Independent Technical Review of the Interim Measure Alternatives Analysis for Chromium Contamination in Groundwater at Los Alamos National Laboratory, New Mexico
The two example scenarios described in the report are built around either boundary condition modification or pump and treat. Boundary condition modification focuses primarily on aggressively reducing the driving force of water that is moving Cr(VI) through the subsurface system at LANL, carefully monitoring hydrologic responses, and quantifying natural attenuation rates in key portions of the plume. This scenario would provide a measurable impact on subsurface hydrology using relatively low-cost methods and emphasizing data collection to support the CME process. The second scenario focuses on active removal of Cr(VI) using pump and treat combined with a variety of data collection activities. This scenario would also include some boundary condition modification and would provide more timely impacts in the mid-plume area. However, it is substantially more costly and faces more significant logistical, regulatory, and data interpretation hurdles. Because of these issues and challenges, the pump and treat based scenario would be appropriate primarily for the case in which Cr(VI) removal and more rapid near-term impacts in the mid-plume are considered to be high, overriding priorities. We recommend careful consideration of the advantages and disadvantages of different “combined remedy” IM scenarios and urge the LANL team and its regulators and stakeholders to assemble and select a scenario that is implementable and that provides useful and actionable data to inform and support the CME. Both of the example scenarios presented meet these criteria.