FY2021 July Monthly Status Report for the Versatile Test Reactor
FY2021 July Monthly Status Report for the Versatile Test Reactor
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
FY2021 July Monthly Status Report for the Versatile Test Reactor
FY2021 September Monthly Status Report for the Versatile Test Reactor
The Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) is a fast-spectrum test reactor being developed in the United States under the direction of the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE). The VTR mission is to enable accelerated testing of advanced reactor fuels and materials required for advanced reactor technologies. The conceptual design of the 300 MWth sodium-cooled metallic-fueled pool-type fast reactor has been led by the US National Laboratories in collaboration with General Electric–Hitachi and Bechtel National, Inc. In support of the VTR project, DOE issued a Notice of Intent (NOI) in the Federal Register on August 5, 2019, announcing the intent to prepare an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) in accordance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and its implementing regulations. The EIS will evaluate alternatives for a versatile reactor–based fast-neutron source facility and associated facilities for the preparation, irradiation, and post-irradiation examination (PIE) of test/experimental fuels and materials. Specifically, the NOI identified two siting alternatives for the VTR reactor facility: Idaho National Laboratory (INL) or Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). In addition, the NOI also specified two siting alternatives for VTR fuel fabrication: INL and the Savannah River Site (SRS). This report provides information in response to data requests made to ORNL to fill in site-specific knowledge gaps to develop a high-quality EIS. The responses provided are not required to provide full details in every aspect; instead, they adequately bound possible environmental impacts or provide sufficient information to adequately assess likely environmental impacts. This work is being performed under a subcontract from INL to ORNL using DOE-NE funds and is directed by DOE-NE and DOE-ID. Leidos has been contracted by DOE-NE to write the VTR EIS, so most data requests have come from Leidos but were often routed through INL or DOE-ID. DOE-ID is overseeing the NEPA and EIS processes for the VTR project. Leidos will use the information provided in this report to inform the VTR EIS and will also cite this document to establish a clear, publicly available source of the information. Section 2 of this report briefly describes the proposed ORNL VTR Alternative and illustrates the location of the proposed site for the ORNL VTR Alternative. Sections 3 through 7 provide direct responses to data requests received by ORNL. These sections use a tabular format in which data requests are divided into separate items to be addressed; the items are numbered, the data requests are restated with more topical information included, and then the responses are provided. Initial data requests and follow-on requests for additional information (RAIs) are combined under the original data request fields. Finally, Section 8 presents summarized conclusions and describes future work.
June 2021 Monthly Status Report for the Versatile Test Reactor Project
Different fuel management approaches have been investigated for the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR). The main design variables were the number of batches, the number of (orifice) zones, and the loading pattern within the core. The optimization criteria are maximizing the fast flux at the centermost position, minimizing the peak assembly power, and reducing fuel consumption. Design constraints were mainly driven by material limits such as peak clad temperature, and maximum fuel burnup. The exploratory study determined that active fuel shuffling only brought very limited benefits. A three-orifice region was found to provide enough flexibility to ensure thermal criteria were met. Lastly, a flexible batch loading termed ‘5-6-8’ was identified as a promising management strategy from a resource utilization standpoint.
This Argonne Reactor Code (ARC) software has taken a pivotal role in the design work of the Versatile Test Reactor. The ARC software itself consists of several independent or semiindependent pieces of software that are used in concert to carry out specific analysis and design objectives. In this report, we discuss the validation that is needed for the ARC software overall and discuss available, usable experimental data and how it relates to the VTR project. We also discuss the verification that is required for the ARC software with respect to its usage in the VTR project and give some concrete examples as to what it must accomplish. A list of goals for the verification and validation work are presented as the general procedure that will be implemented for every individual piece of software in ARC. The ARC software has been continuously developed for over 50 years and many of the features used for the VTR project have thus been rigorously tested for accuracy during that timeframe. The ARC software is presently under source code control and undergoes nightly regression testing of not only the individual pieces, but the interconnected aspects that are common to most analysis projects. Its greatest weakness, from a software verification and validation perspective, is both a lack of documentation and outdated documentation. As an example, much of the previous validation work will require contemporary effort to re-evaluate given the updated base data libraries and modifications to the software that have occurred since. This requires new documentation to be produced to support the usage of the software in the VTR project. The bulk of the ARC software is focused on steady state neutronics and TH behavior of a reactor system. In this regard, we have identified the ZPPR, FFTF, and EBR-II programs as the best candidates for sources of validation data for the VTR project. The ZPPR-15 series in the ZPPR program was chosen as it is the best representation of the VTR fuel form and reactor core layout of all of the ZPPR measurements. Additional support for it comes from the fact that most of the data has already been processed into usable ARC models for VTR validation. The FFTF and EBR-II reactors were both functional reactors that provide reactor scale measurements. FFTF is clearly a closer match to VTR and its startup measurements would be a very valuable validation basis. EBR-II has invaluable burnup related measurements that will play a key role in the ARC software validation work. Each piece of ARC software will require a report detailing the software verification. The validation work will be logically split into the results of modeling each identified experimental resource (ZPPR, EBR-II, FFTF). The intended timeline for the VTR project is to have the ARC software verified and validated by the end of fiscal year 2020. This is incumbent on sufficient funding allocated to V&V activities and no change in programmatic priorities.
Abstract—The self-powered neutron detector (SPND) is a widely used flux monitor in thermal nuclear reactors. Although this is a mature technology, the current state of the art is tuned for a thermal neutron spectrum, so many of the devices currently in use lack sensitivity to fast neutrons. Because current in SPNDs is produced through nuclear reactions with the neutron flux inside a reactor, sensitivity in SPNDs is determined by the neutron cross section of the neutron-sensitive portion of the detector, termed the emitter. This neutron cross section drops by orders of magnitude between thermal and fast neutron energies for many emitters in currently used SPNDs, with a corresponding drop in current from the detector. This paper discusses efforts to develop a fast-spectrum self-powered neutron detector (FS-SPND) that is sensitive to neutrons with energies ranging from 0.025 eV up to 1 MeV. An in-depth analysis of Evaluated Nuclear Data File (ENDF)/B-VII.1 neutron-capture cross sections was performed, and four new materials were identified that are suitable emitter candidates for use in measuring fast neutrons. All four materials are stable mid-shell nuclei in the region between doubly magic 132Sn and 208Pb. Each candidate was simulated with the Geant4 Monte Carlo simulation toolkit to optimize overall detector efficiency.
Shielding design is an important part of the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) design. Various shielding implementations are required to protect workers and reactor components from damaging radiation sources. The major radiation source in VTR during operation is the prompt neutron and photon emitted from nuclear fuel fissions as well as the activated structure and coolant. Shields are needed to protect the structures located inside the reactor vessel, such as the lower grid, the barrel wall, etc., in order to limit the degradation of the materials properties as a result of neutron damage (“displacement per atom”). Another early key challenge of shielding design for a pool-typed Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor (SFR) such as VTR is the activation of the secondary sodium as to flows through the intermediate heat exchangers (IHX). For a pool-typed SFR, the IHXs are placed in the primary sodium pool inside the reactor vessel. During operation, neutrons produced in the core can reach the IHXs due to the small absorption cross section of sodium and the large mean free path of fast neutrons. The secondary sodium gets activated inside the IHX and carries some of that activity outside of the reactor vessel. This source of radioactivity contained in the secondary sodium needs to be mitigated to meet the radiation dose limit sets for personnel working at the plant. This summary focuses on describing the work performed for the in-vessel shielding design and analysis aiming at limiting the secondary sodium activation.
Different fractions of boron carbide were investigated for the control rod assemblies of the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR). Reducing the number of rods per assembly increases the overall volume fraction of B4C, thus increasing reactivity worth. Doing so also reduces the melting margin inside the pellets and the reactivity worth loss by EOL. As a result the control rod layouts with the most (CR61) and least (CR7) number of rods were deemed less favorable for each of those two reasons. Overall, CR19 was found to have sufficient safety margins with the second best reactivity worth. The design only required a 44% 10B enrichment to reach the conservative margins put forward. The arrangement is recommended for both the control and safety rods of the VTR.
A metal driver fuel has been proposed for the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR). About 30 years ago, the Experimental Breeder Reactor-II (EBR-II) was the last reactor in the U.S. to utilize a full core of metal driver fuel. While the necessary knowledge to make metal fuels is well preserved and is practiced for research activities today, re-establishing a production line to support the fuel needs of a 300 MWth reactor has unique technical and engineering challenges. These challenges are the focus of a multi-laboratory and private sector team that has been tasked with the responsibility to fabricate fuel for the VTR.
This paper describes the unique challenges with developing and documenting the Safety Design Strategy for the Versatile Test Reactor in the following key areas: 1. Identification of the key safety goals in the VTR facility design and operation that are to ensure adequate protection of the public, workers, and environment as required by 10 CFR 830, “Nuclear Safety Management.” These goals are fulfilled by an approach that applies defense-in-depth (DID) by applying various layers (or levels) of protection to prevent the release of radioactive and hazardous materials. 2. Early identification of the hazards that are normally associated with a large fast reactor facility can result from postulated failure conditions in one or more of the reactor systems or from operational errors. 3. Identification of the key decisions that must be made during the initial project life cycle that will affect the eventual design and construction of the VTR and enable clarity in safety expectations. 4. Identification of the applicable regulatory framework requirements for demonstrating compliance with safety basis requirements in 10 CFR 830 Subpart B for the VTR. 5. Application of the proposed Licensing Modernization Program (LMP) recommendations for advanced non-LWR reactors as outlined in Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI)-18-04, “Risk-Informed Performance-Based Guidance for Non-Light Water Reactor Licensing Basis Development.”
Safety analysis simulations have been carried out using the SAS4A/SASSYS-1 safety analysis code system to update the baseline set of results for the Versatile Test Reactor conceptual design. Results from a previous revision of this work provided input for the Conceptual Safety Design Report summarizing the overall safety basis for the VTR. This work will also support future analyses that will be required for Chapter 13, “Accident Analysis,” of a preliminary safety analysis report. A number of transients have been evaluated based on categories of postulated accident sequences suggested for consideration in NUREG-1537. Ultimately, the full spectrum of event initiators and subsequent accident sequences will be defined through a probabilistic risk assessment of the plant design following the implementation of the Licensing Modernization Project guidelines as described in the VTR Safety Design Strategy. Since that process is ongoing, the present analysis addresses several transients that are expected to be bounding accident scenarios that represent the three key ways to perturb a reactor: through changes to the core inlet temperature, mass flow rate, or reactivity. These correspond to a loss of heat sink (LOHS), loss of flow (LOF) or station blackout (SBO), and transient overpower (TOP), respectively. Both Protected and Unprotected versions of these transients have been evaluated, along with additional transients that include transient overpower with one stuck rod, pump coast-down failures, seismic events, and overcooling events. At the current stage of design, transient simulation results for the Versatile Test Reactor indicate that large safety margins exist for many event initiators. However, several “enabling” assumptions have been made, in terms of both design features and design limits, in order to perform the analyses; and these assumptions will need to be revised as the design matures. In addition, a larger spectrum of events needs to be evaluated as part of the on-going probabilistic risk assessment process.
The DOE Office of Nuclear Energy established the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) program in February 2017 in response to reports outlining the need for a fast spectrum test reactor. In this framework, Idaho National Laboratory (INL), as the proposed hosting site for the VTR, is expanding its capabilities leveraging on its staff nuclear expertise on experiments design and reactors operation, codes development and assessment, advanced safety analyses. One of the key points of this strategy is to develop capabilities necessary to perform transient analyses in order to understand the plant behavior during upset conditions and appropriately quantify margins. In this context system thermal-hydraulic models of the VTR are being developed using the SAS4A/SASSYS-1 code developed at Argonne National Laboratory as well as the INL code RELAP5-3D. The former provides reference analyses whereas the latter could provide an independent assessment of the reference analyses if deemed necessary by the project. This paper focuses on the RELAP5-3D modeling, highlighting the different solutions adopted for correctly analyzing sodium fast reactor behavior. After showing the modeling activities, we present a set of reference transient analyses for protected and unprotected transients, highlighting the intrinsic safety characteristics of the VTR design.
The traditional modeling approach for sodium fast reactor cores relies on separate physics models, where the fuel performance, thermal–hydraulics, and neutronics calculations required to predict the core physics characteristics for nominal conditions are decoupled by relying on user-imposed boundary conditions. Here, this paper aims at evaluating the impact of multiphysics simulations for predicting the core characteristics of the Versatile Test Reactor, which is being designed as a 300-MWt sodium-cooled fast reactor. The purpose of the Versatile Test Reactor is to accelerate the testing of advanced nuclear materials in the United States. The proposed multiphysics model relies on the Griffin reactor physics code, the SAM thermal–hydraulic system code, the BISON fuel performance code, as well as generic Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment capabilities implemented in the open-source tensor mechanics module. For k eff calculations, the introduction of a tight coupling between the neutronics, thermo-mechanical and thermal–hydraulics models induces a change of around 543 pcm in the eigenvalue, compared to the traditional standalone neutronics calculation where approximate temperature profiles are used. The multiphysics model is then employed for quantifying the impact of the thermal conductivity uncertainties on some of the key figures of merit, such as the fuel centerline temperature, assembly powers, and keff for nominal core conditions. As anticipated, uncertainties on fuel thermal conductivity mostly impact the fuel centerline temperature, and to a lesser extend the k eff .
This work studies the hydrodynamics of the seven pin wire-wrapped rod bundle in the sodium cartridge loop for the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) through scaled water experiments and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations. Here, the scaling analysis is first performed to demonstrate the hydrodynamic similarity between water and sodium flows at the same Reynolds number Re. A separate-effects test facility is designed and constructed based on the scaling analysis. Detailed experimental data on the pressure drop covering a wide range of Re values (1165 to 27 689) are obtained, which are used to evaluate existing correlations for friction factor and to benchmark CFD simulations. The experimentally determined friction factors f Exp agree well with the Upgraded Cheng and Todreas Detailed Correlation and Pacio-Chen-Todreas Detailed Model within ±7% but are significantly underpredicted by Rehme's correlation by 25%. Various CFD near-wall treatment methods are tested using ANSYS Fluent and evaluated by experimental data. It is found that when the recommended wall y + values are met, most of the near-wall treatment methods can give accurate friction factor predictions. The resolved near-wall method (y + ~ 1) with the Shear Stress Transport k - ω turbulence model and the scalable wall functions (y + > 12) with the realizable k - ε turbulence model can predict f Exp within ±5% The standard wall functions (y + > 30) and nonequilibrium wall functions (y + > 30) with the realizable k - ε model can predict f Exp within ±10%.
Students were an integral part of the work done on the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR) this fiscal year (FY). In fact, these students participated in the research, development, and deployment of technologies needed to move the design of advanced experimental vehicles forward. This document summarizes the work performed by these students in several areas, including the Extended Length Test Assembly (ELTA)-Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor (SFR); ELTA-Molten Salt Reactor (MSR); ELTA- Lead/lead-bismuth cooled Fast Reactor (LFA); ELTAGas-cooled Fast Reactor (GFR); ELTA-Materials (M); and Cross-Cutting Technologies areas.
Not Available
A probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) has been initiated to assist with the design, authorization, and future operation of the Versatile Test Reactor (VTR). The PRA is a vital part of a larger risk-informed authorization approach and is being developed in accordance with two applicable standards.