Impact of Thermodiffusively Unstable Hydrogen-Air Flames on the Turbulent Burning Rate and Quenching Process in Flame-Wall Interactions
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The safe operation of aeronautical engines requires an understanding of flame ignition, propagation and extinction. In this study, direct numerical simulations are performed using a 29 species reduced chemical mechanism for jet fuel surrogate Jet A to understand the flame quenching process. Here, initially laminar spherical flames of varying sizes and equivalence ratios are subject to an identical periodic domain of decaying and isotropic high intensity turbulence with a turbulent Reynolds number of 2400. All cases become quenched, except for the larger kernel with lower Karlovitz number. An analysis of the flame structure shows broadened preheat zone, flame shortening on the product side, differential species diffusion and partial fuel pyrolysis in the fresh mixture. Two extinction mechanisms are identified arising from flame shortening and high flame stretch. Flame shortening occurs due to turbulence-chemistry interactions that resemble the flame–flame interaction in a laminar counterflow reactant-to-reactant configuration, which contorts and breaks up the ignition kernel. Flame stretch is a local effect that attenuates the heat release rate and causes the flame to retreat towards the product mixtures, similar to what has been observed for reactant-to-product laminar counterflow flames. Chemical explosive mode analysis was also performed to quantify the flame structure and local combustion mode. The diffusion–reaction balance in pinched-off flame islands favors extinction of these smaller structures, while auto-ignition modes are observed within the flame kernel after fresh mixture is engulfed and preheated in the product kernel. Statistics of the density-weighted displacement speed conditional on local combustion mode indicates strong correlation between the local extinction mode and negative displacement speed. The local balance between diffusion and reaction ultimately determines the propensity for local extinction in both laminar and turbulent flames, the extent of which has an impact on global flame propagation.
The present study investigates the performance of NH, NH 2 , O-atom, and H-atom as heat release rate (HRR) surrogates for NH 3 /H 2 /N 2 –air premixed flame through simulations. The simulations are conducted across different pressures, reactant inlet temperatures, fuel blend compositions, and equivalence ratios. Cantera is used to simulate one-dimensional (1D) freely propagating flames to investigate the spatial correlations of the species with the HRR. PeleLMeX, a low-Mach direct numerical simulation (DNS) code with Adaptive Mesh Refinement (AMR), is used to simulate two-dimensional (2D) flame-vortex interactions to investigate the temporal correlations including stretch effects. Three different mechanisms (Jiang et al. 2020; Glarborg et al. 2018; Okafor et al. 2018) were considered in the 1D flame simulations, whereas only the Jiang mechanism was considered in the flame-vortex simulations. The HRR surrogate performance for the 2D flames is evaluated at two different locations: (1) the centerline and (2) the flame cusp. The cusp is defined as the region in the flame front with the greatest curvature and the centerline encounters the highest tangential strain rate. The 1D flame results suggest that, although there is not uniformly good spatial correlation for HRR across all flame conditions, NH is the best overall as a HRR surrogate for laminar flames. The 2D flame results, however, suggest that O-atom and H-atom have satisfactory temporal correlations at different conditions—the former for rich flames, the latter for high-pressure flames. Furthermore, these simulations provide guidance to experimental measurements of surrogate HRR markers in unsteady multi-dimensional flames using laser diagnostics to detect species such as NH, O-atom, and H-atom.
This paper investigates the effect of laminar-to-turbulent flame transition modeling on the prediction of cycle-to-cycle variations (CCVs) in large eddy simulation (LES) of spark-ignition (SI) engines. A laminar-to-turbulent flame transition model that describes the non-equilibrium sub-filter flame speed evolution during an early stage of flame kernel growth is developed. In the present model, the flame transition is characterized by the flame kernel size at which the flame transition ends, defined here as the flame transition scale. The proposed model captures the effects that variations in a turbulent flow field have on the evolution of early-stage burning rates, through variations in the flame transition scale. The proposed flame transition model is combined with the front propagation formulation (FPF) method and a spark-ignition model to predict CCVs in a gasoline direct injection SI engine. It is found that multi-cycle LES with the proposed flame transition model reproduces experimentally-observed CCVs satisfactorily. When the transition model is not considered or when variations in the transition process are neglected, CCVs are significantly under-predicted for the case considered here. These results indicate the importance of modeling the laminar-to-turbulent flame transition and the effect of turbulence on the transition process, when predicting CCVs, under certain engine conditions. The LES results are also used to analyze sources for variations in the flame transition. It is found, for the present engine case, that the most important source is the cycle-to-cycle variation in the turbulence dissipation rate, which is used to measure the strength of turbulence in the proposed model, near a spark plug. The large-scale velocity field and the variations of the laminar flame speed due to the mixture composition and thermal stratification are also found to be important factors to contribute to the variations in the flame transition.
Incorporation of fire retardants in different types of products is one of the essential steps in the material production process to minimize fire risk and meet fire safety requirements. A variety of commonly used flame retardants based on halogen, mineral, and other compounds has gained popularity due to their efficient flame-retardant behaviors. However, especially in the case of halides, there are numerous toxicity related issues and environmental pollution effects that have urged the building sector to deviate from their use and focus on the development of non-toxic alternatives. Therefore, to enhance the safety of flame retardants, the synthesis of flame retardants from waste feedstocks using phosphorous chemistry with a dual flame-retardant mechanism has been established. A range of waste feedstocks that include cardanol, vanillin, and gallic acids has been converted into a series of flame retardants using a one-step approach by incorporating phosphorous moieties into their structures. The established pathways allow to develop a range of flame-retardant materials by converting waste feedstocks into phosphorous-based materials with inherent flame retardancy. The introduction of abundant aromatic structures from biobased feedstocks enables high charring capabilities in materials in which these biobased flame retardants have been incorporated, increasing their char yields which significantly enhances the flame suppressing properties of the designed materials. Studies show that inclusion of phosphoric moieties into structures allows the displacement of flame enhancing radicals, by releasing non-flammable and non-toxic gases, therefore inhibiting the spread of fire in the gas phase. The resulting biobased flame retardants have been incorporated in wood substrates, foam insulation, and hemp fibers where the results show that only 1-5% of loading of biobased flame retardant suppressed the flame completely. This study represents a novel approach for the development of flame retardants with high performance while utilizing waste feedstocks as a source for their design.
This study analyzes the response of premixed flames to high frequency transverse acoustic disturbances. A significant body of experiment, modeling and simulation efforts has been performed to understand the response of the spatially integrated heat release of premixed flames to low-frequency disturbances. These studies quantified this sensitivity through the Flame Transfer Function (FTF), as the global heat release is the key quantity influencing thermoacoustic stability for acoustically compact flames. Recent efforts have expanded these models to consider high-frequency acoustic disturbances, and the sensitivity of premixed flames through the Rayleigh integral (RI). The full Rayleigh Integral, as opposed to simply the spatially integrated heat release, must be considered in these cases where the flame is not acoustically compact. Prior modeling studies considered several effects - stability of axisymmetric flames centered in a cylindrical combustion chamber and the effect of flame offset from the combustor axis and the effect of mean flame asymmetries in the flame centered in the combustor. These studies showed that the flame's stability was sensitive to all these parameters, as well as to the transverse mode in question. In this paper, we quantify these different parametric sensitivities of premixed flame stability in the presence of high-frequency transverse acoustic modes - specifically sensitivity to flame length and nozzle location within the acoustic mode shape for 2 different transverse modes. The sensitivity of the RI to these control parameters provides an improved understanding of which flame parameters are critical to improve the overall thermoacoustic stability of the system.
The gas and tar composition of a diffusion flame from longleaf pine needles is currently poorly understood and more data are needed to fill in the gap between pyrolysis data and smoke plume data, thus improving physical and chemical modeling of wildland smoke formation. A pilot experiment to measure light gas and tar composition of such a flame is described for three flame regions: persistent flame (flame base), intermittent flame, and smoke plume. Flame gases from 24 experimental fires were collected in canisters and analyzed using EPA method TO-14A for CO 2 , CO, H 2 , CH 4 , and C 2 to C 7 hydrocarbon gases. Condensed gas (tar) samples were collected and analyzed using GC/MS. Other light gases were measured using FTIR spectroscopy. Results from compositional data analysis suggest significant differences in (relative) concentration of compounds detected in the three regions of the flame. Statistical tests for differences in flame zones were performed using the canister data: Concentration of hydrocarbons relative to CO and CO 2 decreased from the persistent flame zone above the pyrolyzing needles through the intermittent flame region into the flame-free plume. This was likely due to both chemical reactions (oxidation) occurring in the flame as well as the introduction of air into the flame/plume by entrainment.
This work characterizes the compressibility dynamics in turbulent fast flames for a range of turbulent flame speeds. These turbulent fast flames experience increased effects of compressibility through the formation of strong shocks and may develop a runaway acceleration combined with a pressure buildup that leads to turbulence induced deflagration-to-detonation transition (tDDT). Simultaneous high-speed particle image velocimetry, OH* chemiluminescence, schlieren, and pressure measurements are used to examine the reacting flow field and flame dynamics. We examine flames with turbulent flame speeds ranging from 100 to 600 m/s. At lower turbulent flame speeds, the flame is not able to produce favorable background conditions for deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT) onset, and thus flame compressibility and turbulence amplification are less dominant, resulting in a weaker acoustic coupling between the flame and compressed region. As the turbulent burning velocities exceed the Chapman–Jouguet deflagration speed, favorable background conditions are produced, as we observe flame-generated shocks and flame-generated turbulence with higher turbulent velocities and larger turbulent scales. At this regime, the flame is categorized to be at the runaway transition regime that leads to tDDT.
A high-pressure hydrogen micromix combustor has been investigated using direct numerical simulation with detailed chemistry to examine the flame structure and stabilisation mechanism. The configuration of the combustor was based on the design by Schefer et al., using numerical periodicity to mimic a large square array. A precursor simulation of an opposed jet-in-crossflow was first conducted to generate appropriate partially-premixed inflow boundary conditions for the subsequent reacting simulation. The resulting flame can be described as an predominantly-lean inhomogeneously-premixed lifted jet flame. Five main zones were identified: a jet mixing region, a core flame, a peripheral flame, a recirculation zone, and combustion products. The core flame, situated over the jet mixing region, was found to burn as a thin reaction front, responsible for over 85% of the total fuel consumption. The peripheral flame shrouded the core flame, had low mean flow with high turbulence, and burned at very lean conditions (in the distributed burning regime). It was shown that turbulent premixed flame propagation was an order-of-magnitude too slow to stabilise the flame at these conditions. Stabilisation was identified to be due to ignition events resulting from turbulent mixing of fuel from the jet into mean recirculation of very lean hot products. Ignition events were found to correlate with shear-driven Kelvin-Helmholtz vortices, and increased in likelihood with streamwise distance. At the flame base, isolated events were observed, which developed into rapidly burning flame kernels that were blown downstream. Further downstream, near-simultaneous spatially-distributed ignition events were observed, which appeared more like ignition sheets. The paper concludes with a broader discussion that considers generalising from the conditions considered here.
This short communication reports, for the first time, the existence of two different self-sustaining cool flame regimes of diethyl ether (DEE) in a diffusion counterflow burner: a weaker autoignition-assisted cool flame near the fuel burner and a normal diffusion cool flame near the stagnation plane. Here, the results show that the normal diffusion cool flame extinction limit increases monotonically with the fuel mole fraction, while the autoignition-assisted cool flame approaches a plateau and can exist at a fuel mole fraction below the normal diffusion cool flame. It is shown that both flame regimes are governed by the same low-temperature chain-branching reaction pathway of DEE. By using in situ laser diagnostics, entrainment of unburned fuel stream to oxygen stream at the outer edge of the fuel burner is identified as the governing physical mechanism causing a partially premixed self-sustained hollow cool flame structure. The results reveal that when a fuel with high low-temperature reactivity, two different cool flame regimes can be observed in a counterflow flame experiment. Future studies with high-reactivity fuels in a counterflow burner must ensure to distinguish between the two self-sustaining cool flame regimes. Moreover, the existence of these different cool flame regimes needs to be examined so that they would not trigger an uncontrolled combustion phasing in advanced engines fed with high low-temperature reactivity fuels.
Here, the growing demand of clean and efficient propulsion and energy systems has sparked an interest in understanding low-temperature combustion at high pressure. Cool flame transition and extinction limits as well as oxygen concentration dependence at elevated pressures provide insights of the low-temperature and high-pressure fuel reactivity. A new experimental high-pressure counterflow burner platform was designed and developed to achieve the studies of high-pressure cool flames. Dimethyl ether (DME) was chosen to study its non-premixed cool flame in high-pressure counterflow burner at pressure up to 5 atm, perhaps for the first time. This paper investigates the effects of pressure on cool flame structure, extinction and transition limits, and oxygen concentration dependence as well as ozone assisted warm flames of DME in experiments and numerical simulations. The results show that the reignition transition from cool flame to hot flame occurs either with the decrease of the strain rate at a given fuel concentration and pressure or with the increase of fuel mole fraction or pressure at a given strain rate. Furthermore, it is shown that the higher pressure shifts the cool flame to higher strain rates and results in higher cool flame extinction strain rates. However, the existing kinetic model of DME fails in predicting the cool flame extinction limit at elevated pressures. Besides, the cool flame extinction limits are proportional to nth power of the oxygen concentration, [O 2 ] n , and the increase of pressure leads to stronger extinction limit dependence (larger n) on oxygen concentration. The present experiment and detailed kinetic analysis show clearly that increasing pressure promotes the low-temperature chemistry including the oxygen addition reactions. In addition, stable warm flame was first experimentally observed by using DME at elevated pressure with ozone sensitization.
Flames in practical combustors and engines are inevitably subject to the effects of upstream chemical reaction progress and stretch, induced by elevated thermodynamic conditions and flow non-uniformities, respectively. Recent shock tube experiments and simulation studies on flame propagation have shown that flame speed under engine-relevant conditions can be enhanced with non-negligible upstream chemical reaction progress, especially when low-temperature heat release is involved in the unburnt mixture. On the other hand, depending on the mixture equivalence ratio and diluents, nonequidiffusion (including the non-unity Lewis number effect and the preferential diffusion effect) can couple with the flame stretch to fundamentally affect the flame propagation, which can manifest as either facilitation or suppression. Depending on the transport property of a reacting mixture, there hence can be either inhibition or promotion from unburnt reaction progress and stretch effects on flame propagation. In the current work, through one-dimensional numerical simulations of transient planar and spherical flames of n-heptane/air under elevated thermodynamic conditions, the combined effects of upstream chemical reaction progress and stretch on flame propagation are investigated. Results show that for both lean and rich n-heptane/air mixtures, flame speed can be substantially promoted with reaction progress, while the rich mixtures can exhibit opposite stretch dependence after first-stage ignition. Different definitions of effective Lewis number are adopted to explain the change in Markstein length for spherical flame in lean and rich mixtures reformed by the low temperature chemistry. Further, this work fills an important gap in laminar premixed flame research relevant to practical combustion systems and can provide useful insight into local turbulent flame behaviors and phi-sensitivity in engine combustion.
The lean blow-off mechanism of the premixed swirl flame is numerically investigated by large eddy simulation (LES) with the subgrid dissipation concept (SDC) combustion model. Three simulated cases cover stable, near blow-off, and transient conditions. Compared with the experiment, the LES-SDC approach captures the flow and combustion features for stable and near blow-off conditions. More importantly, the predictions of the blowoff procedure and duration agree satisfactorily with the experiment, indicating that the LES-SDC approach is a promising tool for predicting strong, unsteady turbulent combustion processes. Further, the numerical results are used to investigate the blow-off mechanism. Two stages in the blow-off procedure are specified. The first is the necking and extinction of the downstream flame surface, and the second is the shrinking of the upstream flame surface. The blow-off mechanism is well explained by the theory of stretched flame extinction. At the end of the recirculation zone, the large negative radial velocity pushes the flame to the central line. The combustion process here can be abstracted as the stretched counter-flame of the reactant-reactant configuration. The excessive flame stretch dominates the flame extinction and triggers the blow-off event. The upstream flame resists the intense stretch with the help of hot product recirculation, and the combustion here can be idealized as the counter-flame of the reactant-product configuration. The alignment of the temperature gradient and flow velocity, together with the excessive stretch, clearly indicates the tendency of flame local extinction. A Damköhler number-based blow-off criterion is raised from the mean flow strain rate and laminar flame bulk extinction strain rate.
Refrigerants with a low global warming potential (GWP) possess mild flammability. Hence, a fundamental understanding of their combustion characteristics is required to assess their fire-hazardous potential. The laminar burning velocity is one fundamental property to describe these under safety evaluation aspects. However, measuring laminar burning velocities for slow-burning components, such as low-GWP alternatives, is challenging. This is due to influencing effects such as buoyant flame deformation, stretch, radiation, and confinement, especially at the flammability limits. Here, in the present study, we investigated near-limit flames of the representative refrigerant difluoromethane (CH 2 F 2 ) with nitrogen-enriched oxidizer mixtures to elucidate the potentials and limitations at ultra-slow flame speeds of two widely used flame speed measurement methods in the closed vessel configuration: the optical flame speed measurement in the early quasi-isobaric regime and the flame speed determination from the pressure-rise during the later phase of the isochoric combustion process. Experiments were performed under terrestrial- and microgravity, conducted in a specially designed setup suitable for drop tower applications, using both methods in parallel. Recommendations for the extraction of flame speed data are derived from the non-buoyant reference investigations under microgravity and transferred to ultra-slow flames at terrestrial gravity. Near-limit flames under microgravity were found to be significantly affected by stretch effects for the optical method so that flame speed extrapolations to unstretched conditions are prone to errors. Stretch also affects the pressure method’s lower evaluation limit, and errors can be estimated by combining flame speed data from the pressure method and Markstein lengths from optical experiments.
Numerical simulations are performed to study the mechanism of deflagration to detonation transition (DDT) in a pre-/main-chamber combustion system with a stoichiometric ethylene–oxygen mixture. A Godunov algorithm, fifth-order in space, and third-order in time, is used to solve the fully compressible Navier–Stokes equations on a dynamically adapting mesh. A single-step, calibrated chemical diffusive model described by Arrhenius kinetics is used for energy release and conservation between the fuel and the product. The two-dimensional simulation shows that a laminar flame grows in the pre-chamber and then develops into a jet flame as it passes through the orifice. A strong shock forms immediately ahead of the flame, reflecting off the walls and interacting with the flame front. The shock–flame interactions are crucial for the development of flame instabilities, which trigger the subsequent flame development. The DDT arises due to a shock-focusing mechanism, where multiple shocks collide at the flame front. A chemical explosive mode analysis (CEMA) criterion is developed to study the DDT ignition mode. Preliminary one-dimensional computations for a laminar propagating flame, a fast flame deflagration, and a Chapman–Jouguet detonation are conducted to demonstrate the validity of CEMA on the chemical-diffusive model, as well as to determine the proper conditioning value for CEMA diagnostic. The two-dimensional analysis with CEMA indicates that the DDT initiated by the shock-focusing mechanism can form a strong thermal expansion region at the flame front that features large positive eigenvalues for the chemical explosive mode and dominance of the local autoignition mode. Thus, the CEMA criterion proposed in this study provides a robust diagnostic for identifying autoignition-supported DDT, of which the emergence of excessive local autoignition mode is found to be a precursor. The effect of grid size, initial temperature, and orifice size are then evaluated, and results show that although the close-chamber DDT is highly stochastic, the detonation initiation mechanism remains robust.
Green hydrogen (H2) and ammonia (NH3) are emerging as carbon free alternatives to hydrocarbon fuels. In gas turbines, flames interact with the combustor liner (wall), which affects the pollutant emissions, the burning efficiency, and the thermal load on the liner. We lack understanding of this important flame-wall interaction (FWI) for alternative fuels. FWI occurs at the scale of the flame thickness, and such scales are only resolved by direct numerical simulation. Here, we resolve the FWI for NH3 and H2 flames. Preliminary results of two distinct projects are presented: 2D laminar anchored V-flame, and 3D turbulent swirling flame. For the laminar flame, we show flame quenching at the wall and resulting leakage of NH3 and increased N2O, but decreased NO emissions. For the swirling flame, we show CO emissions, and comparison of flame shapes and location to experimental measurements. Ultimately we show that quenching and pollutant emissions strongly affected by fuel/air ratio, and that an inclined wall can stabilize very lean turbulent CH4/H2 flames, but prone to large CO emissions.
Ammonia is carbon-free and is regarded as a potential fuel to address global warming issues. Here, in this work, three-dimensional direct numerical simulations (DNS) of ammonia/air turbulent premixed flames were performed to explore the influence of turbulence and equivalence ratio on the flame structure and NO formation characteristics. Two equivalence ratios were considered, i.e. Φ=0.9 and Φ=1.1. The general flame structures were presented and species distributions were examined. The NO mass fraction was found to be the highest in the product for the lean case and in the reaction zone for the rich case. The conditional mean values of species mass fractions and reaction rates were compared with those of the unstrained and strained laminar premixed flames to explore how well the laminar flame structures can approach those of the turbulent flame. The budget analysis of the species transport equations showed that turbulent diffusion plays an important role in species transport. The turbulent diffusivity D T was estimated using the gradient hypothesis based on the DNS data. Various laminar flame simulations with different diffusivities were carried out. It was shown that the conditional means of the DNS agree well with those of the laminar flames including D T in the transport property calculation. The global and local NO formation characteristics were investigated. It was found that the mean NO production conditioned on the progress variable is lower compared with the corresponding laminar flame in the rich case. However, the relative contributions from various NO pathways are rarely affected by turbulence. The NO mass fraction is higher in negative curvature regions compared with positive curvature regions of the flame surface for the rich case, which is due to the preferential diffusion of H 2 and other radicals and the enhanced NO pathways in negatively curved regions.
Lean combustion has the potential to improve the thermal efficiency of spark-ignition engines, but it faces the significant challenge of increased cycle-to-cycle variation due to low mixture reactivity and unstable flame dynamics. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) employing predictive models can guide engine design and optimize operating strategies for lean combustion. However, ignition and combustion models have rarely been validated at fuel-lean conditions, and a fundamental understanding of the early flame kernel growth process is also lacking for a successful sub-model development. Here, the present study develops a numerical simulation framework used to investigate early flame kernel growth in methane/air mixtures. A nanosecond-pulsed discharge (NPD) approach is employed to effectively decouple the flame kernel growth from the electrical discharge due to their difference in timescales, and equivalence ratios near the experimentally measured lean flammability limit (LFL) are selected to focus on challenging mixture conditions. Three numerical investigations, such as the choice of turbulence modeling, grid size, and grid control strategies, are examined to match both LFL and flame kernel structure measured from experiments. It is demonstrated that a quasi-direct numerical simulation (QDNS) with a fixed grid embedding of 10 μm can predict the LFL as φ CFD =0.61 and match the displacement speed of the kernel’s boundary marked in schlieren images. To predict the LFL and flame kernel shape, a fine grid (Δ≤12.5 μm) is needed to capture the consumption of formaldehyde (CH 2 O) in kernel’s reaction branches attached to the anode, and adaptive mesh refinement is replaced with the fixed embedding due to loss of simulation accuracy. Also, it is found that a large-eddy simulation (LES) using the Dynamic Structure model is not suitable for the NPD-induced flame kernel simulation because artificial sub-grid turbulent kinetic energy induced by shock dynamics alters the flow velocity calculation, resulting in divergence of LES from QDNS. Lastly, the simulation well matches the experimental data for the flame kernel evolution in three mixture conditions (φ = 0.7, 0.61, 0.55), showing toroidal flame kernel expansion and flame kernel growth/extinction.