Ni-based alloys in direct-fired supercritical CO2 power cycle environments
Poster presentation titled Ni-based alloys in direct-fired supercritical CO2 power cycle environments at the 2023 High Temperature Corrosion Gordon Research Conference
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Poster presentation titled Ni-based alloys in direct-fired supercritical CO2 power cycle environments at the 2023 High Temperature Corrosion Gordon Research Conference
Paper reviews the research on packaging high temperature integrated circuits to operate at 300 C.
Nonmetallic materials are used in the United States Department of Energy's Hanford Site Tank Farm waste transfer system. These materials include the inner primary hoses in the hose-in-hose transfer lines (HIHTLs), Garlock{sup R} gaskets, ethylene propylene diene monomer (EPDM) O-rings, and other nonmetallic materials. These nonmetallic materials are exposed to β and γ radiation, caustic solutions as well as high temperature and pressure stressors. How the nonmetallic components react to each of these stressors individually has been well established. However, simultaneous exposure of these stressors has not been evaluated and is of great concern to Hanford Site engineers. Florida International University's Applied Research Center engineers worked closely with key Hanford's Washington River Protection Solutions personnel to develop an experimental test plan that determines how these nonmetallic components react to various simultaneous stressor exposures. In this paper, research on the experimental testing of the hose-in-hose transfer lines used in the Hanford tank farm waste transfer system under simultaneous stressor exposures is presented. The stressor exposure experiments consisted of various combinations of simultaneous stressor exposure of caustic solution, high temperature and high pressure stressors. Research efforts focused on evaluating the aging behavior of EPDM by exposing samples of HIHTLs as well as EPDM dog bone shaped specimens to a 25% NaOH solution at (38 deg. C), operating (54 deg. C) and design temperatures (77 deg. C) for 6 months and 12 months. In addition, HIHTL and the EPDM dog-bone specimens were exposed to only hot water at 77 deg. C for a duration of one year. The mechanical and material properties of the samples were characterized and compared with those of the unexposed samples (baseline). Evaluations included burst pressure tests of the EPDM hose-in-hose transfer lines and material tensile strength test of EPDM dog-bone coupons. Both the tensile strength of the EPDM material dog bones and the burst pressure of the HIHTLs significantly decreased with the increasing temperature and increasing exposure time. When compared with the baseline samples, the burst pressure decreased by 28.75% for the sample aged at 77 deg. C after 12 months, in comparison to sample aged at 38 deg. C and 54 deg. C which had about 1.34% and 5.70% loss in burst pressures, respectively, after 12-month exposure. (authors)
Abstract This research investigates the processing–structure–properties–performance relationship in a novel nickel-base superalloy, ABD ® -900AM, designed for extreme environments. Specifically tailored for additive manufacturing (AM), ABD ® -900AM maintains mechanical integrity at high temperatures and is comparable to other nickel-based superalloys with a 30–40% gamma-prime volume fraction. A comprehensive study was conducted using laser-beam powder bed fusion and electron-beam powder bed fusion methods. Factors such as heat treatment, porosity, build orientation, and hot isostatic pressing were evaluated to understand their effects on microstructure and mechanical performance. Microstructural characterization revealed significant differences in grain size and orientation across build processes and heat treatments. High-temperature mechanical testing indicated that grain size, heat treatment, and orientation significantly influence creep behavior. A super-solvus heat treatment led to recrystallization and grain growth, significantly improving creep properties compared to a near-solvus heat treatment. Various creep mechanisms were identified across different conditions, and creep rupture models were developed for each build process. Post-test microstructural analysis showed grain boundary damage, with differences in creep cavitation morphology under varying stress conditions. It was shown that MC carbides grow at the expense of gamma-prime near grain boundaries, leading to precipitate-free zones in specimens tested at higher temperatures. This study fills a significant gap in fundamental research by offering a deeper insight into the high-temperature mechanical behavior of additively manufactured nickel-base superalloys. It also explores critical research questions regarding the role of carbides and the significance of heat treatment. The insights gained enhance confidence in the industry adoption of ABD ® -900AM and similar alloys for high-temperature applications, bridging the knowledge gap and supporting the development of reliable AM processes for extreme environments.
Basic research, under this project, has led to new fundamental discoveries in the effect of electric field (and temperature) on diffusion kinetics, electroluminescence and electronic conductivity in ceramic materials. For example, yttria stabilized zirconia sinters in just seconds well below 1000°C, while, at the same time, exhibiting a highly non-linear rise in conductivity, and intense electroluminescence. The phenomenon has been shown to occur in nearly all ceramics whether they are ionic or electronic conductors, or insulators. The rise in conductivity leads to Joule heating but in-situ measurements with a platinum standard at APS and Brookhaven (NSLS-II) have shown that the temperatures are much below what would have been needed to sinter in a few seconds. We have explored the hypothesis that huge concentrations of Frenkel pairs of vacancies and interstitials are produced. While these point defects accelerate sintering (by the interstitials being transported to the pores and the vacancies to the grain boundaries), they may also produce electron-hole pairs which can impart high electrical conductivity or recombine to emit photons. Many measurements, including in-situ measurements of lattice expansion are consistent with this hypothesis. However, the energy barrier for generating Frenkels in zirconia for example is much larger than can be expected at temperature and electrical fields in these experiments. Most recent work suggests that short wavelength phonons play a critical role in the genesis of the “flash” phenomenon. For example, the Debye temperature has been shown to be the lower bound for initiating flash. Molecular dynamics simulations have shown that large concentrations of Frenkel pairs can form under the proliferation of “optical” phonons at the edge of the Brillouin zone, that is with a wavelength at or below the lattice parameter. This project has led to the development of new experimental techniques as well as a software hardware interface for process and control and data analysis in real time, with a time scale of less than one second. This approach spells a new paradigm in materials science research. It potential impact on high rate manufacturing is self evident.
Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) plants with Thermal Energy Storage (TES), require compressors capable of circulating supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO2) heat transfer fluids (HTFs) at temperatures from 500 to 700+°C and pressures from 8 to 25 MPa (80 to 250 Bar or 1160 to 3626 psia) in order to achieve thermal-to-electric efficiencies >50%. A review of papers relating to SCO2 compressors reveals that in almost every case the conditions being considered either allow for cooling of the SCO2 working fluid or are considering operating conditions close to the critical point at a temperature and pressure of approximately 31°C and 1070 psi). While the technology reported in these papers is relevant to most turbomachinery, the current CSP gas pathway circulator operating pressures are well above the CO2 critical point and do not allow for cooling of the main HTF flow. The purpose of this paper was to describe the key system issues affecting the design of a HTF circulator that could be scaled from a small size research and proof of concept circulator compressor to sizes supporting power plants producint upwards of 100 to 300 Mega Watts of electrical power. Due to the high temperatures and pressures the research scale HTF circulator was designed to be hermetically sealed to prevent leakage of the super critical carbon dioxide to the environment. In order to achieve hermetic sealing the drive motor and centrifugal impeller were fully integrated in a single shaft system configuration. From a preliminary assessment of compression power as a function of operating speed and impeller diameter it was determined that a smaller, higher speed impeller would result in a more efficient circulator. However, due to the high pressure and corresponding density of the sCO2 coupled with high operating speeds, large windage losses (i.e., viscous drag on the high speed rotating shaft) would occur which could result in a substantial reduction in efficiency of the system. Therefore tradoff studies were complerted to identify the operating speeds and system component sizes to achieve high efficiency. Based on the trade studies, the final design was a 55 mm diamter compressor impeller operating at speeds to 85,000 rpm. The unit will be built and tested in the future. Key Words: Super Critical Carbon Dioxide, Heat Transfer Fluid, Turbomachinery, Compressor, Circulator, Critical Point, Concentrating Solar Power, Solar Energy
The objective of the proposed research was to explore the feasibility of making measurements of high-k (electron-scale, ETG-relevant) electron temperature fluctuations in the core plasma of tokamaks and stellarators. We found that soft X-ray imaging combined with our novel pseudolocal tomographic algorithm enables local measurements of low-k (ion-scale, ITG/TEM and KBM/MTM relevant) electron temperature fluctuations in spherical tokamaks. The design parameters needed to consider deploying this new diagnostic are presented, and predictions for what the diagnostic would measure in L-mode and H-mode plasmas at NSTX-U, a high performance spherical tokamak in the USA, suggest that the new diagnostic can be used to study turbulence and transport over a wide range of plasma parameters, such as collisionality and plasma beta.
Beta gallium oxide (β-Ga2O3) shows significant promise in high-temperature, high-power, and sensing electronics applications. However, long-term stable metallization layers for Ohmic contacts at high temperatures present unique thermodynamic challenges. The current most common Ohmic contact design based on 20 nm of Ti has been repeatedly demonstrated to fail at even moderately elevated temperatures (300–400 °C) due to a combination of nonstoichiometric Ti/Ga2O3 interfacial reactions and kinetically favored Ti diffusion processes. Here, we demonstrate stable Ohmic contacts for Ga2O3 devices operating up to 500–600 °C using ultrathin Ti layers with a self-limiting interfacial reaction. The ultrathin Ti layer in the 5 nm Ti/100 nm Au contact stack is designed to fully oxidize while forming an Ohmic contact, thereby limiting both thermodynamic and kinetic instability. This novel contact design strategy results in an epitaxial conductive anatase titanium oxide interface layer that enables low-resistance Ohmic contacts that are stable both under long-term continuous operation (>500 h) at 600 °C in vacuum (≤10−4 Torr), as well as after repeated thermal cycling (15 times) between room temperature and 550 °C in flowing N2. This stable Ohmic contact design will accelerate the development of high-temperature devices by enabling research focus to shift toward rectifying interfaces and other interfacial layers.
The U. S. Department of Energy (DOE) has made a significant investment in research to develop the next generation of reactor technologies as well as to improve the performance and lengthen the life cycle of existing nuclear reactors. Data collected to demonstrate new concepts may also be used in the future to support licensing of these technologies. Provenance of these data must be preserved. The Nuclear Data Management and Analysis System (NDMAS) was established to manage and preserve data collected by fuels and materials research conducted by the high-temperature, gas-cooled reactor program. The scope of NDMAS is expanding to include other nuclear research programs that have the shared need to preserve the provenance of research data. Nuclear research funded by DOE is conducted by Idaho National Laboratory (INL), universities, other national laboratories, foreign research partners, and private companies. This research will generate a large amount of data from a variety of sources over a period of many years. Managing the data generated by the research and development projects presents a significant challenge for retaining data integrity and availability.
The United States High Performance Research Reactor (USHPRR) initiative is currently interested in replacing high-enriched uranium fuel in research reactors with high-assay low-enriched uranium fuel. Here, this work aimed to assist in that mission by providing tensile and bend test data on bare U-Mo and tensile test data on co-rolled Zr/U-10Mo plates at differing thicknesses (0.285 mm, 0.300 mm, and 0.465 mm) and temperatures (293 K, 473 K, and 623 K). Yield strength and ultimate tensile strength values are reported along with an in-depth comparison of how temperature, rolling direction, thickness, and the presence of the Zr-interlayer affect mechanical properties. Results showed that yield strength and ultimate tensile strength in Zr/U-10Mo foils lower as temperature increases by approximately 300 MPa from 293 to 473 K, and another 100 MPa from 473 to 623 K. Additionally it was found that with increased temperature, there is less differentiation in fuel necking and delamination behavior, as well as a greater perceived elongation to fracture. The elastic modulus of co-rolled mini-plates does not follow the volumetric rule of mixtures in terms of averaged strength and is actually lower than the reported moduli of both Zr and U-10Mo.
Since 2009, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Nuclear Energy's Nuclear Energy University Program (NEUP) has been at the forefront of nuclear research, specifically concentrating on advancing high-temperature gas-cooled reactor (HTGR) technologies. By Fiscal Year 2023, NEUP has authorized 35 projects dedicated to HTGR research, each contributing significantly to the enhancement of our understanding of this technology. The outcomes of these diverse projects have been disseminated through final NEUP reports, peer-reviewed journal articles, and presentations at academic conferences, forming a comprehensive tapestry of knowledge. Despite the substantial value of these findings, their dissemination has been fragmented, posing challenges for accessibility to researchers and policymakers and leading to underutilization of DOE investments. Recognizing this critical gap and its potential consequences for the future of nuclear research, the Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART) Gas-Cooled Reactor (GCR) program conducted an extensive survey of completed and ongoing HTGR NEUP projects. This survey enabled the compilation of crucial data, resulting in the development of a specialized public-access database tailored for computational fluid dynamics and system code validation, specifically designed for HTGR applications. However, the data collection process revealed a significant challenge in central data organization due to individual researchers from different institutes employing varying logics and preferences for recording and documenting experimental data. Consequently, an urgent need has been identified to establish a standardized reporting format for HTGR experimental projects. Addressing this issue is essential for enhancing collaboration, maximizing the impact of DOE investments, and ensuring the seamless advancement of HTGR technologies in nuclear research.
This final project report describes the research data and findings. This project aims to develop a new wireless high-temperature sensor network for real-time continuous boiler condition monitoring in harsh environments. Such a wireless high-temperature sensor network enables network-based automatic temperature sensing and data collection, which combined with artificial intelligent (AI) algorithms allow the construction of smart boiler systems with boiling condition management and optimization for significant energy-saving and reliability improvement
Abstract Increased interest in compact heat exchangers (CHXs) to serve as intermediate heat exchangers of very high temperature reactors resulted in significant research and development on their design, analysis, and construction. Printed circuit heat exchangers are a type of CHXs with high thermal efficiency and compactness achieved through diffusion bonding a stack of etched plates with millimeter scaled channels. The diffusion bonding process changes the microstructural and mechanical properties of the wrought metal plates. The current nonnuclear design code ASME section VIII, division 1 captures the material property change through a “joint efficiency factor.” However, the current nuclear design code ASME section III, division 5 does not address or support the diffusion bonded material properties. Hence, there is a need to develop allowable stresses, isochronous curves, and fatigue life curves for various diffusion bonded alloys. In this study, Alloy 800H material was selected to establish the diffusion bonded material properties under tension, creep, fatigue, and creep-fatigue loads at elevated temperatures in the range 550–760 °C. A set of tests on diffusion bonded Alloy 800H (DB 800H) were performed and the acquired data are used in developing allowable stresses Sy, Su, Sr, Sm, St, Smt, So, isochronous curves and fatigue life curves according to the ASME section III, division 5 requirements. This paper also presents detailed procedures used in developing the ASME code section III division 5 design provisions for diffusion bonded Alloy 800H.
Nuclear energy remains a critical component of a diversified and efficient energy portfolio, offering reliable, high-capacity, and low-carbon power. However, in the U.S., aging infrastructure and the slow qualification and deployment of advanced materials and manufacturing techniques hinder progress in next-generation reactor technologies. This study explores the application of laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) additive manufacturing for stainless steel 316H, with a focus on optimizing post-build heat treatments to enhance material properties for high-temperature nuclear applications. The research targets the optimization of stress-relief temperatures to alleviate postbuild residual stresses, ensuring improvements in the microstructural corelated properties. A series of microstructural and mechanical evaluations were performed on LPBF-printed SS-316H samples which were subjected to annealing at temperatures varying between 650 °C and 850 °C. X-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy analyses revealed that increasing the heattreatment temperature accelerated dislocation recovery. Vickers microhardness measurements showed an initial reduction in values, followed by stabilization over extended durations at all the temperatures. While higher temperatures facilitated faster recovery, they also promoted carbide precipitation along grain and solidification cell boundaries, narrowing the safe processing window. In contrast, heat treatment at 650°C preserved the cellular substructure and enabled controlled carbide precipitation over time. In conclusion, these findings highlight the importance of time–temperature optimization and suggest that 650°C for up to 2 h provides the most favorable balance between recovery and carbide control for a stress-relief treatment.
The mechanical strength properties of carbon fibers are generally thought to be correlated with the presence of underlying atomic-level defects. These defects serve to break the underlying translational symmetry of the graphitic or graphene subunits of the fiber construction, resulting in the emergence of new Raman-active spectral features. However, historical attempts to classify the precise origin of defect contributions to the Raman spectra have been challenging because of indistinct and overlapping features in the carbon fiber Raman spectra. Further, while substantial research exists on high-temperature exposure in inert atmospheres for carbon fiber composites, comparatively less addresses microscale behaviors and Raman spectral alterations to monofilament carbon fibers exposed to high-temperature atmospheric environments. Here, we report Raman spectral responses of nine commercially available high-performance, polyacrylonitrile-based carbon fibers exposed to various atmospheric heat treatments. In this work, we introduce a model-independent characterization method, the integrated absolute difference, to quantify the spectral responses to heat treatment of different fiber modulus classes. We combine this new method with a newly reported strategy to standardize spectral fitting for carbon fibers. With this approach, we show that atomic-scale defects in the underlying fiber microstructure manifest in measurably distinct manners and have distinct responses to thermal perturbation. These combined approaches may lay the foundation for disentangling contributions from specific defects in the Raman spectra of carbon fibers.
This limited scope study aims at preserving the results of experimental programs for the safety of light water cooled and advanced reactors by locating and documenting, to the extent possible, where the experimental test information for these programs has been archived. The Light Water Reactor Data Preservation Activity Team initially identified seven (7) experimental programs, exceeding the required five (5) in the scope of work, which were determined to be “at risk” of potentially losing valuable data. The seven (7) experimental programs/subject areas identified are (descriptions of each experiment/experience are provided in Section 3.0): 1. FERMI-1 Reactor Accident 2. Fission Product Behavior During the In-Pile Severe Fuel Damage Test SFD I-4 3. Containment Iodine Computer Code Exercise Based on Radioiodine Test Facility (RTF) Experiment 4. Wide Range Piping Integrity Demonstration (WIND) Project 5. Iodine Chemical Research in Canada 6. High Temperature Fission Product Chemistry and Transport in Steam 7. Anything related to radioactive Methyl Iodide.
This EPSCoR Project has been investigating the synergy between the excellent high-temperature mechanical behavior of FeMnNiAlCr high entropy alloys (HEA) and the high solar absorptance of their native oxides for high efficiency concentrated solar thermal power (CSP) systems working at >700°C. While HEAs have attracted substantial interest in recent years, most investigations have focused on their applications as structural materials rather than functional materials. This EPSCoR project discovered that FeMnNiAlCr HEAs can potentially be applied synergistically as both a structural and functional material for high-efficiency concentrating solar thermal power (CSP) systems working at >700°C. The HEA itself would be used in high-temperature tubing to carry molten salts or supercritical CO 2 , while its surface oxide would act as a high-efficiency solar thermal absorber. With Fe and Mn being the major components in these HEAs (adding up to ~70 at.% of the alloy), these materials are much more cost-effective than the Ni-based superalloys currently being investigated for high-temperature CSP systems. Through this research, these Fe-Mn based HEAs have demonstrated yield strengths 2-3x greater than that of stainless steel at 700°C and a creep lifetime >800 h at 700ºC under a typical CSP tubing mechanical load of 35 MPa. Their Mn-rich surface oxides maintain a high optical-to-thermal conversion efficiency of ~87% under 1000x solar concentration ratio for 20 simulated day-night thermal cycles between 750ºC and room temperature. In preliminary corrosion studies, these HEAs have sustained immersion in unpurified bromide molten salts for 14 days at 750°C with <2% weight loss, in contrast to 70% weight loss from a 316 stainless steel reference. The simultaneous achievement of promising mechanical, optical, and thermochemical properties in this FeMnNiAlCr system opens the door to new applications of HEAs in solar energy harvesting. Partnerships with Ames Laboratory and Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) also advanced our understanding of the fundamental structure-property relationships through atomic scale material characterization and first-principles computational modeling. The key research results in this project can potentially be extended to other HEAs and their native oxides. In terms of applications, the proposed FeMnNiAlCr HEA/native oxide system could potentially exceed the mechanical and the optical performance of existing tubing and solar coating materials under EERE’s CSP program at lower cost, which also aligns well with the EPSCoR Science and Technology strategies of New Hampshire in boosting the deployment of renewable energy.
In this research, material extrusion additive manufacturing (MEAM) has been explored as an SSAM method for fabrication of 3-D components using ODS-FeCrAl alloy. MEAM-printed 3-D parts go through a series of process steps, e.g., chemical treatment, thermal treatment etc. in order to create a high density fully metallic part. Final 3-D part quality is associated with various process steps, e.g., filament fabrication, print design, and thermal treatment optimization. In MEAM, a metal powder loaded filament is used for printing 3-D shapes. Composition of the filament is very important since it provides shape retention at low-to-medium temperature. There are a few commercially available metallic alloy filaments. However, FeCrAl alloy filaments are not commercially available. In this project, we came up with a method to fabricate high quality composite FeCrAl filaments that could be used for MEAM printing. Subsequently, we have optimized MEAM print methods to fabricate samples that are larger than 10 mm, by using a modular print design approach. Finally, we have been able to optimize the chemical and high temperature heat treatment steps to achieve very high density (>98%) in sintered MEAM-printed products.