High-throughput aqueous passivation behavior of thin-film vs. bulk multi-principal element alloys in sulfuric acid
Not provided.
Materials Science↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “vs”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Physics vs structure: A systematic benchmark of learning strategies for multi-zone building thermal dynamics
Recent advances in physics-informed and data-driven machine learning promise improved thermal models for advanced building control, yet there is limited quantitative evidence on when added physics structure and architectural complexity are beneficial. Here, this work presents a systematic benchmark of five representative system identification methods for modeling multi-zone building thermal dynamics: linear state-space models, multi-layer perceptrons, neural state-space models, neural ordinary differential equations, and physically-consistent neural networks. The methods are evaluated across multiple data regimes and zone coupling strategies. Using a high-fidelity multi-zone commercial building emulator, we examine short-term and long-term prediction accuracy, computational efficiency, and ease of development. Our results reveal critical trade-offs between prediction performance, model complexity, and physical consistency. We demonstrate that decoupled, nonlinear black-box models consistently outperform coupled physics-constrained architectures in both predictive accuracy and out-of-distribution robustness in majority of the test cases for the building type considered in the study. Our findings quantify the cost of complexity in building thermal modeling and provide concrete, actionable, scenario-based guidelines for selecting model classes for control-oriented applications.
Building thermal modeling↗
Chemical specificity in polyzwitterion-polyelectrolyte coacervates: polycations vs polyanions
Aqueous solutions containing polyzwitterions and polyelectrolytes were studied to probe the effects of chemical specificity on the complexation among different types of chains and resulting liquid–liquid phase separation (coacervation). Two kinds of blends were studied. A polyzwitterion, poly(sulfobetaine methacrylate) (PSBMA), was blended with either (1) a polycation, poly(diallydimethylammonium chloride) (PDADMAC), or (2) a polyanion, sodium poly(styrene sulphonate) (NaPSS). Coacervation was observed in both blends after equilibration, while the freshly prepared blend solutions exhibited distinct behavior dependent on the mixing protocols. Mixing solutions of the polyzwitterions and the polycations led to coacervation almost instantaneously. In contrast, the blends containing the same polyzwitterions and the polyanions exhibited no such coacervation by following the same mixing protocol. However, blends prepared after dissolving a solid mixture containing the same polyzwitterions and the polyanions in water exhibited coacervation. Based on the small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), cryo-electron microscopy, and rheology measurements, complexation and coacervation in the polyzwitterion-polyelectrolyte blends is rationalized in terms of the entropy change associated with reorganization of solvent (water), which appears to be larger in the polyzwitterion-polycation case in comparison with the polyzwitterion-polyanion blends. These results highlight the importance of chemical specificity and mixing protocols leading to metastable structures in designing a new class of materials based on macromolecular complexation of polyzwitterions.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Composition and persistence of soil organic matter along eroding and depositional transects in buried vs. modern soil layers: A case of the Brady paleosol at Wauneta, Nebraska
Paleosols form when soils are buried through deposition by aeolian, colluvial, alluvial or other processes. Burial of former topsoil isolates soil organic matter (SOM) from surface conditions, allowing carbon to accumulate and potentially remain stable for millennia. In this study, SOM composition, distribution, and persistence were analyzed in the Brady Soil of Nebraska, USA to compare SOM spatial variability in modern and buried soils, as well as the impact of erosional exposure on SOM stability. The Brady Soil, formed as a surface soil during the Pleistocene-Holocene transition and now a paleosol buried up to 6 m deep (or more) by loess deposition during the Holocene, was sampled along burial (up to 5.8 m depth) and erosional (up to 1.8 m depth) transects to compare SOM dynamics in different geomorphic settings. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) and Fourier Transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FTICR-MS) were used to analyze SOM composition, while δ 13 C isotope analyses identified SOM sources and radiocarbon values were used to estimate turnover rates. Results confirmed a vegetation shift from C3 to C4 plants after Brady Soil formation, reflecting warming climatic conditions. Increasing SOM age and decreasing δ 13 C and δ 15 N values with depth indicated slowing of decomposition rate in buried soils. Higher pH in the Brady Soil suggested greater base cation content, supporting SOM stabilization through organo-mineral associations and aggregate formation. However, exposure of the Brady Soil due to surface erosion caused faster SOM turnover. This result suggested susceptibility of buried SOM to losses via decomposition upon erosional exposure, possibly accelerated by priming in response to modern SOM inputs. These findings highlight the potential loss of carbon stocks in buried soils under future climate change, as shifts in soil physicochemical properties may destabilize long-preserved SOM.
Environmental sciences↗
Grid-responsive hydrogen production: Capital utilization and current density vs. efficiency in variable electricity markets
To achieve low-cost hydrogen production from water electrolyzers, grid tied electrolysis may need to operate dynamically to minimize the cost of supplying energy to the electrolyzer stack and produce hydrogen during low-cost hours and turn off/down during high-cost hours. Operating systems in this way can decrease capital utilization (capacity factor) and electricity costs. This strategy would shift the dominant cost drivers away from electricity (and thus efficiency) to the capital costs of the system, due to the underutilized capital when operating at low-capacity factors. Increasing the operational current density of the system could, in effect, reduce the capital cost of the system while producing hydrogen at a lower efficiency on a per unit energy basis. In the variable electricity cost profiles analyzed in this paper, increasing the current density for liquid alkaline from 0.5 A/cm2 to 1.5 Ac/m2 and proton exchange membrane electrolyzers from 2 A/cm2 to 4 A/cm2 resulted in substantial reductions in the levelized cost of hydrogen. Additionally, as capacity factors and electricity costs decrease, the optimal operating current density of the electrolyzer systems analyzed increases. These findings suggest R&D efforts should focus on increasing the operational current densities, reducing the turn down ratios, and understanding the durability implications of those strategies on low-temperature liquid alkaline and proton exchange membrane electrolyzers.
08 HYDROGEN↗
A seasonal study on the microbiomes of Diploid vs. Triploid eastern oysters and their denitrification potential
Not Available
54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
The effect of varying powder feedstock chemistry and printing atmosphere on the microstructure of additively manufactured nickel-based ODS alloys: Role on stabilization of cellular structures vs. oxide dispersion formation
Nickel-based alloys have a wide variety of structural applications due to their high corrosion resistance and mechanical strength which depend on solid solution strengthening, or the formation of oxides and/or intermetallic precipitation for their properties. In this study, the microstructure of six Ni–Cr–Y–Ti–Al powder batches designed for the production of oxide dispersion strengthened nickel were compared. These batches varied in chemistry and atomization technique used which included Gas Atomization Reactive Synthesis (GARS). The batches of powder were then consolidated via Additive Manufacturing (AM) Powder Bed Fusion using Laser Beam (PBF-LB) and characterized via transmission electron microscopy to elucidate the influence of powder feedstock (i.e. synthesis methodology and chemistry) on the PBF-LB microstructure. The study investigates (i) how the amount of yttrium and titanium additions in the powder feedstock and the addition of oxygen during the processing (through GARS) affect the microstructure of the powder itself and the AM printed microstructure, and (ii) how the control of oxygen addition in the printing atmosphere during the PBF-LB printing process itself is another important parameter for achieving the formation of the wanted oxide dispersion versus the stabilization of the cellular structure (often observed in AM processed alloys). Microstructural characterization of both powder particles and additively manufactured nickel alloys in this study provide important insights into the movement of yttrium within the material upon solidification, particularly along cell boundaries, and how yttrium behaves depending on alloy chemistry. When a threshold of yttrium content is reached within the system, yttrium consistently reacts to form an intermetallic along cell boundaries instead of forming oxide nanoparticles.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Superior electrochemical performance and reduced heat generation in 3D printed vs. 2D tape-casted NMC622 electrodes
This study compares the charge storage mechanisms, thermodynamics behavior, ion transport, and heat generation in NMC622 electrodes fabricated using a novel 3D printing process and the conventional 2D tape casting process. First, potentiometric entropy measurements revealed that the charge storage mechanisms for both types of electrodes consisted of lithium deintercalation in a homogeneous solid solution of NMC622 followed by a transition from a hexagonal (H1) phase to another hexagonal (H2) phase through a monoclinic (M) phase. Both types of electrodes had similar thermodynamics behavior with overlapping entropic potential profiles. Furthermore, operando isothermal calorimetry at high C-rates indicated that the 3D printed electrodes featured larger specific capacity and better rate performance than the 2D tape-casted electrodes. The better performance of 3D printed electrodes was attributed to their larger electrode/electrolyte interfacial surface area and electrical conductivity as well as their faster lithium ion transport. As a result, the instantaneous heat generation rates were smaller in 3D printed electrodes than in 2D tape-casted electrodes, thus resulting in lower overall specific electrical energy and thermal energy dissipation per unit charge stored. Overall, additive manufacturing techniques offer great potential in producing electrodes with superior electrochemical performance and reduced heat generation for fast charging batteries.
25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
Assessing the reliability of SiC MOSFET through inverter-like accelerated test vs. power cycling test
Not Available
14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
Longitudinal bunch-by-bunch feedback systems in storage rings: Phase vs. energy sensing
Not Available
Venturini, Marco (ORCID:0009000388836813)↗
Evaluation of RANS vs. LES simulation of fluid flow through 3 × 3 rod bundle with a simple spacer grid as a precursor to coupled fluid–structure interaction simulations
The research literature on Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) of coolant flow through rod bundles with spacer-grids and mixing vanes is replete, ranging from high fidelity Large Eddy Simulation (LES)/Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) simulations to Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) modeled studies. The mixing of flow between subchannels and the pressure drop through the bundle are fundamental quantities useful for comparing and evaluating CFD methods. Less commonly observed and compared are the forces exerted onto the structure by the fluid. The present study seeks to evaluate the use of RANS simulations for predicting the structural response to fluid flow. Wall resolved RANS simulations are benchmarked against LES simulations of fluid flow at a Reynolds number of 15,000 through a 3 × 3 fuel rod bundle with a simple spacer grid. Velocity line-plots are compared showing good agreement between RANS and LES results, ascertaining that the former is capable of capturing the essential time-averaged velocity profile. Additionally, the distribution of forces on the spacer grid and fuel rods are collected as a function of time and space. The RANS methods are evaluated using the frequency and magnitude of the fluctuating forces on various portions of the structure as compared to LES. In conclusion, the power spectral density evaluation of the models reveal underprediction of force amplitude on the rod walls by RANS and also discrepancy in the prediction of high frequency spectra, especially in the immediate vicinity of spacer-grid structure, which may be attributed to the lack of random turbulence fluctuation or insufficient modeling of small-scale eddies in RANS simulation.
FIV↗
Sustainable H 2 -Rich Syngas Production via Microwave-Assisted vs Conventional Catalysis of Pinewood
Catalytic gasification of biomass is a promising method for producing hydrogen-rich syngas, which is a valuable resource for cleanenergy applications. In this study, microwave-assisted biomass gasification was compared with conventional thermally driven biomass gasification using pinewood as the biomass without the use of external gasifying agents (such as air, steam, and CO 2 ), under non-catalytic and catalytic conditions. The catalysts consisted of either an iron or a nickel catalyst, and the pinewood used as biomass contained 42% oxygen. This comparative analysis explores the differences in reaction chemistry, product yields, and the role of key reactions such as the water gas shift (WGS) reaction, Boudouard reaction, etc. The gas-phase and liquid-phase products were analyzed using online gas chromatography, and the fresh and spent catalysts were analyzed using X-ray diffraction (XRD) techniques. It was found that microwave-assisted gasification offers advantages in terms of enhanced reaction efficiency, catalyst stability, and hydrogen yield. For the microwave-assisted reaction, the gas yield reached 87%, the char yield was 12.1%, and the tar yield was less than 1% (0.793%) at 550 °C. In contrast, thermal-assisted gasification using the same catalyst produced a gas yield of 85.796%, char yield of 11.438%, and higher tar yield of 2.8% at 900 °C. The higher microwave-assisted performance was attributed to faster heating and better control over reaction conditions, higher reaction rates, and more favorable conditions for hydrogen production.
biomass↗
Atomic Orbital Energy Matching vs Overlap in Actinide-Ligand Dative Bonding
Prebonding conditions and dative bond formation in actinide(IV)hexachloride complexes with U, Np, and Pu are studied by density functional theory (DFT) calculations, focusing on the interplay of atomic orbital (AO) overlap and AO energy matching in the formation of molecular orbitals (MOs) and the subsequent identification of dative bonds. The extent of donation is tracked via population analysis, MO localization, and bond-order criteria. DFT Fock matrices are used to setup models in which varying numbers of valence AOs interact to form dative bonds. The results confirm, among other effects, a contribution to metal−ligand covalency from the actinide (An) 6p shell. Better matching of An(5f) and Cl(3p) energies occurs as the An(5f) level stabilizes with increasing An effective nuclear charge. A near-degeneracy occurs in the case of the α-spin orbitals of the Pu system, but it is inconsequential. Altogether, better AO energy matching for An(5f) and Cl(3p) along the series U, Np, Pu is counter-balanced by decreasing AO overlap and decreasing availability of 5f acceptor orbitals, leading to similar bond orders and extents of donation in the three systems.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Dehydrogenation vs Apparent Hydrogenation: Unraveling the Mechanisms of He and O 2 Plasma Etching on Colloidal Nanocrystal Films
Removing organic ligands from colloidal nanoparticles is critical for fabricating solid-state devices, yet accurately quantifying this removal remains a significant analytical challenge. Here, we establish a robust and accessible method for this quantification by calibrating Raman spectroscopy against precise ion beam analysis (IBA) for nanoparticle assemblies (CNAs) processed by helium (He) and oxygen (O 2 ) plasmas. We demonstrate that the calibration curves are remarkably independent of plasma power and pressure, depending critically only on the choice of feed gas. He plasma induces rapid dehydrogenation and cross-linking, evidenced by a much faster decrease in the C–H Raman signal relative to the actual carbon loss. Conversely, O 2 plasma leads to a surprising “apparent hydrogenation”, where the carbon backbone is removed significantly faster than the C–H signal diminishes. This counterintuitive effect is explained by a serial mechanism of oxidative fragmentation; β-scission cleaves the alkyl chains, and subsequent stabilization steps enrich the remaining film with hydrogen-rich methyl-terminated fragments, while carbon is efficiently removed as volatile CO. This work provides calibrated functions that enable the rapid determination of absolute carbon content in processed CNAs using simple Raman spectroscopy with uncertainties of ∼8% for O 2 and ∼12% for He plasma, offering a vital tool for both process diagnostics and fundamental studies of plasma–matter interactions in colloidal nanocrystal films.
Animal feed↗
Role of Polymer Architecture in CO 2 Capture from Air Using Supported Poly(alkylenimine)s: Linear vs Branched Polymers
Direct air capture (DAC) of CO 2 coupled with geologic storage is a promising climate change mitigation strategy, with some applications employing amines supported on porous solids as CO 2 sorbents. While branched poly(ethylenimine) (PEI) is the standard benchmark amine material, it suffers from limited oxidative stability. Poly(propylenimine) (PPI), as an alternative, has previously demonstrated improved resistance to degradation under harsh oxidative conditions. Linear and branched PEI are commercially available, though at different molecular weights, while PPI is not commercially available. For this reason, a comparative study of all four polymers (linear PEI, branched PEI, linear PPI, branched PPI) has not been reported for DAC. In this study, we synthesize and compare low-molecular-weight (∼800 g/mol) linear (L) and branched (B) PEI and PPI supported on a model support, SBA-15 silica. These materials are evaluated for CO 2 adsorption under dry, DAC-relevant conditions (400 ppm of CO 2 , 30 °C). LPPI exhibited the highest amine efficiency at all loadings, reaching a maximum of 0.14 mmol CO 2 /mmol N, outperforming BPEI, while LPEI consistently showed the lowest uptake capacity. Temperature-programmed desorption reveals that the structure of the amine polymer impacts the CO 2 binding strength, with branched polymers displaying higher desorption energies of 102−111 kJ/mol. In situ infrared spectroscopy experiments show that all sorbents preferentially capture CO 2 as ammonium carbamate. Isobaric CO 2 uptake studies further underscore the influence of polymer mobility and support pore crowding on performance, while demonstrating the sorbents’ performance at elevated temperatures and CO 2 concentrations. All materials demonstrated good stability over 25 adsorption−desorption cycles using thermal regeneration in an inert gas purge, with only BPPI displaying a 10−11% decrease in capacity/amine efficiency during cycling, possibly due to the loss of low molecular weight, oligomeric amines. This is the first side-by-side comparison of the CO 2 sorption properties of linear and branched PEI and PPI with similar molecular weights. These findings highlight the significant role of polymer architecture in CO 2 capture efficiency and inform future designs of durable, high-performance DAC sorbents.
adsorbents↗
Self-Sorting vs Coassembly in Peptide Amphiphile Supramolecular Nanostructures
The functionality of supramolecular nanostructures can be expanded if systems containing multiple components are designed to either self-sort or mix into coassemblies. This is critical to gain the ability to craft self-assembling materials that integrate functions, and our understanding of this process is in its early stages. Here, in this work, we have utilized three different peptide amphiphiles with the capacity to form β-sheets within supramolecular nanostructures and found binary systems that self-sort and others that form coassemblies. This was measured using atomic force microscopy to reveal the nanoscale morphology of assemblies and confocal laser scanning microscopy to determine the distribution of fluorescently labeled monomers. We discovered that PA assemblies with opposite supramolecular chirality self-sorted into chemically distinct nanostructures. In contrast, the PA molecules that formed a mixture of right-handed, left-handed, and flat nanostructures on their own were able to coassemble with the other PA molecules. We attribute this phenomenon to the energy barrier associated with changing the handedness of a β-sheet twist in a coassembly of two different PA molecules. This observation could be useful for designing biomolecular nanostructures with dual bioactivity or interpenetrating networks of PA supramolecular assemblies.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Kinetics vs Thermodynamics: Engineering Photoredox Reactivity from an Upper Excited State of Fe II
Ultrafast deactivation of metal-to-ligand charge-transfer (MLCT) states into low-lying metal-centered states has long limited the utility of first-row transition-metal complexes in a broad range of applications, including photoredox catalysis. Here we bypass such limitations using a Fe II -pyridinium carbene complex to enable electron transfer reactivity directly from a higher-lying MLCT state. Time-resolved spectroscopic data revealed that the higher-energy MLCT manifold relaxes to lower-lying metal-centered states with a time constant of ca. 3 ps. The nature of the metal-centered (MC) excited state as a 3 MC (i.e., S = 1) was inferred from variable-temperature transient absorption studies. These experiments also revealed that the ground-state recovery process occurs at or very near the “Marcus barrierless regime”, thereby allowing for an estimate of its excited-state redox potential. The detailed picture of the energetics of this compound that emerged enabled fine-tuning of competing thermodynamic and kinetic pathways to effect electron transfer from the higher-energy MLCT excited state prior to relaxation to the ligand-field manifold. We believe these results open an unexplored landscape for the use of earth-abundant first-row transition-metal-based chromophores for applications in light-to-chemical energy conversion.
charge transfer↗