Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Nudging”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2026

Energetics of the nucleation and glide of disconnection modes in symmetric tilt grain boundaries

Grain boundaries (GBs) evolve by the nucleation and glide of disconnections, which are dislocations with a step character. In this work, motivated by recent success in predicting GB properties such as the shear coupling factor and mobility from the intrinsic properties of disconnections, we develop a systematic method to calculate the energy barriers for the nucleation and glide of individual disconnection modes under arbitrary driving forces and a quasi-2D setting. This method combines tools from bicrystallography to enumerate disconnection modes and the Nudged elastic band (NEB) method to calculate their energetics, yielding minimum energy paths and atomistic mechanisms for the nucleation and glide of each disconnection mode. We apply the method to accurately predict shear coupling factors of $[001]$ symmetric tilt grain boundaries in Cu. Particular attention is paid to the boundaries where the dislocation-based disconnection nucleation model produces incorrect nucleation barriers. We demonstrate that the method can accurately compute energy barriers and predict shear-coupling factors in the low-temperature regime. For certain disconnection modes in which the assumptions underlying our method do not hold, we report upper bounds on the energy barriers for disconnection nucleation and glide. In addition, the NEB trajectories reveal interesting phenomena such as the dissociation of a higher energy mode into lower energy modes, and in some cases, shear coupling being mediated by partial disconnections, wherein the GB structure temporarily changes to a metastable state before reverting back to its original structure. Graphical abstract

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Atomistic determination of Peierls barriers of dislocation glide in nickel

The Peierls barrier measures the lattice resistance to dislocation glide in crystalline solids. We use the nudged elastic band (NEB) method to calculate the Peierls barriers for screw and edge dislocation glide in a face-centered cubic (FCC) metal of Ni. The minimum energy paths (MEPs) across single or sequential Peierls barriers are determined under shear loading. The NEB results show the decreasing Peierls barrier with increasing shear stress, giving the Peierls stress at which the Peierls barrier vanishes. The effects of boundary condition and system size on Peierls barriers are studied by comparing strain- and stress-controlled NEB results. Furthermore, the free-end NEB methods are applied to determine MEPs with improved computational efficiency. The NEB results are also used to evaluate the energetic driving force of dislocation glide, which is consistent with that determined from the Peach-Koehler force. The accuracy of the present NEB results based on an empirical interatomic potential is assessed by comparison with a machine-learning potential. This work demonstrates the robust and efficient quantification of Peierls barriers to dislocation glide in an FCC metal, and it lays a solid foundation for the atomistic determination of Peierls barriers in compositionally complex alloys with the FCC structure in future studies.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2026

Revealing the Defect‐Driven Ferroelectric Mechanisms of Aluminum Nitride

Wurtzite III-nitride compounds are CMOS-compatible with widespread industrial interest to exercise ferroelectricity, despite their polar structure being highly resistant to polarization reversal. Here, we induce and tune ferroelectric properties in w-AlN via direct-write ion-beam processing, using nanoscale patterned defect engineering as a post-growth alternative to conventional cation substitution. Nanometric piezoresponse spectroscopy of the focused He + beam patterned defect concentrations in ferroelectric Al 0.92 B 0.08 N measures a localized 10x enhancement in effective piezoresponse and 40% reduction in switching barrier. The irradiation-induced point defects convert piezoelectric AlN into a ferroelectric system with site-saturated nucleation and raise the dielectric susceptibility, switched polarization, and effective piezoelectric coefficient. Enhanced defect-lattice interactions in AlN increase carrier conduction and phonon scattering loss but preserve long-range crystallinity. Here, based on atomistic analysis of nudged elastic band density functional theory calculations and reactive force field simulations, both nitrogen vacancies and defect complexes disrupt bond ordering, facilitating a line-by-line low-barrier switching of pristine AlN.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Water‐mediated Decomposition Pathways of ε‐Hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane

The dominant initial decomposition mechanism of 2,4,6,8,10,12-hexanitro-2,4,6,8,10,12-hexaazaisowurtzitane (HNIW) is understood from the literature to be the N─NO 2 bond scission unimolecular mechanism. Here we have found a water-mediated HONO release initial decomposition mechanism energetically competitive with the N─NO 2 bond scission mechanism modeled using ab initio nudged elastic band simulations. The activation energy of the water-mediated HONO mechanism was calculated to be 138.9 kJ/mol with the Perdew, Burke, and Ernzerhof (PBE) functional (177.8 with PBE0), while the double NO 2 release mechanism is 171.9 kJ/mol (203.3 with PBE0). Branching secondary, tertiary, and quaternary decomposition steps were also discovered including oxidation of HONO or H 2 O causing ring-opening that leads to C─N bond breaking and N 2 O or NO release. The reaction rate of HONO oxidation is much faster than HONO release, making the HONO concentration low. The Helmholtz free energy barrier of the double NO 2 release mechanism is lower than the water-mediated HONO release above 438 K (165°C) due to the vibrational contribution to the free energy. This helps explain why the literature reports more NO 2 release at higher temperatures. The present study reveals a physical mechanism for how water can catalyze the decomposition of HNIW at low enough temperatures, and reveals secondary, tertiary, and quaternary reaction mechanisms leading to NO x release. In conclusion, as water is realistically always present, the reported barriers are important for building kinetic models needed to ensure the safety and reliability of HNIW.

Steele, Brad A. [Lawrence Livermore National Labor↗
DOE OSTI2021

Long-term single-column model intercomparison of diurnal cycle of precipitation over midlatitude and tropical land

General Circulation Models (GCMs) have for decades exhibited difficulties in modelling the diurnal cycle of precipitation (DCP). This issue can be related to inappropriate representation of the processes controlling sub-diurnal phenomena like convection. In this study, 11 single-column versions of GCMs are used to investigate the interactions between convection and environmental conditions, processes that control nocturnal convections, and the transition from shallow to deep convection on a diurnal time-scale. Long-term simulations are performed over two continental land sites: the Southern Great Plains (SGP) in the USA for 12 summer months from 2004 to 2015 and the Manacapuru site at the central Amazon (MAO) in Brazil for two full years from 2014 to 2015. The analysis is done on two regimes: afternoon convective regime and nocturnal precipitation regime. Most models produce afternoon precipitation too early, likely due to the missing transition of shallow-to-deep convection in these models. At SGP, the unified convection schemes better simulate the onset time of precipitation. At MAO, models produce the heating peak in a much lower level compared with observation, indicating too shallow convection in the models. For nocturnal precipitation, models that produce most of nocturnal precipitation all allow convection to be triggered above the boundary layer. This indicates the importance of model capability to detect elevated convection for simulating nocturnal precipitation. Sensitivity studies indicate that (a) nudging environmental variables towards observations has a minor impact on DCP, (b) unified treatment of shallow and deep convection and the capability to capture mid-level convection can help models better capture DCP, and (c) the interactions of the atmosphere with other components in the climate system (e.g. land) are also important for DCP simulations in coupled models. Finally, these results provide long-term statistical insights on which physical processes are essential in climate models to simulate DCP.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2022

Atmospheric teleconnection associated with the Atlantic multidecadal variability in summer: assessment of the CESM1 model

Observational analysis shows that the Atlantic multidecadal variability (AMV) is associated with climate variability in the Northern Hemisphere through a zonal atmospheric teleconnection extending from the North Atlantic Ocean and propagating eastward around the Northern Hemisphere. Here, we studied the fidelity of model simulations in reproducing the observed summer AMV and the associated impacts on the mid-latitude climate by analysing simulations using the National Centre for Atmospheric Research Community Earth System Model Version 1 (CESM1), including CESM1 North Atlantic idealized and pacemaker simulations, CESM1 large ensemble twentieth century uninitialized simulations and large ensemble initialized CESM1 decadal predictions. To further compare the fidelity of CESM1, we also analysed large ensemble simulations from three other models. Our results suggest that the uninitialized large ensemble simulations from all models can produce an AMV time evolution and its regional climate impacts similar to the observations to certain degree. By initializing the observed oceanic condition in decadal prediction simulations, the simulated AMV and its regional impacts are closer to the observed ones than those in uninitialized ensemble simulations. In addition, the pacemaker simulations that nudged the time-evolving observed North Atlantic sea surface temperature anomalies produce spatiotemporal characteristics of the AMV and AMV climate impacts closer to the observed ones than the uninitialized simulations. We conclude that although coupled models can produce AMV and its regional impacts similar to observed, proper initialization and bias correction of the sea surface temperature spatial and temporal structure can improve this capability.

Initialization↗
DOE OSTI2021

Adsorption and Surface Diffusion of Metals on α-Al2O3 for Advanced Manufacturing Applications

Abstract The adsorption and diffusion of Mo and Nb adatoms on the $$\alpha$$ α -Al 2 O 3 (0001) surface were explored using density functional theory-based methods. Adsorption energies of Mo and Nb adatoms at minima sites on the surface were determined. Mo and Nb adatoms prefer to adsorb to the same locations on the surface, and larger adsorption energies calculated for Nb compared to Mo indicate that Nb adatom-surface interactions are stronger than Mo. Using minima adsorption sites as initial and final locations for surface diffusion, energy barriers for diffusion were calculated using the nudged elastic band method. Overall, Mo and Nb follow roughly the same diffusion paths. The diffusion pre-factors for Mo and Nb are similar; however, Mo diffusion has a lower energy barrier and thus a larger diffusion coefficient compared with Nb. These results provide insight into the role of surface diffusion of Mo and Nb adatoms during advanced manufacturing processes.

Biaggne, Austin (ORCID:0000000328074960)↗
DOE OSTI2022

Atomistic modeling of surface and grain boundary dislocation nucleation in FCC metals

Dislocation nucleation plays a critical role in the plastic deformation of crystalline materials. However, it is challenging to predict the active mode and associated rate of dislocation nucleation under typical experimental loading conditions through molecular dynamics simulation due to timescale limitations. In this report we use the free-end nudged elastic band method to determine the activation energies and activation volumes of dislocation nucleation in four typical face-centered cubic metals of Au, Al, Cu and Ni. We focus on the representative processes of surface and grain boundary dislocation nucleation. The atomistically determined activation volumes of these dislocation nucleation processes are larger than 10b3 (with b being the Burgers vector length) under typical experimental loading conditions. These results are compared with experimentally measured activation volumes in ultrafine-grained and nanocrystalline metals, thereby providing mechanistic insight into their rate-controlling deformation mechanisms.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

An automated cluster surface scanning method for exploring reaction paths on metal-cluster surfaces

Metal-cluster surfaces present a wide variety of unique coordination environments. This complexity makes it difficult to manually probe the surface reactivity of such clusters. Here, we present a simple and automated method to systematically discover reaction pathways on cluster surfaces, based on the automated cluster surface scanning (ACSS) technique for mapping out potential energy surfaces. We showcase our method on 55-atom icosahedral Cu and Ag clusters, where we determine the activation energies of four elementary steps common in heterogeneous catalysis – hydrogen recombination (H* + H* → H 2 * + *), oxygen recombination (O* + O* → O 2 * + *), water formation (OH* + H* → H 2 O* + *), and CO oxidation (CO* + O* → CO 2 * + *) – with density functional theory calculations (DFT-PBE + D3). We show that the ACSS method requires significantly less human effort than the established manually performed climbing-image nudged elastic band (MP + CI-NEB) technique and locates transition states with comparable accuracy (root-mean-squared error of 0.10 eV) and similar computational cost. Rigorous sampling of the potential energy surface with the ACSS method allows one to locate all lowest-energy reaction pathways obtained via the MP+CI-NEB approach, as well as alternative pathways that one may have missed with the MP+CI-NEB approach due to the many possible pathways available on these clusters. The accuracy and efficiency afforded by the ACSS method could enable high-throughput exploration of the diverse reactivity of metal clusters.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Hydrogen Localization and Cluster Formation in α-Zr from First-Principles Investigations

We report alpha-zirconium (α-Zr) is a hydrogen atom host material used in nuclear energy and semiconducting applications due to Zr's excellent properties such as corrosion resistance, low thermal neutrons cross-section, and thermodynamically favorable interstitial sequestering of H atoms. Herein we use density functional theory simulations to systematically analyze the initial stages of H insertion in the Zr matrix, and determine optimal hydrogen localization, distribution, and clustering tendencies from a thermodynamics and kinetics perspective. Our results suggest that H occupation of tetrahedral sites is strongly favored, consistent with previous experimental and theoretical studies. Further, a cooperative effect in H localization is shown where H atoms favor clustering. The H pair is found to be the most stable by occupying tetrahedral sites with pairs at second nearest-neighbor positions (TTn2). Among the four H atom clusters, the most favorable configuration has two TTn2 pairs forming "box " or "zig-zag" shaped-cluster with the pairs separated by 3.03 or 3.25 Å, respectively. Nudged elastic band simulations suggest that the formation of TTn2 is facile and is limited by the small diffusion barrier of the monomer of less than 0.1 eV. Further, the formation routes for the 4H atom clusters are also presented. The current study can serve as a foundation to systematically model H atom clustering in metals and alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Ensemble variational Fokker-Planck methods for data assimilation

Particle flow filters solve Bayesian inference problems by smoothly transforming a set of particles into samples from the posterior distribution. Particles move in state space under the flow of an McKean-Vlasov-Itˆo process. This work introduces the Variational Fokker-Planck (VFP) framework for data assimilation, a general approach that includes previously known particle flow filters as special cases. The McKean-Vlasov-Itˆo process that transforms particles is defined via an optimal drift that depends on the selected diffusion term. It is established that the underlying probability density - sampled by the ensemble of particles - converges to the Bayesian posterior probability density. For a finite number of particles the optimal drift contains a regularization term that nudges particles toward becoming independent random variables. Based on this analysis, we derive computationally-feasible approximate regularization approaches that penalize the mutual information between pairs of particles, and avoid particle collapse. Moreover, the diffusion plays a role akin to a particle rejuvenation approach that aims to alleviate particle collapse. The VFP framework is very flexible. Different assumptions on prior and intermediate probability distributions can be used to implement the optimal drift, and localization and covariance shrinkage can be applied to alleviate the curse of dimensionality. A robust implicit-explicit method is discussed for the efficient integration of stiff McKean- Vlasov-Itˆo processes. Here, the effectiveness of the VFP framework is demonstrated on three progressively more challenging test problems, namely the Lorenz ’63, Lorenz ’96 and the quasi-geostrophic equations.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2021

Density functional theory calculations of the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of point defects in β -U

Density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of point defects in the β phase of uranium are reported. Defect energies and entropies were calculated using 2 x 2 x 2 supercells and the Generalized Gradient Approximation (GGA) of Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) for the exchange-correlation potential. Due to computational cost, calculations of the vibrational properties governing entropies were performed by only displacing atoms within (roughly) the 3rd or 4th nearest neighbor shell of the defect, which implicitly assumes that atoms beyond this distance are unaffected by the defect. Migration barriers were estimated by nudged elastic band (NEB) calculations. The low symmetry of the β-U phase (the unit cell is tetragonal and contains 30 atoms) results in many point defect configurations and even more migration pathways. A connectivity map, starting from the most stable point defects, was developed in order to identify the rate-limiting step controlling the net diffusion rate in each crystallographic direction. The uranium self-diffusivity tensor was calculated by combining the defect formation energies, entropies, migration barriers and attempt frequencies. The fastest diffusion rate was determined to be a vacancy mechanism in the z crystallographic direction. The predicted uranium self-diffusivity for this mechanism agrees well with available experimental data. Finally, the diffusion mechanisms and rates identified in this study will inform fuel performance models of swelling and gas evolution.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2026

The impact of chemistry on anion migration in bixbyite-structured lanthanide oxides

This manuscript describes atomistic calculations of oxygen vacancy and interstitial migration in bixbyite structured lanthanide oxides. We examine two types of compounds, one in which only one type of lanthanide cation is present and a second class in which two lanthanides are present in a 3:1 ratio as dictated by the symmetry of the bixbyite crystal structure. Using temperature accelerated dynamics and the nudged elastic band method, we quantify the role of chemistry on the energy barriers for the most important pathways for both vacancy and interstitial migration. We then analyze the impact of these variations on the overall diffusivity of each defect, quantifying the contribution of each pathway using the theory of kinosons. We find that vacancy mobility can vary by as much as three orders of magnitude through changes in chemistry at 500 K. Changes in interstitial mobility are more modest but can still vary by an order of magnitude. This points to the ability to tune the mass transport characteristics of these compounds through appropriate choices in chemistry. We have also included supplementary information containing the atomic structures of the relevant pathways.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Li + Diffusion in Amorphous and Crystalline Al 2 O 3 for Battery Electrode Coatings

Al 2 O 3 is often applied protectively to lithium-ion battery anode and cathode materials to inhibit surface degradation, suppress dendrite formation, and relieve mechanical stresses. Given the very high intrinsic band gap and diffusion barrier of the material, the mechanism that allows Li diffusion through these coatings is not well understood, and widely varying laboratory results indicate that there may be dependencies on morphology and stoichiometry. Using nudged elastic band calculations and ab initio molecular dynamics, we perform a systematic investigation across Al 2 O 3 structures, both crystalline and amorphous, and at various concentrations of Li + to uncover the optimal parameters for maximally diffusive coatings. We find a correlation between the low proximity of Li + to Al 3+ and the low Li + migration barrier. Although barriers are the lowest in the highly diffusive one-dimensional channels of crystalline θ-Al 2 O 3 , the system is structurally delicate and subject to detrimental distortion as the Li + content is increased. The α-Al 2 O 3 lattice is, conversely, highly stable against distortion at all Li + concentrations but disadvantageous for Li + migration. In amorphous systems, unscreened Li + –Li + Coulomb repulsion and pre-emptive occupation of “trapping sites” combine to lower the energy barriers as a function of increasing concentration. One of our most important findings is that Al-deficient materials can sharply increase Li + movement, and we predict that an amorphous material with a combination of high Li + concentration and Al deficiency would enable highly Li + -conductive protective coatings for electrodes.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Influence of External Conditions on the Black-to-Yellow Phase Transition of CsPbI 3 Based on First-Principles Calculations: Pressure and Moisture

All-inorganic CsPbI 3 perovskite has emerged as a promising candidate for next-generation solar cells. However, owing to the poor structural stability of black phase CsPbI 3 perovskite at room temperature, it spontaneously transforms to the yellow, photoinactive, nonperovskite phase at room temperature, limiting further development of CsPbI 3 perovskite solar cells. Here, to better understand the mechanism driving such undesirable phase transformation, we examine the thermodynamics and kinetics associated with γ-to-δ phase transformation using density functional theory calculation. A solid-state nudged elastic band method was employed to find minimum energy pathways assuming a concerted solid-state phase transformation between these two phases. The gas molecules representing atmospheric (H 2 O, O 2 , and N 2 ) and inert (Ar) ambient environments, as well as applied external pressure, were considered to examine the influence of external conditions on the black-to-yellow phase transition. Our calculation reveals that, with increasing pressure, the thermodynamic driving force for converting the γ-phase to the δ-phase increases, whereas a larger activation energy must be overcome for the phase transition to occur. We also investigate the moisture-induced phase transformation with an H 2 O molecule and its dissociated species (H + /OH – ) and demonstrate that the reaction energy barriers can be significantly lowered in the presence of H 2 O or OH – . On the other hand, other nonpolar species (O 2 , N 2 , and Ar) have a negligible effect on the phase transformation kinetics, while they might reduce the thermodynamic driving force for the phase transformation and suppress the undesirable phase transformation. Our theoretical prediction could support recent observations that the γ-to-δ phase transformation occurs rapidly and catalytically in the presence of moisture, whereas in dry argon and dry oxygen atmospheres, the γ-CsPbI 3 remains stable.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2024

Evaluating Material Design Principles for Calcium-Ion Mobility in Intercalation Cathodes

Multivalent-ion batteries offer an alternative to Li-based technologies, with the potential for greater sustainability, improved safety, and higher energy density, primarily due to their rechargeable system featuring a passivating metal anode. Although a system based on the Ca 2+ /Ca couple is particularly attractive given the low electrochemical plating potential of Ca 2+ , the remaining challenge for a viable rechargeable Ca battery is to identify Ca cathodes with fast ion transport. In this work, a high-throughput computational pipeline is adapted to (1) discover novel Ca cathodes in a largely unexplored space of empty intercalation hosts and (2) develop material design rules for Ca-ion mobility. One candidate from the screening, W 2 O 3 (PO 4 ) 2 , is confirmed to have a low Nudged Elastic Band (NEB) barrier of 168 meV within a one-dimensional (1D) ion percolation topology. This candidate is subsequently synthesized and electrochemically tested, achieving reversible Ca cycling with a capacity of 25 mA h/g. To further accelerate the screening for promising Ca intercalation electrodes, machine learning (ML) Random Forest (RF) and Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGB) classification models are created with local environment descriptors based on a large, structurally and chemically diverse dataset of minimum energy pathways, spanning over 5,000 density functional theory (DFT) site energy calculations. Accuracies of 92% are achieved, material design metrics are quantified, ML force-fields are leveraged in an accelerated iteration of the screening, and a total of 27 novel Ca cathode materials are highlighted for further investigation.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Defect Diffusion Graph Neural Networks for Materials Discovery in High-Temperature Energy Applications

Here, the migration of crystallographic defects dictates material properties and performance for a plethora of technological applications. Density functional theory (DFT)-based nudged elastic band (NEB) calculations are a powerful computational technique for predicting defect migration activation energy barriers, yet they become prohibitively expensive for high-throughput screening of defect diffusivities. Without introducing hand-crafted (i.e., chemistry- or structure-specific) descriptors, we propose a generalized deep learning approach to train surrogate models for NEB energies of vacancy migration by hybridizing graph neural networks with transformer encoders and simply using pristine host structures as input. With sufficient training data, computationally efficient and simultaneous inference of vacancy defect thermodynamics and migration activation energies can be obtained to compute temperature-dependent vacancy diffusivities and to down-select candidates for more thorough DFT analysis or experiments. Thus, as we specifically demonstrate for potential water-splitting materials, candidates with desired defect thermodynamics, kinetics, and host stability properties can be more rapidly targeted from open-source databases of experimentally validated or hypothetical materials.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

Revisiting Competing Paths in Electrochemical CO 2 Reduction on Copper via Embedded Correlated Wavefunction Theory

We re-evaluate two key steps in the mechanism of CO 2 reduction on copper at a higher level of theory capable of correcting inherent errors in density functional theory (DFT) approximations, namely, embedded correlated wavefunction (ECW) theory. Here, we consider the CO reduction step on Cu(111), which is critical to understanding reaction selectivity. Here, we optimize embedding potentials at the periodic plane-wave DFT level using density functional embedding theory (DFET). All possible adsorption sites (adsites) for each adsorbate then are screened with ECW theory at the catalytically active site to refine the local electronic structure. Unsurprisingly, DFT and ECW theory predict different adsite preferences, largely because of DFT’s inability to properly situate the CO 2π* level. Differing preferred adsites suggest that different reaction pathways could emerge from DFT versus ECW theory. Starting from these preferred ECW theory adsites, we then obtain reaction pathways at the plane-wave DFT level using the climbing-image nudged elastic band method to determine minimum energy paths. Thereafter, we perform ECW calculations at the catalytically active site to correct the energetics at each interpolated structure (image) along the reaction pathways. Via this approach, we confirm that the first step in CO reduction via hydrogen transfer on Cu(111) is to form hydroxymethylidyne (*COH) instead of formyl (*CHO). Although the prediction to preferentially form *COH is consistent with that of DFT, the two theories predict quite different structural and mechanistic behaviors, suggesting that verification is needed for other parts of the mechanism of CO 2 reduction, which is the subject of ongoing work.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗