Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Shear strength”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 397 records · Page 22
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

AGC-4 Specimen Post-Irradiation Examination Data Interim Report

This interim report documents preliminary results of the post-irradiation examination material property testing from the fourth advanced graphite creep (AGC), AGC 4, capsule specimens. This is the fourth of a series of six irradiation test trains planned as part of the AGC experiment to fully characterize the neutron irradiation effects and radiation creep behavior of current nuclear graphite grades to moderate dose levels (=7 dpa). The AGC 4 capsule was irradiated in the Idaho National Laboratory Advanced Test Reactor at a nominal temperature of 800°C and to a peak dose of 8 dpa. Half of the AGC-4 specimens were subjected to compressive stresses to induce irradiation creep. Post-irradiation testing and measurement results are reported with the exception of thermal testing, which is still in progress, and irradiation mechanical strength testing. Additionally, some specimens initially deemed too hot to be examined in the ART Graphite laboratory may still be measured. The data reported includes specimen dimensions for both stressed and unstressed specimens to establish the irradiation creep rates, mass and dimensional data necessary to derive density, elastic constants (Young?s modulus, shear modulus, and Poisson?s ratio) from ultrasonic time of flight velocity measurements, Young?s modulus from the fundamental frequency of vibration, and electrical resistivity. A more complete evaluation of trends in the material property changes, as well as irradiation-induced creep due to the irradiation environment and applied load on the specimens, will be discussed later in AGC 4 post-irradiation examination analysis reports.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Fabrication of thin-walled tubes from alloy 602 CA using shear assisted processing and extrusion

Thin-walled tube is usually produced seamlessly via an expensive multi-step process or via welding of thin sheets but at reduced performance. To overcome the current process and performance inefficiencies, advanced manufacturing methods need to be investigated. In this investigation, shear assisted processing and extrusion (ShAPE) was used to fabricate thin-walled Inconel 602 tube in a single-step. Tubes measuring 0.83 m length with a 12 mm outer diameter and 1 mm wall thickness were fabricated with an average surface roughness, Ra of 1.6 µm and Rz of 15 µm. Tensile testing of tubes in the as-fabricated condition showed strength increases of 4-35% over current offerings while maintaining or improving elongation. Electron microscopy analysis revealed the recrystallized microstructure with refined inter- and intra-granular carbides. Preliminary results obtained in this investigation shows the feasibility of producing thin-wall high temperature tube in single-step via ShAPE. This achievement marks a significant step towards manufacturing larger diameter nickel alloy tubes for the U.S. Department of Energy’s Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Molecular-Dynamics Analysis of the Mechanical Behavior of Plasma-Facing Tungsten

We report a systematic computational analysis of the mechanical behavior of plasma-facing component (PFC) tungsten focusing on the impact of void and helium (He) bubble defects on the mechanical response beyond the elastic regime. Specifically, we explore the effects of porosity and He atomic fraction on the mechanical properties and structural response of PFC tungsten, at varying temperature and bubble size. We find that the Young modulus of defective tungsten undergoes substantial softening that follows an exponential scaling relation as a function of matrix porosity and He atomic content. Beyond the elastic regime, our high strain rate simulations reveal that the presence of nanoscale spherical defects (empty voids and He bubbles) reduces the yield strength of tungsten in a monotonically decreasing fashion, obeying an exponential scaling relation as a function of tungsten matrix porosity and He concentration. Our detailed analysis of the structural response of PFC tungsten near the yield point reveals that yielding is initiated by emission of dislocation loops from bubble/matrix interfaces, mainly 1/2<111> shear loops, followed by gliding and growth of these loops and reactions to form <100> dislocations. Furthermore, dislocation gliding on the <111>{211} twin systems nucleates 1/6<111> twin regions in the tungsten matrix. These dynamical processes reduce the stress in the matrix substantially. Subsequent dislocation interactions and depletion of the twin phases via nucleation and propagation of detwinning partials lead the tungsten matrix to a next deformation stage characterized by stress increase during applied straining. Furthermore, our structural analysis reveals that the depletion of twin boundaries (areal defects) is strongly impacted by the density of He bubbles at higher porosities. After the initial stress relief upon yielding, increase in the dislocation density in conjunction with decrease in the areal defect density facilitates the initiation of dislocation-driven deformation mechanisms in the PFC crystal.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Manufacturing Dissolvable Alloy Components using ShAPE: A Study on Solid Phase Processing of Mg-W Composites and WJ11 Alloys

Dissolvable alloys and composites are an emerging class of materials that demonstrate tailored sorptivity in corrosive environments. This work explored the viability of solid phase processing (SPP) techniques, namely the shear assisted processing and extrusion (ShAPETM) method, to manufacture dissolvable magnesium composites and alloys components such as rods and tubes. The study also determined the effects of material composition and manufacturing process conditions on material microstructures developed during SPP and the resulting performance of the components. Explicit properties of interest included ultimate tensile strength, ultimate compressive strength, and yield strength. The application fields of interest for dissolvable alloys were identified as oil-and-gas operations and biomedical implants. Accordingly, PNNL collaborated with industrial and academia partners, Fortek Industries, Houston and University of Pittsburgh, during the course of this project for material and ShAPE process development. PNNL determined the viability of the using ShAPE to process the custom-designed materials provided by the project partners. This was done by identifying process parameters such as tool rotation rate, tool plunge rate, and process cooling optimal for manufacturing components with consolidated microstructures. Subsequently, PNNL also performed microstructural characterization on unprocessed and processed samples and mechanical property testing. One of the major findings from this work is that ShAPE was able to manufacture dissolvable magnesium composite and alloy rods and tubes with consolidated homogeneous microstructures and minimal macroscale defects on component surfaces. It was observed that samples processed via ShAPE demonstrated an average grain size < 2 - 5 µm, which was markedly lower than that of the precursors with 8 – 13 µm grains. Results showed that the ShAPE synthesized dissolvable magnesium composite and alloy strength was on par with or better than those components that were manufactured using traditional manufacturing processes such as forging and extrusion. It is noteworthy that the ShAPE samples were made with considerably lower number of process steps.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Testing and modeling of CLT-to-CLT joints made using hardwood dowels and screws with varying spacing

With the increasing popularity of mass timber, utilizing large-diameter wood screws and hardwood dowels can offer an easy and cost-efficient way to join structural elements. However, the existing research on hardwood dowels is limited to single fastener joints under monotonic loading. No research is available on the group effects of joints with multiple hardwood dowels. Here, this paper presents the results of 96 monotonic and cyclic single-shear plane CLT-to-CLT joint tests with hardwood dowels (Red Oak and Yellow Birch, 25.4 mm diameter) and self-tapping wood screws (8 mm diameter) in Grand-Fir CLT, where screws were inserted both perpendicular and at a 45-degree angle to the grain for comparison to hardwood dowels. The study evaluated the mechanical properties of the joints by changing fastener spacing. Mechanical properties such as yielding and peak strength, displacement, elastic and yielding stiffness, and ductility were evaluated. The results showed equal strength and stiffness properties for hardwood dowels comparable with large-diameter screws. Additionally, the hardwood dowel joints demonstrated moderate ductility properties. The strength and stiffness of the tested joints were compared with analytical equations found in the literature by considering the group action factor of the fasteners. Lastly, a nonlinear force-displacement model was presented and compared to the experimental results and analytical calculations, which gives the possibility to predict and optimize the mechanical behavior of hardwood dowel and screw joints with varying numbers and spacing between fasteners.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

A review of technologies for welding magnesium alloys to steels

Here we review various state-of-the-art methods for welding magnesium alloys and steels using different joint configurations. Microstructural characterizations indicate that four microstructures may form at the Mg/steel interface after welding: unwelded gap, metal oxides, solid solutions, or intermetallic compounds. Reaction products at the Mg/steel interface vary with different welding methods, alloying elements in base materials, interlayers or coatings applied, and preparations of base material before welding. Regarding mechanical property characterization, (a) lap tensile shear testing for lap-welded and spot-welded joints, (b) tensile testing for butt-welded joints and (c) fatigue properties of lap-welded and spot-welded joints are summarized and compared, separately. Reaction products at the Mg/steel interface are correlated with mechanical properties. Finally, ways to enhance Mg/steel joint strength, such as introducing interlocking features during friction stir lap and butt welding, are discussed.

Wang, Tianhao↗
DOE OSTI2020

Tuning the mechanical properties of nanoglass-metallic glass composites with brick and mortar designs

We use molecular dynamics simulations to characterize the tensile deformation and failure of metallic glass (MG)-nanoglass (NG) composites designed with a brick and mortar architecture consisting of a 3 nm-grain-size NG matrix and a MG second phase. Results show that the overall strength of the matrix is significantly improved by the second phase without sacrificing the large NG matrix ductility. The mechanical synergy of the two phases is optimized by arranging the MG bricks in a staggered way, which effectively delocalizes the plastic deformation, hindering the buildup of local stress hot spots and the generation of critical shear bands.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Enhancing NDE Reliability for Grade 91 Steel Welds: Ultrasonic Imaging and Microstructural Correlations

Ensuring the integrity of Grade 91 (9Cr-1Mo-V) steel welds is vital for the safe and reliable operation of fossil fuel–fired and nuclear power plants. Here, this study applies an imaging technique for the ultrasonic characterization of two Grade 91 steel welds created with cold metal transfer and flux-cored arc welding processes. Ultrasonic immersion testing in the through-transmission configuration was employed to generate shear waves, which helped identify the weld metal, heat-affected zone, and base metal regions. These weld microstructures were also correlated to their ultrasonic images using metallography, ultrasonic amplitude, hardness measurements, and grain size. The findings from this study can assist practitioners in developing new nondestructive evaluation technologies, improving the inspection reliability of creep strength–enhanced ferritic steel welds by potentially identifying weld microstructure regions susceptible to creep-type failures.

Grade 91 steel↗
DOE OSTI2024

Unlocking Larger Scales and Aspect Ratios in 3D Printed Glass: Coupling Active Mixing and UV Curing for Advanced Printability and Crack Resistance

Recent developments in additive manufacturing (AM) of glass via silica-filled inks have facilitated fabrication of previously unattainable geometries and compositions. However, the maximum processable size of 15 mm limits the use of these prints in applications such as optics. A key limitation lies in the trade-off between material printability and green strength: increasing silica content in the feedstock improves crack resistance and reduces shrinkage but results in dramatic changes in viscoelastic properties that hinder flowability. Here, this paper presents a novel approach that offers expanded versatility in processable size, feedstock formulation, and printing. Described here is a direct ink writing (DIW) system coupled with an active high-shear micromixer and UV light source, capable of simultaneously printing multiple inks with a wide range of rheological properties. Choice of silica sourc, solvent, UV-curable binder, and dispersant is used to tune the ink rheology and improve printability and mechanical properties. Imparting high shear with the micromixer while UV-curing the extrudate allows for increased ink viscosities and reduced nozzle diameters, enabling printing finer feature sizes. With these advances, thin-walled high-aspect ratio structures and a crack-free glass disk measuring 44 mm in diameter are demonstrated, an increase of 3× in the greatest dimension compared to current state-of-the-art.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

MOOSE Optimization Module Overview: Application to Residual Stress Inversion in Nuclear Fuel Plates

Manufacturing methods, material selections and unique plate geometries used in low enriched uranium plate fuels for the High Performance Research Reactor (HPRR) have led to concerns about the residual stresses effect on bond strength of the fuel/cladding interfaces and overall fuel performance under irradiation. The current HPRR plate fuel test program performed residual stress calculations using the contour method with experimental displacement data obtained by incrementally cutting the plate fuel. In this work, we use a gradient based inverse optimization module developed within the MOOSE framework to estimate normal and shear residual stresses within the plate fuels using displacement data taken from a cut placed in the HPRR fuel plate. These results are verified against residual stress calculations obtained from the contour method. The inversion protocol used in this work utilizes two meshes to separately discretize the physics and parameter space. This allows a fine mesh to be used to fully resolve the physics and geometry of the forward problem. A coarser mesh is used to resolve the parameter space with spatially varying mesh density determined from a sensitivity analysis. The adaptive resolution of the parameter space essentially has the effect of regularization as it is designed to achieve the bias-variance tradeoff.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2026

Multi-material additive manufacturing of aluminum 6061-T6 alloy with stainless steel 304: Suppression of intermetallic compounds and interface growth mechanism

Fabricating integrated aluminum-steel structures is difficult because of metallurgical incompatibilities that promote intermetallic compound (IMC) formation at their interfaces. This work introduces a practical route for additively manufacturing 6061-T6 aluminum alloy (AA6061-T6) directly onto 304 stainless steel (SS304) using a high shear strain rate-assisted interfacial bonding mechanism. Through the friction extrusion deposition-based additive manufacturing method, both single- and multi-layer deposits of AA6061-T6 were successfully fabricated on SS304, yielding a robust hybrid multi-material structure. Comprehensive analyses of deposition quality, interface porosity, and bonding performance showed that the interface achieved a tensile strength exceeding 154 MPa under quasi-static loading. Microstructural observations revealed that the deposited aluminum layers experienced severe plastic deformation, resulting in pronounced grain refinement. Importantly, the interfacial zone was found to be free of brittle IMCs, instead containing a thin amorphous layer that evolved through a non-linear reaction-zone growth law. This solid-state additive strategy establishes a promising pathway for lightweight structural systems, nuclear energy component cladding, and multifunctional engineering components, redefining how dissimilar metals can be integrated for advanced applications.

Aluminum alloy↗
DOE OSTI2023

Bond clusters control rupture force limit in shear loaded histidine-Ni 2+ metal-coordinated proteins

Dynamic noncovalent interactions are pivotal to the structure and function of biological proteins and have been used in bioinspired materials for similar roles. Metal-coordination bonds, in particular, are especially tunable and enable control over static and dynamic properties when incorporated into synthetic materials. Despite growing efforts to engineer metal-coordination bonds to produce strong, tough, and self-healing materials, the systematic characterization of the exact contribution of these bonds towards mechanical strength and the effect of geometric arrangements is missing, limiting the full design potential of these bonds. In this work, we engineer the cooperative rupture of metal-coordination bonds to increase the rupture strength of metal-coordinated peptide dimers. Utilizing all-atom steered molecular dynamics simulations on idealized bidentate histidine-Ni 2+ coordinated peptides, we show that histidine-Ni 2+ bonds can rupture cooperatively in groups of two to three bonds. We find that there is a strength limit, where adding additional coordination bonds does not contribute to the additional increase in the protein rupture strength, likely due to the highly heterogeneous rupture behavior exhibited by the coordination bonds. Further, we show that this coordination bond limit is also found natural metal-coordinated biological proteins. Using these insights, we quantitatively suggest how other proteins can be rationally designed with dynamic noncovalent interactions to exhibit cooperative bond breaking behavior. Altogether, this work provides a quantitative analysis of the cooperativity and intrinsic strength limit for metal-coordination bonds with the aim of advancing clear guiding molecular principles for the mechanical design of metal-coordinated materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Investigating Marine Environmental Degradation of Additive Manufacturing Materials for Renewable Energy Applications: Preprint

Marine renewable energy is a relatively young industry where there is a great need for rapid prototyping in design-build-test campaigns to quickly mature groundbreaking technologies. Additive manufacturing has an important role to play in the industry; however, little information is available to marine energy developers to help inform them on which additive manufacturing materials are appropriate for harsh marine environments. This paper presents an initial study on the mechanical characterization of polymeric additive manufacturing materials and the degradation effects of marine environments. Ultem 9085, acrylonitrile styrene acrylate, and chopped carbon-filled nylon, as well as continuous carbon and glass fiber-reinforced nylon were chosen for this study. Samples were manufactured to perform a variety of tension, shear, and compression mechanical characterization tests on the materials. Half of the samples were conditioned in Pacific Ocean water for approximately 6 months at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory's Marine Sciences Laboratory before being returned for mechanical characterization. The mechanical testing results showed that the Ultem 9085 and acrylonitrile styrene acrylate materials experienced little to no degradation in stiffness or strength after exposure to the marine environment. On the other hand, the nylon-based materials suffered significant stiffness and strength degradation (over 50% in some cases) after environmental conditioning. Ultimately, these data sets should serve as starting points to allow marine renewable energy developers to make informed additive manufacturing material choices for their prototype deployments.

additive manufacturing↗
DOE OSTI2020

Hybrid fiber metal composite laminate interlaminar reinforcement through metal interlocks

Aircraft and automobile industries are continually seeking high-performance and lightweight solutions. Fiber-reinforced composites in conjunction with metals are being considered in the form of hybrid materials. There is a continuous need for improvement of interfacial bonding between composite layers and metal constituents. In this study, an innovative hybrid fiber interlocking metal hooks laminate (FIMHL) system was developed in which fiber-reinforced thermoset composite, and metal sheets are mechanically bonded together using out of plane hooks stamped in the metal. Process optimization was performed to gain the full benefit of the through-thickness reinforcement. Microstructural analysis showed improved interaction between the metal hooks and the fiber layers which reduced porosity and resin richness. This was reflected in mechanical properties, as tensile and flexural strength of FIMHL was enhanced by 38.5 and 18.8%, respectively, after process optimization. Furthermore, normalized weight fraction (76.4%) properties of FIMHL also confirmed that the increase in mechanical properties of optimized panel were not only due to increased reinforcement (glass fiber + aluminum) volume fraction but also because of improved metal hooks and fibers interaction. There was no significant effect on lap shear and fracture toughness, as they depend on bend back behavior of the hooks. A bilinear traction-separation model was used to characterize mode-I interlaminar fracture toughness properties, and 4.5% variation was recorded when modeling and experimental values were compared.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Microstructures and deformation mechanisms of the medium-entropy alloy (NiCoCr) 76 (Ni 6 AlTi) 3

Here the microstructures and deformation mechanisms of the f.c.c. medium-entropy alloy (MEA) (NiCoCr) 76 (Ni 6 AlTi) 3 has been analyzed after various thermo-mechanical treatments. The solutionized, single-phase MEA, which had a grain size of 93.4 ± 31.9 μm, was cold-rolled (CR) to a 80% thickness reduction after which it showed both a high yield strength (YS) of 1539 MPa and a high ultimate tensile strength (UTS) of 1602 MPa, but an elongation to failure, ε, of only 16%. The CR MEA was then subjected to one of two heat treatments: (1) the CR MEA was recrystallized at 1100°C for 24 h, which produced a single-phase material with 85 ± 61.7 μm grain size that exhibited a much lower YS and UTS of 364 MPa and 747 MPa, respectively, but a much greater ε of 73%; and (2) the MEA was aged at 700°C for 24 h, which produced a fine-grained (1.1 ± 0.9 μm) material and a high volume fraction (0.35) of 12 nm dia. L1 2 nanoparticles that exhibited an excellent combination of strength and ductility, viz., YS~1501 MPa, UTS~1651 MPa, elongation ~26%. The grain boundary strengthening and precipitation strengthening were together estimated to account for ~58% of the YS in the latter material. After deformation, the recrystallized MEA contained numerous stacking faults and a Taylor lattice structure containing domain boundaries and microbands, while the aged MEA exhibited numerous stacking faults and sheared particles. The density of low-angle grain boundaries (LAGBs) in the recrystallized MEA increased by 100 times to 2.2 × 10 –1 μm/μm 2 while the density of CSL Σ3 n boundaries decreased by 71% to 7.8 × 10 –3 μm/μm 2 after deformation. In contrast, the density of LAGBs in the aged MEA increased by 5 times to 2.6 μm/μm 2 while the density of CSL Σ3 n boundaries decreased by 57% to 0.6 μm/μm 2 after deformation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Utilizing distributed acoustic sensing and ocean bottom fiber optic cables for submarine structural characterization

The sparsity of permanent seismic instrumentation in marine environments often limits the availability of subsea information on geohazards, including active fault systems, in both time and space. One sensing resource that provides observational access to the seafloor environment are existing networks of ocean bottom fiber optic cables; these cables, coupled to modern distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) systems, can provide dense arrays of broadband seismic observations capable of recording both seismic events and the ambient noise wavefield. Here, we report a marine DAS application which demonstrates the strength and limitation of this new technique on submarine structural characterization. Based on ambient noise DAS records on a 20 km section of a fiber optic cable offshore of Moss Landing, CA, in Monterey Bay, we extract Scholte waves from DAS ambient noise records using interferometry techniques and invert the resulting multimodal dispersion curves to recover a high resolution 2D shear-wave velocity image of the near seafloor sediments. We show for the first time that the migration of coherently scattered Scholte waves observed on DAS records can provide an approach for resolving sharp lateral contrasts in subsurface properties, particularly shallow faults and depositional features near the seafloor. Our results provide improved constraints on shallow submarine features in Monterey Bay, including fault zones and paleo-channel deposits, thus highlighting one of many possible geophysical uses of the marine cable network.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗
DOE OSTI2023

Investigating Marine Environmental Degradation Of Additive Manufacturing Materials For Renewable Energy Applications

Marine renewable energy is a relatively young industry where there is a great need for rapid prototyping in design-build-test campaigns to quickly mature ground-breaking technologies. Additive manufacturing has an important role to play in the industry; however, little information is available to marine energy developers to help inform them on which additive manufacturing materials are appropriate for harsh marine environments. This paper presents an initial study on the mechanical characterization of polymeric additive manufacturing materials and degradation effects due to the marine environment. Ultem 9085, acrylonitrile styrene acrylate (ASA), and chopped carbon-filled Nylon, as well as continuous carbon and glass fiber reinforced Nylon were chosen for this study. Samples were manufactured to perform a variety of tension, shear, and compression mechanical characterization tests on the materials. Half of the samples were conditioned in Pacific Ocean water for approximately 6 months at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory’s Marine and Coastal Research Laboratory before being returned for mechanical characterization. The mechanical testing results showed that the Ultem 9085 and ASA materials experienced little to no degradation in stiffness or strength after exposure to the marine environment. On the other hand, the Nylon-based materials suffered significant stiffness and strength degradation (over 50% in some cases) after environmental conditioning. Ultimately, these results should serve as starting points to allow marine renewable energy developers to make informed additive manufacturing material choices for their prototype deployments.

Murdy, Paul↗
DOE OSTI2021

Dark energy survey year 1 results: Constraining baryonic physics in the Universe

ABSTRACT Measurements of large-scale structure are interpreted using theoretical predictions for the matter distribution, including potential impacts of baryonic physics. We constrain the feedback strength of baryons jointly with cosmology using weak lensing and galaxy clustering observables (3 × 2pt) of Dark Energy Survey (DES) Year 1 data in combination with external information from baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) and Planck cosmic microwave background polarization. Our baryon modelling is informed by a set of hydrodynamical simulations that span a variety of baryon scenarios; we span this space via a Principal Component (PC) analysis of the summary statistics extracted from these simulations. We show that at the level of DES Y1 constraining power, one PC is sufficient to describe the variation of baryonic effects in the observables, and the first PC amplitude (Q1) generally reflects the strength of baryon feedback. With the upper limit of Q1 prior being bound by the Illustris feedback scenarios, we reach $\sim 20{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ improvement in the constraint of $S_8=\sigma _8(\Omega _{\rm m}/0.3)^{0.5}=0.788^{+0.018}_{-0.021}$ compared to the original DES 3 × 2pt analysis. This gain is driven by the inclusion of small-scale cosmic shear information down to 2.5 arcmin, which was excluded in previous DES analyses that did not model baryonic physics. We obtain $S_8=0.781^{+0.014}_{-0.015}$ for the combined DES Y1+Planck EE+BAO analysis with a non-informative Q1 prior. In terms of the baryon constraints, we measure $Q_1=1.14^{+2.20}_{-2.80}$ for DES Y1 only and $Q_1=1.42^{+1.63}_{-1.48}$ for DESY1+Planck EE+BAO, allowing us to exclude one of the most extreme AGN feedback hydrodynamical scenario at more than 2σ.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗