Lattice Confinement Fusion Fast Fission - Power System for Accessing Icy Worlds
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Lattice confinement fusion eliminates massive magnets and powerful lasers.
Lattice Confinement Fusion (LCF) • Published 2020, Physical Review C 1,2 • Patented and Commercialized 2024, Astral Systems • LCF in compact neutron generator 50x increase in neutron flux, 99% from LCF • Produce medical radioisotopes • LCF Fast-Fission Hybrid Reaction • No Enriched Uranium • Demonstrated with US Navy and GEC • Modeling and Scaling under NIAC and NSF funding • Application • Deep space • Power: Icy worlds • Propulsion: Nuclear Electric Propulsion • Planetary Surface Power: Lunar and Mars • Terrestrial • DoD Operational Energy • Onsite power for Data Centers
Lattice Confinement Fusion (LCF) • Published 2020, Physical Review C 1,2 • Patented and Commercialized 2024, Astral Systems • LCF in compact neutron generator 50x increase in neutron flux, 99% from LCF • Produce medical radioisotopes • LCF Fast-Fission Hybrid Reaction • No Enriched Uranium • Demonstrated with US Navy and GEC • Modeling and Scaling under NIAC and NSF funding • Application • Deep space • Power: Icy worlds • Propulsion: Nuclear Electric Propulsion • Planetary Surface Power: Lunar and Mars • Terrestrial • DoD Operational Energy • Onsite power for Data Centers
Both NASA and Google have explored and funded Low Energy Nuclear Reaction (LENR) aka Solid-State Fusion or Lattice Confinement Fusion (LCF) research. NASA has funded efforts since 1989, and Google Research began in 2014. Google, and researchers initially-funded by Google, published significant scientific papers in Nature, Nature Communications and the Journal of Applied Physics. NASA began a significant set of LENR-triggering programs in 2012 resulting in papers in Physical Review C, the Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry and the Journal of Condensed Matter Nuclear Science. Both NASA and Google engaged researchers across fields of nuclear physics, chemistry, electrochemistry, material science and more. NASA built upon early novel gas pumping experiments then followed the patented work of the US Navy SPAWAR (US8,419,919, “System and Method to Generate Particles”) and experiments with the Naval Surface Warfare Centers. Google supported researchers at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL), the University of British Columbia (UBC), MIT and others. This resulted in patent applications and two granted patents (US10264661B2, “Target structure for enhanced electron screening” and US10566094B2 “Enhanced electron screening through plasmon oscillations”). These separate efforts, unknown to the researchers at the time, provided the impetus for the DoE ARPA-E LENR program followed by the DARPA DSO “Mechanisms for Amplification of Fusion Reaction Rates in Solids” (MARRS) program. This document briefly describes the overlapping NASA and Google Research efforts in plasma loading and electron screening emphasizing the results of the latest paper in Nature Communications. The papers and patents cited are listed.
Specific Impulse, Isp, is a measure of a rocket engine’s efficiency. It is calculated relative to the Earth’s gravitational field, where Isp = ve/ go, with go= 9.8 m/s2 and the escape velocity of the propellant, ve, in m/s. Chemical rockets have ve < 4.4x103 m/s and Isp < 450 seconds. As an alternative, the NASA Glenn Research Center developed multiple generations of Solar Electric Propulsion (SEP), high Isp, ion engines using Xe gas as a propellant. Consequently, over 100 SEP Ion Thrusters provide geo-synchronous station keeping along with deep space probes like Deep Space One and Dawn. These have ve » 2.9 x 104 m/s with Isp = 3x103 seconds. These thrusters have continuous operating lifetimes of thousands of hours allowing continuous acceleration making up for the very low thrust. Chang-Diaz’ Variable Specific Impulse Magnetoplasma Rocket (VASIMR) has the potential for four times the propellant escape velocity and four times the specific impulse1. Unfortunately, this comes at a tremendous electrical power cost, estimated at 200 kWe for maintaining the International Space Station in Low Earth Orbit (LEO). Although nuclear fission and fusion reactors2 have been suggested for powering nuclear thermal propulsion (NTP) it only doubles the Isp over chemical rockets but with comparable thrust. Instead, we propose using Lattice Confinement Fusion (LCF) reactions.
We are responding to the RFI points A1, A2 and A3. We appreciate the need for a high density, high power, environmentally-benign and carbon-neutral power system. Although fusion has been considered for over 70 years, the nearly intractable means of maintaining a hydrogen plasma at temperatures exceeding the center of the Sun increasingly delays not only commercialization but even the scientific breakeven point. As a recent JASON report notes, the world-wide energy grid is moving towards decentralization which is counter to the large tokamak fusion de-vices necessary given their underdense plasmas. NASA has spent several years understanding and developing Lattice Confinement Fusion as an alternative to thermonuclear fusion by exploring many means of loading and triggering fusion reactions in deuterated metal lattices. Triggering has run the gamut from bremsstrahlung-initiated photo-neutrons to the role of electron screening in assisting these reactions. Electron screening may be responsible for both nuclear effects in deuterium pumped metals as well as fast neutrons observed from electrolytically driven cathodes. Electron screened fusion rate enhancement has been observed by others, including the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. NASA’s need for deep space power drove this research with a goal of a ten-year lifetime for a multi-kWe power system. Previous NASA studies have explored the use of fusion systems for nuclear thermal propulsion for manned spaceflight to the outer planets. Despite these designated uses, small-scale terrestrial power applications as well as medical isotope production are possible once scaling is achieved. ARPA-E can contribute to the Nation’s Green Energy mandates by funding research in this field that builds on condensed matter nuclear science findings by the US Navy and NASA.
LENR experiments using various loading and triggering mechanisms rely on a variety of elemental and isotopic assays to determine LENR effects. These assays include optical microscopy, Scanning Electron Microscopy with Energy Dispersive X-Ray Analysis (SEM/EDX), X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) and Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM). All of these methods observe the surface of a material. By dissolving or vaporizing the sample, Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Element Spectroscopy (ICP-OES) can determine elemental composition (ppb) or with mass spectroscopy, isotopes (ICP/MS). One can use a focused ion beam (FIB) to cut open a sample and observe the “cut” with either SEM/EDX, or Time-of-Flight Secondary Ion Mass Spectroscopy (TOF-SIMS). High Purity Gamma Ray Spectroscopy (HPGe) and alpha/ beta Liquid Scintillator spectroscopy can be used. We’ve employed these assay methods in our NASA GRC research under both the Advanced Energy Conversion and Lattice Confinement Fusion Projects. However, there are limitations associated with each of these methods ranging from handling contamination, instrumental limitations including sensitivity and field of view, and sample preparation.
In 1954, Salpeter calculated nuclear reaction rates would increase via weak and strong electron screening in stars. Astrophysical observations and laboratory astrophysics experiments have confirmed that electron screening reduces the Coulomb Barrier between charged particles. Fermi degenerate strong screening occurs when the electron density exceeds 10e23 electrons/cm3 in the cores of gas giant planets, White Dwarf Stars, the conduction bands of metals, deuterated LENR materials and Inertial Confinement Fusion targets at maximum compression. We have modelled these quantum mechanical effects with Density Functional Theory codes.
Over 36 years of laboratory astrophysics experiments employing accelerated hydrogen isotope beams have demonstrated the role of electron screened, enhanced nuclear reactions. The astrophysical role of weak and strong electron screening was first discussed by Saltpeter [1] in 1954 and later by Hagino and Balantekin [2] in 2002. Assenbaum, et al. [3], Czerski, et al. [4], and Schenkel, et al., [5] have used accelerated deuteron beams on various metal targets and observed increased fusion rates over the expected Astrophysical, S(E), and Gamow Factors for bare deuteron-deuteron fusion rates. The Pines calculated both electron screened direct and asymptotic enhancement factors, f(E) [6]. Arguably, electron screening makes LENR possible.
Over 36 years of laboratory astrophysics experiments employing accelerated hydrogen isotope beams have demonstrated the role of electron screened, enhanced nuclear reactions. The astrophysical role of weak and strong electron screening was first discussed by Saltpeter in 1954 and later by Hagino and Balantekin in 2002. Assenbaum, et al., Czerski, et al., and Schenkel, et al., have used accelerated deuteron beams on various metal targets and observed increased fusion rates over the expected Astrophysical, S(E), and Gamow Factors for bare deuteron-deuteron fusion rates. The Pines calculated both electron screened direct and asymptotic enhancement factors, f(E). Arguably, electron screening makes LENR possible.
Although the most sought-after hot plasma fusion reactions use deuterium-tritium due to its higher fusion cross-section, the deuteron-deuteron fusion reaction is also used and is suspected in Low Energy Nuclear Reactions (LENR). Although LENR reactions are largely aneutronic, the D(d,n)3He reaction produces a 2.45 MeV kinetic energy neutron. In the course of fusion experiments at NASA, ranging from bremsstrahlung photoneutron-initiated fusion to Pd/D co-deposition, we’ve made use of liquid and solid neutron scintillator spectrometers, bubble detectors and Solid State Nuclear Track Detectors (CR-39). We have observed the unfolded neutron energy spectrum from primary fusion and boosted fusion or stripped neutrons from photoneutron induced fusion. Despite an average deuteron energy of 64 keV, the peak unfolded neutron flux was only a few neutrons/minute. The major problem was the 10e14vgamma ray/neutrons/second flux ratio.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Nuclear fusion research for energy applications aims to create conditions that release more energy than required to initiate the fusion process1. To generate meaningful amounts of energy, fuels such as deuterium need to be spatially confined to increase the collision probability of particles2, 3–4. We therefore set out to investigate whether electrochemically loading a metal lattice with deuterium fuel could increase the probability of nuclear fusion events. Here we report a benchtop fusion reactor that enabled us to bombard a palladium metal target with deuterium ions. These deuterium ions undergo deuterium–deuterium fusion reactions within the palladium metal. We showed that the in situ electrochemical loading of deuterium into the palladium target resulted in a 15(2)% increase in deuterium–deuterium fusion rates. This experiment shows how the electrochemical loading of a metal target at the electronvolt energy scale can affect nuclear reactions at the megaelectronvolt energy scale.
Low-density polymer foams of varying sizes, shapes, and densities are of specific interest to the inertial confinement fusion (ICF) program and related high-energy density plasma physics research. Historically, these foams are comprised of polystyrene or other low atomic number materials and have densities in the 30 to 300 mg/cm 3 range. However, at the lower end of this density range, these traditional polymer foams become fragile and difficult to cast and machine into the geometries needed. Recently, the need by experimentalists for materials with densities below 30 mg/cm 3 has increased. To address these needs, we are developing three-dimensional (3-D) printing techniques to create high-precision, low-density, and repeatable complex lattice structures. Using two-photon polymerization 3-D printing, we recently developed the first 5 mg/cm3 low-density lattice structure having an annular hemispherical shape. These microscale to mesoscale structures were modeled and designed using the nTopology software, specifically utilizing the "Voronoi volume lattice" and "random points in body" option blocks. All printing operations were performed using the Nanoscribe Photonic Professional GT instrument. Characterization of these 3-D structures was conducted using various microscopic and X-ray tomographic imaging techniques. Furthermore, overall printed part sizes ranged from 1 to 5 mm in diameter and were composed of lattice ligaments having thicknesses in the 3- to 5-µm range. These structures have been incorporated into ICF targets recently shot on both the University of Rochester’s Laboratory of Laser Energetics Omega laser and the National Ignition Facility.
Laser direct-drive liquid deuterium–tritium (DT) wetted foam capsules hold substantial promise for future advancements in inertial confinement fusion (ICF). For this new class of ICF capsules, additive manufacturing (AM) techniques are used to create low aspect ratio spherical shells of a low-density, foam-like CH lattice, which is wetted with cryogenic liquid DT. In the present paper, we discuss key physics issues intrinsic to ignition and burn propagation in laser direct drive wetted foam capsules. These include requirements on laser energy and power, implosion velocity, fuel adiabat, and initial density and dimensions of the CH lattice shell.
The introduction of a high-precision, 3D-printing method, known as two-photon polymerization (2PP), has created a new means of producing novel targets to study inertial confinement fusion (ICF). Here, this work aims to explore if 2PP fabricated capsules can meet ICF requirements such as size, uniformity, deuteration degree, and ability to maintain gas fill. Two types of capsules with 3D-printed lattices were evaluated on the Omega-60 Laser Facility: (1) carbon-deuterium-oxygen (CDO) lattice with a H 2 gas fill and (2) carbon-hydrogen-oxygen (CHO) lattice with a D 2 gas fill. Experimental results and numerical simulations, which assumed complete mixing of capsule materials, reasonably agreed for both target types. A further study into the effects of capsule preheat or 2PP geometry on material mix is underway. Our work demonstrates that the unique capabilities of customizable, 3D-printed capsules present promising opportunities for further investigation into more sophisticated mix and burn experiments in ICF.