Directed Energy Deposition of Vanadium for Interlayers in Laser Welding
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Presentation for American Welding Society Professional Program 2025.
Directed energy deposition (DED) is a form of additive manufacturing that uses localized melted metal, similar to traditional arc welding, to construct an object. In comparison to polymer systems, metal systems can exert additional control over the build process through manipulation of the pool of melted metal, called the “melt pool.” This is especially important to maintain appropriate layer heights and create high quality builds. Additionally, metal systems allow site-specific control of the printed part, which enables advanced construction techniques that would otherwise not be possible. However, both of these types of control require support from the slicing software and, potentially, sensor feedback. This chapter will discuss these control processes and their basic implementation in a slicing program. The processes described here lay the foundation for more advanced solutions, particularly sensor feedback, that will be discussed later.
This report summarizes the progress made on the project during the first quarter of FY22. The model for deep penetration laser welding continues to be developed to understand and mitigate cracking issues associated with laser welding Alloy 740H. The effects of laser wobble on laser welding of this alloy are also being developed. Additionally, the short-term creep behavior of welds made by various hybrid laser arc parameters has been obtained and the results indicate they are comparable to welds made by conventional gas tungsten arc welding which is a factor 2 slower than the hybrid welds. Additionally, the creep behavior of laser-only welds is also consistent with conventional gas tungsten arc welds as well as the hybrid laser arc welds made under this project. However, the creep rate of the laser-only welds is much higher than that observed in the hybrid laser arc welded specimens. This is most likely due to the narrower weld produced by laser-only welding compared to hybrid laser arc welding and, thus, the higher creep rate of laser-only welded creep specimens is likely a result of the increased fraction of base metal (which exhibits a higher creep rate than weld metal) contained within the gage section of the creep specimen. Creep rupture lifetimes were all about the same for both laser-only and hybrid laser arc welded specimens and consistent with the creep rupture lifetime of conventional gas tungsten arc welded creep specimens.
This report summarizes the progress made on reducing the joining time for thick plates of Alloy 740H. Modeling of deep penetration laser welding of Alloy 740H continues with the goal of explaining cracking in the weld that is observed in experimental laser welds in this alloy. Experimental work was also performed to understand factors influencing hybrid laser arc weld quality as a function of the arc and laser parameters. Laser welds and hybrid laser arc welds have been made using best practices up this point in the project. Welded materials have been sent to a commercial vendor to make creep specimens and perform short term creep tests to help evaluate the quality of the welds that have been made so far.
During the 3rd quarter of FY22, progress was made on modeling and simulation of deep penetration laser welding of Alloy 740H. Advances in the modeling of residual stress development arising from the calculated temperature field of the solidifying weld pool were made to understand the development of solidification cracking. Additionally, preliminary modeling of the temperature field within the weld pool of a wobbling laser heat source was performed. The maximum temperature of the weld pool was found to vary with time. These result will allow modeling of deep penetration laser welding using a wobbling laser to mitigate weld defects and cracking. Also, additional characterization of hybrid laser arc welds indicated that these welds were not defect-free as originally thought and the current HLA welds would not be acceptable under criteria outlined in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section IX. Therefore, additional welding trails with variation of the welding parameters and HLA welding configurations are required to produce welds acceptable under the Section IX criteria. It was shown that considerable reduction of HLAW defects had been achieved with each successive welding campaign. Therefore additional variation of HLAW parameters may still yield the desired defect-free welds, however, options for alternate HLAW configurations as well as plate preheating are outlined as contingency plans to obtain suitable welds. These additional (unplanned) HLAW trial may prevent subsequent milestones from being achieved within the original budget.
Welding repair of irradiated nuclear reactor materials such as austenitic stainless steels used for the reactor internals has been challenging due to irradiation generated helium in the material matrix over an extended period of time. In this study, improved laser welding techniques, including the novel Auxiliary Beam Stress Improved (ABSI) technique that proactively manages the stresses during laser repair welding is investigated to substantially reduce or avoid the occurrence of intergranular helium-induced cracking (HeIC). Here, laser weld cladding, with and without ABSI technique, was applied to deposit weld metal on irradiated stainless steel (Type 304 L) blocks with various helium concentrations up to approximately 20 atomic parts per million (appm). Welded samples were cross-sectioned and analyzed using optical and electron microscopes. It was found that, with the improved laser welding techniques, no macroscopic (millimeter-sized) cracks were observed in any of the samples. Microscopic (less than 50 μm) cracks were present in the heat affected zone. Statistical analysis on the sample with the highest helium concentration (~20 appm) reveals that the ABSI technique could effectively reduce the size and amounts of microscopic cracks.
Welding repair of irradiated nickel-based alloys, such as Alloy 182, poses a significant challenge due to helium-induced cracking (HeIC) and grain boundary degradation (GBD) in the heat affected zone, driven by helium accumulation at grain boundaries and welding-induced tensile stresses. This study investigates the weldability of irradiated Alloy 182 up to 15 wppm doped boron using both conventional laser welding and the Auxiliary Beam Stress Improved (ABSI) laser welding technique. While HeIC was observed at the weld toe of the entry pass in both methods due to the higher effective heat input associated with the initial pass directly on the base metal, no additional cracking occurred elsewhere, even at elevated helium concentrations. Optical and scanning electron microscopy analysis revealed that the ABSI technique, which introduces additional compressive stresses to counteract solidification-induced tensile stresses, significantly reduced GBD formation, lowering its total count from 1,230 to 339 and decreasing both average and maximum GBD lengths. In conclusion, these results demonstrate that the ABSI technique is a promising approach to mitigate helium-induced damage and improve the weldability of irradiated Alloy 182, offering a viable solution for structural repairs for long-term operation of existing nuclear reactors.
The presentation reviews the progress made toward reducing the joining time of an advanced nickel-based alloy, Alloy 740H by a factor of two using a novel two step fusion welding approach. In the first step, a high powered laser is used to rapidly join thick weld groove lands (~10-12 mm thick) during a single pass. Hybrid laser arc welding (HLAW) is then used to fill the remaining weld groove and complete the joint. This sequential process also utilizes laser wobble in both steps to reduce welding defects and refine the weld microstructure to obtain improved properties compared to conventional gas tungsten or gas metal arc welds, GTAW and GMAW, respectively. The creep behavior of laser-only thick weld groove land welds and HLAW welds were found to be the same or slightly improved compared to conventional GMAW or GTAW welds in this alloy. Creep tests have been started to verify the long-term creep behavior (~10,000 hrs) of these welds. Modeling results on deep penetration laser welding are presented and the initial simulations of laser welding with laser wobble are shown. The next phase of the project will combine the two processes to make complete welds - deep penetration laser welds of thick weld groove lands followed by rapid filling of the remaining weld groove by HLAW - in thick plates (32 mm thick) Alloy 740H plate and entails development of narrow weld groove welding to further decrease the joining time of this alloy.
Although progress has been slowed by telecommuting restrictions at INL and PSU, progress has been made by PSU on modeling and simulation of deep penetration laser welding. Additionally, both INL and PSU has received critical equipment, in the form of high-powered laser wobble heads, needed to verify the modeling and simulation results. The equipment was installed at INL and preliminary tests, based on a test matrix that was developed in this 3rd quarter, will be made early in the 4th quarter. Similarly, the PSU laser wobble head is expected to be installed early in the 4th quarter and preliminary experiments are expected to commence shortly thereafter. Completion dates on a few milestones have been impacted and new dates proposed.
Designing a welded joint requires consideration of the welding process, component/assembly structure and weld geometry, material composition, properties, and desired joint performance. The designer must also specify a set of acceptance criteria used to evaluate the welds. This study was conducted to support the design team responsible for specifying the spot weld profile by investigating the relationship between weld process parameters and the weld geometry and properties to further inform design optimization. The subjects of this study are two thin stainless steel 304L (SS304L) components joined by Laser Beam Welding (LBW). The components are the Housing, which contains flexible circuitry, and the Cover that protects the circuitry during handling, installation, and under service loads. Figure 1 illustrates coupon versions of the Cover and Housing used to simulate the interface between these components for weld testing. These coupon representations of assembly components were designed to match the material and relevant geometry related to the welded joint while other features not relevant to the welded joint are excluded.The objective of this study was to characterize the sensitivity of the weld geometry and mechanical properties to the input weld parameters to inform further Finite Element Analysis (FEA) efforts in balancing joint strength against assembly deformation caused by the welding process. Characterization was accomplished by varying laser welding parameters around the current design values and measuring weld geometry on the cross-sections. Nanoindentation with a spherical and flat-ended tip was used on polished section cuts of the weld to obtain direct estimates of the stress-strain response of the Fusion Zone (FZ) for comparison to the Base Metal (BM).
This reports complete Milestone M2.2.3 Produce zirconium hydride moderator material. In this milestone, we report the successful fabrication of FeCrAl alloys cladded zirconium hydride moderator. Different types of crucible designs were presented, including the basic design with bar cladding material, basic design with tube cladding material, and crucible design with position holding function. Mo and FeCrAl were used as the trial cladding materials. The welding techniques and procedures were reported and discussed. Totally three welding techniques were adopted in the development of moderator cladding, and they are electron beam welding (EBW), laser welding (LW), and gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW). After welding, all cladded crucibles were evaluated with two kinds of leak testing, the helium leak test for minor leakage and the bubble test for major leakage. Due to the concern of the poor neutronics performance, Mo was not ideal for future moderator cladding application. Therefore, detailed characterization of the Mo cladded zirconium hydride was not pursued. Instead, the characterization of FeCrAl cladded zirconium hydride was performed. We discussed two material conditions (i.e., as machined and pre-oxidized conditions) prior to the cladding process, evaluated thermal stability of cladded zirconium hydride moderator through directly measuring hydrogen release, and characterized the zirconium hydride following the thermal desorption measurement. The results showed pre-oxidized FeCrAl is capable of efficiently preventing hydrogen release from the moderator assembly.
Here, the goal of this work is to understand if an additively manufactured 304L stainless steel exhibits similar spot-welding behavior as wrought 304L stainless steel. Due to the many differences between an additively manufactured component and wrought product, it is important to determine how the material interacts with the laser and how it affects the weld bead morphology. In this paper, the laser coupling efficiency, weld size, and solidification of spot welds produced in wrought and additively manufactured 304L stainless steel were investigated. The coupling efficiency of wrought and additively manufactured 304L stainless steel of similar surface condition were approximately the same over a range of applied laser energies. Laser welding of the untreated (rougher) surface of additively manufactured 304L, however, showed improved coupling efficiency ranging between 3.3 and 100%. The rougher surface traps the incoming light and increases the coupling efficiency at lower laser energies, while at higher energy, the absorption efficiency is dominated by intrinsic absorption from the keyhole formation rather than surface roughness. The resulting spot weld microstructures differed from welds made in wrought 304L and additively manufactured 304L. Welds made in wrought 304L were fully austenitic containing what is suspected to be massive austenite, which suggests that these welds solidified as primary ferrite. Welds made in additively manufactured 304L were also fully austenitic and contained both cellular austenite and what is suspected to be massive austenite. These observations mean that welds made in additively manufactured 304L solidified as primary ferrite and primary austenite. The differences in weld microstructures made in wrought and AM 304L can be attributed to differences in the composition and solidification rate.
Microchannel recuperators can achieve high-efficiency power cycles and chemical reactions by recovering waste heat from hot turbine exhaust and chemical reaction streams. However, the industrial application of microchannel recuperators are restricted by the high cost of patterning and bonding. The objective of this study was thus to investigate new methods for producing microchannel recuperators for emerging markets. Based on greenfield cost estimates, process designs based on stamping, laser welding and vacuum brazing of 316L stainless steel laminae were found to be more economical than conventional photochemical machining and diffusion bonding. Subsequently, validation experiments were conducted to produce stamped microchannel components using cost model parameters. At a mass flow rate of 0.99 g/s, the test article made with laser welding was found to provide higher effectiveness than the test article produced using vacuum brazing. Preliminary investigations showed that residual stresses during laser welding of the laminae led to significant warpage, collapsing channels and making lamina-to-lamina fit up challenging. In contrast, the test article produced by vacuum brazing of stamped laminae showed no clogging and 4.6% and 10.5% channel height standard deviation for the cold and hot channels, respectively. Channel variation in the vacuum brazing sample was determined to be caused by misregistration of laminae during brazing. In future work, efforts are needed to choose cheaper, more ductile brazing foils as well as design a brazing fixture to improve lamina-to-lamina registration.
During the first quarter of FY20, work focused on implementing a subcontract with Penn State University to collaborate on the project. Significant delays prevented the subcontract from being placed until the end of December. As a result only limited progress was made on the project. Required equipment was researched and ordered during the first quarter but will not be delivered until the middle of the second quarter of FY20. Delays are not expected to adversely impact the schedule of the project.