SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Presentation detailing Major focus: Deployment of A709 for fast reactor structural applications in the area of Design, Fabrication, Supply Chain, and Adx Rx Operation. Also discuss additional work to support A709 development, High level timeline for Irradiation design data, and processing parameters.
Tokamaks are affected by two serious problems. The first problem is the radiation damage to the internal reactor structures by energetic neutrons carrying 80% of the total fusion energy that are generated by the deuterium–tritium fusion cycle that tokamaks are planning to use. The second problem is a loss of plasma control because of the onset of instabilities, causing the sudden shutdown of the tokamak itself. Certainly, no electric utility knowing about these disruptive events would dare to use a tokamak reactor for powering the turbines of its power plant! This paper describes a new fusion reactor based on the Model-C Stellarator that would not be affected by these fatal phenomena.
This report provides an overview of the ASME Boiler & Pressure Vessel Section III, Division 5 rules for the design and construction of high temperature nuclear reactor components. The overview focuses on the application of the rules to the design of Small Modular Reactors (SMRs). The discussion covers the general ASME Code rules for base metal design and construction, the rules for designing weldments, and provides an overview of environmental degradation mechanisms affecting reactor structural materials. The analysis includes historical context on the development of the ASME design approach and a description of what actions could be taken to mitigate the gaps identified in the report. The report concludes with a summary of the key gaps identified in the rules, as they apply to SMR, and a list of recommendations on how those gaps might be addressed.
Commercial fusion reactors operating on a D-T fuel cycle will require a steady supply of tritium to maintain the burning plasma required for continuous power generation. Since tritium has a short half-life, there is negligible natural abundance which necessitates fusion reactors to produce their own source of tritium. Tritium is most easily produced by surrounding a fusion reactor core with lithium (Li), which reacts under the intense neutron flux leaving the reactor core to form tritium and helium. Due to the hazards and technical challenges associated with surrounding a fusion reactor core with many tons of molten Li, other Li-bearing tritium breeder materials have been pursued. Unfortunately, most of the liquid breeders historically examined are exceedingly corrosive to reactor structural materials while many solid breeders in the form of ceramics are forced to make tradeoffs between Li content and mechanical integrity. In this work, to break the historic limit between Li-density and mechanical integrity of traditional solid breeders, a new class of solid tritium breeders is developed: metal-reinforced composite (MERC) breeders. Specifically, the high Li-density of lithium oxide (Li 2 O) is exploited through the addition of a metal reinforcing phase, producing a composite breeder material exhibiting high splitting tensile strength and quasi-ductility with a Li-density greater than other leading solid breeder candidates, including lithium orthosilicate (Li 4 SiO 4 ) and lithium metatitanate (Li 2 TiO 3 ). Mechanical testing, microstructural characterization, and neutronic simulation results are presented and discussed in light of fusion reactor design considerations.
Determining the mechanisms for irradiation-induced ductility loss is crucial for the design of reactor structural components. Here, the deformation characteristics around nanoindents in Fe and Fe10Cr irradiated with Fe ions to ~1 displacement-per-atom at 313 K are non-destructively studied. Slip steps surrounding the nanoindents indicate that deformation is localised in the irradiated materials. Lattice rotation and strain fields near the indent site show over 87% confinement of plasticity in the irradiated material. Cr has little effect on the irradiation-induced changes in pile-up topography and deformation fields, suggesting it has limited impact on retaining strain hardening capacity and reducing irradiation-induced embrittlement.
Third-party and expert analysis is a cost-effective solution for solving specialized problems or processing large datasets related to reactor structural health monitoring and nondestructive evaluation. However, when handling proprietary information, third-party and expert analysts pose a privacy risk. To address this challenge, Homomorphic Encryption (HE) permits arithmetic operations on encrypted data without exposing the underlying data. Implementations of Machine Learning (ML) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) algorithms using HE greatly enhances the capabilities of third-party analysts while maintaining a low security risk. This paper details current success in applying Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Fully Connected Neural Networks (NN) using the Microsoft SEAL implementation of the popular CKKS Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE) algorithm. The MNIST Handwritten Dataset is analyzed as a proof-of-concept demonstration of the implementations.
In this work, to develop advanced reduced-activation ferritic-martensitic (RAFM) steels for fusion reactor structural applications, both carbonitride- and carbide-strengthened castable nanostructured alloys (CNAs) were explored for higher densities of MX (M = Ti/Ta/V/etc. and X = C/N) nanoprecipitates. Additionally, systematic comparisons between the two types of CNAs indicated generally similar microstructures and comparable tensile properties and creep resistance. However, the carbide-CNAs did show some advantages over the carbonitride-CNAs in terms of the uniformly distributed higher density of MC nanoprecipitates, greater Charpy impact upper shelf energies, less deuterium retention and swelling, and potentially less transmutation-induced composition changes and consequently thermodynamically more stable carbides. The carbide-CNAs showed the best-balanced high performance in the examined properties, in contrast to the significantly varied performance of oxide-dispersion-strengthened alloys and the generally lower performance of current RAFM steels.
Among a number of other advantageous features, ferritic/martensitic steels are being considered as fusion reactor structural materials due to their low intrinsic swelling under irradiation. However, under high-energy neutron irradiation, He produced through (n, α) reactions stabilizes vacancy clusters, which then act as seeds for bubble formation and growth, negating the intrinsic swelling resistance of these alloys. Standard models of irradiation damage accumulation and microstructural evolution consider homogeneous nucleation as the basis for bubble formation and growth. However, this generally does not explain the large bubble densities and sizes observed experimentally under a number of different conditions. Here, we propose a more realistic physical model of bubble nucleation, formation, and growth designed to capture recent experimental measurements of He-bubble formation and evolution during co-implantation of He and Fe ions in model ferritic alloys. We find that experimental results are explained only when the following three features are considered simultaneously: (i) heterogeneous nucleation of He-vacancy bubbles at defect sinks (e.g., dislocations, grain boundaries, and second-phase precipitates), (ii) nucleation and growth of bubbles via the ‘trap mutation’ mechanism (i.e., spontaneous production of Frenkel pairs due to absorption of He atoms), and (iii) transition from a growth-limited, He-stabilized bubble regime to a ‘runaway’ void-type growth scenario. The model is implemented into a stochastic cluster dynamics framework that takes advantage of cluster size grouping methods to accelerate the simulations, allowing us to reach 10 dpa of simulated irradiated dose, and to capture cluster sizes in excess of 20 nm. Further, a careful extrapolation exercise conducted assuming classical nucleation theory leads to excellent agreement with the experimental measurements at 50 dpa of irradiation.
A Bayesian optimization procedure is presented for calibrating a multimechanism micromechanical model for creep to experimental data of F82H steel. Reduced activation ferritic martensitic (RAFM) steels based on Fe(8–9)%Cr are the most promising candidates for some fusion reactor structures. Although there are indications that RAFM steel could be viable for fusion applications at temperatures up to 600°C, the maximum operating temperature will be determined by the creep properties of the structural material and the breeder material compatibility with the structural material. Due to the relative paucity of available creep data on F82H steel compared to other alloys such as Grade 91 steel, micromechanical models are sought for simulating creep based on relevant deformation mechanisms. As a point of departure, this work recalibrates a model form that was previously proposed for Grade 91 steel to match creep curves for F82H steel. Due to the large number of parameters (9) and cost of the nonlinear simulations, an automated approach for tuning the parameters is pursued using a recently developed Bayesian optimization for functional output (BOFO) framework (Huang et al., 2021, “Bayesian optimization of functional output in inverse problems,” Optim. Eng., 22, pp. 2553–2574). Incorporating extensions such as batch sequencing and weighted experimental load cases into BOFO, a reasonably small error between experimental and simulated creep curves at two load levels is achieved in a reasonable number of iterations. In conclusion, validation with an additional creep curve provides confidence in the fitted parameters obtained from the automated calibration procedure to describe the creep behavior of F82H steel.
TMAP7 was developed by the Fusion Safety Program at INL primarily as a safety analysis code, to analyze tritium retention and loss in fusion reactor structures and systems during normal operation and accident conditions. TMAP7 solves one-dimensional thermal- and mass-diffusive transport and trapping equations for transport through structures, across the interface between enclosures and structures, and zero dimensional fluid transport between enclosures.
TMAP4 was developed by the Fusion Safety Program at INL primarily as a safety analysis code, to analyze tritium retention and loss in fusion reactor structures and systems during normal operation and accident conditions. TMAP4 solves one-dimensional thermal- and mass-diffusive transport and trapping equations for transport through structures, across the interface between enclosures and structures, and zero dimensional fluid transport between enclosures.
In this work, we develop novel physics-based and machine learning computational techniques to predict fundamental properties of metallic systems that affect radiation damage behavior in reactor structural materials. Oftentimes, atomistic predictions of engineering alloys simplify chemical compositions to a single element to reduce computational cost and complexity, introducing large sources of uncertainty and potentially missing important behavior. In addition, engineering alloys such as SS 316 are particularly challenging to simulate with first principles methods because of the additional degrees of freedom introduced by magnetic natures of the constituent elements, and very little data of this type exists within the literature. These novel methods aim to improve the qualitative prediction of radiation damage in engineering alloys by more accurately simulating their compositions, both by accelerating the computations and by developing novel analyses.
A Bayesian optimization procedure is presented for calibrating a multi-mechanism micromechanical model for creep to experimental data of F82H steel. Reduced activation ferritic martensitic (RAFM) steels based on are the most promising candidates for some fusion reactor structures. Although there are indications that RAFM steel could be viable for fusion applications at temperatures up to 600 °C, the maximum operating temperature will be determined by the creep properties of the structural material and the breeder material compatibility with the structural material. Due to the relative paucity of available creep data on F82H steel compared to other alloys such as Grade 91 steel, micromechanical models are sought for simulating creep based on relevant deformation mechanisms. As a point of departure, this work recalibrates a model form that was previously proposed for Grade 91 steel to match creep curves for F82H steel. Due to the large number of parameters (9) and cost of the nonlinear simulations, an automated approach for tuning the parameters is pursued using a recently developed Bayesian optimization for functional output (BOFO) framework [1]. Incorporating extensions such as batch sequencing and weighted experimental load cases into BOFO, a reasonably small error between experimental and simulated creep curves at two load levels is achieved in a reasonable number of iterations. Validation with an additional creep curve provides confidence in the fitted parameters obtained from the automated calibration procedure to describe the creep behavior of F82H steel at 600 °C. The model is further extended using a temperature dependent scaling law approach to simulate creep response between 550 °C and 650 °C. The efficacy of this extension is compared with the previously used scaling law approach for Grade 91 steel.
Helium bubbles are known to form in nuclear reactor structural components when displacement damage occurs in conjunction with helium exposure and/or transmutation. If left unchecked, bubble production can cause swelling, blistering, and embrittlement, all of which substantially degrade materials and—moreover—diminish mechanical properties. On the mission to produce more robust materials, nanocrystalline (NC) metals show great potential and are postulated to exhibit superior radiation resistance due to their high defect and particle sink densities; however, much is still unknown about the mechanisms of defect evolution in these systems under extreme conditions. Here, the performances of NC nickel (Ni) and iron (Fe) are investigated under helium bombardment via transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Bubble density statistics are measured as a function of grain size in specimens implanted under similar conditions. While the overall trends revealed an increase in bubble density up to saturation in both samples, bubble density in Fe was over 300% greater than in Ni. To interrogate the kinetics of helium diffusion and trapping, a rate theory model is developed that substantiates that helium is more readily captured within grains in helium-vacancy complexes in NC Fe, whereas helium is more prone to traversing the grain matrices and migrating to GBs in NC Ni. Our results suggest that (1) grain boundaries can affect bubble swelling in grain matrices significantly and can have a dominant effect over crystal structure, and (2) an NC-Ni-based material can yield superior resistance to irradiation-induced bubble growth compared to an NC-Fe-based material and exhibits high potential for use in extreme environments where swelling due to He bubble formation is of significant concern.
Austenitic stainless steel D9 is a candidate for Generation IV nuclear reactor structural materials due to its enhanced irradiation tolerance and high-temperature creep strength compared to conventional 300-series stainless steels. But, like other austenitic steels, D9 is susceptible to irradiation-induced clustering of Ni and Si, the mechanism for which is not well understood. This study utilizes atom probe tomography (APT) to characterize the chemistry and morphology of Ni–Si nanoclusters in D9 following neutron or proton irradiation to doses ranging from 5–9 displacements per atom (dpa) and temperatures ranging from 430–683 °C. Nanoclusters form only after neutron irradiation and exhibit classical coarsening with increasing dose and temperature. The nanoclusters have Ni 3 Si stoichiometry in a Ni core–Si shell structure. This core–shell structure provides insight into a potentially unique nucleation and growth mechanism—nanocluster cores may nucleate through local, spinodal-like compositional fluctuations in Ni, with subsequent growth driven by rapid Si diffusion. This study underscores how APT can shed light on an unusual irradiation-induced nanocluster nucleation mechanism active in the ubiquitous class of austenitic stainless steels.
The results of a materials technology program for a long-life (50,000 hr), high-temperature (950 C coolant outlet), lithium-cooled, nuclear space power reactor concept are reviewed and discussed. Fabrication methods and compatibility and property data were developed for candidate materials for fuel pins and, to a lesser extent, for potential control systems, reflectors, reactor vessel and piping, and other reactor structural materials. The effects of selected materials variables on fuel pin irradiation performance were determined. The most promising materials for fuel pins were found to be 85 percent dense uranium mononitride (UN) fuel clad with tungsten-lined T-111 (Ta-8W-2Hf).
Nuclear thermal propulsion (NTP) technology will greatly benefit human travel to Mars by significantly shortening transit times, improving crew safety, and providing more mission flexibility than traditional chemical rockets. As part of DRACO follow-on work to develop, build, and fly a generation zero NTP engine, a full scale flight-like experimental design unit (EDU) reactor was constructed to collect sufficient on-ground performance data to characterize flow induced vibrations (FIV) of critical reactor structures/components, inform development of the engine and reactor control algorithm, and collect pressure drop and flow distribution data across the reactor. The fluid conditions for the test program were designed to achieve system responses equivalent to that of an operational engine through all phases of engine operation including reactor startup, mainstage operation, reactor shutdown, and reactor cooldown. Over 100 tests were executed, flowing either GN2 or GHe through the EDU at varying flow rates and pressures. This experiment provided early validation of flow behavior and vibration risks before nuclear testing, boosted critical subsystem TRLs, informed design iterations, and reduced future test costs. The steady-state flow parameters for the experiment were modeled in Ansys Thermal Desktop, allowing rapid tuning and experiment-informed updates to a flight-like test matrix. The EDU dynamic environment was characterized with accelerometers, strain gauges, and high-frequency pressure transducers all sampled at 20 kHz. While many narrow-band oscillations were identified, no significant FIV occurred; the reactor structural responses tend to be enveloped by typical launch vehicle ascent vibration environments (defined up to 2 kHz), although significant energy is also present at higher frequencies.
High-temperature reactor structural components are often under the complex multiaxial creep-fatigue (CF) loading conditions throughout the lifetime because of geometric and/or metallurgical discontinuities and complex loading paths. To assess the multiaxial CF deformation behavior and to evaluate the CF design rules in the ASME BPVC Section III, Division 5, Subsection HB, Subpart B, experimental and numerical studies are performed on Alloy 617 at 950°C using notch specimen geometries under CF loading in this study.