Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Energy Intensive Processes”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 415 records · Page 23

Tailoring Cementitious Materials Towards Value-Added Use of Large CO 2 Volumes

Hydraulic cements with alternative chemistries were developed for large-volume and value-added use of carbon dioxide. The hydraulic cements were processed using the energy-efficient mechanochemical technique at room temperature and atmospheric pressure. Carbon dioxide was captured directly from combustion emissions during processing. For this purpose, mechanochemical processing of hydraulic cements was accomplished under a flow of combustion emissions prior to the release of emissions to the atmosphere. The process removed a significant fraction of carbon dioxide from combustion emissions. The hydraulic cements captured carbon dioxide at about 10% of their weight. Two hydraulic cement chemistries were developed, and their mechanochemical processing was successfully scaled-up. The characteristic feature of one chemistry was its relatively low (near-neutral) pH where the integration of carbon dioxide yielded clear value. The second cement chemistry was based on alkali activation of industrial wastes. This chemistry could make value-added use of carbon dioxide, but it had to be refined to control the pH drop caused by CO 2 integration. These two cements render binding effects upon hydration by forming a combination of stable carbonates and aluminosilicates or phosphates. Efforts to develop cement chemistries based solely on carbonates were not successful. The mechanochemical process was found to integrate carbon dioxide into the alternative cement chemistries in the form of disordered and metastable carbonates. During hydration reactions, the disordered/metastable carbonates are either transformed into stable carbonate phases with desired binding efforts, or carbonates get integrated into the primary inorganic binders (hydrates). When compared with mechanochemical processing in pure carbon dioxide, mechanochemical processing in combustion emissions produced hydraulic cements with improved engineering properties. The mechanochemical process was scaled-up, and its variables as well as the raw materials formulations were optimized for implementation at pilot scale. Scale-up was found to enhance the carbon capture potential and the engineering qualities of the resulting hydraulic cements. This was because scale-up raises the intensity of mechanical energy input to raw materials. Certain mechanochemical phenomena cannot be induced, irrespective of the cumulative mechanical energy input, unless the intensity of impact is raised above a minimum level that cannot be achieved in laboratory-scale implementation of the process. Due to this effect, the duration of the mechanochemical process as well as its energy demand could be reduced significantly (by an order of magnitude) upon transition from laboratory to pilot scale, with the hydraulic cements produced at pilot scale offering engineering properties that were superior to those realized in laboratory-scale mechanochemical processing. The hydraulic cements produced at pilot scale via mechanochemical processing under a flow of combustion emissions were thoroughly characterized. They were found to meet standard requirements for ‘General Use’ hydraulic cements. They were compatible with the industrial-scale concrete production and construction practices that are used with the currently prevalent hydraulic cements. The new hydraulic cements with integrated carbon dioxide were found to offer distinct advantages over the currently prevalent Portland cement in terms of net carbon footprint and energy content. The combined raw materials and energy costs of the new hydraulic cements are competitive, and major cost savings can be realized because of the simplified production process that significantly lowers the capital investment in cement production plants. Mechanochemical processing of the new hydraulic cements under a flow of combustion emissions can be implemented using some existing components of cement manufacturing plants; this facilitates adoption of the technology by the cement industry.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Integrated Solar Thermochemical Reaction System (Final Report)

This report describes progress accomplished in a three-phase project that has advanced the concept for a Solar Thermochemical Advanced Reactor System (STARS) – a system that is designed to convert solar energy into storable/useful chemical energy – from Technology Readiness Level 3 to Technology Readiness Level 6. STARS accomplishes its objective by directing the heat from a dish concentrator onto a chemical reaction system, increasing the energy content of the feedstock, methane, a chemical fuel that is available from multiple sources including natural gas, landfills and anaerobic digesters. The system uses a parabolic dish solar concentrator, previously developed for electrical power generation, and a compact, process-intensive chemical reaction system based on micro- and meso-channel process technology (MMPT). The combined Dish-STARSTM system provides a solar augment to the incoming methane stream, increasing its chemical energy content by 20-30% while decreasing its carbon intensity. When the immediate chemical product, known as syngas, is directly used for power generation the result is electricity with approximately 20% less CO 2 emissions. Alternately, if the syngas is further reacted to produce valuable chemical products, such as hydrogen, the reduction in carbon emissions is retained and reduced carbon intensities can be attained for the chemical products. In a co-production mode, lowcarbon hydrogen or electricity plus various hydrocarbons (for example, methanol, olefins or plastics) can be produced. Over the course of this project, the efficiency of Dish-STARSTM was improved from a previous value of 63% to slightly over 70%, with results and analyses indicating a potential for values greater than 80%; manufacturing investigations identified fabrication methods for the MMPT components, proofed-out additive manufacturing for microchannel heat exchangers, developed equipment cost models and, together with on-sun testing, supported technoeconomic evaluations. If developed into commercial products, project results indicate the potential for the efficient use of concentrated solar energy in nearterm applications for electrical power generation and the production of chemicals, including hydrogen.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Future PM 2.5 emissions from metal production to meet renewable energy demand

A shift from fossil fuel to renewable energy is crucial in limiting global temperature increase to 2 °C above preindustrial levels. However, renewable energy technologies, solar photovoltaics, wind turbines, and electric vehicles are metal-intensive, and the mining and smelting processes to obtain the needed metals are emission-intensive. We estimate the future PM 2.5 emissions from mining and smelting to meet the metal demand of renewable energy technologies in two climate pathways to be 0.3–0.6 Tg yr -1 in the 2020–2050 period, which are projected to contribute 10%–30% of total anthropogenic primary PM 2.5 combustion emissions in many countries. The concentration of mineral reserves in a few regions means the impacts are also regionally concentrated. Rapid decarbonization could lead to a faster reduction of overall anthropogenic PM 2.5 emissions but also could create more unevenness in the distributions of emissions relative to where demand occurs. Options to reduce metal-related PM 2.5 emissions by over 90% exist and are well understood; introducing policy requiring their installation could avoid emission hotspots.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Rice husks as a sustainable source of nanostructured silicon for high performance Li-ion battery anodes

The recovery of useful materials from earth-abundant substances is of strategic importance for industrial processes. Despite the fact that Si is the second most abundant element in the Earth’s crust, processes to form Si nanomaterials is usually complex, costly and energy-intensive. Here we show that pure Si nanoparticles (SiNPs) can be derived directly from rice husks (RHs), an abundant agricultural byproduct produced at a rate of 1.2 3 108 tons/year, with a conversion yield as high as 5% by mass. And owing to their small size (10– 40 nm) and porous nature, these recovered SiNPs exhibits high performance as Li-ion battery anodes, with high reversible capacity (2,790 mA h g21 , seven times greater than graphite anodes) and long cycle life (86% capacity retention over 300 cycles). Using RHs as the raw material source, overall energy-efficient, green, and large scale synthesis of low-cost and functional Si nanomaterials is possible.

MATERIALS CHEMISTRY↗

Opportunities and challenges in process modeling and simulation of electrochemical systems

Electrochemical technologies have garnered intense interest in both academic research and industrial applications due to their potential to increase energy efficiency and reduce carbon footprint. However, electrochemical process fundamentals have been absent from the chemical process simulators available to millions of chemical engineers worldwide. To expedite process research and development of electrochemical technologies in the chemical industry, it is imperative that essential electrochemical process fundamentals be incorporated into process simulators to support modeling and simulation of electrochemical processes. Here, this study examines three process fundamentals key to the research and development of electrochemical processes: electrochemical reaction kinetics, electrolyte thermodynamics, and heat and mass transfer. It further illustrates application of these process fundamentals with a case study modeling an electrochemical process for the conversion of acrylonitrile to adiponitrile. The modeling example highlights the roles of applied voltage on reaction rates, and electron flow rates on the performance of electrochemical processes. It suggests that the applied voltage and electron flow rates are two unique concepts that should be included in simulators for electrochemical processes.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Technoeconomic Analysis of a Novel Microwave Process to Produce Ethylene from Methane

Ethylene is a critical feedstock in industrial processes, serving as a raw material in the petrochemical industry to produce plastics and commodity chemicals. Conventional ethylene production routes are energy-intensive and contribute substantially to the carbon footprint of chemical manufacturing. In this study, an industrial-scale novel microwave process was simulated using ASPEN Plus to assess its economic viability. Technoeconomic analysis confirmed the economic competitiveness of the novel microwave process, with a levelized cost of ethylene of USD 0.51/kg compared to USD 0.56/kg for the conventional base case. Key economic drivers of the process were identified, and sensitivity analyses were conducted to evaluate their impact on project economics. Furthermore, 87.7% of the total utility consumption in the novel microwave process is electricity, highlighting its potential to contribute to the electrification of the chemical industry. The findings of this study confirm the economic feasibility of both industrial-scale microwave reactors and modular plant configurations for the production of ethylene from methane, offering a promising alternative to conventional processes.

electromagnetic radiation↗

Temperature dependence of nanoscale dynamic processes measured in living millipedes by high resolution inelastic and elastic neutron scattering

We have used high energy-resolution neutron scattering to probe nanoscale dynamic processes in living millipedes (Narceus americanus). We have measured the temperature dependence of the intensity of scattered neutrons that do not exchange energy with the living samples on the 1.5 ns time scale, thereby excluding the signal from the highly mobile intra- and extra-cellular bulk-like aqueous constituents in the sample. This measured “elastic” scattering intensity reflects a non-monotonic temperature dependence, with a noticeable systematic decrease detected between 295 and 303 K on warming up from 283 to 310 K. This decrease demonstrates an excellent inverse correlation with the non-monotonic, as a function of temperature, increase in the slow diffusivity previously observed in planarian flatworms and housefly larvae. This correlation indicates the existence of a biological mechanism, possibly common between different classes (Insects and Myriapods) and even phyla (Arthropods and Platyhelminthes), that dampens the slow nanoscopic dynamics in ectothermic organisms in response to the temperature of the environment exceeding the physiologically optimal range.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Simulating Extreme Precipitation in the United States in the Energy Exascale Earth System Model: Investigating the Importance of Representing Convective Intensity versus Dynamic Structure (Final Report)

Weather events that produce extreme precipitation are associated with severe flooding and winds that result in thousands of deaths and billions of dollars in damages annually in the United States (U.S.). This project aims to improve understanding of the small- and large-scale processes that govern these events and improve our ability to project changes in these extreme events under the influences of natural variability and human activities. We focus on two promising directions in the development of the U.S. Department of Energy’s Energy Exascale Earth System Model (E3SM) to investigate the tradeoffs between resolving the convective-scale processes that control the intensity versus the intermediate-scale processes that control the dynamic structure of the most prominent extreme precipitation events that impact the U.S. throughout the year (i.e., mesoscale convective systems, tropical cyclones, and extratropical cyclone).

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Carbon Intensities of Refining Products in Petroleum Refineries with Co-Processed Biofeedstocks

Petroleum refineries increasingly seek to generate fuels with lower carbon intensities (CIs; a measure of life cycle greenhouse gas [GHG] emissions per unit of energy of fuel; well-to-wheel [WTW]) to meet growing demand. Co-processing refers to a process that adds biomass-derived feedstocks to the fossil-based feedstocks of existing petroleum refinery process units. With the use of biofeedstocks, it is expected that co-processed fuels would have lower CIs than their petroleum counterparts without requiring changes in the existing infrastructure for producing, transporting, and using fuels. To quantify the GHG emissions reduction benefits of co-processing, this study uses a linear programming model to simulate petroleum refinery conditions with and without co-processing. The co-processing cases include three biofeedstocks (soy oil, tallow, and used cooking oil or UCO) used as 10 vol.% of the feedstock to a hydrotreater or hydrocracker since these lipid-based feedstocks have favorable properties to be treated in a hydrotreater or hydrocracker. In addition, we considered pyrolysis oil used as 10 vol.% of the feedstock to a fluid catalytic cracking (FCC) unit in the modeled refinery due to its higher oxygen content compared to other lipid-based feedstocks. Life cycle analysis (LCA) using two distinct approaches—process-level energy allocation and a refinery-level marginal approach—has been conducted for each case. The LCA results using process-level allocation show that there are no noticeable changes in emissions or energy use impacts at the facility level. The life cycle GHG emission reductions of co-processing cases are mainly related to the fraction of biogenic carbon embedded in each fuel product. For example, co-processed jet fuels (a mixture of fossil and biogenic fuels) made via hydrotreating or hydrocracking have higher biogenic carbon, which results in jet fuel CI reductions of 3.9%–8.6% compared to the CI of baseline petroleum jet fuels on a WTW basis. However, analysis of co-processed pyrolysis oil in an FCC shows that a higher fraction of biofeedstocks (29%) becomes process emissions (i.e., CO and CO 2 ), mainly due to the oxygenates in pyrolysis oil, and so it generates less renewable fuel than biofeedstocks co-processed via hydrotreating or hydrocracking. Using the refinery-level marginal approach, the changes in energy use and emissions of co-processing cases compared to the petroleum-only baseline case are allocated to the changes in fuel production (assuming renewable fuels). This approach generates the life cycle GHG emission values of co-processed renewable fuels, which are comparable to the CIs of standalone biofuel production pathways. However, as this approach relies on a rough assumption that product yields and emissions from co-processing units on fossil feedstocks remain the same with and without biofeedstock inputs, co-processing cases like FCC pyrolysis oil may generate quite skewed results.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Energy Penetration into Arrays of Aligned Nanowires Irradiated with Relativistic Intensities: Scaling to Terabar Pressures

Ultra-high-energy-density (UHED) matter, characterized by energy densities > 1 x 10 8 J cm -3 and pressures greater than a gigabar, is encountered in the center of stars and in inertial confinement fusion capsules driven by the world’s largest lasers. Similar conditions can be obtained with compact, ultra-high contrast, femtosecond lasers focused to relativistic intensities onto targets composed of aligned nanowire arrays. Here we report the measurement of the key physical process in determining the energy density deposited in high aspect ratio nanowire array plasmas: the energy penetration. By monitoring the x-ray emission from buried Co tracer segments in Ni nanowire arrays irradiated at an intensity of 4 x 10 19 W cm -2 , we demonstrate energy penetration depths of several μm, leading to UHED plasmas of that size. Relativistic 3D particle-in-cell-simulations, validated by these measurements, predict that irradiation of nanostructures at intensities of > 1 x 10 22 W cm -2 will lead to a virtually unexplored extreme UHED plasma regime characterized by energy densities in excess of 8 x 10 10 J cm -3 , equivalent to a pressure of 0.35 Tbar.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Field reconstruction from proton radiography of intense laser driven magnetic reconnection

Magnetic reconnection is a process that contributes significantly to plasma dynamics and energy transfer in a wide range of plasma and magnetic field regimes, including inertial confinement fusion experiments, stellar coronae and compact, highly magnetized objects like neutron stars. Laboratory experiments in different regimes can help refine, expand and test the applicability of theoretical models to describe reconnection. Laser-plasma experiments exploring magnetic reconnection at moderate intensities (I L ~ 10 14 Wcm -2 ) have been performed previously, where the Biermann battery effect self-generates magnetic fields and the field dynamics studied using proton radiog- raphy. At high laser intensities (I L λ$2\atop{L}$ > 10 18 Wcm -2 μm 2 ), relativistic surface currents and the time-varying electric sheath fields generate the azimuthal magnetic fields. Numerical modeling of these intensities has shown the conditions within the magnetic field region can reach the threshold where the magnetic energy can exceed the rest mass energy such that σ cold = B 2 /(μ 0 n e m e c 2 ) > 1 [A. E. Raymond, et al., Phys. Rev. E, 98, 043207 (2018)]. Presented here is the analysis of the proton radiography of a high-intensity (~ 10 18 Wcm -2 ) laser driven magnetic reconnection geometry. Lastly, the path integrated magnetic fields are recovered using a “field-reconstruction algorithm” to quantify the field strengths, geometry and evolution.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Parallel Monte Carlo Methods for Heterogeneous Hardware Computer Systems Using GPUs and Coprocessors: Recent Development of ARCHER Code - Paper 54

Traditional methods of accelerating Monte Carlo (MC) calculations typically use CPUs as the computing unit. The parallelism is based upon multithreading on a multi-core processor, and message passing interface (MPI) across many processors and nodes. In recent years, the hardware accelerators have been introduced by the high performance computing industry as an alternative approach to achieve massive parallelism. Hardware accelerators have the advantage of high Floating-point Operations Per Second (FLOPS) and high energy efficiency. Examples include graphics processing units (GPUs) and coprocessors. Compute-intensive programs can be off-loaded to them to be concurrently executed by hundreds or thousands of active threads. Existing production MC codes, however, cannot be directly compiled or executed on the new platforms. It is therefore necessary to rewrite or redevelop the code using the hardware accelerator specific programming models and APIs. Several studies have been conducted on using GPUs to accelerate MC calculations in reactor analysis and medical physics. In this paper, we present the recent progress at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) in developing a new parallel MC code called ARCHER (Accelerated Radiation-transport Computations in Heterogeneous Environments) for coupled photon-electron transport simulations. The code is designed as a test bed to evaluate the efficacy of heterogeneous computing systems for low-cost MC-based radiation dosimetric calculations. The code has three variants corresponding to three parallel hardware platforms: ARCHER-CPU (multi-core CPU), ARCHER-GPU (Nvidia GPU) and ARCHER-COP (Intel Xeon Phi coprocessor). The code has been used for several applications, including CT imaging dosimetry, radiotherapy dosimetry and radiation shielding design. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Life cycle energy use and greenhouse gas emissions of ammonia production from renewable resources and industrial by-products

Conventionally, ammonia is produced from natural gas via steam methane reforming (SMR), water-gas shift reaction, and the Haber–Bosch process. The process uses fossil natural gas, which leads to 2.6 metric tons of life cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions per metric ton of ammonia produced. With ammonia being the second most produced chemical in the world, its production accounts for approximately 2% of worldwide fossil energy use and generates over 420 million tons of CO 2 annually. To reduce its carbon intensity, ammonia synthesis relying on renewable energy or utilizing by-products from industrial processes is of interest. In this work, we conduct a life cycle analysis of conventional and alternative ammonia production pathways by tracking energy use and emissions in all conversion stages, from the primary material and energy resources to the ammonia plant gates. Of all the alternative pathways, obtaining N 2 from cryogenic distillation and H 2 from low-temperature electrolysis using renewable electricity has the lowest cradle-to-plant-gate GHG emissions, representing a 91% decrease from the conventional SMR pathway.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Depth profiling of semiconductor structures by X-ray microanalysis using the electron probe energy variation technique

Depth profiling of semiconductor structures by X-ray microanalysis using the electron probe variation technique followed by mathematical processing of the measurement results is described. Experimental dependences of the relative X-ray intensity on the energy of the electron probe were compared to the Monte Carlo simulation results. Concentration depth profiles were estimated using a priori assumptions, and numerical parameters of the depth distributions were determined from the best fit of calculated curves to the experimental data. The technique was applied to determine Al depth profiles in SiC and GaN samples.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Abstract for CRADA between National Energy Technology Laboratory and American Institute of Chemical Engineers dba RAPID Manufacturing Institute

NETL and RAPID Manufacturing will develop advanced electromagnetic (EM) reactors and catalysts to produce light olefins from alternative feedstocks using CO2 soft oxidation. Light olefins are the building blocks for many plastic products, in addition to synthetic fibers, rubbers, and polymers. This project has the potential to produce high-value light olefins from alternative feedstocks with reduced energy consumption (50-70%), carbon intensity (50-70%), and production cost (15-25%) compared to the traditional olefin production processes.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Low-Cost Bio-Based Carbon Fibers for High Temperature Processing

GrafTech International Holdings Inc. (GTI), under Award No. DE-EE0005779, worked with Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) under CRADA No. NFE-15-05807 to develop lignin-based carbon fiber (LBCF) technology and to demonstrate LBCF performance in high-temperature products and applications. This work was unique and different from other reported LBCF work in that this study was application-focused and scalability-focused. Accordingly, the executed work was based on meeting criteria based on technology development, cost, and application suitability. High-temperature carbon fiber based insulation is used in energy intensive industries, such as metal heat treating and ceramic and semiconductor material production. Insulation plays a critical role in achieving high thermal and process efficiency, which is directly related to energy usage, cost, and product competitiveness. Current high temperature insulation is made with petroleum based carbon fibers, and one goal of this protect was to develop and demonstrate an alternative lignin (biomass) based carbon fiber that would achieve lower cost, CO2 emissions, and energy consumption and result in insulation that met or exceeded the thermal efficiency of current commercial insulation. In addition, other products were targeted to be evaluated with LBCF. As the project was designed to proceed in stages, the initial focus of this work was to demonstrate lab-scale LBCF from at least 4 different lignin precursor feedstock sources that could meet the estimated production cost of $5.00/pound and have ash level of less than 500 ppm in the carbonized insulation-grade fiber. Accordingly, a preliminary cost model was developed based on publicly available information. The team demonstrated that 4 lignin samples met the cost criteria. In addition, the ash level for the 4 carbonized lignin samples was below 500 ppm. Processing as-received lignin to produce a high purity lignin fiber was a significant accomplishment in that most industrial lignin, prior to purification, had greater than 4X the ash level needed for this project, and prior to this work there was not a clear path of how to achieve the purity target. The lab scale development of LBCF was performed with a specific functional application in mind, specifically for high temperature rigid insulation. GTI is a consumer of foreign-sourced pitch and rayon based carbon fibers for use in its high temperature insulation products, and the motivation was that LBCF had potential to decrease costs and increase product competitiveness in the marketplace through lowered raw material costs, lowered energy costs, and decreased environmental footprint. At the end of this project, the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) remained at 5 for LBCF in high temperature insulation.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Mechanisms of Hydrogen-Assisted Magnesiothermic Reduction of TiO{sub 2}

Direct reduction of TiO{sub 2} powder has been attempted for decades by researchers in an effort to decrease titanium (Ti) metal production costs. The main objective has been to avoid energy-intensive steps involved in production of primary Ti by the Kroll process. The emerging hydrogen-assisted magnesiothermic reduction process, which uses Mg to directly reduce TiO{sub 2} powder under a H{sub 2} atmosphere, has been shown to have the potential to compete directly with the Kroll process. The present studies represent an effort to understand the reduction reaction mechanisms of this process. Phase transformations and the reaction pathways are examined by SEM/EDX analysis of partially reduced powder cross-sectional, X-ray diffraction, and other analytical techniques. The results show important morphological changes, the prominent intermediate and final phases under the H{sub 2} atmosphere, as well as the local deposition behavior of the MgO byproduct. The effect of the specific surface areas of the initial particles is also discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Optimal composition of europium gallium oxide thin films for device applications

Europium gallium oxide (Eu{sub x}Ga{sub 1-x}){sub 2}O{sub 3} thin films were deposited on sapphire substrates by pulsed laser deposition with varying Eu content from x=2.4 to 20 mol %. The optical and physical effects of high europium concentration on these thin films were studied using photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy, x-ray diffraction (XRD), and Rutherford backscattering spectrometry. PL spectra demonstrate that emission due to the {sup 5}D{sub 0} to {sup 7}F{sub J} transitions in Eu{sup 3+} grows linearly with Eu content up to 10 mol %. Time-resolved PL indicates decay parameters remain similar for films with up to 10 mol % Eu. At 20 mol %, however, PL intensity decreases substantially and PL decay accelerates, indicative of parasitic energy transfer processes. XRD shows films to be polycrystalline and beta-phase for low Eu compositions. Increasing Eu content beyond 5 mol % does not continue to modify the film structure and thus, changes in PL spectra and decay cannot be attributed to structural changes in the host. These data indicate the optimal doping for optoelectronic devices based on (Eu{sub x}Ga{sub 1-x}){sub 2}O{sub 3} thin films is between 5 and 10 mol %.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗