Development of Diffusion Barrier Coatings for Miti
Fuel Cladding Chemical Interactions (FCCI) in a nu
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Fuel Cladding Chemical Interactions (FCCI) in a nu
A refined understanding of zirconium-based cladding thermomechanical performance during rapid transients is essential for enhancing the safety and operation of light-water reactors. Traditional models for zirconium alloys under accident conditions generally assume that creep dominates fuel cladding performance. Here, these historic models have largely remained unchanged and serve as the basis for safety criteria development. As the U.S. nuclear industry pursues higher burnup levels, the increased release of fission gases during transients raises the risk of cladding failure in the low-temperature hcp α-phase, making the fidelity of these models of greater importance. Creep testing was conducted from 550–700°C with 25–120 MPa applied hoop stresses to investigate Zircaloy-4 deformation at accident-relevant temperatures in the α-phase. Step-loading was employed to capture creep behavior across a wide stress range from a single sample. The stress-strain rate data at higher temperatures (650 and 700°C) were well-described by isotropic versions of the Erbacher and Kaddour models, while the lower temperature data (550 and 600°C) were underpredicted by both anisotropic and isotropic model variants. Greater strain rates during the initial loading step at 650 and 700°C were attributed to recrystallization and grain growth of sub-micron crystallites. Yet, texture analysis revealed the basal split texture remained after testing. These observations produced results suggesting Zircaloy-4 claddings experience higher creep rates across the α-phase than previously thought, possibly related to dynamic anisotropy due to temperature dependent activation of deformation mechanisms, effects of biaxial loading, and variation in material condition between the current testing used in previous model development.
Silicon carbide fiber in a silicon carbide matrix composite (SiC-SiC) has been actively researched as a potential structural material to be used in advanced high temperature gas reactors (HTGR) and as an accident tolerant cladding material for light water reactors (LWR). This ceramic composite material demonstrates desirable properties for use in nuclear reactor core that include retention of strength from ambient to LWR and HTGR operating and accident temperatures and stability under neutron radiation. However, the ceramic composite material must be designed to meet all the necessary, application driven requirements before it could be implemented in a reactor design. As one of the requirements for a fuel cladding material, the composite has to maintain high level of impermeability as to retain fission gases throughout the fuel cycle. General Atomics (GA) had previously reported results on permeability levels obtained by CVI produced SiC-SiC composites. It has been determined that for LWR size cladding tube that is 51 mm long the permeability allocation equivalent to currently used claddings is 7.3 E-10 atm*cc/sec. With high level of attention to possible sources of leaks in a test setup, it has been demonstrated that a CVI SiC-SiC composites produced by GA can achieve a leak rate of 1 E-12 atm*cc/sec, and therefore it meets the permeability allocation for a fuel cladding. Further study showed that a particular SiC-SiC composite tube can remain impermeable after being pressure loaded well above LWR normal operating conditions. In the study done by Deck et al., hoop stress was applied to a composite tube using pressure load on the inside surface in a load-unload stepwise sequence with increasing maximum applied stress at each step and measuring permeability between steps. The tested composite comprised of 70% thickness of SiC-SiC composite which provides fracture toughness and bears a majority of the applied stress and a 30% thickness of monolithic SiC layer on the outside surface to provide an impermeable barrier. The composite remained impermeable up to internal pressure of 56 MPa which is more than 2.5 times greater than a typical pressure at the end of life in a fuel rod.
The United States Department of Energy (US DOE) is conducting research and development (R and D) activities within the Used Fuel Disposition Campaign (UFDC) to support storage, transportation, and disposal of used nuclear fuel (UNF) and wastes generated by existing and future nuclear fuel cycles. R and D activities are ongoing at nine national laboratories, and are divided into two major topical areas: (1) storage and transportation research, and (2) disposal research. Storage R and D focuses on closing technical gaps related to extended storage of UNF. For example, uncertainties remain regarding high-burnup nuclear fuel cladding performance following possible hydride reorientation and creep deformation, and also regarding long-term canister integrity. Transportation R and D focuses on ensuring transportability of UNF following extended storage, addressing data gaps regarding nuclear fuel integrity, retrievability, and demonstration of subcriticality. Disposal R and D focuses on identifying multiple viable geologic disposal options and addressing technical challenges for generic disposal concepts in various host media (e.g., mined repositories in salt, clay/shale, and granitic rocks, and deep borehole disposal in crystalline rock). R and D will transition to site-specific challenges as national policy advances. R and D goals at this stage are to increase confidence in the robustness of generic disposal concepts, to reduce generic sources of uncertainty that may impact the viability of disposal concepts, and to develop science and engineering tools that will support the selection, characterization, and ultimately licensing of a repository. The US DOE has also initiated activities that can be conducted within the constraints of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act to facilitate the development of an interim storage facility and supporting transportation infrastructure. (authors)
This contribution investigates fuel constituent segregation and fuel-cladding chemical interactions (FCCI) in three U-Pu-Zr fuel pins irradiated to ~11% burnup in Experimental Breeder Reactor-II as part of the X441 DP-1 experiment. In examined pins, Zr content ranged from 6 to 10 and 14 wt.%, while Pu concentration was constant at 19 wt.% Pu. The primary goal of the investigation was to determine the role Zr content plays in fuel performance and this manuscript provides assessment of both constituent redistribution and FCCI as a function of axial position. FCCI was observed in all pins, though no cladding failure was noted. Optical and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) results show that variation in Zr content alters the number and relative size of constituent redistribution zones in the fuel. For example, larger Zr-rich central regions and smaller U-rich intermediate regions were observed in 14 wt.% Zr fuels. More importantly, all examined fuels have four or more discrete constituent redistribution regions, where each region has dissimilar morphological features. The existence of four to six distinctive regions deviates from traditionally accepted three region redistribution model, highlights complexity of constituent redistribution in this metal fuel, and identifies the need to conduct additional studies using state-of-the-art instrumentation.
The report presents a detailed plan for conducting case studies to characterize probabilistic safety margins associated with different fuel cladding types in a way that supports a valid comparison of different fuels' performance. Recent work performed in other programs is described briefly and used to illustrate the challenges posed by characterization of margin in a probabilistic way. It is additionally pointed out that consistency of evaluation of performance across different cladding types is not easy to assure; a process for achieving the needed consistency is described.
Antimony and tellurium have been identified as promising additives in metallic fuel, which can immobilize free-lanthanide fission products into stable intermetallic compounds in order to mitigate the fuel-cladding chemical interaction. Ce 4 Sb 3 , Ce 2 Sb, and CeTe are the primary compounds formed by Sb or Te with the lanthanide Ce present in the fuel. If these compounds are present at the outer periphery of the fuel, they will come in contact with and react with the cladding after the fuel swells. The present study investigates the reactivity of these compounds with two cladding materials, HT9 and Fe. The diffusion couple tests between these compounds and HT9 or Fe were conducted at 853 K. Scanning electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy were used to analyze the morphology, microstructure, and phase distribution of the diffusion region. It was observed that the diffusion region thickness formed by the three compounds was significantly reduced compared to free Ce. Moreover, there was no observed diffusion or reaction between Ce 4 Sb 3 or Ce 2 Sb with either HT9 or Fe. CeTe was found to diffuse and react with HT9, forming Cr 3 Te 4 and TeFe at the diffusion region, as well as to penetrate into Fe, mainly by intergranular diffusion.
The purpose of this report is to review technical issues relevant to the performance evaluation of dry storage systems during vacuum drying and long-term storage operations. It also provides updates on experimental components under development that are vital for pursuing advanced studies. Validation of the extent of water removal in a multi-assembly dry storage system using an industrial vacuum drying procedure is needed, as operational conditions leading to incomplete drying may have potential impacts on the fuel, cladding, and other components in the system. Water remaining in canisters/casks upon completion of vacuum drying can lead to cladding corrosion, embrittlement, and breaching, as well as fuel degradation. Therefore, additional information is needed to evaluate the potential impacts of water retention on extended long-term dry storage. A general lack of data and experience modeling the drying process necessitates the testing of advanced concepts focused on the simulation of industrial vacuum drying. Smaller-scale tests that incorporate relevant physics and well-controlled boundary conditions are necessary to provide insight and guidance to the modeling of prototypic systems undergoing drying processes. This report describes the development and testing of waterproof, electrically-heated spent fuel rod simulators as a proof of concept to enable experimental simulation of the entire dewatering and drying process. This report also describes the preliminary development of specially-designed, unheated mock fuel rods for monitoring internal rod pressures and studying water removal from simulated failed fuel rods. A variety of moisture monitoring instrumentation is also being considered and will be downselected for the tracking of dewpoints of gas samples. The effects of cladding oxidation and crud on water retention in dry storage systems can be explored via separate effects tests (SETs) that would measure chemisorbed and physisorbed water content on cladding samples. The concepts listed above will be incorporated into an advanced dry cask simulator with multiple fuel assemblies in order to account for important inter-assembly heat-transfer physics. Plans are described for harvesting up to five full-length 5x5 laterally truncated assemblies from commercial 17x17 PWR skeleton components with the goal of constructing this simulator.
Cladding thermal conductivity is an important physical property in assessing the performance of silicon carbide (SiC)-cladded fuels for nuclear reactors. However, there is a significant lack of reliable data, particularly for irradiated materials, because the geometry complicates the measurement. This study investigates the thermal diffusivity of coupons with a curvature, machined from SiC fiber–reinforced SiC matrix composite tubes, with and without neutron irradiation under light water reactor–relevant temperature and dose conditions. The tested materials included full composite and duplex SiC composite tubes. The measurements were conducted using a modern flash diffusivity apparatus. The analyzed area on the specimen during diffusivity testing was reduced for improved measurement accuracy due to sample curvature. Post-irradiation measurements showed that the effects of neutron irradiation on thermal conductivity (e.g. thermal defect resistivity) are different between SiC composite plates versus tubes. The difference was explained by higher matrix density of the tube than the plate. This study provides reliable thermal properties of prototypic SiC composite tubes useful for fuel performance modeling of SiC-based cladding.
Zirconium-based alloys Zircaloy-2 and Zircaloy-4 are widely used in the nuclear industry as cladding materials for light water reactor (LWR) fuels. These materials display a very good combination of properties such as low neutron absorption, creep behavior, stress-corrosion cracking resistance, reduced hydrogen uptake, corrosion and/or oxidation, especially in the case of Zircaloy-4. However, over the last couple of years, in the post-Fukushima Daiichi world, energetic efforts have been undertaken to improve fuel clad oxidation resistance during off-normal temperature excursions. Efforts have also been made to improve upon the already achieved levels of mechanical behavior and reduce hydrogen uptake. In order to facilitate the development of such novel materials, it is very important to achieve not only engineering control, but also a scientific understanding of the underlying material degradation mechanisms, both in working conditions and in storage of used nuclear fuel. This report strives to contribute to these efforts by constructing the thermodynamic models of both alloys; constructing of the respective phase diagrams, and oxidation mechanisms. A special emphasis was placed upon the role of zirconium suboxides in hydrogen uptake reduction and the atomic mechanisms of oxidation. To that end, computational thermodynamics calculations were conducted concurrently with first-principles atomistic modeling.
Iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are candidates to be used as nuclear fuel cladding for increased accident tolerance. An analysis of the response of FeCrAl under normal operating and loss of coolant conditions has been performed using fuel performance modeling. In particular, recent information on FeCrAl material properties and phenomena from separate effects tests has been implemented in the BISON fuel performance code and analyses of integral fuel rod behavior with FeCrAl cladding have been performed. BISON simulations included both light water reactor normal operation and loss-of-coolant accidental transients. In order to model fuel rod behavior during accidents, a cladding failure criterion is desirable. For FeCrAl alloys, a failure criterion is developed using recent burst experiments under loss of coolant like conditions. The added material models are utilized to perform comparative studies with Zircaloy-4 under normal operating conditions and oxidizing and non-oxidizing out-of-pile loss of coolant conditions. The results indicate that for all conditions studied, FeCrAl behaves similarly to Zircaloy-4 with the exception of improved oxidation performance. Here, further experiments are required to confirm these observations.
In order to improve the accident tolerance of light water reactor (LWR) fuel, alternative cladding materials have been proposed to replace zirconium (Zr)-based alloys. Of these materials, there is a particular focus on iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys due to much slower oxidation kinetics in high-temperature steam than Zr-alloys. This should decrease the energy release due to oxidation and allow the cladding to remain integral longer in the presence of high temperature steam, making accident mitigation more likely. As a continuation of the development for these alloys, suitability for normal operation must also be demonstrated. This research is focused on modeling the integral thermo-mechanical performance of FeCrAl-cladded fuel during normal reactor operation. Preliminary analysis has been performed to assess FeCrAl alloys (namely Alkrothal 720 and APMT) as a suitable fuel cladding replacement for Zr-alloys, using the MOOSE-based, finite-element fuel performance code BISON and the best available thermal-mechanical and irradiation-induced constitutive properties. These simulations identify the effects of the mechanical-stress and irradiation response of FeCrAl, and provide a comparison with Zr-alloys. In comparing these clad materials, fuel rods have been simulated for normal reactor operation and simple steady-state operation. Normal reactor operating conditions target the cladding performance over the rod lifetime (~4 cycles) for the highest-power rod in the highest-power fuel assembly under reactor power maneuvering. The power histories and axial temperature profiles input into BISON were generated from a neutronics study on full-core reactivity equivalence for FeCrAl using the 3D full core simulator NESTLE. Evolution of the FeCrAl cladding behavior over time is evaluated by using steady-state operating conditions such as a simple axial power profile, a constant cladding surface temperature, and a constant fuel power history. The fuel rod designs and operating conditions used are based off the Peach Bottom BWR and design consideration was given to minimize the neutronic penalty of the FeCrAl cladding by changing fuel enrichment and cladding thickness. As this study progressed, systematic parametric analysis of the fuel and cladding creep responses were also performed.
HERA is a joint experimental program (JEEP) operating within the Nuclear Energy Agency’s (NEA’s) framework for irradiation experiments (FIDES). HERA is dedicated to the understanding of light water reactor (LWR) fuel performance at high burnup under reactivity-initiated accidents (RIA). During RIAs the fuel cladding can be breached by one of two mechanisms; pellet-cladding mechanical interaction or high temperature balloon and rupture. Pellet-cladding mechanical interaction (PCMI) failure occurs in the early phase of an RIA transient where the fuel pellet expands rapidly into the cladding prior to any meaningful heat transfer from the pellet to the cladding. This results in high stresses in the cladding resulting in crack propagation through the base Zircaloy metal and axially along the cladding tube. Failure by PCMI is a brittle failure mode and occurs at low cladding strains, approximately 2% hoop strain. If the cladding survives the PCMI phase of the transient, it may still fail due to ballooning and rupture induced by extended exposure to high temperature. Thermal transport from the fuel pin to the coolant is significantly reduced if a transition to film boiling on the cladding surface occurs. This result in both a rapid increase in fuel temperature, which drives fission gas release, and a spike in cladding temperature, which results in loss of mechanical strength. If the internal pressure of the fuel rod is greater than the system pressure the cladding can inelastically deform and eventually rupture. Failure by swelling and rupture occurs at larger strains, generally greater than 5% hoop strain. While PCMI failures are generally seen as more limiting, the dominance of one failure mode over the other can be affected by both the cladding material conditions, and the transient evolution.
HERA is a joint experimental program (JEEP) operating within the Nuclear Energy Agency’s (NEA’s) framework for irradiation experiments (FIDES). HERA is dedicated to the understanding of light water reactor (LWR) fuel performance at high burnup under reactivity-initiated accidents (RIA). During RIAs the fuel cladding can be breached by one of two mechanisms; pellet-cladding mechanical interaction or high temperature balloon and rupture. Pellet-cladding mechanical interaction (PCMI) failure occurs in the early phase of an RIA transient where the fuel pellet expands rapidly into the cladding prior to any meaningful heat transfer from the pellet to the cladding. This results in high stresses in the cladding resulting in crack propagation through the base Zircaloy metal and axially along the cladding tube. Failure by PCMI is a brittle failure mode and occurs at low cladding strains, approximately 2% hoop strain. If the cladding survives the PCMI phase of the transient, it may still fail due to ballooning and rupture induced by extended exposure to high temperature. Thermal transport from the fuel pin to the coolant is significantly reduced if a transition to film boiling on the cladding surface occurs. This result in both a rapid increase in fuel temperature, which drives fission gas release, and a spike in cladding temperature, which results in loss of mechanical strength. If the internal pressure of the fuel rod is greater than the system pressure the cladding can inelastically deform and eventually rupture. Failure by swelling and rupture occurs at larger strains, generally greater than 5% hoop strain. While PCMI failures are generally seen as more limiting, the dominance of one failure mode over the other can be affected by both the cladding material conditions, and the transient evolution.
The Advanced Fuels Campaign in collaboration with industry are working to develop enhanced accident tolerant fuels for light water reactors. The initial irradiations of these concepts were performed in the Idaho National Laboratory Advanced Test Reactor using simple drop-in style irradiations. These irradiations are collectively referred to as ATF 1. The postirradiation examination of ATF 1 has begun and some concepts have now completed initial examination. This report describes the results of examinations on ATF 1 irradiations designed to test the feasibility of enhancing UO 2 thermal conductivity with additives, ATF 1 irradiations of uranium silicide, and the current status of ATF 1 irradiations that are in process at the hot cell. Enhanced thermal conductivity uranium dioxide composites containing silicon carbide (UO 2 SiC) and diamond (UO 2 diamond) have been irradiated to low burnup. The conditions of this irradiation test and subsequent postirradiation examinations are discussed. These irradiations evaluate fuel microstructure and potential fuel cladding interaction under representative light water reactor power conditions. Both non destructive and destructive techniques have been used to evaluate fuel integrity, fission gas release, fission product distribution, burnup, fuel swelling and cladding strain. Examination of the UO 2 SiC pellets revealed enhanced cracking when compared to a UO 2 rodlet also irradiated under similar conditions. Additionally, instability of the SiC whiskers in the uranium dioxide matrix was observed in the pellet central region, where the local temperatures exceeded 1300 °C. The microstructure of the diamond added UO 2 was severely disrupted during irradiation, resulting in local migration of cesium along the fuel stack and increased fission gas release when compared with the expected release from the Vitanza curve at corresponding values of burnup and irradiation temperature. The postirradiation examination results cast doubt on the suitability of these additives to improve UO 2 fuel performance in a way that would lead to enhanced accident tolerance. Additionally, postirradiation examination data of U 3 Si 2 fuels at low burnup (i.e., < 20 GWd/tHM) for application in advanced Light Water Reactor (LWR) is presented. The U 3 Si 2 pellets show limited cracking in comparison to the expected behavior of UO 2 at same power level. In addition, gamma scanning data did not reveal migration of fission products. Minor homogeneous hardening along the pellet radius due to accumulation of fission products and radiation damage was measured by microindentation. The fission gas release and swelling remains very low. Formation of fission gas bubbles resolvable with optical microscopy occurs from the pellets center outward to approximately 60% of the fuel pellet radius. The overall data suggest a good performance of this accident tolerant fuel candidate at low burnup. Finally, the current status of postirradiation examination on other ATF 1 irradiations will be discussed. These irradiations include UO 2 clad in an FeCrAl alloy, an alternative uranium silicide compound U 3 Si 5 also clad in a FeCrAl alloy, and an interaction test between UO 2 and different FeCrAl alloys.
Fuel cladding, channel box, and control rod designed with new materials and concepts have been developed in Japan for increasing accident tolerance of Light Water Reactors (LWRs). Fundamental data have been mainly accumulated from the viewpoint of material technology. In order to create the technical basis for the practical use of the accident tolerant fuels (ATFs) and the other components in LWRs, a program sponsored and organized by the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) of Japan has been initiated. Main candidate materials of the ATFs and components in Japan are silicon carbide (SiC), stainless steel including oxide-dispersion strengthened (ODS) FeCrAl alloys, and tri-structural-isotropic (TRISO) fuel. First of all, current status of development of the candidates was investigated using information released from inside and outside Japan. Based on the results of the investigation, technology readiness of the candidates was evaluated and the attribute guide was created to clarify technical subjects for the practical use as the core components of the existing LWRs. For that purpose, a technology readiness table was reviewed in terms of fuel rod design, production and quality management, core and plant design, safety evaluation for design basis accident and severe accident, safety evaluation for transport and storage, establishment of treatment and disposal technologies, and development of standards and criteria, with 9 readiness levels. Considering the reviewed technology readiness table and the additionally evaluated influence of implementation of the new materials, a map of remaining subjects for research/development (Attribute guide) was prepared. Finally, a research plan was drafted for design and fabrication towards implementation of ATFs and components to the existing LWRs. (authors)
To determine the hoop tensile properties of irradiated fuel cladding in a hot cell, a cone wedge ring expansion test method was developed. A four-piece wedge insert was designed with tapered angles matched to the cone shape of a loading piston. The ring specimen was expanded in the radial direction by the lateral expansion of the wedges under the downward movement of the piston. The advantages of the proposed method are that implementation of the test setup in a hot cell is simple and easy, and that it enables a direct strain measurement of the test specimen from the piston’s vertical displacement soon after the wedge-clad contact resistance is initiated.
Metallic/ceramic composite waste forms are being developed to immobilize combined metallic and oxide waste streams generated during electrochemical recycling of used nuclear fuel. Composites were made for corrosion testing by reacting HT9 steel to represent fuel cladding, Zr and Mo to simulate metallic fuel waste, and a mixture of ZrO2, Nd2O3, and UO2 to represent oxide wastes. More than half of the added UO2 was reduced to metal and formed Fe-Zr-U intermetallics and most of the remaining UO2 and all of the Nd2O3 reacted to form zirconates. Fe-Cr-Mo intermetallics were also formed. Microstructure characterization of the intermetallic and ceramic phases that were generated and tests conducted to evaluate their corrosion behaviors indicate composite waste forms can accommodate both metallic and oxidized waste streams in durable host phases. (c) 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.