On the origin of the moon, with emphasis on bulk composition
A new analysis of altimetric, gravimetric, and seismological results, together with petrological and thermal history constraints, obtains an estimated Al2O3 content of 5.0%, 2.1 times chondritic. Hence the moon definitely has a refractory lithophile excess as well as an iron deficiency. In addition, the lunar surface is characterized by refractory siderophile depletions. The combination of these properties appears to require a previous stage of differentiation in a planetary body or bodies. Siderophile and chalcolphile depletions and dispersions in eucrites suggest that these bodies are not necessarily large. Possible mechanisms of lunar formation include impacting of a very large body into the earth; tidal disruption of sizeable differentiated planetesimals by the earth; and selective capture of differentiated planetesimal material by small moonlets. Each mechanism has its difficulties; the major unknown affecting all of them is the size distribution of planetesimals.