Results for “Model comparison” — Page 31

NASA NTRS1984

Wind streaks on Mars: Comparisons of production models with observations of bright streaks

To investigate the influence of crater size on martian wind streaks, the characteristics of bright streaks associated with craters ranging from approximately 100 m to 80 km in diameter were analyzed in several regions. The ratio of streak length to obstacle height (L/h) could be diagnostic of the relative effectiveness of different sized obstacles in disturbing near surface atmospheric flow; since the crater rim height to diameter relationship has not previously been determined for Mars, the rim heights of numerous craters were estimated from shadow measurements. In all areas studied, bright streak L/h values decrease with increasing h, indicating that smaller obstacles produce longer streaks relative to their height than do larger obstacles. Several models of bright streak production are used to explain this behavior are discussed.

Lee, S. W.↗

NASA NTRS1986

Comparison of Decision Models

Two methods of multiattribute decision analysis compared in report. One method employs linear utility model. Other utilizes multiplicative utility model. Report based on interviews with experts in automotive technology to obtain their preferences regarding 10 new types of vehicles.

Feinberg, A.↗

NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of regression modeling techniques for resource estimation

The development and validation of resource utilization models is an active area of software engineering research. Regression analysis is the principal tool employed in these studies. However, little attention was given to determining which of the various regression methods available is the most appropriate. The objective of the study is to compare three alternative regession procedures by examining the results of their application to one commonly accepted equations for resource estimation. The data studied was summarized, the resource estimation equation was described, the regression procedures were explained, and the results obtained from the proceures were compared.

Card, D. N.↗

NASA NTRS1986

Comparison of ERBE inferred and model computed clear-sky albedos

Over-ocean clear-sky albedos measured with instruments on the Earth Radiation Budget Satellite (ERBS) are compared with albedos simulated using a radiative transfer model (RTM). The comparison covers the monthly mean albedos for November 1984. The ERBS albedo was calculated with a scene identification algorithm. Techniques used to suppress cloud cover uncertainties are discussed. The plane-parallel delta-Eddington RTM accounted for O3, O2, CO2 and H2O gaseous absorption and background aerosol absorption.

Briegleb, B. P.↗

NASA NTRS1987

Response of middle atmosphere to short-term solar ultraviolet variations. I - Observations. II - Theory

The effects of solar UV variability on ozone and temperature are studied using Nimbus 7 stratospheric and mesospheric ozone, temperature, and 205-nm solar UV data, and Solar Mesosphere Explorer 1.27-micron ozone and 121.6-nm solar UV data. Consideration is given to the temperature/UV relation, the O3/UV relation with and without temperature feedback, and the responses of HNO3 and NO2 to solar UV variability. It is observed that the response times of temperature to solar UV variability are 6 days at 2 mbar and 1 day at 0.01 mbar. The stratospheric ozone response (with no correction for temperature effects) increases, while in the mesosphere a decrease is detected. The responses of ozone and temperature to solar variability are examined and calculated using a one-dimensional chemical-radiative time-dependent model. The comparison of the model results with the satellite-observed responses reveals generally good correlation between the data; however, the model predicts a larger time lag of the temperature response and a larger stratospheric HNO3 mixing ratio than the satellite data. It is noted that the relation between short-term variations in the solar UV radiation and stratospheric ozone is affected by the coupling between ozone and temperature.

Keating, G. M.↗

NASA NTRS1986

Comparison of abrasion model differences in heavy ion fragmentation - Optical versus geometric models

Two different abrasion formalisms, one based on an energy-independent geometric model and the other based on a quantum-mechanical optical model, are shown to yield comparable fragmentation cross section predictions when used as input to an abrasion-ablation frictional-spectator interaction fragmentation calculation which includes electromagnetic dissociation contributions. The results suggest that any dependence upon the incident ion's kinetic energy above 200 MeV/nucleon is weak. It is also noted that the larger surface diffusiveness of the optical model densities only affects nuclear cross sections for near-projectile-mass fragments, while for heavier nuclei, the sizable cross-section contributions from electromagnetic dissociation negate these differences.

Townsend, L. W.↗

NASA NTRS1986

Comparison of two models of total electron content at three midlatitude stations

TEC values calculated with the Bent model were used instead of actual data for the Madrid Deep Space Communications Complex during most of the Voyager Uranus approach and encounter. These values were used from December 1, 1985 to January 16, 1986 for Voyager Uranus, and for March 1986 to support the Pathfinder mission; thus, the Halley flybys of Vega 1 and 2 and Giotto were included. Provided sunspot numbers are below 130, the Bent model can be used with confidence to calculate TEC values for midlatitude stations when actual TEC data or monthly averages are not available.

Royden, H. N.↗

NASA NTRS1988

Stratospheric responses to solar ultraviolet variations - Comparisons with photochemical models

At latitudes and altitudes where transport effects on ozone mixing ratio can be neglected, ozone and temperature responses to short-term changes in solar ultraviolet flux can be used to calculate implied bounds on two basic photochemical parameters: the odd oxygen photochemical relaxation time and the chemical sensitivity of odd oxygen to local temperature changes. Seasonally averaged values of these parameters are derived from response measurements and are compared with model calculations between 0.7 and 4 mbar at tropical latitudes. Results are in agreement within measurement and model uncertainties at all pressure levels. Model values of mean ozone and of the response of ozone to perturbations are functions of the same photochemical data. Therefore this agreement provides a constraint which should be considered when changes are proposed in model input data for the purpose of improving agreement between measured and calculated high-altitude ozone.

Hood, L. L.↗

NASA NTRS1989

Results from baseline tests of the SPRE 1 and comparison with code model predictions

The space power research engine (SPRE), a free piston Stirling engine with linear alternator, is being tested at NASA-Lewis as a candidate for high capacity space power. Results are presented of baseline engine tests at design and off-design operating conditions. The test results are compared with code model prediction.

Cairelli, James E.↗

NASA NTRS1989

A critical comparison of turbulence models for homogeneous shear flows in a rotating frame

A variety of turbulence models, including five second-order closure models and four two equation models, are tested for the problem of homogeneous turbulent shear flow in a rotating frame. The model predictions for the time evolution of the turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate, as well as those for the equilibrium states, are compared with the results of physical and numerical experiments. Most of the two-equation models predict the same results for all rotation rates (omega/S) in which there is an exponential time growth of the turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate. The second-order closures are qualitatively superior since, consistent with physical and numerical experiments, they only predict this type of unstable flow for intermediate rotation rates in the range -0.1 less than or equal to omega/S less than or equal to 1.6. For rotation rates outside this range, there is an exchange of stabilities with a solution whose kinetic energy and dissipation rate decay with time. Although the second-order closures are superior to the two-equation models, there are still problems with the quantitative accuracy of their predictions.

Speziale, Charles G.↗

NASA NTRS1989

A critical comparison of turbulence models for homogeneous shear flows in a rotating frame

A variety of turbulence models, including five second-order closure models and four two equation models, are tested for the problem of homogeneous turbulent shear flow in a rotating frame. The model predictions for the time evolution of the turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate, as well as those for the equilibrium states, are compared with the results of physical and numerical experiments. Most of the two-equation models predict the same results for all rotation rates (omega/S) in which there is an exponential time growth of the turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate. The second-order closures are qualitatively superior since, consistent with physical and numerical experiments, they only predict this type of unstable flow for intermediate rotation rates in the range -0.1 less than or equal to omega/S less than or equal to 1.6. For rotation rates outside this range, there is an exchange of stabilities with a solution whose kinetic energy and dissipation rate decay with time. Although the second-order closures are superior to the two-equation models, there are still problems with the quantitative accuracy of thier predictions.

Speziale, Charles G.↗

NASA NTRS1990

Comparison between analytical models and finite-difference simulations in transmission-line tap resistors and L-type cross-Kelvin resistors

Approximate analytical models of the transmission-line tap resistor and the cross-Kelvin resistor are compared with computer-simulated pseudo-three-dimensional resistor network models. The analytical formulas are in good agreement with the simulations over a useful range of parameters and are readily applied to the extraction of the contact resistivity and the sheet resistances of the semiconducting layer under and outside the contacts. The extraction procedure, which is easily implemented on a personal computer, is carried out for the case of alloyed AuGeNi/GaAs contacts, illustrating the importance of (1) distinguishing between layer sheet resistance under and outside the contacts and (2) considering two-dimensional current flow in the semiconducting layer.

Scorzoni, Andrea↗

NASA NTRS1989

Results from baseline tests of the SPRE I and comparison with code model predictions

The space power research engine (SPRE), a free-piston Stirling engine with linear alternator, is being tested at NASA-Lewis as a candidate for high capacity space power. Results are presented of baseline engine tests at design and off-design operating conditions. The test results are compared with code model prediction.

Cairelli, James E.↗

NASA NTRS1990

A critical comparison of turbulence models for homogeneous shear flows in a rotating frame

A variety of turbulence models, including five second-order closure models and four two equation models, are tested for the problem of homogeneous turbulent shear flow in a rotating frame. The model predictions for the time evolution of the turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate, as well as those for the equilibrium states, are compared with the results of physical and numerical experiments. Most of the two-equation models predict the same results for all rotation rates (omega/S) in which there is an exponential time growth of the turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate. The second-order closures are qualitatively superior since, consistent with physical and numerical experiments, they only predict this type of unstable flow for intermediate rotation rates in the range -0.1 less than or equal to omega/S less than or equal to 1.6. For rotation rates outside this range, there is an exchange of stabilities with a solution whose kinetic energy and dissipation rate decay with time. Although the second-order closures are superior to the two-equation models, there are still problems with the quantitative accuracy of their predictions.

Speziale, Charles G.↗

NASA NTRS1990

A comparison of different models for beam vibrations from the standpoint of control design

Different models for beam vibrations are analyzed from the standpoint of designing finite-dimensional controllers to stabilize the beam vibrations. A distributed system described by an undamped Euler-Bernoulli equation cannot be stabilized by any finite-dimensional controller, i.e., any controller which can be described an ordinary differential equation with constant coefficients. If viscous damping is included, a similar problem occurs in that all the poles can not be moved to the left of a given vertical line. These negative results should be interpreted as a commentary on the limitations of these models, rather than on the control of real beams. If a Rayleigh damping model is used, a finite-dimensional controller may be designed to move the closed loop system poles essentially as far to the left in the complex plane as desired. This result will also hold for certain hysteresis damping models. This has implications for the settling time of the vibrations.

Morris, K. A.↗

NASA NTRS1992

Comparison of laser models

The final phase of modeling solar pumped lasers considers the photodissociation of the perfloralkyl molecules n - C3F7I ,t - C4F9I, and i - C3F7I. Computer modeling was compared to laboratory data and good agreement between theory and experiment was achieved. The following is a summary of the modeling of solar pumped lasers. A perfloride gas enters a tube at a point z = 0 and travels a distance L at a velocity, W, and then exits at the point z = L. During the flow, the gas is solar pumped over the initial distance 0 less than or = z less than or = z sub 0, where z sub 0 is less than or equal to L. The perfloride gas interacts chemically with light and a chain of chemical reactions occur.

Heinbockel, John H.↗

NASA NTRS1992

Comparison of turbulence models for powered-lift flow fields

The development of a practical turbulence model for the complex flows with strong streamline curvature associated with powered-lift aircraft was investigated. The approach was to modify existing models that were compatible with the widely used kappa-epsilon model already available in an existing 3D Navier-Stokes code. The state-of-the-art of current turbulence models was examined. Several models that provide curvature corrections to the kappa-epsilon model were numerically investigated. An algebraic Reynolds stress model, which provides additional physics, was also examined. Test cases including an impinging jet, an impinging jet in a crossflow, and two adjacent impinging jets with the resultant upwash fountain were calculated. The first two test cases could be modeled reasonsbly well with some of the models. The upwash fountain could not be modeled with sufficient accuracy, which is consistent with the findings of other investigators.

Roberts, Donald W.↗

NASA NTRS1993

A comparison of refined models for flexible subassemblies

Interactions between structure response and control of large flexible space systems have challenged current modeling techniques and have prompted development of new techniques for model improvement. Due to the geometric complexity of envisioned large flexible space structures, finite element models (FEM's) will be used to predict the dynamic characteristics of structural components. It is widely accepted that these models must be experimentally 'validated' before their acceptance as the basis for final design analysis. However, predictions of modal properties (natural frequencies, mode shapes, and damping ratios) are often in error when compared to those obtained from Experimental Modal Analysis (EMA). Recent research efforts have resulted in the development of algorithmic approaches for model improvement, also referred to as system or structure identification.

Smith, Suzanne Weaver↗