Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Liquid structure simulation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 379 records · Page 21

Molecular dynamics simulation studies of 1,3-dimethyl imidazolium nitrate ionic liquid with water

The fundamental understanding of intermolecular interactions of ionic liquids (ILs) with water is essential in predicting IL–water thermodynamic properties. In this study, intermolecular or noncovalent interactions were studied for 1,3-dimethyl imidazolium [DMIM]+ cation and nitrate [NO 3 ] – anion with water, employing quantum mechanics and molecular dynamics simulations. Molecular dynamics simulations were performed using a revised multipolar polarizable force field. The effect of water on ionic liquids was evaluated in terms of thermodynamic and dynamic properties. Thermodynamic properties included liquid densities ρ, excess molar volumes ΔV E , and liquid structures g(r)⁠. Dynamic properties included self-diffusion coefficients D of mixture constituents as a function of water concentration. The density of ionic liquid–water mixtures monotonically decrease with increasing concentration of water. A negative excess volume was obtained for low and high water concentrations, demonstrating strong intermolecular interactions of water with ionic liquid components. Liquid structures of ionic liquid–water mixtures revealed a tendency for anions to interact with cations at shorter intermolecular distances when the water concentration is increased. Diffusion rates were found to increase for all mixture components with increase in the fraction of water. A significant change in the diffusion rate was found at ~0.3 weight fraction of water. However, the water self-diffusion coefficient was dominant at all concentrations. Furthermore, the ratio of water/anion and anion/cation self-diffusion coefficients was found to decrease linearly with increasing concentration of water molecules.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The composite load spectra project

Probabilistic methods and generic load models capable of simulating the load spectra that are induced in space propulsion system components are being developed. Four engine component types (the transfer ducts, the turbine blades, the liquid oxygen posts and the turbopump oxidizer discharge duct) were selected as representative hardware examples. The composite load spectra that simulate the probabilistic loads for these components are typically used as the input loads for a probabilistic structural analysis. The knowledge-based system approach used for the composite load spectra project provides an ideal environment for incremental development. The intelligent database paradigm employed in developing the expert system provides a smooth coupling between the numerical processing and the symbolic (information) processing. Large volumes of engine load information and engineering data are stored in database format and managed by a database management system. Numerical procedures for probabilistic load simulation and database management functions are controlled by rule modules. Rules were hard-wired as decision trees into rule modules to perform process control tasks. There are modules to retrieve load information and models. There are modules to select loads and models to carry out quick load calculations or make an input file for full duty-cycle time dependent load simulation. The composite load spectra load expert system implemented today is capable of performing intelligent rocket engine load spectra simulation. Further development of the expert system will provide tutorial capability for users to learn from it.

Newell, J. F.↗

Adaptive Water-Resistive Barrier for Building Envelopes

Excessive moisture transport into building enclosures can lead to elevated moisture levels in wall cavities and associated damage. Such conditions can also produce increased energy consumption. Currently, architects and builders are limited to using static membranes as water-resistive barriers that exhibit a single vapor permeance irrespective of environmental conditions. Membranes with a high permeance may allow moisture ingression under hot and humid ambient conditions, while membranes with a low permeance may not allow wall cavities to dry out when moisture accumulates within them.An electrostatically actuated, dual permeance membrane previously demonstrated for protective apparel is under development for use as a water-resistive barrier for building envelopes. When outdoor temperature and relative humidity are high as detected by sensors, the membrane exhibits low permeance (~0.5 perms) to inhibit water vapor ingression into the building enclosure; but when humidity in the wall cavity is high, the membrane exhibits high permeance (~50 perms) to facilitate water vapor egression to the outside. The membrane changes state by electrostatic actuation using a very low current electrical power supply.In order to quantify the benefits of a dual permeance water-resistive barrier, WUFI® hygrothermal modeling simulations were completed comparing the adaptive membrane to conventional fixed permeance membranes relative to inhibiting mold growth for various US climates and several wall constructions. The WUFI® code was modified to accommodate switching the permeance of the adaptive membrane between low and high permeance states for several humidity setpoint control strategies. The effect of liquid water leakage into the wall cavity was also considered.This report summarizes the initial steps in development of dual permeance, electrostatically actuated water-resistive barriers focusing on the results of hygrothermal model simulations of these adaptive structures and testing of subscale adaptive structures to demonstrate the capability of the technology to achieve the preferred permeance levels suggested by the modeling.

Trentacosta, Joseph↗

Activated relaxation in supercooled monodisperse atomic and polymeric WCA fluids: Simulation and ECNLE theory

Here, we combine simulation and Elastically Collective Nonlinear Langevin Equation (ECNLE) theory to study the activated relaxation in monodisperse atomic and polymeric Weeks–Chandler–Andersen (WCA) liquids over a wide range of temperatures and densities in the supercooled regime under isochoric conditions. By employing novel crystal-avoiding simulations, metastable equilibrium dynamics is probed in the absence of complications associated with size polydispersity. Based on a highly accurate structural input from integral equation theory, ECNLE theory is found to describe well the simulated density and temperature dependences of the alpha relaxation time of atomic fluids using a single system-specific parameter, a c , that reflects the nonuniversal relative importance of local cage and collective elastic barriers. For polymer fluids, the explicit dynamical effect of local chain connectivity is modeled at the fundamental dynamic free energy trajectory level based on a different parameter, N c , that quantifies the degree of intramolecular correlation of bonded segment activated barrier hopping. For the flexible chain model studied, a physically intuitive value of N c ≈ 2 results in good agreement between simulation and theory. A direct comparison between atomic and polymeric systems reveals that chain connectivity can speed up activated segmental relaxation due to weakening of equilibrium packing correlations but can slow down relaxation due to local bonding constraints. The empirical thermodynamic scaling idea for the alpha time is found to work well at high densities or temperatures but fails when both density and temperature are low. The rich and subtle behaviors revealed from simulation for atomic and polymeric WCA fluids are all well captured by ECNLE theory.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Machine learning dielectric screening for the simulation of excited state properties of molecules and materials

Accurate and efficient calculations of absorption spectra of molecules and materials are essential for the understanding and rational design of broad classes of systems. Solving the Bethe–Salpeter equation (BSE) for electron–hole pairs usually yields accurate predictions of absorption spectra, but it is computationally expensive, especially if thermal averages of spectra computed for multiple configurations are required. We present a method based on machine learning to evaluate a key quantity entering the definition of absorption spectra: the dielectric screening. We show that our approach yields a model for the screening that is transferable between multiple configurations sampled during first principles molecular dynamics simulations; hence it leads to a substantial improvement in the efficiency of calculations of finite temperature spectra. We obtained computational gains of one to two orders of magnitude for systems with 50 to 500 atoms, including liquids, solids, nanostructures, and solid/liquid interfaces. Importantly, the models of dielectric screening derived here may be used not only in the solution of the BSE but also in developing functionals for time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations of homogeneous and heterogeneous systems. Overall, our work provides a strategy to combine machine learning with electronic structure calculations to accelerate first principles simulations of excited-state properties.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Investigation on Microsegregation of IN718 Alloy During Additive Manufacturing via Integrated Phase-Field and Finite-Element Modeling

In this work, we apply a multi-scale model combining finite-element method (FEM) and phase-field model (PFM) to simulate the evolution of solidification microstructures at different locations within a molten pool of an additively manufactured IN718 alloy. Specifically, the FEM is used to calculate the shape of molten pool and the relative thermal gradient G at the macroscale. Then, the calculated thermal information is input into PFM for microstructure simulation. Finally, the morphology of solidification structures and formation of Laves phase at different sites are studied and compared. We found that the solidification site with a large angle between the temperature gradient and the preferred crystalline orientation could build up a high niobium (Nb) concentration in the liquid during solidification but has less possibility of forming continuous long chain morphology of Laves phase particles. This finding provides an understanding of the microstructure evolution inside the molten pool of IN718 alloy during solidification. Further, the finding indicates that the site with a large misorientation angle will have a good hot cracking resistance after solidification.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Composite load spectra for select space propulsion structural components

The objective of this program is to develop generic load models with multiple levels of progressive sophistication to simulate the composite load spectra that are induced in space propulsion system components, representative of Space Shuttle Main Engines (SSME), such as transfer ducts, turbine blades, and liquid oxygen (LOX) posts and system ducting. These models will be developed using two independent approaches. The first approach consists of using state-of-the-art probabilistic methods to describe the individual loading conditions and combinations of these loading conditions to synthesize the composite load spectra simulation. The methodology required to combine the various individual load simulation models (hot-gas dynamic, vibrations, instantaneous position, centrifugal field, etc.) into composite load spectra simulation models will be developed under this program. A computer code incorporating the various individual and composite load spectra models will be developed to construct the specific load model desired. The second approach, which is covered under the options portion of the contract, will consist of developing coupled models for composite load spectra simulation which combine the (deterministic) models for composite load dynamic, acoustic, high-pressure and high rotational speed, etc., load simulation using statistically varying coefficients. These coefficients will then be determined using advanced probabilistic simulation methods with and without strategically selected experimental data. This report covers the efforts of the third year of the contract. The overall program status is that the turbine blade loads have been completed and implemented. The transfer duct loads are defined and are being implemented. The thermal loads for all components are defined and coding is being developed. A dynamic pressure load model is under development. The parallel work on the probabilistic methodology is essentially completed. The overall effort is being integrated in an expert system code specifically developed for this project.

Newell, J. F.↗

A first-principles machine-learning force field for heterogeneous ice nucleation on microcline feldspar

The formation of ice in the atmosphere affects precipitation and cloud properties, and plays a key role in the climate of our planet. Although ice can form directly from liquid water at deeply supercooled conditions, the presence of foreign particles can aid ice formation at much warmer temperatures. Over the past decade, experiments have highlighted the remarkable efficiency of feldspar minerals as ice nuclei compared to other particles present in the atmosphere. However, the exact mechanism of ice formation on feldspar surfaces has yet to be fully understood. Here, we develop a first-principles machine-learning model for the potential energy surface aimed at studying ice nucleation at microcline feldspar surfaces. The model is able to reproduce with high-fidelity the energies and forces derived from density-functional theory (DFT) based on the SCAN exchange and correlation functional. Our training set includes configurations of bulk supercooled water, hexagonal and cubic ice, microcline, and fully-hydroxylated feldspar surfaces exposed to vacuum, liquid water, and ice. In this work, we apply the machine-learning force field to study different fully-hydroxylated terminations of the (100), (010), and (001) surfaces of microcline exposed to vacuum. Our calculations suggest that terminations that do not minimize the number of broken bonds are preferred in vacuum. We also study the structure of supercooled liquid water in contact with microcline surfaces, and find that water density correlations extend up to around 10 Å from the surfaces. Finally, we show that the force field maintains a high accuracy during the simulation of ice formation at microcline surfaces, even for large systems of around 30,000 atoms. Future work will be directed towards the calculation of nucleation free energy barriers and rates using the force field developed herein, and understanding the role of different microcline surfaces on ice nucleation.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Shear thinning rheology in a concentrated suspension of fibers: the role of attractive interactions

Fiber-reinforced composites are ubiquitously encountered in the engineering, automobile, and aerospace industries. Fabrication of these composites requires the mixing of fibers dispersed in a liquid, and the final structure is affected by fiber properties, interactions, and flow fields. A good understanding of the rheology of fiber suspensions can aid in the design and optimization of the fabrication processes. To this end, we simulate the simple shear flow of fiber suspensions by accounting for short range lubrication, van der Waals attractive, electrostatic repulsion interactions, as well as friction between fibers. Direct numerical simulations are performed using the Immersed Boundary Method where the fibers are modeled as flexible slender bodies governed by the Euler-Bernoulli beam theory and the fluid flow is resolved using the Navier-Stokes equations. The simulation results for the suspension viscosity and yield stress are consistent with the experimental data from the literature for polyamide fiber suspensions. The shear-thinning behavior becomes stronger as we increase the magnitude of attractive interactions. Furthermore, we perform a parametric study varying fiber flexibility, volume fraction, aspect ratio, inertia and examine suspension viscosity and yield stress.

Khan, Monsurul↗

Challenging Common Assumptions of Thick-Wall Chamber Dynamics in Inertial Fusion Systems using MOOSE

As an increasing number of companies look toward commercial Inertial Fusion Energy (IFE) designs, there is a pressing need to understand the physics of thick-wall chamber gas dynamics. The thick liquid wall approach implements a renewable wall to mitigate the fusion target emissions, thereby reducing the radiation damage rate and significantly extending the lifetime of chamber structures, leading to increased plant availability and reduced waste streams in comparison to dry wall chamber designs. It is necessary, however, to assess the critical performance and safety aspects of these systems. For example, it is crucial to predict (1) where the mass ablated from the liquid walls will vent, which determines the placement of condensing surfaces; (2) debris propagation up the beam lines, which provides essential information for design and protection requirements; (3) peak pressures and impulse on chamber walls, which affect chamber structural design; and (4) momentum transfer to the liquid jets, which constrains the shape and positioning of the jets. In turn, the chamber design and its liquid walls affect shielding requirements, material activation, and tritium fuel cycle. Currently available simulation tools, however, are unable to accurately capture key thick-wall chamber dynamics. Significant assumptions are often made to simplify the system and reduce computational cost and modeling capability needs, but the impact of these assumptions on simulation predictions has not been evaluated. For example, no three-dimensional simulations can be found in the open literature to evaluate gas venting and momentum transfer to the jets with simulations using two-dimensional domains to represent complex three-dimensional geometries. Moreover, limited studies have been dedicated to jet breakup due to both turbulence and neutron heating, and no studies have been found that evaluate how jet breakup can impact shock-jet interaction. Furthermore, effects of radiative heat transfer have rarely been included for the hydrodynamic phase of shock propagation, and integration of proper equations of state in shock dynamics codes has been mostly exploratory. In this study, we use the flexible, high-fidelity Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) to model these complex phenomena and inform design and safety studies. Capabilities to model thick-wall chamber gas dynamics are being developed, and the impact of the assumptions listed above (i.e., two-dimensional vs three-dimensional, absence of jet breakout, no radiative heat transfer, and ideal gas behavior) are being quantified.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

CFD Simulation of Liquid Rocket Engine Injectors

Detailed design issues associated with liquid rocket engine injectors and combustion chamber operation require CFD methodology which simulates highly three-dimensional, turbulent, vaporizing, and combusting flows. The primary utility of such simulations involves predicting multi-dimensional effects caused by specific injector configurations. SECA, Inc. and Engineering Sciences, Inc. have been developing appropriate computational methodology for NASA/MSFC for the past decade. CFD tools and computers have improved dramatically during this time period; however, the physical submodels used in these analyses must still remain relatively simple in order to produce useful results. Simulations of clustered coaxial and impinger injector elements for hydrogen and hydrocarbon fuels, which account for real fluid properties, is the immediate goal of this research. The spray combustion codes are based on the FDNS CFD code' and are structured to represent homogeneous and heterogeneous spray combustion. The homogeneous spray model treats the flow as a continuum of multi-phase, multicomponent fluids which move without thermal or velocity lags between the phases. Two heterogeneous models were developed: (1) a volume-of-fluid (VOF) model which represents the liquid core of coaxial or impinger jets and their atomization and vaporization, and (2) a Blob model which represents the injected streams as a cloud of droplets the size of the injector orifice which subsequently exhibit particle interaction, vaporization, and combustion. All of these spray models are computationally intensive, but this is unavoidable to accurately account for the complex physics and combustion which is to be predicted, Work is currently in progress to parallelize these codes to improve their computational efficiency. These spray combustion codes were used to simulate the three test cases which are the subject of the 2nd International Workshop on-Rocket Combustion Modeling. Such test cases are considered by these investigators to be very valuable for code validation because combustion kinetics, turbulence models and atomization models based on low pressure experiments of hydrogen air combustion do not adequately verify analytical or CFD submodels which are necessary to simulate rocket engine combustion. We wish to emphasize that the simulations which we prepared for this meeting are meant to test the accuracy of the approximations used in our general purpose spray combustion models, rather than represent a definitive analysis of each of the experiments which were conducted. Our goal is to accurately predict local temperatures and mixture ratios in rocket engines; hence predicting individual experiments is used only for code validation. To replace the conventional JANNAF standard axisymmetric finite-rate (TDK) computer code 2 for performance prediction with CFD cases, such codes must posses two features. Firstly, they must be as easy to use and of comparable run times for conventional performance predictions. Secondly, they must provide more detailed predictions of the flowfields near the injector face. Specifically, they must accurately predict the convective mixing of injected liquid propellants in terms of the injector element configurations.

Farmer, Richard↗

Vortex Flow and Cavitation in Liquid Injection: A Comparison between High-Fidelity CFD Simulations and Experimental Visualizations on Transparent Nozzle Replicas

Experimental instantaneous shadowgraph visualizations on transparent glass nozzle replicas of high-pressure fuel injectors have been used to validate a novel in-house high-fidelity LES-VOF multiphase solver, to study the evolution of vortex flow and fuel cavitation. Both experiments and simulations capture the formation of an unsteady vapor structure inside the nozzle volume, which is referred to as 'string-cavitation'; strings are found at the core of the recirculation zones. Furthermore, high-fidelity simulations provide a very detailed insight into the vortex generation in the injector nozzle; strings appear within the time scales that are relevant for fast injection events (on the order of 0.1 milliseconds) and, for the problem under consideration, their generation seems mostly related to the flow pattern in the sac. It is also shown that vortexes interact, merge till they disrupt and favor the temporary inception of shear cavitation.

3-phase LES-VOF solver↗

Composite load spectra for select space propulsion structural components

The objective of this program is to develop generic load models with multiple levels of progressive sophistication to simulate the composite (combined) load spectra that are induced in space propulsion system components, representative of Space Shuttle Main Engines (SSME), such as transfer ducts, turbine blades, and liquid oxygen posts and system ducting. The first approach will consist of using state of the art probabilistic methods to describe the individual loading conditions and combinations of these loading conditions to synthesize the composite load spectra simulation. The second approach will consist of developing coupled models for composite load spectra simulation which combine the deterministic models for composite load dynamic, acoustic, high pressure, and high rotational speed, etc., load simulation using statistically varying coefficients. These coefficients will then be determined using advanced probabilistic simulation methods with and without strategically selected experimental data.

Newell, J. F.↗

Reversible Physical Gelation of Thermotropic Liquid Crystals Driven by Nanoplate Self-Assembly

Physically gelled soft materials, driven by the self-assembly of low-molecular-mass gelators (LMGs), have emerged as a platform for designing advanced gels that exhibit reversible gelation and property tunability. Liquid crystal (LC) gels are of great interest due to their supramolecular orderings as gel hosts and their enhanced electro-optical properties. In this study, we demonstrate the physical gelation of a nematic LC driven by nanoplate self-assembly, expanding the concept of gelators from small molecules to nanoparticles. These nanoplates are functionalized with promesogenic ligands and form a fibrillar network in LCs with face-to-face interplate stacking, resembling LMGs. The critical gelation volume fraction in the tilt test is only 0.14 v %, comparable to values reported for LMGs. Rheological analyses confirm viscoelastic properties characteristic of gelation. In situ small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) characterizes the formation of nanoplate networks in the LC with decreasing temperature, wherein LC mesogens become trapped in pores. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations reveal that the interaction between ligand-coated nanoplates and LC-forming mesogens induces a multidomain LC structure, increasing friction between LC domains and stabilizing the gel. This study establishes direct relationships among molecular interactions, nanostructures, and mechanical properties in physically gelled LCs. In conclusion, the findings inspire the future gelator design of both LMGs and nanoplates, with potential applicability in bioscaffold engineering and liquid crystalline nanocomposites.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Preferential Paths of Air-water Two-phase Flow in Porous Structures with Special Consideration of Channel Thickness Effects

Accurate understanding and predicting the flow paths of immiscible two-phase flow in rocky porous structures are of critical importance for the evaluation of oil or gas recovery and prediction of rock slides caused by gas-liquid flow. A 2D phase field model was established for compressible air-water two-phase flow in heterogenous porous structures. The dynamic characteristics of air-water two-phase interface and preferential paths in porous structures were simulated. The factors affecting the path selection of two-phase flow in porous structures were analyzed. Transparent physical models of complex porous structures were prepared using 3D printing technology. Tracer dye was used to visually observe the flow characteristics and path selection in air-water two-phase displacement experiments. The experimental observations agree with the numerical results used to validate the accuracy of phase field model. The effects of channel thickness on the air-water two-phase flow behavior and paths in porous structures were also analyzed. The results indicate that thick channels can induce secondary air flow paths due to the increase in flow resistance; consequently, the flow distribution is different from that in narrow channels. This study provides a new reference for quantitatively analyzing multi-phase flow and predicting the preferential paths of immiscible fluids in porous structures.

42 ENGINEERING↗

High Radiation Environment Nuclear Fragment Separator Magnet (Final Report)

Dipole magnets with a field of 2 T are needed for the 30° bend in the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB) fragment separator. This magnet will be subjected to extremely high radiation and heat loads from the high radiation. Superconducting coils for this magnet would allow low power operation but traditional NbTi and Nb3Sn superconductors are sensitive to quenches from beam loss and must operate near 4.5 K where the removal of thermal heat generated by beam loss is inefficient due to basic Carnot principles. High Temperature Superconductor (HTS) offers a unique solution for the magnets in the high radiation environment expected at FRIB. These conductors can operate at 40 K where heat removal is an order of magnitude more efficient than at 4.5 K. The curved separator dipoles subtend a large angular bend which introduces some complications in the winding of the coils. One approach would be to wind the coils with a curved section on the inner and outer radial segments (banana shaped). The inner radial segment would be wound with a negative curvature that would tend to unwind. An alternate approach would be to use a straight segment on the inner segment to avoid the negative curvature (D-shaped). In Phase I coils with a limited number of turns were successfully wound for both configurations described. These coils were tested at 77 K in liquid nitrogen. The Phase II program concentrated on the design, structural analysis, prototyping and test of the HTS curved dipole coils required for the high radiation environment of the FRIB fragment separator region. A thermal analysis was performed to simulate that the heat load can be removed. A test coil containing 500 m of HTS conductor was constructed to be tested at the 40 K operating temperature. The anticipated heat load was simulated with heater strips to demonstrate that the heat can be removed and that the coil can operate in a stable state.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Radar Reflectivity in Wingtip-Generated Wake Vortices

This report documents new predictive models of radar reflectivity, with meter-scale resolution, for aircraft wakes in clear air and fog. The models result from a radar design program to locate and quantify wake vortices from commercial aircraft in support of the NASA Aircraft Vortex Spacing System (AVOSS). The radar reflectivity model for clear air assumes: 1) turbulent eddies in the wake produce small discontinuities in radar refractive index; and 2) these turbulent eddies are in the 'inertial subrange' of turbulence. From these assumptions, the maximum radar frequency for detecting a particular aircraft wake, as well as the refractive index structure constant and radar volume reflectivity in the wake can be obtained from the NASA Terminal Area Simulation System (TASS) output. For fog conditions, an empirical relationship is used to calculate radar reflectivity factor from TASS output of bulk liquid water. Currently, two models exist: 1) Atlas-based on observations of liquid water and radar reflectivity factor in clouds; and 2) de Wolf- specifically tailored to a specific measured dataset (1992 Vandenberg Air Force Base).

Marshall, Robert E.↗

The flame structure and vorticity generated by a chemically reacting transverse jet

An analytical model describing the behavior of a turbulent fuel jet injected normally into a cross flow is developed. The model places particular emphasis on the contrarotating vortex pair associated with the jet, and predicts the flame length and shape based on entrainment of the oxidizer by the fuel jet. Effects of buoyancy and density variations in the flame are neglected in order to isolate the effects of large-scale mixing. The results are compared with a simulation of the transverse reacting jet in a liquid (acid-base) system. For a wide range of ratios of the cross flow to jet velocity, the model predicts flame length quite well. In particular, the observed transitional behavior in the flame length between cross-flow velocity to jet velocity of orifice ratios of 0.0 to 0.1, yielding an approximate minimum at the ratio 0.05, is reproduced very clearly by the present model. The transformation in flow structure that accounts for this minimum arises from the differing components of vorticity dominant in the near-field and far-field regions of the jet.

Karagozian, A. R.↗