Assessment of Ku- and Ka-band Dual-Frequency Radar for Snow Retrieval
Dual-frequency Ku/Ka-band radar retrievals of snow parameters such as liquid-equivalent snowfall rate (R) and mass-weighted diameter (Dm) have two principal errors, namely, the differences between the assumed particle size distribution (PSD) model from the actual PSD and inadequacies in characterizing the single-scattering properties of snowflakes. Regarding the first issue, this study, based on radar simulations from a large amount of observed PSD data, shows that there exist relatively high correlations between the estimated snow parameters and their true values derived directly from the measured PSD. For PSD data with R greater than 0.1 mm h−1, a gamma PSD model with a fixed shape factor (μ) equal to 0 (or exponential distribution) provides the best estimates of R and Dm. This is despite negative biases of up to −15 % in R and underestimates and overestimates in Dm for small and large Dm, respectively. The μ = 0 assumption, however, produces relatively poor estimates of normalized intercepts of a gamma PSD (Nw), whereas the best estimates are obtained when μ is considered either 3 or 6. However, the use of an inappropriate scattering table increases the errors in snow retrieval. Simple evaluations are made for cases where the scattering databases used for the algorithm input differ from that used for retrieval. The mismatched scattering databases alone could cause at least 30 %-50 % changes in the estimates of snow water content (SWC) and R and could affect the retrievals of Dm and Nw and their dependence on μ.