Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “high-throughput sequencing”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 37 records · Page 2
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

GMFOLD: Subgraph matching for high-throughput DNA-aptamer secondary structure classification and machine learning interpretability

Aptamers are oligonucleotide receptors that bind to their targets with high affinity. Here, we consider aptamers comprised of single-stranded DNA that undergo target-binding-induced conformational changes, giving rise to unique secondary and tertiary structures. Given a specific aptamer primary sequence, there are well-established computational tools (notably mfold) to predict the secondary structure via free energy minimization algorithms. While mfold generates secondary structures for individual sequences, there is a need for a high-throughput process whereby thousands of DNA structures can be predicted in real-time for use in an interactive setting, when combined with aptamer selections that generate candidate pools that are too large to be experimentally interrogated. We developed a new Python code for high-throughput aptamer secondary structure determination (GMfold). GMfold uses subgraph matching methods to group aptamer candidates by secondary structure similarities. We also improve an open-source code, SeqFold, to incorporate subgraph matching concepts. We represent each secondary structure as a lowest-energy bipartite subgraph matching of the DNA graph to itself. These new tools enable thousands of DNA sequences to be compared based on their secondary structures, using machine-learning algorithms. This process is advantageous when analyzing sequences that arise from aptamer selections via systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX). This work is a building block for future machine-learning-informed DNA-aptamer selection processes to identify aptamers with improved target affinity and selectivity and advance aptamer biosensors and therapeutics.

Aptamer↗
DOE OSTI2025

High-throughput micro-scale bandgap mapping for perovskite-inspired materials with complex composition space

Abstract To realize the full promise of high-throughput experimental workflows, the rate of sample synthesis must be matched by that of characterization. Of growing interest are contactless optical techniques that can rapidly measure material homogeneity and properties. Here, we present a hyperspectral imaging method to measure local optical bandgap distributions within samples, utilizing spatially-resolved reflectance spectra coupled with automated data analysis. We collect approximately one million optical bandgap data across the compositional space of Cs 3 (Bi x Sb 1-x ) 2 (Br y I 1-y ) 9 perovskite-inspired materials. Our results show non-monotonic bandgap variations (i.e., bandgap bowing) along six composition gradient sequences, in addition to identifying samples with multiple bandgaps in statistics. High-throughput transient absorption spectroscopy reveals that within these compositions, the depletion of the ground state carriers to excited states occurred at discrete energy levels with independent carrier dynamics, consistent with the bandgap observation and indicative of phase separation. This work demonstrates the potential for rapid optical measurements to assess material quality and homogeneity in a high-throughput experimental setting, supporting screening and recipe optimization of optoelectronic material candidates with desired carrier dynamics and optical properties.

Science & Technology - Other Topics↗
DOE OSTI2025

Long-read sequencing transcriptome quantification with lr-kallisto

RNA abundance quantification has become routine and affordable thanks to high-throughput “short-read” technologies that provide accurate molecule counts at the gene level. Similarly accurate and affordable quantification of definitive full-length, transcript isoforms has remained a stubborn challenge, despite its obvious biological significance across a wide range of problems. “Long-read” sequencing platforms now produce data-types that can, in principle, drive routine definitive isoform quantification. However some particulars of contemporary long-read datatypes, together with isoform complexity and genetic variation, present bioinformatic challenges. We show here, using ONT data, that fast and accurate quantification of long-read data is possible and that it is improved by exome capture. To perform quantifications we developed lr-kallisto, which adapts the kallisto bulk and single-cell RNA-seq quantification methods for long-read technologies.

Loving, Rebekah K. (ORCID:0000000187250376)↗
DOE OSTI2026

Exploring the impact of nucleotide length on lipid nanoparticle structure and properties

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are versatile carriers for nucleic acid (NA) therapeutics, including ASOs, siRNA, mRNA, and poly-IC. While lipid composition is known to influence LNP properties, the impact of NA length on morphology and internal structure is less understood, particularly during the stages of carrier–cargo assembly. Here, we examine NA length and lipid composition immediately after mixing using high-throughput SAXS, dynamic light scattering, and cryogenic electron microscopy. All LNPs form ordered NA/lipid compartments, with longer NAs promoting inverse hexagonal (H II ) phases and larger intercompartment distances. In contrast, short NAs, especially in formulations with SM102 ionizable lipid, favor lamellar phases. SAXS peak deconvolution quantifies ordered versus disordered phases via a Robustness of Ordered Phase factor, which correlates with particle size and encapsulation efficiency. Formulations with MC3 ionizable and DOPE helper lipids exhibit the most stable H II -phase packing, highlighting the role of helper-lipid curvature in compartment stabilization. Variations in NA compartmentalization indicate differences in payload capacity, offering a framework for rational LNP design across diverse nucleic acid cargos.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Structure–Function Relationships in Sequence-Controlled Copolymers for Rare Earth Element Chelation

The ability to tune material function through primary sequence is a defining feature of biological macromolecules, allowing precise control over structure and target interactions in complex aqueous environments. However, translating sequence–structure–function relationships to synthetic macromolecules is challenging due to their dispersity in sequence, conformation, and composition. Here, we report systematic studies of amphiphilic polymer chelators designed to probe how composition and patterning influence binding affinity and selectivity for rare earth elements (REEs), a series of technologically relevant metals with challenging separation profiles. A library of copolymers varying hydrophobic monomer composition and patterning was synthesized via reversible addition–fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization, spanning statistical, gradient, and block architectures. REE binding was quantified using a high-throughput colorimetric assay, and reconstruction of polymer ensembles using kinetic stochastic simulations enabled quantitative comparisons of sequence heterogeneity, linking local monomer colocalization to emergent REE binding. Further, we investigated the role of different hydrophobic comonomers in tuning metal coordination, with binding trends linked to structural features that influence binding site desolvation. Complementary dynamic light scattering (DLS) and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) measurements showed that both polymer and monomer architecture modulate metal-induced conformational changes, and that multichain assembly behavior emerges beyond critical hydrophobic thresholds. Sequence control also altered REE selectivity, with nonmonotonic differences observed across compositionally identical polymers with different sequence architectures. Together, these findings establish design principles that connect polymer sequence and structure to binding performance, guiding the design of macromolecular chelators with enhanced affinity and selectivity for applications in separations, sensing, and catalysis.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Functional characterization of glycosyltransferases in duckweed to enable predictive biology

Glycosyltransferases (GTs) catalyze the formation of glycosidic linkages to produce almost all complex carbohydrates. This project used a multi-disciplinary, high-throughput (HTP) biochemical and computational biology approach focused on duckweed as a model energy crop, to study carbohydrate metabolic processes. To achieve this, developed and carried out out high-throughput (HTP) functional characterization of plant glycosyltransferases (GTs) role of enzymatic microenvironments be assessed through a combined proteomic and computational biology approach, and the combined data was used to populate deep-learning frameworks to predict plant GT function. Functional validation achieved through this research is being used to assign gene function and study plant processes at the systems level to efficiently link the genome sequence with gene function. Together, the combined approaches used within this study provide a foundation for how computational prediction, in combination with high-throughput functional validation, can be used to study plant processes at the systems level and translate knowledge gained to efficiently link genome sequence with gene function in a species agnostic manner.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗
DOE OSTI2025

Structural genomics of bacterial drug targets: Application of a high-throughput pipeline to solve 58 protein structures from pathogenic and related bacteria

Antibiotic resistance remains a leading cause of severe infections worldwide. Small changes in protein sequence can impact antibiotic efficacy. Here, we report deposition of 58 X-ray crystal structures of bacterial proteins that are known targets for antibiotics, which expands knowledge of structural variation to support future antibiotic discovery or modifications.

PDB↗
DOE OSTI2025

Discovery of unconventional and nonintuitive self-assembling peptide materials using experiment-driven machine learning

Prediction of peptide secondary structure is challenging because of complex molecular interactions, sequence-specific behavior, and environmental factors. Traditional design strategies, based on hydrophobicity and structural propensity, can be biased and could indeed prevent discovery of interesting, diverse, and unconventional peptides with desired nanostructure assembly. Using β sheet formation in pentapeptides as a case study, we used an integrated high-throughput experimental workflow and an artificial intelligence–driven active learning framework to improve prediction accuracy of self-assembly. By focusing on sequences where machine learning (ML) predictions deviate from conventional design strategies, we synthesized and tested 268 pentapeptides, successfully finding 96 forming β sheet assemblies, including unconventional sequences (e.g., ILFSM, LMISI, MITIY, MISIW, and WKIYI) not predicted by traditional methods. Our ML models outperformed conventional β sheet propensity tables, revealing useful chemical design rules. A web interface is provided to facilitate community access to these models. This work highlights the value of ML-driven approaches in overcoming the limitations of current peptide design strategies.

Talluri, Y. Nissi [Indian Inst. of Technology (IIT↗
DOE OSTI2026

High-throughput Single-Cell Proteomics and Transcriptomics from the Same Cells with a Nanoliter-Scale Spin-Transfer Approach

Single-cell multiomic platforms provide a comprehensive snapshot of cellular states and cell types by offering critical insights into the spatiotemporal regulation of biomolecular networks at a systems level, thereby defining the basis of multicellularity. Here, we introduce nanoSPINS, an advanced platform that enables high-throughput profiling and integrative analysis of the transcriptome and proteome from the same single cells using RNA sequencing and isobaric labeling LC-MS-based proteomics, respectively. NanoSPINS can efficiently transfer mRNA-containing droplets across two microarrays via a centrifugation-based approach, while proteins are retained on the initial platform. Benchmarking of nanoSPINS on two cell lines demonstrates its ability to generate global proteomic and transcriptomic profiles that align well with previously established methodologies/platforms. The incorporation of isobaric TMTpro labeling into this single-cell multiomics platform significantly enhances the throughput of single-cell proteomic analyses. Through the high-throughput quantification of the proteome and transcriptome, nanoSPINS not only facilitates the identification of molecular features at both mRNA and protein level but also provides larger sample sizes for improved statistical power in clustering and differential abundance. Given the broad applicability of single-cell multiomics in biological research and clinical settings, we believe nanoSPINS represents a powerful platform for the characterization of heterogeneous cell populations.

multi 'omics↗
DOE OSTI2026

Multi-strain analysis of Pseudomonas putida reveals the metabolic and genetic diversity of the species

Pseudomonas putida is a gram-negative bacterial species increasingly utilized in biotechnology due to its robust growth, ability to degrade aromatic compounds, solvent tolerance, and genetic tractability. In this study, we report a comprehensive multi-strain analysis of 164 P. putida strains based on the reconstruction of a pan-putida metabolic network and the formulation of strain-specific genome-scale metabolic models (GEMs). We performed whole-genome sequencing and hybrid assembly for 40 strains, contributing a ~8% increase to the available genomic data for P. putida . Furthermore, high-throughput phenotypic profiling using the Biolog phenotype microarray system for 24 strains on 190 unique carbon sources, along with 15 aromatic compounds not present on Biolog plates, yielded 4,920 unique strain-phenotype measurements. These data were leveraged to curate GEMs for 24 representative strains, including a refined model for strain KT2440, which comprised 1,480 genes and 2,191 metabolites, achieving a prediction accuracy of 91.2% in carbon utilization. Systematic comparison of genomes and GEMs revealed both conserved core pathways and significant allelic and functional divergence across strains, highlighting strain-specific variation in aromatic degradation. While pathways for protocatechuate and phenylacetate degradation were widely conserved, metabolic capabilities for compounds such as ferulate, phenol, and cresols varied markedly, suggesting adaptation to distinct ecological niches. Alleleome analysis of enzymes, such as PcaI and PcaJ, revealed distinct, functionally similar clades, indicating possible convergent evolution or horizontal gene transfer. These results provide computable resources and informative models for selecting P. putida strains with desired traits for biomanufacturing and bioremediation and offer insights into the evolution and phylogeny of the P. putida species.

aromatics utilization↗
DOE OSTI2025

High-throughput spin-bath characterization of spin defects in semiconductors

Detailed knowledge of the local environments of spin defects in semiconductors, such as nitrogenvacancy (NV) centers in diamond or divacancies in silicon carbide, is crucial for optimizing control and entanglement protocols in quantum sensing and information applications. However, at present a direct experimental characterization of individual defect environments is not scalable, as conventional spin-bath measurements are time consuming and difficult to automate. Achieving high-throughput characterization requires short experiments to probe the spin bath. However, with fewer and noisier measurements, the inverse problem of recovering spin-bath properties from measured data becomes ill posed, with multiple spin baths having a high likelihood of yielding the same data. In this work, we present a set of computational tools to resolve the ill-posed inverse problem of recovering the atomic positions and hyperfine couplings of random nuclei surrounding spin defects from sparse, noisy experimental coherence data, which can be obtained in hours. Here, we use a trans-dimensional Bayesian approach that incorporates ab initio data to yield full posterior distributions over nuclear spin environments, enabling robust recovery from limited data. We also provide practical tools and guidelines to determine the limits of detectability for hyperfine couplings under specific dynamical decoupling sequences and sampling conditions. In addition, we demonstrate how the tools developed here, in combination with ab initio simulations of spin baths, can guide the design of efficient experimental protocols for application-specific high-throughput screening. To showcase the utility of our approach, we apply it to design fast dynamical decoupling experiments to characterize the spin baths often individual NV centers in diamond. While the primary focus is on accelerating spin-bath characterization of spin defects, this Bayesian approach also lays the foundation for digital-twin studies of spin defects, where a virtual model of the spin-defect system evolves in real time with ongoing experimental measurements. Together, the set of tools we designed and applied paves the way for scalable deployment of spin defects in semiconductors for quantum sensing and information applications.

Bayesian methods↗
DOE OSTI2026

Benchtop Autonomous Electrochemical Characterization System for Combinatorial Thin-Film Solid Oxide Electrodes

The design of materials for electrochemical energy conversion is complicated by a vast search space of candidate materials and multifaceted property requirements: multicarrier conductivity, stability, and catalytic activity are all necessary but rarely intersect. Although self-driving laboratories are rapidly rising to address such material optimization problems, the required infrastructure for integrated, large-scale robotic facilities can be cost-prohibitive. Here we develop and evaluate a closed-loop measurement system for efficient screening of proton-conducting oxide electrodes for ceramic fuel cells and electrolyzers, building on top of an existing benchtop instrument and integrating techniques for rapid impedance measurement and automated analysis. This system exemplifies a “minimum viable” self-driving implementation that can deliver substantial benefits with relatively simple infrastructure. Combinatorial thin-film microelectrode libraries are characterized with a recently developed joint time-domain and frequency-domain impedance measurement technique, which provides an order-of-magnitude acceleration relative to conventional impedance spectroscopy. The distribution of relaxation times is extracted from impedance data and analyzed without human intervention. These results feed an active learning and Bayesian optimization process that learns to predict electrochemical impedance as a function of material composition, measurement temperature, oxygen partial pressure, and electrical bias, which further reduces the screening time by tenfold with optimized experimental sequences. We apply this system to Ba⁡(Co,Fe,Zr,Y)⁢O 3−𝛿 combinatorial libraries and evaluate its effectiveness for learning material property trends and optimizing expensive-to-evaluate properties such as activation energy. This offers insights into key methodological aspects of practical autonomous experimentation, including surrogate model validation, cost-aware acquisition functions, and high-throughput data interpretation. Our results demonstrate the efficacy of the system for rapidly gathering information, but also highlight real-world experimental challenges of thin-film degradation and numerical instability in surrogate models.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

NGPINT V3: a containerized orchestration Python software for discovery of next-generation protein–protein interactions

Abstract Summary Batch yeast two-hybrid (Y2H) assays, leveraged with next-generation sequencing, have afforded successful innovations for the analysis of protein–protein interactions. NGPINT is a Conda-based software designed to process the millions of raw sequencing reads resulting from Y2H–next-generation interaction screens. Over time, increasing compatibility and dependency issues have prevented clean NGPINT installation and operation. A system-wide update was essential to continue effective use with its companion software, Y2H-SCORES. We present NGPINT V3, a containerized implementation built with both Singularity and Docker, allowing accessibility across virtually any operating system and computing environment. Availability and implementation This update includes streamlined dependencies and container images hosted on Sylabs (https://cloud.sylabs.io/library/schuyler/ngpint/ngpint) and Dockerhub (https://hub.docker.com/r/schuylerds/ngpint), facilitating easier adoption and integration into high-throughput and cloud-computing workflows. Full instructions and software can be also found in the GitHub repository https://github.com/Wiselab2/NGPINT_V3 and Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15256036.

Biochemistry & Molecular Biology↗
DOE OSTI2025

Decoding crops one cell at a time: from cell atlases to single-cell genetics

Understanding the mechanisms underlying key agricultural traits remains a central challenge in crop research, but recent advances in technologies are providing powerful tools to address this issue. Among these, single-cell and spatial transcriptomics have revealed tissue heterogeneity and spatial organization, offering unique insights into cellular gene expression dynamics and the coordinated activity of multiple cell types. These approaches help uncover how specific cell types contribute to agricultural traits and refine candidate loci lists through integration with trait-associated loci. Additionally, single-cell and spatial transcriptomics have the potential to serve as cell-level readout platforms integrating cellular perturbations, enabling high-throughput discovery of causal relationships between genotype and gene expression at the cellular level in plants. Successful implementation will accelerate the identification of key genetic variants for crop improvement. Furthermore we review lessons learned from application of single-cell screening in mammalian cells, highlight major technical and biological barriers to its use in plants, and outline potential strategies to overcome these challenges. Together, the widespread application and integration of single-cell and spatial transcriptomics with other technologies enable not only the descriptive cataloging of cell states but also the causal interrogation of sequence functions and regulatory networks at cell type resolution, ultimately advancing gene function studies and accelerating crop improvement.

Cellular heterogeneity↗
DOE OSTI2026

Automation of Laser Plasma Focused Ion Beam Microscopy for Next-Gen Energy Materials

Automation can revolutionize the use of ultrafast laser ablation and plasma-focused ion beam (PFIB) techniques for high-throughput, reproducible cross-sectioning and various sample preparation in materials characterization. As these methods become essential for analyzing complex energy materials and next-generation devices, efficient, standardized workflows are needed to minimize variability and enhance precision. This work highlights our advancements in developing automated processes for sample preparation that integrates machine learning, workflow optimization, and large-scale data acquisition to improve efficiency and scalability in applications such as electrolyzers, photovoltaic cells, and microelectronics. To streamline cross-sectioning and lamella fabrication, we have implemented fully automated workflows that standardize laser ablation and PFIB milling sequences. These workflows incorporate pre-programmed protocols for material removal, alignment, and thinning, reducing user intervention and ensuring consistency across different sample types. Machine learning algorithms further enhance automation by predicting optimal milling strategies and adapting parameters based on material properties and sectioning requirements. This approach significantly improves throughput while maintaining the structural integrity of prepared samples for high-resolution imaging and analysis, including transmission electron microscopy. Beyond sample preparation, our automation platform enables the acquisition of large, high-resolution datasets through serial sectioning, image alignment, and 3D reconstruction. These automated routines facilitate multi-scale characterization, capturing structural and compositional details from the nanoscale to the device level. By reducing variability and increasing efficiency, our automated approach enhances defect analysis, failure diagnostics, and process optimization, accelerating advancements in materials research and device engineering.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Biosynthesis of bioprivileged, linear molecules via novel carboligase reactions

Over the award period, we made progress on the three aims. We screened twenty-five carboligases for activity coupling twenty-one possible -keto acids (Aim 1). The carboligases were selected across a diverse set of protein sequences. Using Q-Exactive UHPLC-MS, we tested a total of 210 coupled products per enzyme and generated a dataset of 5250 enzyme-substrate activity relationships. We identified multiple enzymes that had activity for synthesizing suberic acid and heptanoic acid (Aim 2). We built a random forest model for predicting the activity of each enzyme toward substrates on which it was not tested using the data from Aim 1. Finally, we evaluated growth defects that occurred due to expression of different carboligases in E. coli (Aim 3). We were able to identify specific metabolites and putative pathways that, when supplemented in the media, recovered the growth defect associated with the presence of specific carboligases. We are in the process of publishing two manuscript describing the methods for high-throughput screening of enzyme promiscuity, using machine learning to predict activity on untested substrates, and enzyme activity data we collected. This project has produced enabling data for biosynthesis of a range of new-to-nature compounds to support biomanufacturing.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2026

Engineering and Application of a Thermostable MHETase for PET Depolymerization

Enzymatic hydrolysis of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) releases mono(2-hydroxyethyl) terephthalate (MHET) as a major product, the accumulation of which can prolong reactor residence times and complicate downstream monomer separations. The use of a MHETase enzyme can enable MHET hydrolysis to the monomers, terephthalic acid and ethylene glycol, but industrial PETases typically operate at thermophilic temperatures and the well-known MHETase from Ideonella sakaiensis is a mesophilic enzyme, thus warranting the development of thermophilic MHETases. Here, we characterize thermostable MHET-active enzymes from a natural diversity screen by applying a hidden Markov model based on the previously reported, archaeal ferulic acid esterase, PET46. We identified enzymes with higher thermostability than PET46 and quantified their MHETase activity in reactions at 70 °C. The crystal structure of MHT077, the homologue with the highest MHETase activity and an apparent melting temperature (T m,app ) of 94.6 °C, informed site saturation mutagenesis in the active site and lid-domain interface. MHT077 exhibited a ∼100-fold slower unfolding rate at 65 °C than PET46, indicating substantially greater kinetic stability. In parallel, we applied evolution-informed design, a probabilistic model that leverages coevolutionary patterns in large multiple sequence alignments, to improve the activity and thermostability of five ferulic acid esterases. One design, EV-MHT043–5 was identified with a comparable thermostability (T m,app = 96.1 °C) and a 3-fold improvement in its MHETase activity relative to the wildtype enzyme, MHT043. Combination variants of beneficial mutations were screened and afforded a variant, MHT077 LFK , which reduced MHET accumulation in bioreactor experiments with postconsumer PET waste. Overall, this study expands the known MHET-hydrolyzing protein scaffolds available for enzymatic PET recycling.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Data-Driven Discovery of Bimetallic Nanoparticles Catalysts for the Hydrogenolysis of Polyethylene

Supported platinum nanoparticles are known to convert polyolefins to high-quality liquid hydrocarbons with hydrogen under relatively mild conditions. However, no systematic study has been undertaken using bimetallic catalysts for polyethylene upcycling. Specifically, a total of 98 monometallic and bimetallic combinations (Ag, Cr, Co, Cu, Fe, Ga, In, Mn, Ni, Pd, Pt, Rh, Ru, Zr) on alumina were synthesized utilizing surface organometallic chemistry (SOMC) technique via robotic platform. These were investigated at a small scale (10 mg of catalyst and 50 mg of polyethylene) for their activity for the hydrogenolysis of polyethylene in a high-throughput batch reactor. Combinations of Ni and Co were selected as candidates with high activity toward conversion into paraffin oils. Reaction conditions were optimized with Ni/Co/Al 2 O 3 catalyst at a larger scale (300 mg catalyst and 3 g polyethylene) to obtain a high yield (93.1%) of paraffin wax with desired properties (M n = 380 Da) and low polydispersity (Đ = 1.2). Ni/Co/Al 2 O 3 was compared against Co/Ni/Al 2 O 3 to understand the role of the deposition sequence. When Co is deposited before Ni, a layer of cobalt aluminate is formed upon reduction, stabilizing the deposition of 5 nm metallic Ni particles. When nickel is deposited before Co, particles are larger (average >20 nm) and more oxidized (Ni δ+ in NiAl 2 O 4 ), decreasing the availability of the catalytically active metallic Ni. In conclusion, the difference in electronic environments was also described by DFT calculations, which revealed that smaller 3D clusters of Ni are preferred on CoAl2O4 over the 3D clusters on NiAl 2 O 4 and that these smaller clusters are more reducible, as confirmed experimentally.

Polymer↗