Strategies towards enabling lithium metal in batteries: interphases and electrodes
Perspective on recent improvements in experiment and theory towards realizing lithium metal electrodes with liquid electrolytes.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Perspective on recent improvements in experiment and theory towards realizing lithium metal electrodes with liquid electrolytes.
Lithium–sulfur (Li–S) batteries continue to be considered promising post-lithium-ion batteries owing to their high theoretical energy density. In pursuit of a Li–S cell with long-term cyclability, most studies thus far have relied on using ether-based electrolytes. However, their limited ability to dissolve polysulfides requires a high electrolyte-to-sulfur ratio, which impairs the achievable specific energy. Recently, the battery community found high donor electrolytes to be a potential solution to this shortcoming because their high solubility toward polysulfides enables a cell to operate under lean electrolyte conditions. Despite the increasing number of promising outcomes with high donor electrolytes, a critical hurdle related to stability of the lithium-metal counter electrode needs to be overcome. This review provides an overview of recent efforts pertaining to high donor electrolytes in Li–S batteries and is intended to raise interest from within the community. Furthermore, based on analogous efforts in the lithium-air battery field, strategies for protecting the lithium metal electrode are proposed. In this review, it is predicted that high donor electrolytes will be elevated to a higher status in the field of Li–S batteries, with the hope that either existing or upcoming strategies will, to a fair extent, mitigate the degradation of the lithium–metal interface.
With numerous reports on protecting films for stable lithium (Li) metal electrodes, the key attributes for how to construct these efficient layers have rarely been fully investigated. Here, we report a rationally designed hybrid protective layer (HPL) with each component aligning with one key attribute; i.e., cross-linked poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) enhances flexibility, polyethylene glycol (PEG) provides homogeneous ion-conducting channels, and glass fiber (GF) affords mechanical robustness. A significant improvement of the electrochemical performance of HPL-modified electrodes can be achieved in Li/HPL@Cu half cells, HPL@Li/HPL@Li symmetric cells, and HPL@Li/LiFePO 4 full cells. Even with an industrial standard LiFePO 4 cathode (96.8 wt % active material), the assembled cell still exhibits a capacity retention of 90% after 100 cycles at 1 C. More importantly, the functionality of each component has been studied comprehensively via electrochemical and physical experiments and simulations, which will provide useful guidance on how to construct efficient protective layers for next-generation energy storage devices.
Ab initio molecular dynamics simulations were performed for Li + conducting electrolytes based on trimethyl phosphates (TMP) and lithium bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide (Li + FSI – ) salt in contact with a Li-metal electrode. We focused on the transient-state behavior at the electrolyte, interfacial electrolyte–Li-metal electrode, and lithium reference electrode–electrolyte–Li-metal electrode to study dynamics and activation energy barriers of the Li + ion, electrochemical and thermal stability of the interface electrode-electrolyte, and potential behavior of the Li-metal electrode, respectively. Our results show that in the most stable state, Li + ions are tetrahedrally coordinated to three TMPs and one FSI – . The inner solvation shell of a Li-ion is composed of three TMP and one FSI – in one contact ion-pair and four TMPs in a solvent-separated ion-pair. On the other hand, Li-ions transport through electrolyte cages takes place when they are coordinated with three or less molecules that could be a combination of TMPs and FSI – . The decomposition pathway of the LiFSI salt when in direct contact with the Li-metal anode starts with defluorination of FSI – , rapidly losing F– to the lithium surface, forming LiF species. The remaining FSO 2 NSO 2 –2 with the addition of 2e – from the Li-metal decomposes into SO 2 –2 and NFSO 2 –2 . SO 2 –2 deposits on the Li-surface and decomposes into Li 2 O and Li 2 S. The remaining NFSO 2 –2 defluorinates, losing F – ion to the lithium surface, resulting in LiF and the remaining NSO 2 –1 deposits on the lithium surface and decomposes in the following picoseconds, forming several binary compounds such as Li 3 N, Li 2 S and Li 2 O. In contrast, when the salt is solvated by the TMP molecules, avoiding a direct contact with the Li metal electrode, only one defluorination occurs, decomposing the FSI – into FSO 2 NSO 2 –2 and a F – . The two anions remain stable as they are solvated by the TMP molecules. Furthermore, we also analyzed the open circuit potential energy (OCPE) of the Li-metal electrode during the SEI formation. OCPE is calculated from the average local potential profile difference within the Li-metal electrode and a pristine Li-crystal reference electrode (LRE). When no SEI is formed, the Li-metal electrode has an average OCPE of +0.36 eV vs LRE. Due to the formation of a SEI, the Li-metal electrode has an average OCPE between -0.07 and -0.21 eV vs LRE. The OCPE of the Li-metal electrode decreases by ~0.42 eV when a SEI is formed.
A lithium-ion electrochemical cell comprises a first electrode, a second electrode comprising elemental silicon, a microporous separator membrane between the first and second electrodes, and an electrolyte in contact with the electrodes and the membrane. The electrolyte comprises a lithium salt at a concentration in the range of about 0.1 M to about 5 M, and an additional metal salt at a concentration in the range of about 0.001 to about 5 M dissolved in an organic solvent. The additional metal salt comprises a metal cation that can form a lithium-silicon-metal Zintl phase; and the first electrode comprises metallic lithium or a cathode active material capable of donating and accepting lithium ions to and from the second electrode during electrochemical cycling. Electrolytes for use with silicon-containing electrodes also are described.
Methods for making solid-state laminate electrode assemblies include methods to prevent devitrifying and damaging a lithium ion conducting sulfide glass substrate during thermal evaporation of lithium metal, as well as methods for making thin extruded lithium metal foils.
The Wadsley–Roth compound PNb 9 O 25 is a promising fast charging lithium ion battery anode material with high operating voltage to prevent solid electrolyte interface formation. Here, in this work, we present potentiometric entropy measurements featuring signatures of semiconductor-to-metal transition and intralayer ordering upon lithiation in the anode material PNb 9 O 25 that could not be observed with in situ X-ray diffraction. In addition, the instantaneous heat generation rates at the PNb 9 O 25 working electrode and at the lithium metal counter electrode during galvanostatic cycling were measured individually for the first time by operando isothermal calorimetry. The heat generation rate decreased at the PNb 9 O 25 electrode upon lithiation due to the decrease in electrical resistivity caused by the semiconductor-to-metal transition observed in potentiometric entropy measurements. Furthermore, the heat generation rate at the lithium metal electrode was positive during delithiation due to the exothermic plating of Li + ions on the lithium metal counter electrode associated with dendrite formation. Furthermore, calorimetric measurements established that the entropy change dominated the reversible heat generation rate at each electrode. Finally, the contribution of enthalpy of mixing was relatively small even at high C-rates thanks to the high Li + ion mobility in PNb 9 O 25 confirming its promises as a fast charging anode material.
Disclosed are methods for pre-conditioning or pre-treating the surface of a metal (e.g., lithium) electrode such that the cycle life and efficiency of the electrode within an electrochemical cell are improved through the prevention of dendrite growth. The pretreatment process includes the use of an alternating current to modify the surface properties of the metal electrode, such that a more uniform flux of metal ions is transferred across the electrode-electrolyte Interface in subsequent electrodeposition and electrodissolution processes. As a result, an electrode treated with such a process exhibits improved performance and durability, including markedly lower overpotentials and largely improved metal (e.g., lithium) retention in strip plate tests as compared with untreated electrodes.
High-rate capable, reversible lithium metal anodes are necessary for next generation energy storage systems. In situ tomography of Li/LLZO/Li cells is carried out to track morphological transformations in Li metal electrodes. Machine learning enables tracking the lithium metal morphology during galvanostatic cycling. Nonuniform lithium electrode kinetics are observed at both electrodes during cycling. Hot spots in lithium metal are correlated with microstructural anisotropy in LLZO. Mesoscale modeling reveals that regions with lower effective properties (transport and mechanical) are nuclei for failure. Advanced visualization combined with electrochemistry represents an important pathway toward resolving non-equilibrium effects that limit rate capabilities of solid-state batteries.
An electrochromic device comprising a counter electrode layer comprised of lithium metal oxide which provides a high transmission in the fully intercalated state and which is capable of long-term stability, is disclosed. Methods of making an electrochromic device comprising such a counter electrode are also disclosed.
Metal oxides have been actively explored as promising conversion-type electrode materials for lithium ion batteries due to high deliverable capacity but still notorious for poor cyclability, capacity fading, voltage hysteresis, etc. Yet, the fundamental reason for the undesirable properties of metal oxides behind the repetitive conversion process is still obscure. In this work, we take advantage of synchrotron X-ray techniques as well as transmission electron microscopy to monitor the structural changes during both conversion (lithiation) and reconversion (delithiation) reactions. Difference in diffusion rates of lithium and metal plays a decisive role in determining the reaction pathway. We find lithium accommodation and extraction occur via different reaction routes: lithiation follows a kinetically driven way while delithiation adopts a route close to the thermodynamic ground state path. Thermodynamic structural evolution features the formation of an intermediate phase of Li-Metal (M)-O, suggesting lithium removal accompanies with the Li/M ionic exchange and rearrangement of oxygen framework. The slow diffusion of metal ions and the high kinetic and energy barrier for dissociating the intermediate phase are mainly responsible for uncompleted reconversion reaction, evidenced by remaining Li-M-O phase at the end of charge. Imperfect reconversion reaction eventually limits the utilization of lithium ions over the repeated cycling. Furthermore, this work sheds light on structural changes occurring at metal oxides during both conversion and reconversion processes, which is strongly linked with the performances of conversion-type materials in applications.
Solid-state batteries (SSBs) offer a safer, higher-energy-density alternative to lithium-ion batteries, yet commercialization is hindered by incompatibility with lithium metal. Here, to overcome these challenges, we developed a cost-effective, commercially available prelithiated micro carbon fiber framework (Li-Cf) anode featuring a high-pressure-tolerance, for use with argyrodite solid-state electrolytes (SSEs). This 3D structure accommodates uniform lithium deposition, simplifies cell assembly under elevated pressure, inhibits dendrite growth toward SSEs, reduces heat generation, and enhances overall compatibility. Notably, our architecture enables the cell to tolerate pressures up to 400 MPa without short-circuiting during assembly. Meanwhile, the 3D framework serves as a preferential pathway for lithium deposition, thereby reducing lithium growth toward the SSEs and mitigating the risk of dendrite formation in SSEs. Operando calorimetry and distribution of relaxation times analysis reveal that lithium morphology degradation at the interface with the SSEs is a key failure mechanism in lithium metal argyrodite SSBs, leading to increased diffusion resistance and heat generation. In contrast, the Li-Cf anode mitigates these issues by reducing both heat flux and charge transfer resistance. Full cells with LiNi 0.8 Co 0.1 Mn 0.1 O 2 /Li 6 PS 5 Cl/Li-Cf retain ~79% capacity after 600 cycles, demonstrating significantly improved cycling stability and strong potential for practical energy storage applications.
We report the practical application of lithium (Li) metal electrodes is impeded by Li dendrite growth and unstable solid electrolyte interphase (SEI). Herein, a multi-grafting polymer network, poly(dimethyl siloxane)-g-[poly(poly(ethylene glycol) methyl ether methacrylate)-r-sodium poly(p-styrene sulfonate)] (PPS), is chemically synthesized from reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization. With integrated stretchability, ionic conductivity, and mechanical robustness, it serves a dual role to stabilize the Li electrode. As artificial SEI layer, the PPS enables superior electrochemical performance in half cells, symmetric cells, and full cells (PPS@Li/LiFePO 4 , capacity retention of >70% after 600 cycles). Utilized as solid polymer electrolyte (SPE), the all-solid-state Li/SPE/LiFePO 4 full cell delivers excellent cycling performance with an unprecedented capacity retention of 90% over 1,700 cycles at 0.5 C and 81% over 1,000 cycles at 1.0 C. With high-voltage LiNi 0.8 Mn 0.1 Co 0.1 O 2 (NMC811) as cathode, the Li/SPE/NMC811 cell exhibits an initial discharge capacity of 162.2 mAh g -1 with a capacity retention of 72% after 200 cycles. The assembled solid-state Li/SPE/LiFePO4 pouch cell with SPE exhibits stable cycling performance over 200 cycles with a capacity retention of 75% and still operates well even after curling, folding, and cutting, demonstrating great potential for achieving ultra-safe and high energy density batteries.
A primary barrier preventing repetitive fast charging of Li-ion batteries is lithium metal plating at the graphite anode. One approach toward mitigating Li metal deposition is the deliberate modification of the graphite anode surface with materials demonstrating high overpotentials unfavorable for Li metal nucleation, such as Ni or Cu nanoscale films. This research explores Ni and Cu surface coatings at different areal loadings (3 or 11 μg cm -2 ) on the electrochemistry of graphite/LiNi 0.6 Mn 0.2 Co 0.2 O 2 (NMC622) type Li-ion batteries. Extended galvanostatic cycling of control and metal-coated electrodes in graphite/NMC622 pouch cells are conducted under high rate conditions. Based on the overpotential of Li deposition on metal foil, both Ni and Cu treatments were anticipated to result in reduced lithium deposition. The higher metal film loadings of 11 μg cm -2 Ni- or Cu-coated electrodes exhibit the highest capacity retention after 500 cycles, with mean improvements of 8% and 9%, respectively, over uncoated graphite electrodes. Li plating quantified by X-ray diffraction indicates that the metal films effectively reduce the quantity of plated Li compared to untreated electrodes, with 11 μg cm -2 Cu providing the greatest benefit.
Lithium (Li) metal electrode cannot endure elevated temperature (e.g., >200 °C) with the regular battery configuration due to its low melting point (180.5 °C) and high reactivity, which restricts its application in high-temperature Li metal batteries for energy storage and causes safety concerns for regular ambient-temperature Li metal batteries. Herein, this work reports a Li 5 B 4 /Li composite featuring a 3D Li 5 B 4 fibrillar framework filled with metallic Li, which maintains its initial structure at 325 °C in Ar atmosphere without leakage of the liquid Li. The capillary force caused by the porous structure of the Li 4 B 5 fibrillar framework, together with its lithiophilic surface, restricts the leakage of liquid metallic Li and enables good thermal tolerance of the Li 5 B 4 /Li composite. Thus, it can be facilely operated for rechargeable high-temperature Li metal batteries. Li 5 B 4 /Li electrodes are coupled with a garnet-type ceramic electrolyte (Li 6.5 La 3 Zr 0.5 Ta 1.5 O 12 ) to fabricate symmetric cells, which exhibit stable Li stripping/plating behaviors with low overpotential of approximate to 6 mV at 200 °C using a regular sandwich-type cell configuration. This study affords new insights into realizing a stable Li metal anode for high-temperature Li metal batteries with a simple battery configuration and high safety, which is different from traditional molten-salt Li metal batteries using a pristine metallic Li anode.
Serving as a proof of concept, additive manufacturing and electrophoretic deposition are leveraged in this work to enable structural lithium-ion batteries with load-bearing and energy storage dual functionality. The preparation steps of a complex 3D printed copper current collector, involving the formulation of a photocurable resin formulation, as well as the vat photopolymerization process followed by a precursors-based solution soaking step and thermal post-processing are presented. Compression and microhardness testing onto the resulting 3D printed copper current collector are shown to demonstrate adequate mechanical performance. Electrophoretic deposition of graphite as a negative electrode active material and other additives was then performed onto the 3D printed copper collector, with the intention to demonstrate energy storage functionality. Half-cell electrochemical cycling of the 3D multi-material current collector/negative electrode versus lithium metal finally demonstrates that structural battery components can be successfully obtained through this approach.
Substituted Li-layered transition-metal oxide (LTMO) electrodes such as Li x Ni y Mn z Co 1-y-z O 2 (NMC) and Li x Ni y Co 1-y-z Al z O 2 (NCA) show reduced first cycle Coulombic efficiency (90-87% under standard cycling conditions) in comparison with the archetypal Li x CoO 2 (LCO; similar to 98% efficiency). Focusing on Li x Ni 0.8 Co 0.15 Al 0.0.5 O 2 as a model compound, we use operando synchrotron X-ray diffraction (XRD) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to demonstrate that the apparent first-cycle capacity loss is a kinetic effect linked to limited Li mobility at x > 0.88, with near full capacity recovered during a potentiostatic hold following the galvanostatic charge- discharge cycle. This kinetic capacity loss, unlike many capacity losses in LTMOs, is independent of the cutoff voltage during delithiation and it is a reversible process. The kinetic limitation manifests not only as the kinetic capacity loss during discharge but as a subtle bimodal compositional distribution early in charge and, also, a dramatic increase of the charge-discharge voltage hysteresis at x > 0.88. 7 Li NMR measurements indicate that the kinetic limitation reflects limited Li transport at x > 0.86. Electrochemical measurements on a wider range of LTMOs including Li x (Ni,Fe) y Co 1-y O 2 suggest that 5% substitution is sufficient to induce the kinetic limitation and that the effect is not limited to Ni substitution. In this paper, we outline how, in addition to a reduction in the number of Li vacancies and shrinkage of the Li-layer size, the intrinsic charge storage mechanism (two-phase vs solid-solution) and localization of charge give rise to additional kinetic barriers in NCA and nonmetallic LTMOs in general.
Disclosed are electrochemical devices and methods for making electrochemical devices such as metal infiltrated electrodes for solid state lithium ion and lithium metal batteries. In one method for forming an electrode, a metal is infiltrated into the pore space of the active material of the electrode providing improved electronic conductivity to the electrode. The electrode may also include a solid-state ion conducting material providing improved ion conductivity to the electrode. Before infiltration of the metal, a stabilization coating may be applied to the active material and/or the solid-state ion conducting material to the stabilize electrode interfaces by slowing, but not eliminating, the chemical reactions that occur at elevated temperatures during sintering of the active material and/or the solid-state ion conducting material forming the electrode.