Reducing uncertainties in nucleation rates: A comparison of measurements and simulations
Recently, large uncertainties in amine nucleation thermodynamics associated with the description of interactions of H{sub 2}SO{sub 4}, the key atmospheric nucleation precursor, with pre-nucleation clusters have been revealed. Here we investigate the formation of (H{sub 2}SO{sub 4}){sub 2}(H{sub 2}O){sub n} (n=0-5) clusters via H{sub 2}O–induced dimerization using conventional RI-MP2 and PW91PW91 methods and recently developed multistep BRIMP2 and B3RICC2 methods widely used in nucleation studies and compare the obtained results with measurements for equilibrium constants of H{sub 2}O–induced dimerization. Variations in K{sub p} and Gibbs free energies predicted by different methods were found to be unexpectedly large, several times of those in hydration free energies commonly used to benchmark computational quantum methods. This means that the common hydration benchmarks are not fully representative of nucleation and that the validation of quantum methods to be recommended for use in nucleation studies is impossible without a thorough assessment of H{sub 2}SO{sub 4}-H{sub 2}SO{sub 4} interactions. We show clearly that only conventional RI-MP2 and PW91PW91 methods are consistent with experiments and that a thorough validation of theoretical predictions against experimental data on H{sub 2}SO{sub 4} clustering is needed prior to recommending a quantum–chemical method for use in nucleation research. We also shows that conclusions about the role of Amine-Enhanced Ternary Homogeneous Nucleation (ATHN) in atmospheric nucleation may be affected by the large uncertainties in nucleation thermodynamics associated with the application of B3RICC2 and BRIMP2 methods and may need a thorough revision.