On the Prospect of Chemically Transferable Coarse-Grained Electronic Models for Soft Materials
Electronic coarse-graining (ECG) methods predict quantum-mechanical electronic properties directly from coarse-grained (CG) molecular configurations, enabling electronic predictions at mesoscale length scales. Here, we present a diagnostic assessment of the feasibility of chemically transferable ECG models across a broad polymer-relevant chemical space using all-atom, united-atom, and Martini-scale representations. While high-resolution ECG models achieve near-quantitative accuracy, we show that chemically transferable ECG at the Martini resolution fails because the CG force field does not sample the same configurational distribution of local molecular structure as that underlying the DFT-parameterized ECG model. We demonstrate that our proposed Element-Count-Label (ECL) representation, which augments Martini beads with explicit stoichiometric data, significantly improves chemical generalization across diverse polymer chemistries. However, we find that even with improved chemical resolution, the model cannot recover electronic property distributions that are absent from the configurational space sampled by the CG force field. These results demonstrate that chemically transferable ECG requires future Martini-like force fields to explicitly preserve quantum chemistry–compatible local molecular structure in addition to thermodynamic and structural fidelity.