TRISO Fuel Part I: Background, Fabrication, and Irradiation Performance
Review TRISO fuel design, fabrication, and performance, with a focus on recent results and developments in the last ~15 years
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Review TRISO fuel design, fabrication, and performance, with a focus on recent results and developments in the last ~15 years
A TRISO-coated fuel thermo-mechanical performance study is performed for the hybrid LIFE engine to test the viability of TRISO particles to achieve ultra-high burnup of a weapons-grade Pu blanket. Our methodology includes full elastic anisotropy, time and temperature varying material properties for all TRISO layers, and a procedure to remap the elastic solutions in order to achieve fast fluences up to 30 x 10{sup 25} n {center_dot} m{sup -2} (E > 0.18 MeV). In order to model fast fluences in the range of {approx} 7 {approx} 30 x 10{sup 25} n {center_dot} m{sup -2}, for which no data exist, careful scalings and extrapolations of the known TRISO material properties are carried out under a number of potential scenarios. A number of findings can be extracted from our study. First, failure of the internal pyrolytic carbon (PyC) layer occurs within the first two months of operation. Then, the particles behave as BISO-coated particles, with the internal pressure being withstood directly by the SiC layer. Later, after 1.6 years, the remaining PyC crumbles due to void swelling and the fuel particle becomes a single-SiC-layer particle. Unrestrained by the PyC layers, and at the temperatures and fluences in the LIFE engine, the SiC layer maintains reasonably-low tensile stresses until the end-of-life. Second, the PyC creep constant, K, has a striking influence on the fuel performance of TRISO-coated particles, whose stresses scale almost inversely proportional to K. Obtaining more reliable measurements, especially at higher fluences, is an imperative for the fidelity of our models. Finally, varying the geometry of the TRISO-coated fuel particles results in little differences in the scope of fuel performance. The mechanical integrity of 2-cm graphite pebbles that act as fuel matrix has also been studied and it is concluded that they can reliable serve the entire LIFE burnup cycle without failure.
This is a deck of slide to be presented to the 6th Workshop on Material Properties of TRISO Fuels October 19-20, 2022.
The NEAMS Multiphysics Applications team continues to assess code usability and functionality for microreactor design and safety analyses, while demonstrating that NEAMS tools capture both steady-state and transient behavior across distinct microreactor concepts. In FY2025, the team advanced full-core, high-fidelity, multiphysics models that solve more complex problems and strengthen verification/validation for several microreactor systems: heat-pipe microreactor (HPMR), gas-cooled microreactor (GCMR), and the KRUSTY experiment. These models employ the MOOSE MultiApp/Transfers architecture with Griffin for neutronics, BISON for heat conduction/thermomechanics, Sockeye for heat pipes, SAM/THM for coolant channels and loops, and SWIFT for hydride behavior, with meshes generated via the MOOSE Reactor Module. The graphite models available in the Grizzly code were also investigated for future analyses. For the HPMR, a Na-HPMR variant was constructed to align with recently validated heat-pipe experiments and Sockeye’s LCVF capability, enabling mechanistic heat-pipe transients and startup modeling. The Na-HPMR will serve as the primary model for HPMR investigations in upcoming tasks. The load-following and single heat-pipe failure scenarios (Griffin/BISON/Sockeye), which were previously modeled for the K-HPMR, were replicated for the Na-HPMR, showing strong negative temperature feedback and highly localized thermal effects, respectively, while the startup case captured vapor-front progression and heat-removal activation. Solid mechanics was added to the previously built K-HPMR full-core model in BISON, showing minimal impact on steady-state reactivity yet enabling stress-field predictions that prepare the path for full-core TRISO performance analyses. For the GCMR, automated steady-state and four transient scenarios were executed using Griffin/BISON/SAM/SWIFT. Results confirm robust inherent safety: power collapses promptly in loss-of-cooling events, the inlet-temperature drop settles to a new equilibrium, and a single-channel blockage yields only a ~30 K local fuel-temperature rise with <0.4% power decrease. SWIFT-predicted hydrogen redistribution affects reactivity during both steady-state and transient conditions, underscoring its importance. A Brayton-cycle balance of plant (BOP) model in SAM/THM demonstrated stable startup behavior, and xenon-driven reactivity during load following was analyzed. To improve TRISO-compact temperature fidelity, a fast multiscale Heat Source Decomposition (HSD) treatment was implemented. Against heterogeneous benchmarks, HSD reduces underprediction of kernel temperatures and lowers predicted peak powers in reactivity-insertion transients compared to previous homogenized models. KRUSTY warm-critical validation progressed from FY2024 baselines: the 15Ȼ insertion shows excellent agreement in peak power (~2% high) and temperature trends, and the 30Ȼ case was automated via a feedback controller that maintained power near 3 kW for ~150 s with close agreement to data. The successful modeling of the warm critical tests has laid a strong foundation for simulating more complex nuclear system tests in the years ahead. Throughout FY2025, developer feedback was provided (e.g., MOOSE batch mesh generation, distributed pre-split meshes, Griffin sweeper on displaced meshes), several new models were contributed to the Virtual Test Bed, and an OECD-NEA WPRS multiphysics benchmark based on the HPMR was initiated to enable broader cross-comparison and best-practice development with the nuclear community at large.
This document is a presentation intended to be provided as a status update on current work developing compact-level TRISO fuel performance analyses.
Not Available
This document is a PowerPoint presentation basically summarizing the publication found here: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022311522002082
Several development and analysis tasks were undertaken in FY21 under the Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation program to enhance modeling of non light–water reactors (LWRs) with Shift. Specifically, these efforts targeted enhancements for tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel modeling. A new Shift user interface was developed that allows for much better usability and ease of modeling for non-LWR problems and TRISO fuel. Performance studies were conducted using an HTR-10 fuel pebble model by comparing different geometry packages in Shift, KENO-VI, and Serpent. These studies showed that the new geometry package in Shift performs well compared to Serpent for TRISO fuel modeling with consistent tracking options between both packages. The studies also identified the most critical areas of improvement for more efficiently performing Monte Carlo transport on TRISO fuel models with Shift. Tally calculations in Shift were optimized for non-LWR cross section generation and depletion calculations, and areas for further optimization and accuracy improvements were identified. Finally, initial collaboration efforts were formed between Idaho National Laboratory, Argonne National Laboratory, and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to use Shift for Comprehensive Reactor Analysis Bundle support.
Fuel performance modeling status update and potential model improvements overview of TRISO fuel performance modeling codes PARFUME/BISON, AGR experiment support, potential modeling improvements, BISON smeared cracking model, BISON fission product source term, and AGR-3/4 reirradiation heating test.
For all high-temperature gas-cooled reactors, TRIS
High Temperature Gas Reactor (HTGR), widely recognized as one of the top candidates for the Next Generation Nuclear Power-plant (NGNP) fleet, has received ever-increasing interest due to its superior safety and many other desirable features. TRISO fuel particles are the basic form of the fuel used in both pebble-bed and prismatic reactors. Since they are a key component of the HTGR core design, the success of the reactor depends on the safety and quality of the TRISO particles. During operation, a TRISO particle undergoes complex thermo-mechanical processes. Fission gases accumulate inside the kernel and the buffer layer, and lead to buildup of internal pressure. Uneven thermal conditions lead to asymmetric thermal expansion. The pyrolytic carbon, in both the IPyC and OPyC layers, is known to experience dimensional change (shrinkage or swelling) under fast neutron irradiation. In the mean time, both the IPyC and OPyC layers creep as a function of stress and fast neutron fluence. Macro cracks in the IPyC layer, corrosion in the SiC layer due to chemical attack, and debonding at the interface between IPyC and SiC, have been observed in post-irradiation examinations. All these processes further complicate the stress states in a TRISO particle, and might lead to failure of a single coating layer or the particle as a whole. It is very difficult to duplicate the actual environment that a particle is exposed to in experiments. It is even more difficult to isolate one process from another, thus making it nearly impossible to evaluate the impacts that a particular process has on the fuel particle by conducting experiments. The problem can however at least partially be addressed by modeling and simulation. Hence, multi-dimensional, multi-physics and comprehensive models are greatly needed to simulate and evaluate the performance of a TRISO particle under normal and accidental conditions. Existing models are inadequate as they are usually one-dimensional models that over-simplified these processes or do not include all the main physics. The goal of this thesis is to develop a comprehensive, multi-dimensional and multi-physics model to simulate and evaluate TRISO fuel performance. It includes all the main processes taking place in the fuel particle. Three equally important components of this modeling exercise are: 1) 3D heat transfer and temperature distribution analysis; 2) 3D neutronics, heat generation, and fission gas generation and release analysis; 3) 3D stress analysis and failure prediction of the TRISO particle. The 3D thermal model consists of the solution of the heat conduction equation using the finite difference technique. The temperature calculated using this model is compared to analytical solutions and to the results reported in literature. Good agreements are observed. Thermal models are developed to calculate temperature distribution in a pebble under different power and asymmetric convective boundary conditions caused by, for example, contacts with other pebbles. Three-dimensional temperature distribution in a TRISO particle is also calculated under various conditions such as in the presence of an off-center gas bubble. Three-dimensional neutronics models are developed using MCNP5/X. Burnup calculations are performed to track the number densities of a few important isotopes and to calculate gas production. The fractional gas release on both intra- and inter-granular level are calculated using the White and Tucker’s model. The gas pressure inside the buffer layer is also quantified. Finally, 3D axisymmetric stress models are developed using an open-source finite element code, FEAP. Modifications are introduced to FEAP to include PyC shrinkage and creep, etc. The modified code is benchmarked against Miller’s results, and good agreements are observed. A number of variables are studied to evaluate their impacts on stresses and failure probabilities. These variables include creep constant, creep Poisson’s ratio, irradiation temperature, BAF, layer thickness, etc. Some transient thermal conditions such as power surge, and defective cases such as a radial crack in IPyC, debonding and corrosion to SiC, are also studied. Among all, a few variables/conditions have significant impacts on stresses and failure probabilities, namely: shrinkage strain, creep constant, creep Poisson’s ratio, particle size, irradiation temperature, BAF and cracked IPyC. Order of magnitude of stresses resulting from temperature changes, pressure buildup due to gas generation, and due to PyC shrinkage/creep show that in the case of TRISO particle (when using specific empirical constants or existing dataset found in literature to calculate shrinkage/creep strains), stresses due to temperature changes and internal gas pressure are orders of magnitude lower than those resulting from shrinkage/creep. Failure probabilities of both IPyC and SiC are also calculated. The failure probability of IPyC under most conditions borderlines with the design requirement (1E-4) except under low irradiation temperature. The failure probability of SiC under normal conditions is minimal because it is always under compression; except when there is a radial crack in IPyC, in which case the stress in part of SiC becomes tensile and the failure probability is higher than 1E-4, and increases at higher burnup. The comprehensive fuel performance model developed in this work and implemented in a suite of computer codes simulates the thermo-mechanical behavior of a TRISO fuel particle under irradiation. This work leads to a better understanding of TRISO fuel particle evolution over its lifetime, and provides insights in how to improve the safety and reliability of TRISO fuel. The models developed here can be useful for other purposes related to TRISO fuel or for fuel performance evaluation of other forms of nuclear fuels. (author)
TRIstructural ISOtropic (TRISO) single sub-millimeter-diameter nuclear fuel particle consists of a spherical fuel kernel surrounded by four coating layers. During reactor operation, the TRISO coating layers are subjected to irradiation-induced dimensional changes and the associated thermomechanical behavior of each layer. One of the observed behaviors is gap formation between the buffer and IPyC layer due to the porous buffer’s irradiation-induced shrinkage exceeding that of the IPyC layer. To predict TRISO thermomechanical performance, multi-physics models have been built that are continually updated and refined. The BISON code is a finite element-based nuclear fuel performance code that may be used for TRISO particle simulations. One of the recent additions to the BISON code is the ability to model the process of layer debonding. This paper will focus on the simulation results of the improved BISON debonding model that will utilize updated strengths measured from irradiated TRISO fuel particles. The new experimental strength data from micromechanical tests of irradiated TRISO fuel samples were exercised in the BISON simulations and compared to baseline strength data to assess their applicability in the models. This also includes updated buffer-IPyC bond strengths to simulate layer delamination. Based on current experimental observations it is noted that the buffer-IPyC separation occurs not exactly at the junction of these two layers, but more on the side of the buffer layer. This improved modeling approach using experimental strength data to characterize buffer-IPyC debonding and its potential subsequent cracking will be presented in the paper along with comparisons to available experimental observations.
Uranium oxycarbide (UCO)-bearing tri-structural isotropic (TRISO) particle fuels are expected to be used in numerous U.S. commercial reactor applications within the next decade. Here, in this work, we reviewed historical particle fuel transient experiments to identify gaps in TRISO fuel performance transient testing. A BISON–Griffin modeling framework was then developed to conduct preliminary TRISO transient analyses and begin to address these gaps. The framework was demonstrated using limiting-case transient conditions from a prototypic high-temperature gas-cooled reactor (HTGR). It was then applied to develop a matrix of experiments that could be performed in the Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) to (1) evaluate UCO-fueled particle performance at moderate and high heat rates, (2) assess whether historical testing involving UO 2 -fueled particles is applicable to modern UCO-fueled particles, (3) deconvolute the impacts of temperature and heat rate on particle transient response, and (4) collect the data needed for fuel performance model validation and/or further development.
Idaho National Laboratory (INL) performs post irradiation examination (PIE) of tri-structural isotropic (TRISO)-coated particle fuel to help qualify it for high temperature gas cooled reactors. TRISO fuel compacts are re-irradiated in the Neutron Radiography Reactor (NRAD) to generate the short lived fission products needed for fission product release testing. The Fuel Accident Condition Simulator (FACS) furnace and newly added Screen Neutron Irradiated Fuel for Failure (SNIFF) furnace heat the compacts in helium to temperatures of up to 2,000°C, prompting fission product release—predominantly gaseous xenon and krypton isotopes and condensable products such as cesium—from failed particles. These released isotopes are transported to a fission gas monitoring system (FGMS 1 or FGMS 3), where they accumulate in cryogenic cold traps and are quantified using high-purity germanium (HPGe) detectors. The addition of SNIFF and FGMS 3 increases throughput by enabling simultaneous testing of multiple compacts. Furthermore, automated INL developed software provides continuous, near-real time monitoring of fission product inventories and manages the liquid nitrogen cooling of the traps. These system enhancements improve the efficiency, data quality, and testing capacity of TRISO fuel performance evaluations.
The DB Program monthly highlights report for August 2010, ORNL/TM-2010/184, was distributed to program participants by email on September 17. This report discusses: (1) Core and Fuel Analysis - (a) Core Design Optimization in the HTR (high temperature helium-cooled reactor) Prismatic Design (Logos), (b) Core Design Optimization in the HTR Pebble Bed Design (INL), (c) Microfuel analysis for the DB HTR (INL, GA, Logos); (2) Spent Fuel Management - (a) TRISO (tri-structural isotropic) repository behavior (UNLV), (b) Repository performance of TRISO fuel (UCB); (3) Fuel Cycle Integration of the HTR (high temperature helium-cooled reactor) - Synergy with other reactor fuel cycles (GA, Logos); (4) TRU (transuranic elements) HTR Fuel Qualification - (a) Thermochemical Modeling, (b) Actinide and Fission Product Transport, (c) Radiation Damage and Properties; (5) HTR Spent Fuel Recycle - (a) TRU Kernel Development (ORNL), (b) Coating Development (ORNL), (c) Characterization Development and Support, (d) ZrC Properties and Handbook; and (6) HTR Fuel Recycle - (a) Graphite Recycle (ORNL), (b) Aqueous Reprocessing, (c) Pyrochemical Reprocessing METROX (metal recovery from oxide fuel) Process Development (ANL).
TRIstructural ISOtropic (TRISO) fuel is a nuclear fuel commonly used in High Temperature Gas-cooled Reactors (HTGRs). A single sub-millimeter-diameter TRISO fuel particle consists of a spherical fuel kernel surrounded by four coating layers: a low-density pyrocarbon buffer layer, an inner pyrolytic carbon (IPyC) layer, a silicon carbide (SiC) layer, and an outer pyrolytic carbon (OPyC) layer. The kernel is commonly made of UO2 or a mixture of uranium carbide and uranium oxide (UCO). During reactor operation, the TRISO coating layers are subjected to irradiation-induced dimensional changes and the associated thermomechanical behavior of each layer. One of the observed behaviors is gap formation between the buffer and IPyC layer due to the porous buffer’s irradiation-induced shrinkage exceeding that of the IPyC layer. Not all irradiated particles will experience buffer-IPyC gap formation. The debonding may be partial, or it may be nearly total. However, from post-irradiation examination of UCO TRISO fuels irradiated as part of the Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) Fuel Development and Qualification Program, it was concluded that partial buffer-IPyC debonding was the most common type of buffer-IPyC interaction. To predict TRISO thermomechanical performance, multi-physics models have been built that are being continually updated and refined. The BISON code is a finite element-based nuclear fuel performance code that may be used for 1D, 2D, and 3D TRISO particle simulations. This code is used to calculate fuel temperature, kernel swelling, buffer densification, thermal and irradiation creep, fracture, and fission gas production and release. One of the recent additions to the BISON code is the ability to model the process of layer debonding. This paper will focus on the simulation results of the improved BISON debonding model that will utilize updated strengths measured from irradiated AGR TRISO fuel particles. The new experimental strength data from micromechanical tests of irradiated TRISO fuel samples were exercised in the BISON simulations and compared to baseline strength data to assess their applicability in the models. This also includes updated buffer-IPyC bond strengths to simulate layer delamination. Based on current experimental observations it is noted that the buffer-IPyC separation occurs not exactly at the junction of these two layers, but more on the side of the buffer layer. That observation is also implemented in the TRISO interface debonding model. This improved modeling approach using experimental strength data to characterize buffer-IPyC debonding and its potential subsequent cracking will be presented in the paper along with comparisons to available experimental observations.
Uranium oxycarbide (UCO)-bearing tri-structural isotropic (TRISO) particle fuels are expected to be used in numerous US commercial reactor applications within the next decade. In this work, we reviewed historical particle fuel transient experiments to identify gaps in the TRISO fuel performance transient testing. A BISON--Griffin modeling framework was then developed to conduct preliminary TRISO transient analyses and begin to address these gaps. The framework was demonstrated using limiting-case transient conditions from a prototypic high-temperature gas-cooled reactor. It was then applied to develop a matrix of experiments that could be performed in the Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) to (1) evaluate UCO-fueled particle performance at moderate and high heat rates, (2) assess whether historical testing involving UO$_2$-fueled particles is applicable to modern UCO-fueled particles, (3) deconvolute the impacts of temperature and heat rate on particle transient response, and (4) collect the data needed for fuel performance model validation and/or further development.