A critical evaluation of methods for computing wing-body interference at supersonic speeds.
Research effort on wing-body interference at supersonic speeds
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Research effort on wing-body interference at supersonic speeds
This paper presents a summary of the experimental supersonic store separation studies that have been conducted at the NASA Langley Research Center. These studies have included investigations of rectangular box cavity flowfields, store separation tests of missiles from various cavity configurations, and tests of a passive venting system for improving the separation characteristics of stores from shallow cavities. Selected results from these investigations are presented which illustrate the types of cavity flowfields that exist at supersonic speeds and the effect of these flowfields and various cavity configurations on the separation characteristics of stores.
Results of a free-flight investigation at supersonic speeds to determine zero-lift drag of a series of bodies of revolution are presented. Configurations tested included two parabolic bodies with fineness ratios of 17.78 and 24.5 and two 8 degree cone-cylinder bodies with fineness ratios of 17.2 and 21.2. Results of previous tests of similar parabolic bodies but with lower fineness ratios are included in this paper for comparison. All bodies for which data are presented in this paper had a base-to-maximum-diameter ratio of 0.437. Calculated drag coefficients are shown for all bodies for which data are presented. (author)
Aerodynamic interference effects on effectiveness of aircraft vertical tail at supersonic speeds
A procedure for calculating three-dimensional steady and nonsteady supersonic flows with the method of characteristics is developed and discussed. An approximate method is deduced from the characteristics method and shown to be of practical value at high supersonic speeds.
Expressions based on linearized supersonic-flow theory are derived for the perturbation velocity potential in space due to wing thickness for rectangular wings with biconvex airfoil sections and for arrow, delta, and quadrilateral wings with wedge-type airfoil sections. The complete range of supersonic speeds is considered subject to a minor aspect-ratio-Mach number restriction for the rectangular plan form and to the condition that the trailing edge is supersonic for the sweptback wings. The formulas presented can be utilized in determining the induced-flow characteristics at any point in the field and are readily adaptable for either numerical computation or analytical determination of any velocity components desired.
The effects of crossflow and shock strength on transition of the laminar boundary layer behind a swept leading edge have been investigated analytically and with the aid of available experimental data. An approximate method of determining the crossflow Reynolds number on a leading edge of circular cross section at supersonic speeds is presented. The applicability of the critical crossflow criterion described by Owen and Randall for transition on swept wings in subsonic flow was examined for the case of supersonic flow over swept circular cylinders. A wide range of applicability of the subsonic critical values is indicated. The corresponding magnitude of crossflow velocity necessary to cause instability on the surface of a swept wing at supersonic speeds was also calculated and found to be small. The effects of shock strength on transition caused by Tollmien-Schlichting type of instability are discussed briefly. Changes in local Reynolds number, due to shock strength, were found analytically to have considerably more effect on transition caused by Tollmien-Schlichting instability than on transition caused by crossflow instability. Changes in the mechanism controlling transition from Tollmien-Schlichting instability to crossflow instability were found to be possible as a wing is swept back and to result in large reductions in the length of laminar flow.
A theory is developed for the airfoil of finite span at supersonic speed analogous to the Prandtl airfoil theory of 1918-1919 for incompressible flow. In addition to the profile and induced drags, account must be taken at supersonic flow of still another drag, namely, the wave drag, which is independent of the wing aspect ratio. Both wave and induced drags are proportional to the square of the lift and depend on the Mach number, that is, the ratio of flight to sound speed. In general, in the case of supersonic flow, the drag-lift ratio is considerably less favorable than is the case for incompressible flow. Among others the following examples are considered: 1) lifting line with constant lift distribution (horseshoe vortex); 2) computation of wave and induced drag and the twist of a trapezoidal wing of constant lift density; 3) computation of the lift distribution and drag of an untwisted rectangular wing.
The stability derivatives valid for a limited range of supersonic speeds are presented for a series of sweptback wings tapered to a point with sweptback or sweptforward trailing edges. These wings were derived by modifying the trailing edge of a basic triangular wing so that it coincided with lines drawn from the wing tips to the wing axis of symmetry. The stability derivatives were formulated by using the pressure distributions previously obtained for the basic triangular wing for angle of attack, constant vertical acceleration, sideslip, pitching, rolling, and yawing. Explicit expressions are given for the stability derivatives with respect to principal body axes, and conversion formulas are provided for the transformation to stability axes. The results are limited to Mach numbers for which the wing is contained within the Mach cones springing from the vertex and from the trailing edge of the center section of the wing.
A review of research conducted at the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) Langley Research Center (LaRC) into high-speed vortex flows during the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s is presented. The data are for flat plates, cavities, bodies, missiles, wings, and aircraft with Mach numbers of 1.5 to 4.6. Data are presented to show the types of vortex structures that occur at supersonic speeds and the impact of these flow structures on vehicle performance and control. The data show the presence of both small- and large-scale vortex structures for a variety of vehicles, from missiles to transports. For cavities, the data show very complex multiple vortex structures exist at all combinations of cavity depth to length ratios and Mach number. The data for missiles show the existence of very strong interference effects between body and/or fin vortices. Data are shown that highlight the effect of leading-edge sweep, leading-edge bluntness, wing thickness, location of maximum thickness, and camber on the aerodynamics of and flow over delta wings. Finally, a discussion of a design approach for wings that use vortex flows for improved aerodynamic performance at supersonic speeds is presented.
Pitch and control stiffness effects on flutter characteristics of all-moveable wing and vertical and horizontal tails on fighter aircraft at supersonic speeds
A method is derived for calculating the damping coefficients in pitch and roll for a series of triangular wings and a restricted series of sweptback wings at supersonic speeds. The elementary "supersonic source" solution of the linearized equation of motion is used to find the potential function of a line of doublets, and the flows are obtained by surface distributions of these doublet lines. The damping derivatives for triangular wings are found to be a function of the ratio of the tangent of the apex angle to the tangent of the Mach angle. As this ratio becomes equal to and greater than 1.0 for triangular wings, the damping derivatives, in pitch and in roll, become constant. The damping derivative in roll becomes equal to one-half the value calculated for an infinite rectangular wing, and the damping derivative in pitch for pitching about the apex becomes equal to 3.375 times that of an infinite rectangular wing.
Panel flutter results for flat and curved titanium skin panels at supersonic speed
Panel-flutter tests have been made at transonic and supersonic speeds With particular reference to buckled curved panels with longitudinal stringers. Other panel configurations were also tested in an attempt to determine effects of skin thickness, curvature, stringers, buckling, pressure differential, and Mach number on the dynamic pressure necessary to start flutter. For buckled curved panels with longitudinal stringers, the dynamic pressure required to start flutter was increased by increasing the skin thickness and increasing the pressure differential across the panel. There was no apparent effect of Mach number variation from 1.3 to 2.0. None of the curved panels failed because of flutter although the dynamic pressure at the start of flutter was exceeded by a factor of 3 in many cases. curved panels and four flat panels failed because of flutter. The flat panels fluttered at lower dynamic pressures than the curved panels and four flat panels failed because of flutter.
The problem of chordwise, or camber, divergence at transonic and supersonic speeds is treated with primary emphasis on slender delta wings having a cantilever support at the trailing edge. Experimental and analytical results are presented for four wing models having apex half-angles of 5 deg, 10 deg, 15 deg, and 20 deg. A Mach number range from 0.8 to 7.3 is covered. The analytical results include calculations based on small-aspect-ratio theory, lifting-surface theory, and strip theory. A closed-form solution of the equilibrium equation is given, which is based on low-aspect-ratio theory but which applies only to certain stiffness distributions. Also presented is an iterative procedure for use with other aerodynamic theories and with arbitrary stiffness distribution.
Video is an overview of the AETC Capability Challenge: Evaluation of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) for Testing at High Supersonic Speeds. Featuring assessments of a series of wind tunnel tests and CFD analysis conducted with a focus on air flow and the potential of optimizing future testing. This video is beneficial for sharing with other organizations that operate or test in wind tunnels.
An investigation has been conducted to explore the potential for optimizing airfoil shape at high supersonic speeds by utilizing the two-dimensional shock-expansion method. Theoretical and experimental force and moment coefficients are compared for four delta-planform semispan wings having a leading-edge sweep angle of 65 deg and incorporating modified diamond airfoils with a thickness-chord ratio of 0.06. The wings differ only in airfoil maximum-thickness position and camber. The experimental data are obtained at Mach numbers of 3.95 and 4.63 and at a Reynolds number of 9.84 million per meter. A relatively simple method is developed for predicting, in terms of lift-drag ratio, the optimum modified diamond airfoil at high supersonic and hypersonic speeds.
Some results of recent experimental investigations at supersonic and transonic speeds are presented to show the present status in the estimation of load distributions on controls and adjacent wing surfaces resulting from the deflection of flap controls and spoiler controls. The results indicate that the development of methods for predicting loads associated with controls has not kept pace with the acquisition of experimental data. At low supersonic speeds sweeping the hinge line induces strong three-dimensional-flow characteristics which cannot be treated by the simplified methods previously developed for controls without sweep. At transonic speeds the estimation of loads associated with controls must usually be dependent upon experimental information inasmuch as the latest attempts to predict chordwise and spanwise loadings have met with only limited success.