Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “variance reduction”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 37 records · Page 2

Discrete velocity computations with stochastic variance reduction of the Boltzmann equation for gas mixtures

We extend a variance reduced discrete velocity method developed at UT Austin [1, 2] to gas mixtures with large mass ratios and flows with trace species. The mixture is stored as a collection of independent velocity distribution functions, each with a unique grid in velocity space. Different collision types (A-A, A-B, B-B, etc.) are treated independently, and the variance reduction scheme is formulated with different equilibrium functions for each separate collision type. The individual treatment of species enables increased focus on species important to the physics of the flow, even if the important species are present in trace amounts. The method is verified through comparisons to Direct Simulation Monte Carlo computations and the computational workload per time step is investigated for the variance reduced method.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

TU-H-CAMPUS-IeP1-01: Bias and Computational Efficiency of Variance Reduction Methods for the Monte Carlo Simulation of Imaging Detectors

Purpose: Variance reduction techniques (VRTs) are employed in Monte Carlo simulations to obtain estimates with reduced statistical uncertainty for a given simulation time. In this work, we study the bias and efficiency of a VRT for estimating the response of imaging detectors. Methods: We implemented Directed Sampling (DS), preferentially directing a fraction of emitted optical photons directly towards the detector by altering the isotropic model. The weight of each optical photon is appropriately modified to maintain simulation estimates unbiased. We use a Monte Carlo tool called fastDETECT2 (part of the hybridMANTIS open-source package) for optical transport, modified for VRT. The weight of each photon is calculated as the ratio of original probability (no VRT) and the new probability for a particular direction. For our analysis of bias and efficiency, we use pulse height spectra, point response functions, and Swank factors. We obtain results for a variety of cases including analog (no VRT, isotropic distribution), and DS with 0.2 and 0.8 optical photons directed towards the sensor plane. We used 10,000, 25-keV primaries. Results: The Swank factor for all cases in our simplified model converged fast (within the first 100 primaries) to a stable value of 0.9. The root mean square error per pixel for DS VRT for the point response function between analog and VRT cases was approximately 5e-4. Conclusion: Our preliminary results suggest that DS VRT does not affect the estimate of the mean for the Swank factor. Our findings indicate that it may be possible to design VRTs for imaging detector simulations to increase computational efficiency without introducing bias.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Godiva IV Thermal Neutron Dosimetry Modeling and Variance Reduction

The transfer of the Godiva IV experiment from the Los Alamos Critical Experiments Facility (LACEF) to the National Critical Experiments Research Center (NCERC) introduced a vastly different experiment room return to the neutron flux. The contribution of the background to the burst neutron energy spectrum is significant in the thermal and epithermal neutron energies. Target materials may be placed in various locations in the Godiva room, or outside of the room, for thermal neutron activation. Modeling of this dosimetry problem in Monte Carlo N-Particle (MCNP) presented a novel challenge compared to previous Godiva IV glory hole irradiation simulations. An advanced dosimetry modeling framework for high efficiency calculations in locations far from the Godiva IV fission source was desired. The mesh-based weight windows and point detector advanced variance reduction techniques in MCNP were implemented and tested using adaptations of the critical experiment benchmark model of the Godiva IV problem. The models were validated against measured activations of Nickel, Indium, Scandium, and Cobalt foils at locations 2 meters from the Godiva IV core. Dosimetry measurements were performed in collaboration with Sandia National Laboratory. The weight windows and point detector variance reduction coupled method resulted in the highest problem efficiency.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

CoVVVR: Control Variates & Vegas Variance Reduction

This package is a wrapper over the vegas integration package. The control variate variance reduction method is applied to the function when integrated along with the techniques applied in vegas such as importance sampling. To understand control variates, lets first look at how Monte Carlo works.

Scott, JacobL. [Univ. of Kansas, Lawrence, KS (Uni↗

Importance Sampling Variance Reduction in GRESS ATMOSIM

This document is intended to introduce the importance sampling method of variance reduction to a Geant4 user for application to neutral particle Monte Carlo transport through the atmosphere, as implemented in GRESS ATMOSIM.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Verification of the history-score moment equations for weight-window variance reduction

The history-score moment equations that describe the moments of a Monte Carlo score distribution have been extended to weight-window variance reduction, The resulting equations have been solved deterministically to calculate the population variance of the Monte Carlo score distribution for a single tally, Results for one- and two-dimensional one-group problems are presented that predict the population variances to less than 1% deviation from the Monte Carlo for one-dimensional problems and between 1- 2% for two-dimensional problems,

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

A Comparison of the FW-CADIS and MR-CADIS Variance Reduction Methods

The Consistent Adjoint Driven Importance Sampling (CADIS) method, which uses an adjoint deterministic estimate for making variance reduction parameters that optimize Monte Carlo (MC) shielding calculations, was introduced in 1998. This method was designed to optimize a single tally, typically an integrated response such as a detector count rate or a dose rate. Because both deterministic and stochastic methods are employed, CADIS is referred to as a hybrid method. In 2007, the forward-weighted CADIS (FW-CADIS) method was introduced to optimize several tallies at once, giving more uniform relative uncertainties among the tallies for both high-flux and low-flux areas of the problem. This method can be used for several small detectors, for semi-global problems (mesh tally over a large fraction of the problem), or for global problems (mesh tally over the entire problem). Optimization can be done for an integrated response such as a dose rate D(r) as a function of position, the total flux {phi}(r) as a function of position, or the space/energy flux {phi}(r,E). Both the CADIS and FW-CADIS methods have been in the MAVRIC sequence of SCALE for three versions (6.0 in 2009, 6.1 in 2011, and 6.2 in 2016). The ADVANTG package released in 2015 uses the CADIS and FW-CADIS methods to accelerate MCNP neutron/photon shielding calculations. In 2014, the multi-response CADIS (MR-CADIS) method was presented as a way to obtain even more uniform relative uncertainties for problems with multiple tallies than those obtained with FW-CADIS. The method does not use a forward deterministic calculation but instead uses one adjoint calculation for every tally to be optimized in the Monte Carlo calculation. This work compares the above methods.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Comparison Of Hybrid Methods For Global Variance Reduction In Shielding Calculations

For Monte Carlo shielding problems that calculate a mesh tally over the entire problem, the relative uncertainties computed for each voxel can vary widely. This can lead to unacceptably long run times in order to reduce the uncertainties in all areas of the problem to a reasonably low level. Hybrid methods using estimates from deterministic calculations to create importance maps for variance reduction in Monte Carlo calculations have been successfully used to optimize the calculation of specific tallies. For the global problem, several methods have been proposed that create importance maps that distribute Monte Carlo particles in such a way as to achieve a more uniform distribution of relative uncertainty across the problem. The goal is to compute a mesh tally with nearly the same relative uncertainties in the low flux/dose areas as in the high flux/dose areas. Methods based on only forward deterministic estimates and methods using both forward and adjoint deterministic methods have been implemented the SCALE/MAVRIC package and have been compared against each other by computing global mesh tallies on several representative shielding problems. Methods using both forward and adjoint estimates provide better performance for computing more uniform relative uncertainties across a global mesh tally.

FW-CADIS↗

A novel MC TRT method: vectorizable variance reduction for the energy spectra

Data produced up to now gives us confidence that we will continue to see variance reduction behavior at amenable runtimes as we move this test bed forward. This method has characteristics of event and history based Monte Carlo transport, without the bulky modifications required by event based Monte Carlo while avoiding some overhead.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Importance sampling variance reduction for the Fokker–Planck rarefied gas particle method

The Fokker–Planck approximation to the Boltzmann equation, solved numerically by stochastic particle schemes, is used to provide estimates for rarefied gas flows. This paper presents a variance reduction technique for a stochastic particle method that is able to greatly reduce the uncertainty of the estimated flow fields when the characteristic speed of the flow is small in comparison to the thermal velocity of the gas. The method relies on importance sampling, requiring minimal changes to the basic stochastic particle scheme. We test the importance sampling scheme on a homogeneous relaxation, planar Couette flow and a lid-driven-cavity flow, and find that our method is able to greatly reduce the noise of estimated quantities. Significantly, we find that as the characteristic speed of the flow decreases, the variance of the noisy estimators becomes independent of the characteristic speed.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Global variance reduction method applied to HBR-2 benchmark - 25144

It is a great challenge to obtain reliable results in reasonable time by the Monte Carlo (MC) method in solving deep-penetration shielding problems. Global variance reduction (GVR) method uses biased source and weight window to decrease MC calculation tally error for deep-penetration problems. However, excessive splitting of large weight particles out of the source region is time-consuming for problems with significant fluence rate variation. A new GVR method, which performs space and energy splitting/roulette based on the importance of the phase space, is proposed in this paper to avoid excessive splitting of large weight particles. The improved GVR method is applied to HBR-2 benchmark. Numerical results show that the new GVR method achieves good corresponding results to those of references. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Improving computational efficiency of Monte Carlo simulations with variance reduction

CCFE perform Monte-Carlo transport simulations on large and complex tokamak models such as ITER. Such simulations are challenging since streaming and deep penetration effects are equally important. In order to make such simulations tractable, both variance reduction (VR) techniques and parallel computing are used. It has been found that the application of VR techniques in such models significantly reduces the efficiency of parallel computation due to 'long histories'. VR in MCNP can be accomplished using energy-dependent weight windows. The weight window represents an 'average behaviour' of particles, and large deviations in the arriving weight of a particle give rise to extreme amounts of splitting being performed and a long history. When running on parallel clusters, a long history can have a detrimental effect on the parallel efficiency - if one process is computing the long history, the other CPUs complete their batch of histories and wait idle. Furthermore some long histories have been found to be effectively intractable. To combat this effect, CCFE has developed an adaptation of MCNP which dynamically adjusts the WW where a large weight deviation is encountered. The method effectively 'de-optimises' the WW, reducing the VR performance but this is offset by a significant increase in parallel efficiency. Testing with a simple geometry has shown the method does not bias the result. This 'long history method' has enabled CCFE to significantly improve the performance of MCNP calculations for ITER on parallel clusters, and will be beneficial for any geometry combining streaming and deep penetration effects. (authors)

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Learning the generating functional for variance reduction in lattice QCD

The generating functional in quantum field theory provides the natural framework for constructing correlation functions as derivatives with respect to source operators. We present a methodology that leverages machine-learned normalizing flows to reduce the variance of arbitrary $N$-point correlation functions of bosonic operators in lattice gauge field theory calculations by encoding a representation of the generating functional. We show that it is possible to systematically approach noiseless estimators of correlation functions in this framework. We demonstrate this methodology with applications to calculations of glueball correlation functions and Wilson loops in Quantum Chromodynamics and Yang-Mills theory. The results show up to three orders of magnitude variance reduction.

Abbott, Ryan [Columbia U.] (ORCID:0000000258778005↗

Variance reduction via simultaneous importance sampling and control variates techniques using vegas

Monte Carlo (MC) integration is an important calculational technique in the physical sciences. Practical considerations require that the calculations are performed as accurately as possible for a given set of computational resources. To improve the accuracy of MC integration, a number of useful variance reduction algorithms have been developed, including importance sampling and control variates. In this work, we demonstrate how these two methods can be applied simultaneously, thus combining their benefits. We provide a python wrapper, named CoVVVR, which implements our approach in the VEGAS program. The improvements are quantified with several benchmark examples from the literature.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Comparison of hybrid methods for global variance reduction in shielding calculations

For Monte Carlo shielding problems that calculate a mesh tally over the entire problem, the statistical uncertainties computed for each voxel can vary widely. This can lead to unacceptably long run times in order to reduce the uncertainties in all areas of the problem to a reasonably low level. Hybrid methods - using estimates from deterministic calculations to create importance maps for variance reduction in Monte Carlo calculations - have been successfully used to optimize the calculation of specific tallies. For the global problem, several methods have been proposed to create importance maps that distribute Monte Carlo particles in such a way as to achieve a more uniform distribution of relative uncertainty across the problem. The goal is to compute a mesh tally with nearly the same relative uncertainties in the low flux/dose areas as in the high flux/dose areas. Methods based on only forward deterministic estimates and methods using both forward and adjoint deterministic methods have been implemented in the SCALE/MAVRIC package and have been compared against each other by computing global mesh tallies on several representative shielding problems. Methods using both forward and adjoint estimates provide better performance for computing more uniform relative uncertainties across a global mesh tally. (authors)

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Fast variance reduction for steady-state simulation and sensitivity analysis of stochastic chemical systems using shadow function estimators

We address the problem of estimating steady-state quantities associated to systems of stochastic chemical kinetics. In most cases of interest, these systems are analytically intractable, and one has to resort to computational methods to estimate stationary values of cost functions. In this work, we introduce a novel variance reduction algorithm for stochastic chemical kinetics, inspired by related methods in queueing theory, in particular the use of shadow functions. Using two numerical examples, we demonstrate the efficiency of the method for the calculation of steady-state parametric sensitivities and evaluate its performance in comparison to other estimation methods.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

A Method to Alleviate the Long History Problem Encountered in Monte Carlo Simulations via Weight Window Variance Reduction

When the weight window is implemented in large and complex models, streaming path and deep penetration could lead to a long history problem that takes a disproportionate amount of time for the accomplishment of Monte Carlo simulations and exerts a detrimental effect on the efficiency of parallel computing. An approach set the limitation of weight window splitting was proposed for the alleviation of long history problem. Tests were conducted on a streaming dog-leg geometry model and a 3D model of the Chinese Fusion Engineering Testing Reactor. The results show that a suitable parameter in the alleviation method could optimize both the performance of variance reduction and the efficiency of parallel calculation, which makes long history problem tractable.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗