloying Pd on the local lattice distortion (LLD) in the Ni and FeCoNiCr host matrixes is quantified by integrating local structure characterization and theoretical calculations. The local structure measurements reveal that the mean LLD in the FeCoNiCrPd high-entropy alloy (HEA) is twice as high as the Ni 80 Pd 20 binary alloy though the FeCoNiCr base alloy has a negligible mean LLD. Density functional theory calculations unveil that the unexpected high mean LLD in FeCoNiCrPd is related to the high fluctuation of LLD in the FeCoNiCr matrix. Finally, these observations suggest a synergetic effect of chemical complexity on HEAs' mean LLD.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Kinetically Controlled Synthesis of Rhodium Nanocrystals with Different Shapes and a Comparison Study of Their Thermal and Catalytic Properties

Here, we report the synthesis of Rh nanocrystals with different shapes by controlling the kinetics involved in the growth of preformed Rh cubic seeds. Specifically, Rh nanocrystals with cubic, cuboctahedral, and octahedral shapes can all be obtained from the same cubic seeds under suitable reduction kinetics for the precursor. The success of such a synthesis also relies on the use of a halide-free precursor to avoid oxidative etching, as well as the involvement of a sufficiently high temperature to remove Br – ions from the seeds while ensuring adequate surface diffusion. The availability of Rh nanocrystals with cubic and octahedral shapes allows for an evaluation of the facet dependences of their thermal and catalytic properties. The data from in situ electron microscopy studies indicate that the cubic and octahedral Rh nanocrystals can keep their original shapes up to 700 and 500 °C, respectively. When tested as catalysts for hydrazine decomposition, the octahedral nanocrystals exhibit almost 4-fold enhancement in terms of H 2 selectivity relative to the cubic counterpart. As for ethanol oxidation, the order is reversed, with the cubic nanocrystals being about three times more active than the octahedral sample.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Measurement of Photoneutrons from Depleted Uranium and Comparison Study Using MCNPX-PoliMi

High-energy photon interrogation is a nondestructive technique that is used to detect special nuclear materials and characterize nuclear waste. The development of such systems is complex and requires Monte Carlo simulations to optimize system performance. Monte Carlo simulations rely on various scattering, absorption, and photonuclear cross-section data. While the scattering and absorption cross-section data have been extensively studied and validated with experiments, the results obtained from photonuclear simulations are often found to underpredict measured results, indicating uncertainties in the photonuclear cross sections themselves. Thus, there is a need for new measured results that can be used to quantify underpredictions in simulations using photonuclear cross-section data. In the present work, we interrogated depleted uranium with a 9-MV electron linac and detected photoneutrons with trans-stilbene organic scintillators. The measurement of photoneutrons with organic scintillators is challenging due to the presence of the intense photon flux, which causes issues such as pulse pile-up, detector saturation, and poor signal-to-background ratio. To mitigate these challenges, we used iron and polyethylene shielding of varying thicknesses around the depleted uranium target and a neural network–based digital pulse processing algorithm to recover neutron and photon information from piled-up events. Our goal was to compare the measured photoneutron count rate with the simulated rate obtained using the MCNPX-PoliMi transport code. For a light output window of 0.28 to 2.67 MeVee (1.66- to 6.85-MeV proton recoil energy), we found that the simulated count rate obtained using the ENDF/B-VII photonuclear cross-section library underpredicts the measured rate by 32.8% 3.2%. Additionally, we compared the simulated and measured photoneutron light output distributions. For the least thicknesses of shielding, the simulation was found to underpredict measurements in the 0.70- to 2.67-MeVee light output window. For the greatest thicknesses of shielding, the simulation was found to underpredict the measurement across the entire light output window of 0.28 to 2.67 MeVee.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗
DOE OSTI2018

A Comparison Study of the Performance of South/North Facing vs East/West-Facing Bifacial Modules under Shading Condition

Horizon obstructions can decrease the diffuse and direct light received by photovoltaic (PV) modules. In this paper, we compare the performances of the two bifacial PV system orientations: optimally tilted facing south/north (Bi S/N ), and vertically installed facing east/west (Bi E/W ) under no-shading and shading conditions. We considered multiple locations with different latitudes and weather types and observed that without any horizon obstructions, Bi S/N outperforms Bi E/W for most locations. However, certain types of obstructions cause Bi E/W to have higher energy yield than Bi S/N . For sunnier and lower latitude locations such as Albuquerque, NM, a very large obstruction at south causes this result. On the other hand, for higher latitude locations (e.g. Anchorage, AK), much smaller obstructions at south is enough to have higher energy yield for Bi E/W than Bi S/N . Under certain shading conditions Bi E/W produces up to 75 kWh/year more energy than Bi S/N.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2019

Sensitivity/Uncertainty Comparison Study: Oak Ridge National Laboratory Results [Slides]

Various methods and sensitivity/uncertainty tools have been developed over the years to assist in determining upper subcritical limits (USLs). The task is to compare calculated USLs from various methods on a small set of benchmark problems. The benchmark experiments selected are the following applications: HEU-MET-FAST-013-001, HEU-SOL-THERM-001-008, PU-MET-FAST-022-001, and PU-SOL-THERM-001-001.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2025

Comparison Study of Conventional and Adaptive Mesh Refinement in Organic Material Decomposition Models

This study compares conventional mesh refinement techniques, specifically Uniform Mesh Refinement (UMR), with a new Adaptive Mesh Refinement (AMR) method, applied to Organic Material Decomposition (OMD) models. The proposed benefit of AMR is that only areas that require refinement, based on minimizing a specific field gradient, are refined thus decreasing model wall time compared to conventional UMR methods. This work specifically focuses on comparing UMR and AMR methods on decomposing (both No-Flow and Porous-Flow material models) Polymeric Methylene Diisocyanate (PMDI) polyurethane foam. Throughout the work, the geometry increased in complexity to assess the refinement methods performance at varying levels geometric intricacy. While AMR has been shown to work well in a variety of applications, the UMR approach proved to be computationally faster, for many of the geometries and foam decomposition models, than AMR. However, it was observed that at higher levels of refinement, greater than 3 UMR, AMR begins to be computationally better. Additionally, the settings used to perform AMR greatly impact its performance, and lessons learned, in terms of OMD models, are shared. Due to physics involved in material decomposition, specifically the evolution of state variables, these problems don’t fully benefit from the advantages of AMR.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2019

WEC-Sim Array Development and Experimental Comparison Study: Preprint

Wave energy is still considered to be an emerging industry, and one significant contribution that researchers are making is to find solutions that reduce costs. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory and Sandia National Laboratories have contributed to this by creating WEC-Sim, an opensource modeling toolbox, to assist with early design decisions related to the design of wave energy converters (WECs). Previously, studies involving WEC-Sim have focused on single WEC modeling. In this paper, we will conduct a validation study to investigate the accuracy and ability of WEC-Sim to model arrays of WECs. The results from the WEC-Sim array simulations are compared to those from an existing experimental study. In addition, the array model is used to investigate the interaction between the WECs in the array and the influence of array spacing on the WECs' hydrodynamic performance.

16 TIDAL AND WAVE POWER↗