Towards informatics-driven design of nuclear waste forms
Informatics-driven approaches, such as machine learning and sequential experimental design, have shown the potential to drastically impact next-generation materials discovery and design.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Informatics-driven approaches, such as machine learning and sequential experimental design, have shown the potential to drastically impact next-generation materials discovery and design.
Herein, we describe a first-of-a-kind study where lead tellurite (Pb-Te-O), iron phosphate (Fe-P-O), and lanthanide aluminoborosilicate (LABS) waste forms are evaluated for treating and/or immobilizing waste streams containing high rare-earth (RE) content, e.g., RECl 3 , REOCl, and/or REO x . Results from this study show that NdOCl can be immobilized in 78TeO 2 -22PbO glass at up to 10 mass%. Higher loadings of up to 15 mass% were demonstrated, but with a small fraction of crystallization. Two Fe-P-O glasses produced from either RECl 3 (RE = Nd,Ce) or NdOCl revealed products with very similar properties, demonstrating that the phosphate process can be used to chlorinate a variety of RE-containing waste streams. Two LABS glasses produced from Nd 2 O 3 or NdOCl showed similar properties, but the LABS-NdOCl glass did have some residual Cl present. Characterization is provided for all waste forms including chemical analysis, X-ray diffraction, and bulk density.
The primary objective of the work described herein was to develop and identify HLW glass compositions and glass forming additive blends that achieve high waste loadings and processing rates for high phosphorus HLW streams while maintaining acceptable glass properties. Another objective was to determine the effect of phosphate form (aluminum, iron, sodium) on feed processing properties, glass production rates, and product quality while vitrifying a high phosphorus HLW stream. This was accomplished through a combination of crucible-scale tests, vertical gradient furnace tests, and confirmation tests on a DM100 melter system.
Corrosion tests were performed to assess the dissolution behaviors of developmental iron phosphate materials that are being evaluated as an alternative to the glass-bonded sodalite ceramic waste form to immobilize salt wastes from electrochemical separation operations. Production of the iron phosphate waste form results in dehalogenation of the waste salt that increases potential waste loading. Ferric oxide is added to the waste form to increase the chemical durability. Tests conducted to optimize the amount of ferric oxide used to make the waste form are summarized in this report. Specimens prepared from materials made with between 17 and 34 mole % ferric oxide were subjected to two test methods to assess the effects of the iron content on the relative durability and retention of immobilized salt cations including cesium, strontium, and neodymium. Modified ASTM C1308 test results show the intrinsic durability was significantly higher for materials made with 27 mol % ferric oxide. Further additions generated iron-rich inclusion phases and did not improve durability. Modified ASTM C1285 test results show that solution feedback attenuates the dissolution rate similar to what is observed for borosilicate glasses within seven days. Analyses of test specimens after 42 days show no evidence that surface layers formed. Combined with previous studies addressing the salt loading, a composition region of the ammonium (di)hydrogen phosphate-waste salt-ferric oxide ternary has been defined for durable waste form compositions. Materials with that composition can be used to determine optimal processing conditions, assess long-term performance, and parameterize a degradation model.
Mass spectrometry methods are currently under development by the atmospheric mercury (Hg) research community to elucidate the identity of atmospheric oxidized mercury (Hg II ) compounds. Due to high instrument detection limits, materials that can quantitatively preconcentrate atmospheric Hg II without facilitating compound-altering chemical reactions are needed to support these methods. Cation exchange membranes (CEM) and nylon membranes are currently used to preconcentrate ambient Hg II for concentration measurements and Hg II compound estimation, respectively. However, CEM and nylon membranes are poor candidates for observations by mass spectrometry methods due to release of interfering compounds upon heating; glasses do not have this problem. Here, three metal oxide glasses were explored as potential alternatives for Hg II preconcentration for future use with mass spectrometry methods: calcium phosphate (CaP), iron phosphate (FeP), and calcium aluminate (CaAl). The glasses demonstrated quantitative selective capture of HgBr 2 without capture of Hg 0 . Under ambient conditions, the CaP, FeP, and CaAl sorbed 36.4 ± 12.6% of the total HgII as the CEM. However, when Hg concentrations were normalized to surface area, CaP, FeP, and CaAl sorbed more HgBr 2 in the laboratory and ambient HgII compared to CEM. The CEM and CaP retained similar concentrations of HgBr 2 when preloaded samples were deployed in the field. Additionally, a permeation tube-based calibrator was used to load sorbents with HgBr 2 for investigation of HgII retention on CEM and thermal desorption profile changes on nylon membranes during active sampling. Nylon membranes were purchased from three vendors and used to compare HgBr 2 retention; a different HgBr 2 thermal desorption profile was achieved for each vendor’s nylon membrane.
Phosphate glasses have a range of applications including as hosts for immobilizing radioactive wastes. Studies have shown that addition of iron and/or aluminum oxides can drastically improve the chemical durability of phosphate glasses where the accurate measurement of chemical durability is one of the most important factors for determining the long-term viability of a given waste form. However, due to inconsistencies with the experimental methods used to generate chemical durability data, comparing and interpreting such data is a tedious task. These variables include the temperature of the test, the specimen form (e.g., coupon, particles), the pressure of the test (e.g., atmospheric pressure, elevated pressure in an autoclave), the exposure time, the exposure medium, and how the loss is documented (e.g., total mass lost, normalized elemental release). This review paper summarizes a large collection of chemical durability tests on aluminophosphate glasses in various studies. In addition, the effects of different oxides on the properties of phosphate glasses are summarized.
Cosmic ray nuclei from the April 17, 1972 solar flare were recorded in polycarbonate plastic and phosphate glass track detectors exposed on the Apollo 16 flight. The energy spectra of iron group nuclei and of carbon and heavier nuclei were measured down to about 0.02 MeV/nucleon, revealing that the enrichment of iron relative to carbon and heavier nuclei increases markedly in this very low energy region.
In this report, issues that must be addressed to advance the technology readiness level of phosphate glass waste forms being developed to immobilize high-level radioactive salt waste streams are identified, the states of understanding various technical aspects of formulation, processing, and performance are summarized, and approaches supporting further development are recommended. Processing results in dehalogenation of the waste salt, capture of the gaseous halide-bearing species, and immobilization of the residual salt components in a phosphate glass waste form. The approach is suitable for high-level salt waste from electrochemical reprocessing and molten salt reactors. The technology has been demonstrated for chloride-based salts and may also be suitable for the treatment and immobilization of fluoride-based and iodide-bearing waste salts. Aspects of the process requiring further development are identified and approaches recommended.
This research explored vitrification of U-Zr nuclear fuel that exhibits an explosion hazard when processed by common nitric acid dissolution. Glass frits were chosen based on properties that had been previously measured as well as being demonstrated successfully in production at the Defense Waste Process Facility (DWPF). Zirconium and Aluminum metal powders were chosen to represent the spent fuels after literature demonstrated that the potential phase that causes the issue for explosive reaction in the effluent stream is tied to the Zirconium-III phase field. DSC measurements were carried out on various simulants and waste forms to better understand thermal behavior of these materials. Zirconium (Zr) was tested with both nitric acid and the new effluent flowsheet that is under development by the SRNL Chemical Process Control (CPC) group. The nitric acid test did show the expected exothermic behavior as well as how the behavior is affected by particle size of the powders used. In contrast, the effluent samples did not show an exothermic peak. However, the concentration of metal in the samples was orders of magnitude lower than in the nitric acid testing and further testing of the effect of concentration on the exothermicity that could be measured confirmed a dampened signal. Tests were run that included frit, both DWPF Frit 510 and Iron Phosphate frit, exhibiting complex curves that included multiple endothermic and exothermic peaks during heating and cooling. The final crucible samples appear similarly to the bulk glasses pointing to these peaks being a part of the dissolution of the simulant into the base glasses.
Under the above grant research was funded in the following areas: 1. Pallasites: Rare earth element measurements in phosphates to determine if all pallasites fit into only two trace element groups. This work has been completed. 2. HIAB irons: To complete work on the only known silicate inclusion in a IIIAB iron meteorite. This work has been completed. 3. IIIAB irons: To continue the search for Cr-53 excesses in IIIAB iron meteorite phosphates. A part of this work has been completed 4. IIIAB irons: To complete the identification of the phosphate minerals in IIIAB iron meteorites and try to determine the phase relations and chemical history of trace element distributions during the core formation process. Work on this has been largely completed and preliminary results have been reported. The final work is being assessed prior to preparation of a manuscript for publication. 5. IIE irons: To complete work on the unique silicate assemblage in the IIE iron meteorite. Work on this was completed and a paper published. 6. Ungrouped irons: A partially devitrified silicate glass inclusion has been found in the ungrouped iron meteorite. Preliminary work on this has been reported. All the work on this has been now completed and a manuscript has been prepared and submitted for publication.
This report provides experimental details and results on the elemental distributions (compositions), crystalline/amorphous phase distribution, and microstructures for DPF5-336 reference materials made with ERV3b salt that were subjected to the canister centerline cooling (CCC) heat treatment process. To fabricate these materials, ammonium dihydrogen phosphate was mixed with ERV3b salt simulant and a dechlorination procedure was run in the generation-2 dechlorinator at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory up to 600°C in an alumina crucible. After the dechlorination process, the product was removed from the crucible, lightly crushed, loaded into a new alumina crucible, Fe 2 O 3 was added, and this was vitrified at 1100°C for 1 hour and quenched. The quenched material was mostly amorphous but showed some small diffraction peaks attributed to Li 3 Fe 2 (PO 4 ) 3 . This quenched material was ground to a fine particle size in a milling chamber, and this was subjected to the CCC cooling profile in duplicate within alumina and fused quartz crucibles. The CCC experiment is designed to simulate the slowest cooling profile (the vertical centerline) of a 0.61-m diameter canister where the slower cooling profile often results in the production of a variety of different crystalline phases upon formation of which result in a residual glass of unknown composition and properties. The information gleaned from these types of experiments will lead to improved composition-property predictions for materials with similar compositions. The results of the alumina and fused quartz experiments show different microstructures but similar diffraction patterns providing evidence of similar crystalline phases being present in each sample. Both samples had monazite [i.e., (Ce,Nd)PO 4 ] and mixtures of phases containing P, Fe, and alkali metal elements. This report completes the milestone M4FT-23PN030104042 with details provided in Appendix B.
Microbially induced corrosion (MIC) focuses on the degradation of solid materials, such as glass or metal. Soil microbes are often associated with the corrosion of foreign objects in the rhizosphere. Paenibacillus polymyxa SCE2, a facultative anaerobic bacterium in soil, is of the same genus as bacteria found near nuclear waste disposal sites. Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) was used for imaging surface changes induced by P. polymyxa SCE2 cultured on two synthetic glass coupons to represent natural analogs of materials that were studied in relation to the vitrification of nuclear waste. Multimodal imaging was used to verify bacterial coverage across the glass surface after long-term growth. ToF-SIMS spectral analysis showed detection of glass component ions, such as silicon oxide (m/z – 59.96 SiO 2 – ) and aluminum oxide (m/z – 101.95 Al 2 O 3 – ), and biofilm’s extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) components, such as pentadecanoic acid (m/z – 241.22 C 15 H 29 O 2 – ) and sterol lipids (m/z – 311.16 C 20 H 23 O 3 – ). ToF-SIMS spectral, imaging, and depth profiling analyses showed that the glass rich in silica and other light elements (“granite glass”) had more “corrosion related” peaks than the glass that was less silica-rich and contained more iron (“dike glass”). Furthermore, these surface and interface compositional and spatial differences observed in the mass spectra and imaging were attributed to bacterial metabolism and an electron transfer mechanism influenced by morphological and compositional differences between the two types of glasses. ToF-SIMS is effective in studying microbial effects, bringing new molecular insights into MIC in a broader context of materials degradation.