Corrosion behavior of additively manufactured refractory-based alloys
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Melia, Michael Anthony↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “REFRACTORY ALLOY”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Microstructural stability and mechanical properties of the as-cast and heat-treated newly developed TiNbCrTa refractory complex concentrated alloy
In this study, a TiNbCrTa refractory complex concentrated alloy (RCCA) was prepared using vacuum arc remelting. The microstructural evolution and mechanical properties of both as-cast and heat-treated RCCA samples were analyzed. Heat treatment (HT) was performed at 800–1200 °C for 1 h in a vacuum-sealed environment. These samples exhibited a formation of Cr 2 Nb and Cr 2 Ti Laves phases. A variation in elemental distribution was observed, with interdendritic (ID) regions showing higher fractions of Ti and Cr, while the dendritic regions had a greater concentration of Ta and Nb. Micro-segregation at the IDs was confirmed through energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy mapping, which inferred the formation of Cr- and Ti-rich phases during HT at 800–1200 °C. High-temperature HT at 1200 °C for 1 h led to the evolution of the hcp omega phase. Prolonged HT at 1200 °C for 96 h resulted in the evolution of a Cr-rich Laves phase (Cr 2 Ta), which was homogeneously distributed within the microstructure, indicating an unstable microstructure. Furthermore, despite prolonged HT, a variation in the elemental distribution persisted due to the presence of dendritic and ID regions. Electron backscattered diffraction analysis revealed the presence of bcc and hcp phases in the dendritic and ID regions, respectively, of the as-cast and HTed samples. The as-cast samples demonstrated a high compressive strength of approximately 2 GPa. Micro-hardness values increased with the HT temperature up to 1000 °C. Further increases under HT conditions did not significantly reduce the microhardness value, whereas prolonged HT at 1200 °C led to an increase in the microhardness value. Overall, the newly developed TiNbCrTa RCCA exhibited high-strength behavior even after the phase transformation.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Bi‐Continuous W‐Rich Refractory High Entropy Alloy‐Cu Composite: Toward Material Innovation of Nuclear Reactor Coolant System
Abstract Refractory high‐entropy alloys (RHEAs) are considered promising candidate materials for next‐generation nuclear reactors due to their superior mechanical strength, irradiation resistance, and thermal stability at high temperatures. However, the significant positive heat of mixing between refractory alloying elements and Cu, commonly used in cooling systems, poses challenges in forming composite structures. This study addresses the issue using a liquid metal dealloying (LMD) process. A precursor alloy (WTaVTi) with a directional dendrite‐interdendrite structure is fabricated and reacted with molten Cu at 1200 °C for 96 h. This approach produced a RHEA‐Cu composite with a stable interface between RHEA (W 31.5 Ta 30.9 V 21.4 Ti 14.3 ) and Cu, featuring a spontaneously formed W‐rich interlayer that enhances interfacial bonding. The composite showed excellent irradiation resistance, with 30% less swelling under α‐ion irradiation than pure W. It also exhibited low thermal conductivity at room temperature, but reached ≈120 W m −1 ·K −1 at ≈650 °C, surpassing pure W. This temperature‐dependent rise in κ, with a positive gradient of +0.075 W m −1 ·K − 2 , is attributed to decreasing diffuse mismatch at elevated temperatures. The large‐scale reaction and stable microstructure achieved through LMD process highlight its industrial potential. This work offers a strategy for developing high‐performance materials by combining RHEA's radiation resistance with Cu's thermal conductivity for extreme environments.
Chemistry↗
Computational Design of Interlayers for Thermally Stable Compositionally Graded Coatings on Nickel Alloys
To extend the service life of Ni-based superalloys, refractory metal coatings are often used. However, direct bonding between metals with dissimilar crystal structure promotes brittle intermetallic phase formation. This work presents a computational thermodynamic framework for high throughput design of functionally graded interlayers to suppress deleterious phases that may form at the interlayer. The Thermo-Calc software package was used to screen candidate metallic interlayer elements based on stability of solid-solution phases. Vanadium was identified as a promising interlayer due to its consistent suppression of intermetallic phases. Temperature-dependent phase diagram mapping between 600 and 1000 °C guided selection of a compositional pathway that significantly reduced intermetallic formation compared to directly joining the Ni-based and Nb refractory alloys. Time–temperature–transformation analysis was performed to assess whether equilibrium-predicted phases are kinetically accessible along regions of the graded path where non-solid-solution phases are not fully suppressed. The methodology was further applied to additional Ni-based alloy and coating systems, illustrating its transferability as an approach for rapid computational design of graded interlayers in dissimilar high-temperature materials.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Transferable predictions of energetic and structural properties for refractory solid solution alloys across chemical compositions
We present a data-efficient approach to train graph neural networks (GNNs) on density functional theory (DFT) data for accurate and transferable predictions of energetic and structural properties of refractory solid solution alloys in the niobium-tantalum-vanadium (Nb-Ta-V) chemical space. We start by training the GNN model only on DFT data that describes refractory binary alloys niobium-tantalum (Nb-Ta), niobium-vanadium (Nb-V), and tantalum-vanadium (Ta-V) to predict formation enthalpy and root mean squared displacement. Once trained, the GNN predictions are tested on DFT data describing refractory ternary alloys Nb-Ta-V. While, unsurprisingly, direct transferability from binary to ternary is not sufficiently accurate, augmenting the training with only 1% of the available ternary data (uniformly distributed across the entire range of chemical compositions) improves significantly the quality of the GNN predictions. For comparison, we assess the transferability in the opposite direction by training GNN models on ternary Nb-Ta-V data and making predictions on binaries Nb-Ta, Nb-V, and Ta-V, which exhibits notably higher predictive errors. The proposed methodology, which favors transferability from lower-component to higher-component alloys, offers an efficient path towards avoiding the curse of dimensionality incurred when collecting DFT data for discovery and design of multi-component disordered alloys.
Density functional theory calculations↗
Alloying Effects on the Transport Properties of Refractory High-entropy Alloys
Additive Manufacturing (AM) has opened new frontiers for the design of refractory high-entropy alloys (HEAs) for high-temperature applications. The thermal conductivity of the AM feedstock is among the most important thermo-physical properties that control the melting and solidification process. Despite its significance, there remains a notable gap in both computational and experimental research concerning the thermal conductivity of HEAs. Here, we use density functional theory (DFT) to systematically investigate the alloying effects on the transport properties of Ti-Cr-Mo-W-V-Nb-Ta RHEAs, including electrical and thermal conductivities and Seebeck coefficient. The relaxation time of charge carriers is a key underlying parameter determining thermal conductivity that is exceedingly challenging to predict from first principles alone, and we thus follow the approach by Mukherjee, Satsangi, and Singh [Chem Mater 32, 6507 (2022)] to optimize the relaxation time for RHEAs. Here we validated thermal conductivity predictions on elemental solids, binary and ternary alloys, and RHEAs and compared them against thermodynamic (CALPHAD) predictions and our experiments with good correlations. To understand observed trends in thermal conductivity, we assessed the phase stability, electronic structure, phonon, and intrinsic- and tensile strength of down-selected RHEAs. Our electronic structure and phonon results connect well with the observed compositional trends for thermal transport in RHEAs. Our DFT assessment and CALPHAD predictions provide a unique design guide for RHEAs with tailored thermal conductivity, a critical consideration for AM and thermal-management applications.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
A theoretical study of solid solution strengthening in the refractory medium entropy alloy Nb 45 Ta 25 Ti 15 Hf 15
The refractory medium-entropy alloy (RMEA) Nb 45 Ta 25 Ti 15 Hf 15 exhibits exceptional tensile ductility and fracture toughness at ambient temperature, but its engineering applications are limited by a lack of high temperature strength. Using a machine-learning interatomic potential (MLIP) with near-density functional theory (DFT) accuracy, we conducted molecular dynamics (MD) and statics simulations of the behavior of dislocations with both screw and edge characters. We also analyze experimentally measured yield strengths using the Rao-Suzuki model and the Maresca-Curtin model modified to include a temperature-dependent shear modulus and a bulk modulus-dependent misfit volume, thereby uncovering the mechanisms underlying the yielding of this RMEA. Compared with the published experimental yield strength, the models parameterized by the MLIP effectively reproduce the experimental results over a wide temperature range. The models and MD simulations indicate that yielding is governed by screw dislocations, with dipole dragging as the dominant mechanism. In MD simulations, we observed a potential softening mechanism not considered by the Rao-Suzuki screw model: slow migration of interstitial jogs along the dislocation core, which could lead to the annihilation of vacancy and interstitial jog pairs by their combination.
BCC complex concentrated alloys↗
A high-temperature heat flux sensor using the transverse Seebeck effect in elemental rhenium
Heat flux sensors compatible with hot environments are critical to advance aerospace, materials, and energy generation technologies that cope with extreme thermal conditions. In this work, we report on the development and characterization of a high-temperature heat flux sensor using the transverse Seebeck effect in rhenium single crystals. The sensor leverages refractory alloys and ceramics compatible with temperatures exceeding 1000 °C. The heat flux sensor was characterized from room temperature to 500 °C using a temperature-controlled calibration facility. At constant temperature, the sensor’s voltage output is linear with respect to the absorbed heat flux. The responsivity of the sensor varies with temperature, from 1.3 μV/(W/cm 2 ) at room temperature to −3.2 μV/(W/cm 2 ) at 500 °C, increasing monotonically in magnitude after changing sign from positive to negative at approximately 300 °C. The experimental results are in good agreement with analytical predictions of the sensor’s temperature-dependent responsivity, which suggest a further increase in magnitude up to −7.4 μV/(W/cm 2 ) at 1000 °C. These results highlight the unique characteristics of rhenium as a TSE transducer. The design offers compatibility with a wide range of operating temperatures and yields a measurement sensitivity that increases as the environmental conditions become more challenging.
20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗
Synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction of a refractory high entropy alloy, Mo 0.20 Nb 0.21 Ta 0.19 V 0.20 W 0.20
Powder X-ray diffraction data collected at the Advanced Photon Source 16-BM–D, confirms that the alloy with composition Mo 0.20 Nb 0.21 Ta 0.19 V 0.20 W 0.20 crystallizes in a simple body-centered cubic (bcc) structure with all five elements distributed over a single crystallographic site (Wyckoff position 2a of space group Im $\bar{3}$ m ).
high-entropy alloy↗
History and State of the Art in Advanced Thermal Protection Systems
This report documents the current state of the art of thermal protection systems (TPS) relevant to missile application materials and MTCR control language. The information is intended to provide data on current TPS for determining the current state of development and identifying potential research directions. Various vehicle configurations and types of TPS are described, including the evolution of materials and systems. Vehicle configurations such as high drag rocket and capsule systems and low-drag air-breathers are discussed. TPS are complex, transitioning from often very low temperatures to temperatures exceeding 3000°C and heat fluxes of up to 30,000 W/cm 2 . They can take the form of blankets, sheets, tiles and fabricated rigid structures, and can be made from high temperature capable alloys, refractory metals, ceramics, ceramic matrix composites, ultra-high temperature ceramics, carbon-carbon composites or ablative carbonaceous materials. Current state of the art in TPS is based on materials any systems developed for the initial space program. TPS was upgraded to the point of the Space Shuttle development and has stagnated since them.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
The Path towards Plasma Facing Components: A Review of State-of-the-art in W-Based Refractory High-Entropy Alloys
Developing advanced materials for plasma-facing components (PFCs) in fusion reactors is a crucial aspect for achieving sustained energy production. Tungsten (W) - based refractory high-entropy alloys (RHEAs) have emerged as promising candidates due to their superior radiation tolerance and high-temperature strength. This review paper will focus on recent advancements in W-based RHEA research, particularly emphasizing the key role of modelling using machine learning (ML) in the stage of discovery by predicting properties for each composition and expediting the identification of optimal RHEA compositions with desired properties. Additionally, the application of additive manufacturing (AM) techniques for fabricating W-based RHEAs is explored, highlighting their advantages for rapid prototyping and multi-compositional sample production in a high throughput manner. The review critically evaluates the current understanding of mechanical properties relevant to PFC applications, including high-temperature strength and ductility. Furthermore, the radiation tolerance of W-based RHEAs under irradiated conditions is discussed. Finally, the validity of current AM-manufactured W-based RHEAs as PFC materials is assessed, and key challenges and opportunities for future research are identified. This review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of W-based RHEAs for fusion applications and their potential to guide the development and validation of advanced refractory high entropy alloys.
Hatler, Caleb [University of Wisconsin-Madison]↗
Rapid Design of Cost-Effective Refractory High Entropy Alloys Strengthened by Precipitation
Funded by the ARPA-E ULTIMATE program, this project aims to develop cost-effective refractory high entropy alloys (RHEAs) for gas turbine blades applications at 1300 degree Celsius and above. The alloy design focuses on carbides precipitation strengthening in a strong and ductile solid solution BCC matrix. The goal is to achieve balanced mechanical properties including room temperature ductility & fracture toughness and high temperature strength and creep resistance, while maintaining comparable oxidation resistance and densities to Ni-base superalloys. To accelerate alloy design, multiscale modeling including CALPHAD and first-principles density functional theory (DFT) calculations and machine learning are performed. Specifically, high throughput phase diagram calculations and screening are carried out using CALPHAD; DFT calculations are performed to predict intrinsic ductility, grain boundary strengthening potential, coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) and temperature-dependent elastic constants. Temperature dependent yield stress, creep strain and CTE are also predicted using machine learning. Down-selected alloys are synthesized in small buttons of about 250g using arc melting for rapid evaluation on microstructure and mechanical properties before employing plasma arc melting and additive manufacturing for producing large ingots. Preliminary computational and experimental results of this project will be presented and future direction in RHEA development will be discussed.
high temperature materials↗
Additively manufactured refractory high-entropy alloys with superior radiation resistance
Refractory high-entropy alloys (RHEAs) are promising candidates for next-generation nuclear and high-temperature applications. Among many approaches to manufacture RHEAs, additive manufacturing (AM) represents the most recent and advanced metal manufacturing method which allows near-net-shape manufacturing to reduce material waste and post-processing time. However, performance of AM RHEAs under complex irradiation conditions remains largely unexplored. Here, in this study, we demonstrate for the first time the response of directed energy deposition (DED) AM quaternary RHEAs (HfTaVW, CrTaVW) subjected to sequential dual-beam ion irradiation, consisting of helium pre-implantation followed by high-dose heavy ion bombardment. Compositions of DED AM RHEAs were selected using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations based on a cluster expansion (CE) Hamiltonian parameterized by density functional theory (DFT). Post-irradiation microstructural characterization revealed that the AM RHEA maintained remarkable stability, with suppressed helium bubble growth and reduced defect accumulation compared to conventional alloys. Even at high doses (∼100 dpa), the alloy exhibited no void swelling, a low density of dislocation loops, and no evidence of severe degradation. These results highlight the intrinsic ability of AM-derived microstructures and multicomponent chemistry to synergistically mitigate irradiation effects. Our findings establish AM RHEAs as a class of materials with superior resistance to radiation damage under conditions relevant to advanced fusion and fission environments and demonstrate the importance of sequential ion beam studies in evaluating their long-term performance.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Rationalization of the tensile creep behavior of the Nb45Ta25Ti15Hf15 bcc refractory complex concentrated alloy using Rao-Suzuki screw dislocation glide model
Published experimental tensile creep data for refractory body-centered cubic alloy Nb45Ta25Ti15Hf15 (NTTH) at temperatures ranging from 850–950 °C and applied tensile stresses 50–300 MPa are analyzed using the Rao-Suzuki screw dislocation glide model of solid solution strengthening. It is shown that the experimental creep data as well as transmission electron microscopy observations of post- creep deformation dislocation microstructure are in agreement with the model results. This suggests that the creep deformation of NTTH at 850–950 °C is controlled by screw dislocation glide.
Rao, Satish I↗
Shear strength of a refractory high entropy alloy MoNbTaVW under high pressure
Radial X-ray diffraction (R-XRD) was performed in situ using a Panoramic Diamond Anvil Cell on the refractory high entropy alloy MoNbTaVW. The lattice parameters were determined through a Le Bail fit using a body centered cubic (BCC) lattice of symmetry $Im$$\overline{3}$$m$ (international space group number 229). Upper and lower bounds to the shear strength were determined up to 80 GPa nonhydrostatically using copper as a pressure standard. The equation of state was derived at the magic angle ψ = 54.7° and yielded a bulk modulus of K 0 = 220.8 ± 1.65 GPa. The experimental lattice parameters and bulk modulus match closely with corresponding density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The BCC phase remains stable up to the highest pressure of 80 GPa studied and is shown to be elastically anisotropic. The shear strength was found to saturate around 70 GPa with a value of τ = 1.75 GPa, and the shear moduli are presented in different limits of iso-strain and iso-stress.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Homogenization of Dendritic Structures and the High-Temperature Strength of the Refractory High-Entropy Alloy MoNbTaVW
MoNbTaVW, a pioneering refractory high-entropy alloy (RHEA), is renowned for its exceptional strength at elevated temperatures. Like most RHEAs, it solidifies into a dendritic microstructure with steep concentration gradients, necessitating heat treatment for equilibration. Steep concentration gradients typically complicate mechanical property analysis and modeling, key challenges for high-throughput alloy discovery. This study examines the effects of high-temperature homogenization (1800 °C for 8 hours) on the microstructure and mechanical properties of MoNbTaVW across temperatures up to 1200 °C. Postmortem microstructural analysis, coupled with chemical, crystallographic, and mechanical assessments, revealed that yield strength was surprisingly insensitive to homogenization, with less than a 3 pct difference between as-cast and heat-treated materials. Nanoindentation confirmed minimal nanohardness changes across the dendritic structure at room temperature. However, homogenization significantly enhanced high-temperature work hardening, producing higher peak compressive strength. Both as-cast and homogenized MoNbTaVW exhibited room-temperature strengths of 1400 MPa, exceeding previously reported values. These findings demonstrate that high-temperature treatment enables microstructural homogenization without compromising strength, a unique behavior among RHEAs. In conclusion, while not universally applicable, this insight highlights the importance of understanding microstructural development in experimental alloys and offers a pathway to design alloys that achieve homogeneous-like properties without heat treatment.
Rietema, C. J. [Lawrence Livermore National Labora↗
High-throughput oxidation screening and down-selection of refractory high entropy alloys in the Al-Cr-Mo-Nb-Ta-Ti system
Rapid experimentation and characterization are ever-present needs in the discovery of high entropy alloys. High entropy alloy systems are difficult to survey with systematic composition sweeps using traditional synthesis methods. The number of distinct compositions in even a four-element system is experimentally intractable. Exploration of these, and higher-element systems, necessitates thermodynamic prediction coupled with an automated sample creation method and a rapid screening methodology to effectively down-select alloys with targeted properties. As a result, a high-throughput method for evaluating the oxidation performance of refractory high entropy alloys was developed and tested. The six-element system of aluminum, chromium, molybdenum, niobium, tantalum, and titanium was evaluated for single phase stability and short-duration oxidation resistance. Target compositions were initially determined via thermodynamic predictions of single-phase stability across a wide temperature range. A twenty-five-sample build plate was produced using directed energy deposition additive manufacturing. After fabrication, the twenty-five 1 cm 3 samples were heat treated and characterized for composition and phase identification. The build plate was exposed to a high temperature oxidizing environment at 1000 °C for three hours. After oxidation, the composition, morphology, and chemistry of the oxides formed were characterized. Of the twenty-five samples produced, nine exhibited a favorable oxidation response, from which a single-phase BCC alloy at a composition of Al 13 Cr 7 Mo 19 Nb 18 Ta 26 Ti 17 was identified as the alloy with the most protective oxidation coating with a thin, adherent oxide scale. Finally, the complete experimental down-selection—from machine setup to final alloy identification—required approximately 45 labor hours, demonstrating a rapid validation for alloy discovery.
Additive manufacturing↗
Thin film combinatorial sputtering of TaTiHfZr refractory compositionally complex alloys for rapid materials discovery
Many applications from advanced nuclear reactors to aerospace and automotive industries require materials to operate in extreme environments. In search of new materials that can operate in these extremes, the present work explores this space whereby: (1) guided by atomistic and thermodynamic calculations we utilize thin film combinatorial synthesis to rapidly explore mechanical and thermal properties in a broad range of refractory compositionally complex alloys, and (2) observe transformation induced plasticity via oscillations in the thin film nanoindentation load depth curves that are attributed to, (3) a stress-induced HCP-to-BCC phase transformation in the resulting nanogranular microstructure, which to our knowledge has not been observed before in this alloy system; and finally (4) scale to bulk materials to compare the thin film results.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗