Utilizing Probabilistic Analyses to Explore Performance Margins of Natural Gas Infrastructure for the Transport and Delivery of Hydrogen and Hydrogen Blends
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This is the final technical report of the DOE NETL project with award number DE-FE0032079
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
To reduce carbon emissions, the US natural gas infrastructure is seen as a primary solution for efficiently transporting hydrogen gas. Blending hydrogen gas with natural gas and transporting it across a national infrastructure could save significant infrastructure costs. To properly operate the infrastructure under the new gas system, it is critical to understand material compatibility with hydrogen under various conditions. The Blended Gas CRADA, a Hyblend project, is established to determine the material compatibility of existing natural gas pipes with hydrogen gas. In this study, we investigate the in-plane fracture behaviors of MDPEMarlex and HDPEGDB exposed to hydrogen and hydrogen-methane blended gas. Single-edge notch bending geometry is used. All tests are executed in-situ with the gas environment. The experimental results show a significant effect of the gas environment on HDPEGDB specimens, reducing 5% (H2) to 42% (Blended gas) of specific fracture energy compared to non-aged specimens. For the MDPEMarlex, the effects of the gas environment have increased the specific fracture energy by 10% (H2) to 15% (Blended gas). Fracture surfaces of the tested samples are observed using an electronic microscope. The in-plane fracture surface of HDPEGDB shows a pronounced dimple fracture pattern after exposure to hydrogen and blended gas. The expanded fracture pattern contributes to lower the specific fracture energy. These observations provide critical information for validating polymer pipeline materials when interact with hydrogen and hydrogen-blend gas.
This is FECM/NETL H2 pipeline transportation cost and economic model development and analysis. The paper will report the results of the analysis and potential applications. The models have been released through the link https://netl.doe.gov/node/14168
Blending hydrogen into existing natural gas pipelines is a current initiative for large-scale hydrogen deployment in the United States. Understanding changes in hazards and risk for fuel blends can help inform regulations. A differential risk assessment was conducted to understand how the safety profile of fires and unignited flammable plumes of leaking fuel would change based on blend composition. The area affected by harmful heat fluxes from jet fires was found to be larger for blends with more natural gas in them, while the distance affected by unignited flammable fuel concentrations was found to be larger for blends with more hydrogen in them. Component leak frequencies and ignition probabilities greatly impact both heat flux risk and the flammable plume risk. The collection of additional blend-specific industry data could help understand which assumptions are most valid to make when calculating risk.
To achieve US decarbonization goals, hydrogen is being considered as an alternative energy source to reduce carbon emissions. Blending hydrogen into existing natural gas pipelines is an intuitive first step to enable near term emission reductions. However, there are numerous challenges and uncertainties that complicate the transition to transporting hydrogen long-distance through existing natural gas pipelines. The main challenge is hydrogen embrittlement (HE), which reduces the ductility, fracture toughness and fatigue resistance of pipeline steels. This work delivers a technical review on HE effects on the material properties of pipeline carbon steels, such as Grade B, X52, X65, X70, X80, and X100. An important aspect of laboratory tests to capture the HE effect is the hydrogen test environment. This includes hydrogen pre-charged specimens tested in air and specimens tested in a hydrogen gas environment. A review of the mechanical properties of pipeline steel in different hydrogen environments determined through tensile testing is given first, which includes HE effects on yield strength, ultimate tensile strength, and ductility for blended hydrogen-natural gas pipelines. Then, the HE effects on fracture toughness and fatigue crack growth resistance are discussed. Last, impacts of HE to pipeline integrity and major technical challenges are discussed.
Hydrogen can be used to reduce carbon emissions by blending into other gaseous energy carriers, such as natural gas. However, hydrogen blending into natural gas has important implications for safety which need to be evaluated. Hydrogen has different physical properties than natural gas, and these properties affect safety evaluations concerning a leak of the blended gas. The intent of this report is to begin to investigate the safety implications of blending hydrogen into the natural gas infrastructure with respect to a leak event from a pipeline. A literature review was conducted to identify existing data that will better inform future hazard and risk assessments for hydrogen/natural gas blends. Metrics with safety implications such as heat flux and dispersion behavior may be affected by the overall blend ratio of the mixture. Of the literature reviewed, there was no directly observed separation of the hydrogen from the natural gas or methane blend. No literature was identified that experimentally examined unconfined releases such as concentration fields or concentration at specific distances. Computational efforts have predicted concentration fields by modified versions of existing engineering models, but the validation of these models is limited by the unavailability of literature data. There are multiple literature sources that measured flame lengths and heat flux values, which are both relevant metrics to risk and hazard assessments. These data can be more directly compared to the outputs of existing engineering models for validation.
As energy utilities implement climate change mitigation policies, system planners require strategies for achieving affordable emissions reductions. Coordinated planning of electric power and natural gas systems will allow synergistic investments to address cross-sector operational constraints, competing uses for net-zero emissions fuels, and shifts in energy demands across energy carriers. In this study, we develop a novel optimization program that finds the cost-minimizing mix of infrastructure expansion or reduction across gas and electric systems to satisfy sector-specific emissions constraints. Alongside energy supply resources, our framework allows for central-planning of end-use equipment stocks to allow switching between gas and electric appliances upon failure or premature replacement. The proposed model is used to simulate case study scenarios for a benchmark 24-pipe gas network coupled to a 24-node power system test network. We find that electrification of greater than 80% of core gas demands is a component of the least-cost solution for modeled energy systems. Despite this substitution, the gas system is maintained to service difficult-to-electrify customers and to deliver net-zero emissions gas to electricity generators in times of peak electricity demand. Restricting electrification of gas appliances increases reliance on power- to-gas technologies and increases annual costs by 15% in 2040. Neglecting constraints on pipeline blending of hydrogen can produce a misleading result that relies on hydrogen blend fractions of greater than 50%. In all cases, we find the average costs of delivered gas increase nearly 5-fold across the decarbonization transition, highlighting the importance of future work investigating cost-allocation strategies for ensuring an equitable energy transition.
BlendPATH provides case-by-case techno-economic analysis for potential projects where hydrogen is blended into a natural gas transmission pipeline. BlendPATH estimates 1) the transmission pipeline modifications and operating conditions necessary to blend hydrogen to a user specified volume faction of hydrogen in pipeline gas and 2) the incremental capital and operating expenses to prepare said transmission pipeline for hydrogen blending. BlendPATH is developed in Python and requires SAInt, a underlying commercial natural gas pipeline network modeling software, to run. Pipeline modification and operation condition estimation is guided by ASME B31.12. The intent of this software is to target application for projects in the initial project assessment stage and provide the user with the capability of assess promising opportunities before the use proceeds with further detailed pipeline evaluation based on a probable economic outcome.
Abstract To address the shortage of fossil fuels and the environmental impact of exhaust emissions, research efforts in combustion seek to identify candidates for sustainable fuels. Hydrogen is an example, from which water is produced as the main combustion product. However, when used as neat hydrogen, it is very difficult to control hydrogen combustion due to its high flame speed, pre-ignition propensity, and flashback characteristics. One method to control hydrogen combustion is to blend it with a well-established fuel. Natural gas is a common fuel for use in engines or gas turbines. Natural gas is characterized by slow flame speeds and poor lean-burn ability; thus, engine power is decreased in the lean-burn region. Consequently, natural gas engines are typically operated at stoichiometric conditions to maximize output. Blending hydrogen to natural gas has several advantages: (i) Control of hydrogen’s ignition characteristics, (ii) extension of Natural gas’s lower flammability limit — making it easier to ignite, and (iii) reduced greenhouse gas emissions. In this study, the laminar burning speed (LBS) for neat natural gas and natural gas/hydrogen mixtures at 5 atm and 296 K were measured. Schlieren optical imaging was utilized to validate laminar flame conditions and further investigate the structure of natural gas/hydrogen flames. Results indicate that replacing 50% of natural gas with hydrogen increases the peak laminar burning velocity by a factor of ∼1.6 times. LBS simulations were conducted with NUI 1.1 and UCF NG/H2 mechanisms; Predictions by both mechanisms were found to be satisfactory for neat NG mixtures. However, for 50% NG/ 50% H2 mixture, the true LBS for fuel-lean conditions was under-predicted by both models, while predictions for fuel-rich conditions were satisfactory. Additionally, a literature review and similar experimental analysis will be performed for methane, ammonia, and hydrogen fuel blends to better understand the combustion phenomena of natural gas fuels.
The growth of hydrogen as an alternative clean fuel for fulfilling thermal energy needs of multiple economic sectors globally requires access to reliable, safe, energy efficient, emission free combustion technology. The work described in this short communication shows the applicability of a novel heterogeneous combustion design in utilizing a wide range of hydrogen blended methane concentrations to cleanly and safely generate thermal energy. The utilization of a simple first principles design approach along with engineered materials yielded a fuel-flexible hybrid infrared-convection burner design capable of lowering NOx emissions by more than 95% while simultaneously improving the heat transfer efficiency by 15% with a wide range of hydrogen concentrations. Here, the safety and performance of the combustion design was demonstrated in an burner at capacities of up to 12,000 Btu/h in producing temperatures of 900 °C. The atmospheric burner concept was integrated in a cooktop configuration with combined thermal power rating of 30,000 Btu/h and operated with hydrogen blended natural gas.
Abstract There are many challenges of commissioning a hydrogen combustor into future gas turbine engines; especially regarding achieving emissions goals. Previously, Escudero et al. and Tran et al. conducted a study to adapt the liquid fuel Lean Direct Injection (LDI) concept from Jet-A to gaseous natural gas-hydrogen blends and pure hydrogen [1], [2]. Experimental data was collected at atmospheric conditions using a Box Behnken design of experiments. The design of experiments suggested that biasing the air split in favor of the inner air circuit and increasing the swirl strength of this inner air passage resulted in improved NOx emissions, while the inverse was true for stability, which was quantified by studying the lean blowoff point (LBO) [1], [2]. The trends revealed by the original experiment [1], [2] provided a design direction for further iterations of the experimental hardware. The study presented herein describes the further investigation of such LDI injectors through experimental methods and computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulations at atmospheric conditions, which were used to identify potential flow behaviors driving enhanced emissions performance. Further evaluation of select injectors from both studies was then conducted at elevated pressures up to 6 atmospheres. The results from both experiments are presented in this study, which include flame observations, emissions measurements, and operational challenges. NOx emissions results are reported on a volume basis in ppmvd corrected to 15% O2 and corrected for fuel. A predictive model for relating NOx emissions to test conditions at atmospheric conditions show high significance to adiabatic flame temperature while little to no significance to fuel composition for the best performing configurations. The results illustrate the connection between atmospheric testing and testing elevated pressures. The design direction indicated by the initial tests and CFD results in promising configurations for implementation into a Multi-point LDI array.
Hydrogen ions produced during corrosion or through hydrogen blending into natural gas pipelines can lead to the degradation of ductility of metals used in these transmission pipelines. The effect of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of pipeline steels was studied for three grades of API 5L steels: X56, X65, and X100. These steels are either commonly used in or considered for use in natural gas transmission pipelines which are being considered for use in hydrogen blending. These steels were subjected to constant strain rate tensile testing after charging with electrochemically generated hydrogen. This presentation reports on work to extend the life of the natural gas pipeline network via understanding the effect of hydrogen embrittlement induced by corrosion processes.