Rise and fall of Mott insulating gaps in YNiO 3 paramagnets as a reflection of symmetry breaking and remaking
The YNiO 3 nickelate is a paradigm d-electron oxide that manifests the intriguing temperature-mediated sequence of three phases transitions from (i) magnetically ordered insulator to (ii) paramagnetic (PM) insulator and then to (iii) PM metal. Such phenomena raised the question of the nature of the association of magnetism and structural symmetry breaking with the appearance in (i) and (ii) and disappearance in (iii) of insulating band gaps. It is demonstrated here that first-principles mean-field–like density-functional theory (DFT), driven by molecular dynamics temperature evolution, can describe not only the origin of the magnetically long-range ordered insulating phase (i), but also the creation of an insulating paramagnet (ii) that lacks spin- long-range order, and of a metallic paramagnet (iii) as temperature rises. This approach provides the patterns of structural and magnetic symmetry breaking at different temperatures, in parallel with band gaps obtained when the evolving geometries are used as input to DFT electronic band-structure calculations. This disentangles the complex interplay among spin, charge, and orbital degrees of freedom. Analysis shows that the success in describing the rise and fall of the insulating band gaps along the phase transition sequence is enabled by allowing sufficient flexibility in describing diverse local structural and magnetic motifs as input to DFT. This entails the use of sufficiently large supercells that allow expressing structural disproportionation of octahedra, as well as a description of PM phases as a distribution of local magnetic moments (rather than using a single averaged moment). It appears that the historic dismissal of mean-field–like DFT as being unable to describe such Mott-like transitions was premature, as it was based on consideration of averaged crystallographic unit cells, a description that washes out local symmetry-breaking motifs. The magnetically ordered insulating YNiO 3 phase (i) and the PM insulating phase (ii) result in DFT from allowing symmetry breaking, evident already by considering the athermal internal energy. In contrast, the PM metallic phase (iii) is formed thermally by smearing out thus weakening symmetry breaking. Analysis of snapshots of the different forms of structural vs magnetic symmetry breaking shows that only the loss of the polymorphous distribution of magnetic moments existing in (ii) causes the fall of the band gap, resulting in the metallic state in (iii). Finally, the interesting conclusion is that such a description of the rise [in phases (i) and (ii)] and fall [in phase (iii)] of the insulating gap does not rely on the traditional Mott-like strong correlation understanding, but on breaking and remaking of magnetic and structural symmetries reflected in energy lowering.