Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Li stability”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 451 records · Page 25
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2024

High‐Energy LiNiO 2 Li Metal Batteries Enabled by Hybrid Electrolyte Consisting of Ionic Liquid and Weakly Solvating Fluorinated Ether

Abstract In pursuit of the highest possible energy density, researchers shift their focus to the ultimate anode material, lithium metal (Li 0 ), and high‐capacity cathode materials with high nickel content (Ni > 80%). The combination of these aggressive electrodes presents unprecedented challenges to the electrolyte. Here, we report a hybrid electrolyte consisting of a highly fluorinated ionic liquid and a weakly solvating fluorinated ether, whose hybridization structure enables the reversible operation of a battery chemistry based on Li 0 and LiNiO 2 (Ni = 100%), delivering nearly theoretical capacity of the latter (up to 249 mAh g −1 ) for >300 cycles with retention of 78.6% and in absence of unwanted morphological changes in both electrodes. Extensive characterization assisted by molecular dynamic simulation and density functional theory calculations reveals the function of the fluorinated ether to be far more profound than simple dilution and viscosity reduction. Instead, it induces drastic changes in Li + ‐solvation environment, the consequence of which engenders simultaneous stabilization of electrode/electrolyte and interfacing via formation of respective interfacial chemistries. This study further unlocks fundamental knowledge underneath the prevailing “diluent strategy” that is extensively applied by the electrolyte researchers and opens more design space for the next‐generation electrolytes and interphases for these coveted battery chemistries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Disordered Rocksalts as High‐Energy and Earth‐Abundant Li‐Ion Cathodes

To address the growing demand for energy and support the shift toward transportation electrification and intermittent renewable energy, there is an urgent need for low‐cost, energy‐dense electrical storage. Research on Li‐ion electrode materials has predominantly focused on ordered materials with well‐defined lithium diffusion channels, limiting cathode design to resource‐constrained Ni‐ and Co‐based oxides and lower‐energy polyanion compounds. Recently, disordered rocksalts with lithium excess (DRX) have demonstrated high capacity and energy density when lithium excess and/or local ordering allow statistical percolation of lithium sites through the structure. This cation disorder can be induced by high temperature synthesis or mechanochemical synthesis methods for a broad range of compositions. DRX oxides and oxyfluorides containing Earth‐abundant transition metals have been prepared using various synthesis routes, including solid‐state, molten‐salt, and sol‐gel reactions. This review outlines DRX design principles and explains the effect of synthesis conditions on cation disorder and short‐range cation ordering (SRO), which determines the cycling stability and rate capability. In addition, strategies to enhance Li transport and capacity retention with Mn‐rich DRX possessing partial spinel‐like ordering are discussed. Finally, the review considers the optimization of carbon and electrolyte in DRX materials and addresses key challenges and opportunities for commercializing DRX cathodes.

Li-ion batteries↗
DOE OSTI2020

Chemical interaction and enhanced interfacial ion transport in a ceramic nanofiber–polymer composite electrolyte for all-solid-state lithium metal batteries

This article reports the synergy between ceramic nanofibers and a polymer, and the enhanced interfacial Li-ion transport along the nanofiber/polymer interface in a solid-state ceramic/polymer composite electrolyte, in which a three-dimensional (3D) electrospun aluminum-doped Li 0.33 La 0.557 TiO 3 (LLTO) nanofiber network is embedded in a polyvinylidene fluoride-hexafluoropropylene (PVDF-HFP) matrix. Strong chemical interaction occurs between the nanofibers and the polymer matrix. Addition of the ceramic nanofibers into the polymer matrix results in the dehydrofluorination of the PVDF chains, deprotonation of the –CH 2 moiety and amorphization of the polymer matrix. Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra reveal that lithium ions transport via three pathways: (i) intra-polymer transport, (ii) intra-nanofiber transport, and (iii) interfacial polymer/nanofiber transport. In addition, lithium phosphate is coated on the LLTO nanofiber surface before the nanofibers are embedded into the polymer matrix. The presence of lithium phosphate at the LLTO/polymer interface further enhances the chemical interaction between the nanofibers and the polymer, which promotes the lithium ion transport along the polymer/nanofiber interface. This in turn improves the ionic conductivity and electrochemical cycling stability of the nanofiber/polymer composite. As a result, the flexible LLTO/Li 3 PO 4 /polymer composite electrolyte membrane exhibits an ionic conductivity of 5.1 × 10 -4 S cm -1 at room temperature and an electrochemical stability window of 5.0 V vs. Li/Li + . A symmetric Li|electrolyte|Li half-cell shows a low overpotential of 50 mV at a constant current density of 0.5 mA cm -2 for more than 800 h. In addition, a full cell is constructed by sandwiching the composite electrolyte between a lithium metal anode and a LiFePO 4 -based cathode. Such an all-solid-state lithium metal battery exhibits excellent cycling performance and rate capability.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Autonomous Strategies for Improved Performance and Reliability of Li‐Ion Batteries

Abstract The battery community has devoted significant effort to improve the performance and reliability of Li‐ion batteries through the development of new materials. The integration of autonomous function provides an alternative strategy to further extend performance. Autonomous material systems mimic the ability of biological systems to self‐protect, sense, regulate, and heal in response to damage and other environmental changes. When incorporated in batteries, these materials enable autonomic restoration of battery performance upon degradation, as well as autonomic shutdown or extinguishment in response to thermal runaway. Successful strategies for improving Li‐ion battery performance include controlled release of microencapsulated functional additives and the integration of self‐healing or adaptive interlayers and binders. These methods have been effective for stabilizing the solid electrolyte interface, preventing battery fires, restoring electrode conductivity, and suppressing Li dendrite growth. Challenges and opportunities exist in the further application of autonomous strategies in the battery environment. A greater variety of encapsulated additives with precise triggered‐release are needed to address specific battery degradation mechanisms. Incorporation of self‐healing polymers in solid‐state batteries facilitates improvement in interfacial and mechanical stability. The integration of autonomous strategies with battery management systems potentially enables enhanced control over multiple battery cycling parameters.

Zhao, Lihong↗
DOE OSTI2022

Achieving High Stability and Performance in P2-Type Mn-Based Layered Oxides with Tetravalent Cations for Sodium-Ion Batteries

We report P2-type sodium-manganese-based layered cathodes, owing to their high capacity from both cationic and anionic redox, are a potential candidate for Na-ion batteries to replace Li-ion technology in certain applications. Still, the structure instability originates from irreversible oxygen redox at high voltage remains a challenge. Here, a high sustainability cobalt-free P2- Na 0.72 Mn 0.75 Li 0.24 X 0.01 O 2 (X= Ti/Si) cathode is developed. The outstanding capacity retention and voltage retention after 150 cycles are obtained in Na half-cells. Our finding shows Ti locates on the surface while Si diffuses to the bulk of the particles. Thus, Ti can act as protective layer that alleviate side reactions in carbonate-based electrolyte. Meanwhile, Si can regulate the local electronic structure and suppress oxygen redox activities. Notably, full-cells with hard carbon (≈300-335 Whkg -1 based on the cathode mass) deliver the capacity retention of 83% for P2- Na 0.72 Mn 0.75 Li 0.24 Si 0.01 O 2 and 66% for P2-Na 0.72 Mn 0.75 Li 0.24 Ti 0.01 O 2 after 500 cycles; this electrochemical stability is the best compared to other reported cathodes based on oxygen redox at present. The superior cycle performance also stems from the ability to inhibit microcracking and planar gliding within the particles. Altogether, this finding offers new composition towards developing high performance low-cost cathodes for Na-ion batteries and highlights the unique role of Ti/Si ions.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2020

TiO2 Nanocrystal-Framed Li 2 TiSiO 5 Platelets for Low-Voltage Lithium Battery Anode

Titanium-based anode materials are attracting considerable attention for use in high-performance lithium-ion batteries, but the compromised energy density caused by high voltage plateaus and unsatisfactory capacities severely retards their practical applications. Herein, a molten-salt synthesis of Li 2 TiSiO 5 crystalline platelets and a subsequent selective facet modification by in situ growth of TiO 2 nanocrystal frames are facilely achieved. The discharge voltage plateau at around 0.5 V renders the Li 2 TiSiO 5 anode safe compared with graphite and confers a high energy density compared with zero-strain Li 4 Ti 5 O 12 anode. With the optimized size, structure, and content of modified TiO2 nanocrystals associated with the exposed (001) plane of Li 2 TiSiO 5 , the Li 2 TiSiO 5 -based anodes can deliver a capacity of above 300 mAh g -1 , enhanced rate performance, and a capacity retention of 66% after 10 000 cycles. In situ X-ray diffraction and ex situ transmission electron microscopy have demonstrated the structural stability of the anodes upon charge/discharge. Further theoretical calculation reveals 3D migration paths of Li + ions in Li 2 TiSiO 5 . The selective modification of in situ grown TiO2 nanocrystals on certain facets of crystallites opens a new door for the development of electrode materials possessing superior electrochemical properties.

anodes↗
DOE OSTI2022

Phase Stability of Garnet Solid-Electrolyte Interfacing with Various Cathodes in All Solid-State Batteries

Garnet-structured Li 6.75 La 3 Zr 1.75 Ta 0.25 O 12 (LLZTO) is one of the most promising electrolyte materials for solid-state Li batteries (SS-LiB). The design and fabrication of a good cathode/electrolyte interface is an important criterion for the SS-LiB. In this work, we performed a systematic study on the impact of cathode crystal structure and chemical compositions on their chemical stabilities against the LLZTO at elevated temperatures, which are required for their adhesion during cell fabrication processes. X-ray Diffraction (XRD) and Rietveld refinement analyses revealed the chemical stabilities of various cathode materials in contact with the LLZTO. While layered LiCoO 2 cathode showed good stability in contact with LLZTO to 900 °C, LiNiO 2 or Ni-rich LiNi x Mn y Co 1–x–y O 2 (NMC) cathodes suffered from the formation of La 4 NiLiO 8 due to La-diffusion from LLZTO. Furthermore, Mn-rich LiMn 2 O 4 spinel and layered LiNi 1/3 Mn 1/3 Co 1/3 O 2 cathodes suffered from the formation of La 2 Zr 2 O 7 due to Li-diffusion and production of Li 2 MnO 3 . As a result, LiNi 0.6 Mn 0.2 Co 0.2 O 2 , having an ideal balance of Ni/Mn/Co composition, or Li 2 MnO 3 containing cathodes such as Li 1.2 Ni 0.15 Mn 0.55 Co 0.1 O 2 were found to have excellent phase stability as the cathodes for LLZTO-based SS-LiBs.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Investigating Ternary Li–Mg–Si Zintl Phase Formation and Evolution for Si Anodes in Li-Ion Batteries with Mg(TFSI) 2 Electrolyte Additive

Improved electrochemical performance of Si was recently reported by adding multivalent cation salts (such as Mg 2+ , Al 3+ , Ca 2+, etc.) in the electrolyte. This is achieved via the formation in an in situ manner of relatively more stable Li-M-Si ternary phases with less chemical reactivity. These phases stabilize Si anions and thus reduce side reactions with electrolytes at the surface and eventually benefit the overall electrochemistry. To understand the mechanism of ternary Zintl phase formation and its dynamics upon lithiation/delithiation, high-resolution solid-state 7 Li and 29 Si nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) are utilized to directly probe the local Li and Si environments on Si electrodes harvested from coin and pouch cells at various states of (de)lithiation. The NMR spectra along with the electrochemical characterization reveal that lithiation of Si starts from the surface Si-O layer further confirmed by 7 Li– 29 Si cross-polarization NMR. Lithiation progresses with heterogeneous silicon clustering with Si -4 anions at high states of lithiation. At a fully lithiated state, the formation of overlithiated Si species is detected. At a low-voltage region (below 100 mV), direct evidence for Mg-ion insertion is found, postulated by two possible mechanisms: ion exchange with fully or overlithiated binary domains (Li 3.75+x Si) and/or a coinsertion with slightly underlithiated domains (similar to Li 3.55 Si). Upon delithiation, Li extraction starts from overlithiated Si domains. No evidence is found for electrochemical Mg removal. Evidence for a lithium-deficient Li y Mg 0.1 Si phase is found as a result of Li removal during charging. This investigation sheds light on the possible mechanisms of a new Si anode chemistry, which could enable the development of stable Si-based anodes for lithium-ion batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Atomic-Level Understanding of Surface Reconstruction Based on Li[Ni x Mn y Co 1–x–y ]O 2 Single-Crystal Studies

The stability of cathode particle surfaces that are directly exposed to the electrolyte is one of the most crucial and determining factors for cathode performance at high operating voltages. Theory has predicted a strong dependence of surface stability on chemical compositions as well as surface facets of layered oxides, yet conflicting results on the correlations exist as most experimental studies focus on cycled secondary particles recovered from composite electrodes. Here, we synthesize well-formed Li[Ni x Mn y Co 1–x–y ]O 2 (NMC) single-crystal samples, carefully define pristine surface properties, and then monitor their evolution with cycling. Atomic-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) imaging and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) analysis show the formation of a surface reconstruction layer (SRL) as well as an extended surface reduction layer on pristine, Li-permeable non-(001) surfaces, even before cycling. We reveal a transition region with chemical gradient, in which the layered structure gradually densifies and eventually transforms into the SRL on the top surface. Contrary to these observations, no SRL is observed on pristine, Li-impermeable (001) surfaces, revealing the facet-dependent nature of surface reconstructions during particle synthesis. Upon electrochemical cycling, significant composition-and facet-dependent SRL growth is observed. The driving force and mechanism for surface reconstruction are further discussed. The present study provides insights into the origin as well as the nature of SRLs, highlighting the significance of surface engineering in cathode material optimization.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Bridging Transition Metal and Anion Redox Processes in Li-Rich Sulfide Cathodes

Li-ion batteries are essential for decarbonizing global transport and energy, but their scalability is constrained by limited supplies of critical cathode elements, such as Ni, Mn, Co, and P. To address this, we previously introduced high-energydensity Li-ion cathodes composed of Al, Fe, and S, which are elements already produced globally at industrial scale and batterygrade purity. These cathodes leverage sulfide anion redox, involving nonbonding S 3p states and localized distortions that form and break S−S bonds, enabling high capacity. Here, we expand this chemical space by incorporating Cu into cathodes Li 2.2d−z Cu z Al 0.2 Fe 0.6 S 2 (0 ≤ z ≤ 0.4), where highly covalent Cu−S interactions stabilize holes on Cu as Cu >1+ . This Cu redox extends charge compensation that was previously restricted to localized, electronically isolated S−S bonds. Cu also limits capacity, which we attribute to structural destabilization of the delithiated phase, despite the thermodynamic stability of Cu >1+ . By describing the effects of Cu on charge compensation and phase stability, we present a sulfide anion redox mechanism for next-generation multielectron redox Li-ion cathodes, where highly covalent transition metal states participate in otherwise electronically isolated redox processes involving anion nonbonding states.

Anions↗
DOE OSTI2021

Materials design of sodium chloride solid electrolytes Na3MCl6 for all-solid-state sodium-ion batteries

All-solid-state sodium-ion batteries have attracted increasing attention owing to the low cost of sodium and the enhanced safety compared to conventional Li-ion batteries. Recently, halides have been considered as promising solid electrolytes (SEs) due to their favorable combination of high ionic conductivity and chemical stability against high-voltage cathode materials. Although a wide variety of lithium chloride SEs, Li 3 MCl 6 , have been developed for high-voltage all-solid-state batteries, only a limited number of sodium chloride SEs have been reported. This study aims to offer a material design insight for the development of sodium chloride SEs through systematic assessment of the phase stability, electrochemical stability, and transport properties of novel Na 3 MCl 6 SEs. Structural calculations indicate that Na 3 MCl 6 exhibits trigonal $P\bar{3}$1c, monoclinic P2 1 /n, and trigonal $R\bar{3}$ phases, and the stable phase of Na 3 MCl 6 is dependent on the type and ionic radius of M. Na 3 MCl 6 typically exhibits a high oxidation potential, demonstrating good electrochemical stability against cathodes. The bond-valence site energy and ab initio molecular dynamics calculations revealed that Na 3 MCl 6 with P2 1 /n and $R\bar{3}$ phases showed low ionic conductivity, while the $P\bar{3}$1c phase slightly improved the ionic conductivity of Na 3 MCl 6 . The formation of Na vacancies by aliovalent substitution considerably increased the ionic conductivity up to four orders of magnitude for pristine Na 3 MCl 6 , exhibiting ~10 –5 S cm –1 for trigonal $P\bar{3}$1c and $R\bar{3}$ phases. The formation of defects could further enhance the ionic conductivity of Na 3 MCl 6 , and the optimization of defect type and ratio can be helpful in developing superionic Na chloride SEs. The material design of Na 3 MCl 6 in this study will provide fundamental guidelines for the development of novel sodium halide SEs for all-solid-state sodium-ion batteries.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Demarcating the Impact of Electrolytes on High–Nickel Cathodes and Lithium–Metal Anode

The ever-growing demand for low-cost, high-energy-density lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) makes high-nickel layered oxide cathodes, especially LiNiO 2 (LNO), one of the most appealing candidates. However, poor structural and surface instability that leads to a short cycle life remains a formidable challenge. Herein, a systematic investigation of LNO performance in two different electrolytes (a conventional carbonate-based LP57 electrolyte and an ether-based localized high-concentration electrolyte (LHCE)) with different charge cut-off voltages is presented. These findings show that the cathode-electrolyte reactivity is the main factor dictating the performance degradation of LNO at high voltages rather than bulk integrity. While LHCE can provide good stability beyond 4.2 V with a robust, uniform solid–electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer on the Li-metal anode, there is no significant difference in cyclability at 4.15 V (96% capacity retention after 200 cycles) for both LP57 and LHCE. From LNO symmetric cells, carbonate-based electrolyte is found to be good for LNO stability while ether-based electrolyte is beneficial toward Li-metal anode. Furthermore, a suitable electrolyte or a low cut-off voltage is necessary to maintain a decent cycle life. Altogether, this work highlights the impact of electrolyte and cut-off voltage on LNO and Li-metal, which can help guide the development of cells based on LNO.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Layer spacing gradient (NaLi) 1–x CoO 2 for electrochemical Li extraction

Designing materials with high Li to Na selectivity is the key for direct extraction of Li from unconventional sources, such as seawater, without complex separations. However, material discovery is hindered by an insufficient understanding on how a material's composition and structure relate to Li selectivity during electrochemical co-intercalation. Here, we synthesized a core-shell structured (NaLi) 1-x CoO 2 with a core Li phase (Li 0.94 CoO 2 ), a shell Na phase (Na 0.51 CoO 2 ), and a transition intermediate phase via Na ion-exchange of parent Li 1-x CoO 2 . We reveal that the chemical compositions and spatial relation of these phases play critical roles in governing high Li to Na selectivity. The core Li phase restricts large layer spacing expansion and inhibits Na intercalation. The shell Na phase serves to maintain the electrode stability against further Na ion exchange. With the layer spacing gradient design, we achieved a high Li selectivity of 1.5 x 10 5 with a recovery of similar to 7.6:1 Li to Na from 1:20,000 initial ratio.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

An In Situ Formed Surface Coating Layer Enabling LiCoO 2 with Stable 4.6 V High‐Voltage Cycle Performances

Abstract The development of high‐voltage LiCoO 2 is essential for achieving lithium‐ion batteries with high volumetric energy density, however, it faces a great deal of challenges owing to the materials, structure and interfacial instability issues. In this work, a strategy is developed, through heat annealing a precoated surface layer to in situ form a high‐voltage‐stable surface coating layer, which is demonstrated to be highly effective to improve the high‐voltage performance of LiCoO 2 . It is discovered that LiCoO 2 reacts with Li 1.5 Al 0.5 Ti 1.5 (PO 4 ) 3 (LATP) at 700 °C to form exclusively spinel phases in addition to Li 3 PO 4 , which are structurally coherent to the layered lattice of LiCoO 2 . The heat annealing of the precoated thin layer of LATP enables the formation of a high‐quality surface layer. Spinel phases possess high‐voltage‐stable structures with much weaker oxidizing ability of lattice oxygen than layered structure. In addition, the Li 3 PO 4 is a good lithium‐ion conductor with excellent chemical stability at high voltages. All these benefits contribute to the construction of a uniform and conformal high‐voltage‐stable surface layer with favorable lithium conducting kinetics at the LiCoO 2 surface. The modified LiCoO 2 shows excellent 4.6 V high‐voltage cycle performance at both room temperature and 45 °C. The thermal stability is greatly enhanced as well.

Wang, Yi↗
DOE OSTI2021

Insights into Layered Oxide Cathodes for Rechargeable Batteries

Layered intercalation compounds are the dominant cathode materials for rechargeable Li-ion batteries. In this article we summarize in a pedagogical way our work in understanding how the structure’s topology, electronic structure, and chemistry interact to determine its electrochemical performance. We discuss how alkali–alkali interactions within the Li layer influence the voltage profile, the role of the transition metal electronic structure in dictating O3-structural stability, and the mechanism for alkali diffusion. We then briefly delve into emerging, next-generation Li-ion cathodes that move beyond layered intercalation hosts by discussing disordered rocksalt Li-excess structures, a class of materials which may be essential in circumventing impending resource limitations in our era of clean energy technology.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Stabilization and manipulation of highly concentrated copper single atoms by high entropy oxides

Facile and controllable methodologies capable of providing single atom catalysts (SACs) with high-density active metal sites and sintering-resistance under harsh conditions are highly desired and grand challenges in heterogeneous catalysis. Herein, the entropy effect was leveraged to stabilize and manipulate the electronic properties of copper SACs. The as-developed ultrasonication-driven approach could integrate highly concentrated Cu SAs within the lattice of fluorite-structured high entropy oxide (HEFO) under ambient conditions (CuO-HEFO). The dual benefits from the high entropy effect of the support and the in-situ lattice engineering led to the generation of abundant Cu 1+ species and oxygen defects, together with ultra-high stability and sintering-resistance under extremely harsh conditions. This was confirmed by deploying non-high entropy support (CuO-CeO 2 ) or Cu sites located on the surface of HEFO (CuO@HEFO). In conclusion, the catalytic activity of CuO-HEFO surpassed that of CuO-CeO 2 and CuO@HEFO in CO oxidation together with well-maintained long-term stability and resistance to gas impurities.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Probing the elastic modulus and hardness of superionic boron cluster solid electrolytes

Polyhedral borane salts are highly tunable compounds with the potential to be used as solid electrolytes due to their high Li and Na superionic conductivity and relatively wide electrochemical stability window. In considering their application to all solid-state batteries, their mechanical properties play a critical role in their operation due to stresses the solid electrolyte is subjected to during battery operation. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations have provided an initial assessment of bulk and elastic moduli for some selected boron cluster solid electrolytes, but direct measurements are still scarce. Here, in this paper, we report the elastic moduli and hardnesses of LiCB 11 H 12 , LiCB 9 H 10 , NaCB 11 H 12 , and NaCB 9 H 10 for the first time using nanoindentation continuous stiffness method (CSM) measurements under inert atmosphere. Experimental modulus values ranging 8.8–12.3 GPa and hardness values ranging 0.15–0.38 GPa are lower than that of other inorganic solid-state electrolytes such as oxide- and sulfide-based solid electrolytes. DFT calculations on the expected moduli of these compounds are also presented and discussed. Analysis of the indentation plasticity index reveals that these compounds have higher plasticity index compared to other common oxide and sulfide solid electrolytes. According to the calculated Pugh's ratio, all compounds in this study except LiCB 11 H 12 are considered ductile.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗