Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “dynamic simulation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3

Molecular Origin of Nanoscale Anion Ordering of LiTFSI Electrolytes Revealed through SAXS/WAXS and Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Recent developments in “water-in-salt” electrolytes have precipitated a renewed effort to study imide-based electrolytes. While previous small-/wide-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS/WAXS) studies have attributed the emergence of a low-Q peak in the SAXS profile of aqueous LiTFSI electrolytes to nanometer-scale anion clustering, a molecular-level understanding of the root of these clusters remains unclear. Here, in this study, we combined molecular dynamics simulations and SAXS/WAXS to study the solvation structures of LiTFSI in acetonitrile, methanol, and water. We concluded that hydrogen bonding in water and MeOH stabilizes anion clusters, while nonpolar methyl groups on methanol and acetonitrile interrupt the nanoscale ordering of TFSI anions. This causes LiTFSI in water and MeOH electrolytes to exhibit two low-Q SAXS profile peaks while LiTFSI in acetonitrile exhibits only a single peak below Q = 1 Å –1 . These findings shed light on the underlying molecular origins of nanoscale anion clusters, which may help in the design of the next generation of electrolyte chemistries.

Trojanowski, Lucas [Univ. of Michigan, Ann Arbor, ↗

Ab-initio informed cluster dynamics simulation of self- and Xe diffusivity in uranium mononitride under irradiation

Uranium mononitride (UN) is one of the ceramic nuclear fuel alternatives to oxide fuels considered for light water reactor and advanced reactor designs, as it presents significant advantages such as high uranium density (better economics) and high thermal conductivity and melting point (increased safety). Self- and fission gas diffusivities need to be better understood, given that they influence key fuel performance phenomena like swelling and fission gas release. Recently, radiation enhanced diffusivity was investigated in UN by means of cluster dynamics simulations relying on empirical potential-based parameterizations, the reliability of which highly depends on the interatomic potential accuracy. Here, in this work, we refine this approach by determining, using ab-initio calculations, the properties of defect clusters containing vacancies, self-interstitials and Xe impurities. We also consider larger clusters than previous studies. The obtained dataset (formation enthalpies, entropies, and migration barriers) is used to parameterize a cluster dynamics model of mobile clusters, and to calculate the defect cluster concentrations under irradiation. This gives us access to the radiation enhanced self- and fission gas diffusivities. Although the resulting diffusivities are close to the values reported in the literature, we find important qualitative differences in the diffusion mechanisms. Capturing the correct mechanisms is crucial to properly describe the chemistry and fission rate dependence of the model.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Effect of Solvents on Lignin–Surface Interactions via Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Lignin, an essential building block of lignocellulosic biomass, is a potential abundant source of aromatic monomers for the polymer and chemical industry. Reductive catalytic fractionation (RCF) is one promising process that can produce high yields of phenolic monomers and oligomers from lignin under different catalytic conditions. An important choice in optimizing RCF is the selection of solvent; however, detailed insights into solvent effects on lignin behaviors and interactions remain limited. Here, in this work, we perform all-atom molecular dynamics simulations to study the solvation of lignin, solvent-mediated conformational changes, and the interaction of solvated lignin oligomers with model surfaces. We focus on the behavior of an oligomeric lignin model compound in methanol, ethanol, a binary mixture of ethanol and water, and water at both the RCF reaction temperature (473 K) and room temperature. Analysis of structural features of lignin suggests that these three organic solvent systems favorably solvate lignin, resulting in a more extended conformation suitable for catalytic conversion to valuable chemicals. We further introduce model palladium (Pd) and carbon (C) surfaces to understand how solvent choice impacts adsorption onto a representative catalytic surface and support, and to quantify the competition among the reactant and solvent molecules for the surface. Unbiased simulations suggest strong adsorption of lignin on both Pd and C surfaces at 473 K, with notable solvent-mediated differences in adsorption energies. Additionally, our findings indicate that lignin adsorption is promoted by the entropy change resulting from the displacement of solvent molecules from the surface. This study provides a molecular perspective of adsorption of lignin onto varying surfaces, which is a step towards understanding and optimizing the catalytic conversion of lignin into valuable chemicals.

adsorption↗

Molecular dynamics simulations of uranyl and plutonyl cations in a task-specific ionic liquid

Ionic liquids (ILs) are a unique class of solvents with potential applications in advanced separation technologies relevant to the nuclear industry. ILs are salts with low melting points and a wide range of tunable physical properties, such as viscosity, hydrophobiciy, conductivity, and liquidus range. ILs have negligible vapor pressure, are often non-flammable, and can have high thermal stability and a wide electrochemical window, making them attractive for use in separations processes relevant to the nuclear industry. Metal salts generally have a low solubility in ILs; however, by incorporating new functional groups into the IL cation or anion that promote complexation with the metal, the solubility can be greatly increased. One such task-specific ionic liquid (TSIL) is 1-carboxy-N, N, N-trimethylglycine bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ([Hbet][Tf 2 N]). Water, which is detrimental for electrochemical separations, is a common impurity in ILs and can coordinate with actinyl cations, particularly in ILs containing only weakly coordinating components. Understanding the behavior of actinides in TSIL/water mixtures on a molecular level is vital for designing improved separations processes. Classical molecular dynamics simulations of uranyl(VI) and plutonyl(VI) in 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ([EMIM][Tf 2 N]) with deprotonated Hbet (betaine) and water have been performed to understand the coordination and dynamics of the actinyl cations. We find that betaine is a much stronger ligand than water and prefers to coordinate the metal in a bidentate manner. Potential of mean force simulations yield a relative free energy for betaine coordination of approximately -120 to -90 kJ/mol in mixtures with water. As the amount of betaine coordinated to the actinide increases, the diffusion coefficient of the actinyl cation decreases. Moreover, the betaine ligand is able to bridge between two metal centers, resulting in dimeric complexes with actinide–actinide distances of ~5 Å. Potential of mean force simulations show that these structures are stable, with relative free energies of up to -40 kJ/mol. The crystal structure for [(UO 2 ) 2 (bet) 6 (H 2 O) 2 ][Tf 2 N] 4 shows that the betaine bridges between two uranium atoms to form dimeric complexes similar to those found in our simulations.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Sticking Coefficients of Fusion Reactor Impurities from Molecular Dynamics Simulations for the Design of Cryopumps

A cryopump can be utilized as an impurity removal component of a direct internal recirculation (DIR) system for the fusion fuel cycle. The DIR facilitates a low fuel inventory by continuously pumping unburnt fuel while removing impurities from the fusion exhaust stream. A cryopump can target multiple impurity species by maintaining a temperature lower than the gas triple-point temperature that promotes desublimation. The desublimation/condensation of gases in cryopumps can be characterized by the sticking coefficient, which is defined as the probability for a gas particle to stick to a (cryo-)surface upon collision. The sticking coefficient is one of the important design/operation parameters for cryopumps, and it depends on a variety of surface and gas properties. Here, in this study, molecular dynamics simulations were utilized to estimate the sticking coefficients of typical fusion gas impurity species N 2 , CO 2 , and CH 4 over a Cu surface for a range of gas temperatures and surface coverages. The molecular dynamics study showed that the sticking coefficients for gases decrease with an increase in gas temperature. The presence of a single full monolayer of condensate on the metallic surface showed an adverse effect on the sticking of gases; however the sticking improved with two full monolayers of condensate on the surface. The sticking of gases over the mixed condensate on a surface was more favorable than the condensate of the same species for N 2 and CH 4 , with an exception for CO 2 , which showed a decrease in sticking over the mixed condensate.

cryopump↗

Active learning of a crystal plasticity flow rule from discrete dislocation dynamics simulations

Continuum-scale material deformation models, such as crystal plasticity (CP), can significantly enhance their predictive accuracy by incorporating input from lower-scale (i.e. mesoscale) models. The procedure to generate and extract the relevant information is however typically complex and ad hoc, involving decision and intervention by domain experts, leading to long development times. In this study, we develop a principled approach for calibration of continuum-scale models using lower scale information by representing a CP flow rule as a Gaussian process model. This representation allows for efficient parameter space exploration, guided by the uncertainty embedded in the model through a process known as Bayesian optimization (BO). We demonstrate a semi-autonomous BO loop which instantiates discrete dislocation dynamics simulations whose initial conditions are automatically chosen to optimize the uncertainty of a model CP flow rule. Our self-guided computational pipeline efficiently generated a dataset and corresponding model whose error, uncertainty, and physical feature sensitivities were validated with comparison to an independent dataset four times larger, demonstrating a valuable and efficient active learning implementation readily transferable to similar material systems.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Microscale mechanical property variations of Al-substituted LLZO: insights from compression testing and molecular dynamics simulations

Ceramic solid electrolytes based on LLZO (Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 ) are promising candidates for all-solid-state batteries due to their high ionic conductivity and good apparent stability vs. lithium metal, however they are prone to mechanical failure. Lithium metal intrusions, alongside cell stack pressure, transition polycrystalline solid electrolyte grains into a compressed state that promotes crack propagation and fracture. Here this work examines the mechanical response of Al-substituted LLZO to compressive forces by measuring ultimate strength under pillar compression with a flat punch tip. Failure modes characterized by in situ scanning electron microscopy show diverse splitting patterns arising from internal porosity, grain boundaries, and slip planes. Large correlated variations in compressive strength (0.93–2.63 GPa) and Young's modulus (72.1–150.97 GPa) are observed across microscale regions of the solid electrolyte. Molecular dynamics simulations of LLZO with different porosities describe the variation of compressive strength and Young's modulus, and enable a microscale porosity model to be fit accounting for Young's modulus reduction across the solid electrolyte. Overall, the results indicate the importance of microscale mechanical testing of ceramic solid electrolytes to identify preferential sites for mechanical degradation and Li intrusion, and ensure the robust design of all-solid-state lithium metal batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Consistent and reproducible computation of the glass transition temperature from molecular dynamics simulations

In many fields, from semiconductors for opto-electronic applications to ionic liquids (ILs) for separations, the glass transition temperature (Tg) of a material is a useful gauge for its potential use in practical settings. As a result, there is a great deal of interest in predicting Tg using molecular simulations. However, the uncertainty and variation in the trend shift method, a common approach in simulations to predict Tg, can be high. This is due to the need for human intervention in defining a fitting range for linear fits of density with temperature assumed for the liquid and glass phases across the simulated cooling. The definition of such fitting ranges then defines the estimate for the Tg as the intersection of linear fits. We eliminate this need for human intervention by leveraging the Shapiro–Wilk normality test and proposing an algorithm to define the fitting ranges and, consequently, Tg. Through this integration, we incorporate into our automated methodology that residuals must be normally distributed around zero for any fit, a requirement that must be met for any regression problem. Consequently, fitting ranges for realizing linear fits for each phase are statistically defined rather than visually inferred, obtaining an estimate for Tg without any human intervention. The method is also capable of finding multiple linear regimes across density vs temperature curves. We compare the predictions of our proposed method across multiple IL and semiconductor molecular dynamics simulation results from the literature and compare other proposed methods for automatically detecting Tg from density–temperature data. We believe that our proposed method would allow for more consistent predictions of Tg. We make this methodology available and open source through GitHub.

Chemistry↗

Deep potential molecular dynamics simulations of low-temperature plasma-surface interactions

Machine learning approaches to potential generation for molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of low-temperature plasma-surface interactions could greatly extend the range of chemical systems that can be modeled. Empirical potentials are difficult to generalize to complex combinations of multiple elements with interactions that might include covalent, ionic, and metallic bonds. This work demonstrates that a specific machine learning approach, Deep Potential Molecular Dynamics (DeepMD), can generate potentials that provide a good model of plasma etching in the Si-Cl-Ar system. Comparisons are made between MD results using DeepMD models and empirical potentials, as well as experimental measurements. Pure Si properties predicted by the DeepMD model are in reasonable agreement with experimental results. Simulations of Si bombardment by Ar + ions demonstrate the ability of the DeepMD method to predict sputtering yields as well as the depth of the amorphous-crystalline interface. Etch yields as a function of flux ratio and ion energy for simultaneous Cl 2 and Ar + impacts are in good agreement with previous simulation results and experiment. Predictions of etch yields and etch products during plasma-assisted atomic layer etching of Si-Cl 2 -Ar are shown to be in good agreement with MD predictions using empirical potentials and with experiment. Finally, good agreement was also seen with measurements for the spontaneous etching of Si by Cl atoms at 300 K. Further, the demonstration that DeepMD can reproduce results from MD simulations using empirical potentials is a necessary condition to future efforts to extend the method to a much wider range of systems for which empirical potentials may be difficult or impossible to obtain.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Understanding the structural mechanics of ligated DNA crystals via molecular dynamics simulation

DNA self-assembly is a highly programmable method to construct arbitrary architectures based on sequence complementarity. Among various constructs, DNA crystals are macroscopic crystalline materials formed by assembling motifs via sticky end association. Due to their high structural integrity and size ranging from tens to hundreds of micrometers, DNA crystals offer unique opportunities to study the structural properties and deformation behaviors of DNA assemblies. For example, enzymatic ligation of sticky ends can selectively seal nicks resulting in more robust structures with enhanced mechanical properties. However, the research efforts have been mostly on experiments involving different motif designs, structural optimization, or new synthesis methods, while their mechanics are not yet fully understood. The complex properties of DNA crystals are difficult to study via experiments alone, and numerical simulation can complement and aid the experiments. The coarse-grained molecular dynamics (MD) simulation is a powerful tool that can probe the mechanics of DNA assemblies. Here, we investigate DNA crystals made of four different motif lengths with various ligation patterns (full ligation, major directions, connectors, and in-plane) using oxDNA, an open-source, coarse-grained MD platform. We found that several distinct deformation stages emerge in response to mechanical loading and that the number and the location of ligated nucleotides can significantly modulate structural behaviors. These findings should be useful for predicting crystal properties and thus improving the design.

DNA crystal↗

Coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulation of solvent-dependent cellulose nanofiber interactions

Associations between cellulose are important both in biofuel production and in the use of cellulose for biomaterials. Cellulose nanofibers (CNFs) are sustainable, strong, light-weight alternatives to traditional materials in manufacturing, but are challenging to obtain due to irreversible aggregation in solution during preparative fibrillation. Therefore, it is imperative to understand the underlying factors driving aggregation with a view to designing solvents that can effectively compete with interfiber interactions, hence reducing aggregation. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation at atomic detail can provide useful information on local interactions. However, the length and timescales accessible are too short to fully capture association processes. Here, we provide a method for accessing the longer length and timescales required using coarse-grained (CG) MD simulations with a MARTINI force field to calculate the interaction behavior of CNFs in three selected solvents: NaOH-urea-water, acetone, and neat water. The CG results are consistent with our prior all-atom MD and with previous experimental results. While acetone is found not to be an effective solvent, urea and ionic moieties in NaOH-urea-water not only solvate the fibrils but also improve the confinement of water molecules around them as shown by the solvent residence times and mean-square displacements. Overall, the presence of urea and ions reduces the likelihood of aggregation in multi-CNF systems relative to neat water irrespective of whether the hydrophobic or hydrophilic CNF surfaces are interacting. In conclusion, the CG method shows clear promise for selecting potential high-performance solvents for experimental prioritization in bioenergy and biomaterials research in a relatively fast manner as well as for understanding the aggregation and rheological behavior of CNF-solvent systems.

aggregation↗

Primary defect production from molecular dynamics simulations of high-energy displacement cascades in NbMoTaW alloys

In this work, we report on large-scale molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations of displacement cascades in equiatomic NbMoTaW alloys at PKA energies ranging from 0.15 to 150 keV. We find defect production to be strongly dependent on recoil energy, scaling sublinearly up to 10 keV, and linearly thereafter. We find the sublinear regime to be defined by low values of surviving Frenkel pairs, typically found as isolated point defects or small defect clusters, while at higher recoil energies dense cascades become more frequent, leading to splitting into subcascades and the production of relatively large prismatic-dislocation loops with ⟨111⟩ and ⟨001⟩ Burgers vectors. These loops immobilize large fractions of defects, leading to a rapid growth of the number of surviving defects in the linear regime. We also anneal post-cascade defect configurations using object-kinetic Monte Carlo (OKMC) simulations to account for intracascade recombination on time scales not accessible to MD simulations. Cascade annealing is strongly temperature dependent, with the OKMC simulations only showing significant recovery at 1000 K but not below. Our results are in general agreement with existing published data for refractory concentrated alloys.

Zhou, Xinran [Lawrence Berkeley National Laborator↗

Linear Discriminant Analysis-Based Machine Learning and All-Atom Molecular Dynamics Simulations for Probing Electro-Osmotic Transport in Cationic-Polyelectrolyte-Brush-Grafted Nanochannels

Deciphering the correct mechanisms governing certain phenomena in polyelectrolyte (PE) brush grafted systems, revealed through atomistic simulations, is an extremely challenging problem. In a recent study, our all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations revealed a non-linearly large electroosmotic (EOS) flow (in the presence of an applied electric field) in nanochannels grafted with PMETAC [Poly(2-(methacryloyloxy)ethyl trimethylammonium chloride] brushes. Given the lack of any formal procedure that would have directed us to identify the correct factors responsible for such an occurrence, we needed to spend several months and devote significant analyses to unravel the involved mechanisms. In this paper, we propose a Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) based Machine Learning (ML) approach to address this gap. At first, we obtain data on certain basic features from the all-atom MD data. These basic features represent the number of atoms of certain species around one atom of another (or same) species. Here, we obtain such data on basic features for a reference case (case of an EOS flow in PMETAC-brush-grafted nanochannels with a smaller electric field) and a perturbed case (case of an EOS flow in PMETAC-brush-grafted nanochannels with a larger electric field) in bins in which the nanochannel half height has been divided into. These datasets are high-dimensional dataset, to which the LDA is applied. This leads to the projection of the data (between the reference and the perturbed states) in a highly separated form on a 1D line. From such LDA calculations, we are able to identify the relative importance of the different basic features in ensuring this separation of the data (between the reference and the perturbed states) on the 1D line. This relative importance of the different basic features is quantified as “importance scores” for the different features, which in turn tell us what to study and where to study. Such knowledge enables us to rapidly identify the key factors responsible for the non-linearly large EOS transport in PMETAC-brush-grafted nanochannels.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Unraveling the Nature of Vibrational Dynamics in CsPbI 3 by Inelastic Neutron Scattering and Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Cesium lead iodide, CsPbI 3 , is an optoelectronic material of large interest for various technological applications; however, fundamental questions surrounding the vibrational dynamics of this material, especially regarding its role in structural phase transitions, remain to be elucidated. Here, in a combined variable temperature inelastic neutron scattering (INS) and machine-learning based molecular dynamics (MD) simulation study, we show that the stable phase at room temperature, i.e., the nonperovskite δ-phase, exhibits phonon modes with weak anharmonicity with only a weak temperature dependence from 10 K all the way up to the transition to the cubic perovskite α-phase at approximately 600 K. In contrast, the α-phase features anharmonic and damped vibrational dynamics, mainly associated with overdamped tilting motions of the PbI 6 octahedra. Crucially, these overdamped tilting modes, which relate to the tetragonal and orthorhombic distorted perovskite phases (β- and γ-phase, respectively) formed at lower temperatures, stay overdamped by more than 100 K above the respective phase transition. This suggests a flat energy landscape of octahedral tilting motions in α-CsPbI3 and with structural fluctuations on the picosecond time scale with tilting patterns that locally resemble the structure of the β- and γ-phases. The vibrational dynamics of α-CsPbI 3 are also characterized by pronounced anharmonic motions with large thermal displacements of the Cs + ions, but these modes remain underdamped at 600 K.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Energy-efficient, Large-scale Molecular Dynamics Simulations via Hardware- and Algorithm-level Optimization

This work aims to develop a framework for energy-efficient computing that will enable molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of large-scale phenomena with atomic precision and simultaneously remove computational bottlenecks limiting the speed of MD simulations. We seek to implement such an approach through the development of surrogate models for the interatomic force calculation combined with the use of mixed numerical precision formats. For a model system of neutral atoms (only pairwise interactions), significant force calculation efficiency improvements were achieved, without detrimental effects on atomic structures or average energies, using single precision, by developing a surrogate model (deep neural network), and by quantizing this surrogate model. For a model system of charged atoms, the reciprocal-space calculation of electrostatic interactions was identified as the main bottleneck, and the development of a surrogate model should be pursued to achieve an estimated one-order-of-magnitude additional speedup.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Deep potential molecular dynamics simulations of ion-enhanced etching of silicon by atomic chlorine

The continued development of plasma-assisted processing techniques requires a fundamental understanding of plasma-surface interactions. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have been employed to complement experimental studies and better understand the properties of such systems. Recently, machine learning (ML) methods have enabled the development of ab initio-based interatomic potentials, which can be generalized to complex combinations of multiple atom types. In this work, we use ML potentials developed using the Deep Potential Molecular Dynamics (DeepMD) framework to provide a model of ion-enhanced etching of Si by Cl atoms. We demonstrate the importance of proper selection of the training data set to the accuracy of the DeepMD model and compare our results to MD results using empirical potentials, as well as to experimental measurements. Exposure of undoped Si at 300 K to thermal Cl atoms yields a steady-state Cl coverage of 1.25 monolayers, which is slightly lower than the value obtained in previous experimental studies. Predictions of Si etch yields by simultaneous Cl atom and Ar + ion impacts as a function of ion energy, neutral to ion flux ratio, and angle of incidence of the ions are in reasonably good agreement with classical MD results and experimental measurements. Finally, etch yields and SiCl x mixed layer thicknesses during simultaneous bombardment of the Si(100) surface by Cl atoms and Cl + ions are in good agreement with experimental data. In conclusion, the present work is a necessary condition for the extension of the DeepMD procedure to more complex systems of interest in plasma-surface interactions.

Artificial neural networks↗

Operator learning for energy-efficient building ventilation control with computational fluid dynamics simulation of a real-world classroom

Energy-efficient ventilation control plays an important role in reducing building energy consumption while ensuring occupant health and comfort. While Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations provide detailed and physically accurate representations of indoor airflow, their high computational cost limits their use in real-time building control. In this work, we present a neural operator learning framework that combines the physical accuracy of CFD with the computational efficiency of machine learning to enable building ventilation control with the high-fidelity fluid dynamics models. Our method jointly optimizes the airflow supply rates and vent angles to reduce energy use and adhere to air quality constraints. We train an ensemble of neural operator transformer models to learn the mapping from building control actions to airflow fields using high-resolution CFD data. This learned neural operator is then embedded in an optimization-based control framework for building ventilation control. Experimental results show that our approach achieves significant energy savings compared to maximum airflow rate control, rule-based control, as well as data-driven control methods using spatially averaged CO 2 prediction and deep learning–based reduced-order models, while consistently maintaining safe indoor air quality. These results highlight the practicality and scalability of our method in maintaining energy efficiency and indoor air quality in real-world buildings.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Si–Cl 2 –Ar + Atomic Layer Etching Window: A Fundamental Study Using Molecular Dynamics Simulations and a Reduced Order Model

Silicon (Si) atomic layer etching (ALE) by alternating exposure to chlorine gas (Cl 2 ) and argon ions (Ar + ) is studied by using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and a reduced order model (ROM). Here, the purpose of this study is to elucidate the properties of the ALE window, a range of ion energies where the amount of Si etched over a series of cycles is nonzero and nearly independent of ion energy. Experimental studies of the Si–Cl 2 –Ar + ALE system report contradictory results related to the ALE window’s ion energy range. Both MD simulations and the ROM show that there is an ALE window present from approximately 15 to 20 eV for normal incidence argon ions. The Si–Cl 2 –Ar + system, therefore, exhibits a narrow ALE window. The amount of Si etched per cycle is less than one atomic layer because of the higher etch yield of Cl atoms relative to atomic Si and silicon chlorides. A modified version of the ROM with an artificially increased Si physical sputtering threshold energy expands the ALE window, illustrating the importance of the difference in chemical and physical sputtering threshold energies in the ALE window energy range. The ROM is also used to examine the dependence of the EPC on the Ar + ion fluence.

energy↗