Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “program compilers”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 559 records · Page 31

Manage OpenMP GPU Data Environment Under Unified Address Space

OpenMP has supported the offload of computations to accelerators such as GPUs since version 4.0. A crucial aspect in OpenMP offloading is to manage the accelerator data environment. Currently, this has to be explicitly programmed by users, which is non-trival and often results in suboptimal performance. The unified memory feature available in recent GPU architectures introduces another option, implicit management. However, our experiments show that it incurs several performance issues, especially under GPU memory oversubscription. In this paper, we propose a compiler and runtime collaborative approach to manage OpenMP GPU data under unified memory. In our framework, the compiler performs data reuse analysis to assist runtime data management. The runtime combines static and dynamic information to make optimized data management decisions.We have implement the proposed technology in the LLVM framework. The evaluation shows our method can achieve significant performance improvement for OpenMP GPU offloading.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

CCD photometric study and period investigation of V508 Oph

In this paper, new CCD photometric observations of V508 Oph obtained in 2009 and 2010 at the Xinglong Observatory are presented. From the new observations, six new times of minimum light were derived. The light curves were analyzed by using the 2003 version of the Wilson–Devinney program. It is found that the asymmetric light curves can be modeled by a hot spot on the secondary component. The degree of overcontact is 15.4%, implying that the system is a shallow-contact binary. Combining the new times of minimum light with the photoelectric and CCD data compiled from the database, we investigate its orbital period. The results show that the orbital period may be undergoing multiple changes: a long-term decrease at a rate of dP/dt=−(1.502±0.063)×10{sup −7} days year{sup −1}, and a small periodic variation with a period of 24.27(±0.34) years. Since V508 Oph is an overcontact system and both components are late-type stars, we discuss the possible connection between the mass transfer, magnetic activity, the third body, and the orbital period changes.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Directive-Based, High-Level Programming and Optimizations for High-Performance Computing with FPGAs

Reconfigurable architectures like Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) have been used for accelerating computations from several domains because of their unique combination of flexibility, performance, and power efficiency. However, FPGAs have not been widely used for high-performance computing, primarily because of their programming complexity and difficulties in optimizing performance. In this paper, we present a directive-based, high-level optimization framework for high-performance computing with FPGAs, built on top of an OpenACC-to-FPGA translation framework called OpenARC. We propose directive extensions and correspond- ing compile-time optimization techniques to enable the compiler to generate more efficient FPGA hardware configuration files. Empirical evaluation of the proposed framework on an Intel Stratix V with five OpenACC benchmarks from various application domains shows that FPGA-specific optimizations can lead to significant increases in performance across all tested applications. We also demonstrate that applying these high-level directive-based optimizations can allow OpenACC applications to perform similarly to lower-level OpenCL applications with hand-written FPGA-specific optimizations, and offer runtime and power performance benefits compared to CPUs and GPUs.

Lambert, Jacob↗

Data from "A Bayesian Record Linkage Approach to Applications in Tree Demography Using Overlapping LiDAR Scans"

Processed LiDAR data and environmental covariates from 2015 and 2019 LiDAR scans in the Vicinity of Snodgrass Mountain (Western Colorado, USA), in a geographic subset used in primary analysis for the research paper.This package contains LiDAR-derived canopy height maps for 2015 and 2019, crown polygons derived from the height maps using a segmentation algorithm, and environmental covariates supporting the model of forest growth. Source datasets include August 2015 and August 2019 discrete-return LiDAR point clouds collected by Quantum Geospatial for terrain mapping purposes on behalf of the Colorado Hazard Mapping Program and the Colorado Water Conservation Board. Both datasets adhere to the USGS QL2 quality standard. The point cloud data were processed using the R package lidR to generate a canopy height model representing maximum vegetation height above the ground surface, using a pit-free algorithm.This dataset was compiled to assess how spatial patterns of tree growth in montane and subalpine forests are influenced by water and energy availability. Understanding these growth patterns can provide insight into forest dynamics in the Southern Rocky Mountains under changing climatic conditions.This dataset contains .tif, .csv, and .txt files. This dataset additionally includes a file-level metadata (flmd.csv) file that lists each file contained in the dataset with associated metadata; and a data dictionary (dd.csv) file that contains column/row headers used throughout the files along with a definition, units, and data type.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Extension of Alvis compiler front-end

Alvis is a formal modelling language that enables possibility of verification of distributed concurrent systems. An Alvis model semantics finds expression in an LTS graph (labelled transition system). Execution of any language statement is expressed as a transition between formally defined states of such a model. An LTS graph is generated using a middle-stage Haskell representation of an Alvis model. Moreover, Haskell is used as a part of the Alvis language and is used to define parameters’ types and operations on them. Thanks to the compiler’s modular construction many aspects of compilation of an Alvis model may be modified. Providing new plugins for Alvis Compiler that support languages like Java or C makes possible using these languages as a part of Alvis instead of Haskell. The paper presents the compiler internal model and describes how the default specification language can be altered by new plugins.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

There is Nothing Here for You: Passive Institutional Controls and Preemptive Resource Exploitation - 16197

The Department of Energy (DOE) Carlsbad Field Office (CBFO) is required by Title 40 CFR Part 191.14(c) and Title 40 CFR Part 194.43 to develop a Passive Institutional Controls (PICs) program to prevent the likelihood for future human intrusion into the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP). The purpose of this paper is to explore how the exploitation of resources under nuclear waste repositories as a part of PICs could reduce the risk of future human intrusion. The WIPP, located in the northern Permian Basin near Carlsbad, New Mexico, is a geologic repository for the permanent isolation of defense-related transuranic waste. In 1995, a series of geophysical surveys by the New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources estimated the total hydrocarbon reserves underneath the WIPP, which included a 16-section area plus a one mile buffer. Since that time the Delaware Basin well database has been maintained to closely monitor hydrocarbon extraction activities. The database was used in compiling relevant oil and gas extraction data retrieved from The New Mexico Oil Conservation Division. The volume of hydrocarbons extracted from 1995 to the present suggests that if current extraction growth trends continue (as historic market and production data indicate they will), all known crude oil reserves under the WIPP, obtainable through current extraction technology, will be depleted within approximately 10 years, i.e., by 2026. This is well before the anticipated WIPP closure and start of the Active Institutional Controls (AICs) program called for in 40 CFR Part 194.41(b). In addition, gas resources, although more difficult to forecast, are not expected to last beyond 2137. Title 40 CFR 194.33 states, 'Inadvertent and intermittent intrusion by drilling for resources... is the most severe human intrusion scenario'. This human intrusion scenario is the feature, event, and process (FEP) that performance assessment (PA) has identified as having the most significant impact on radionuclide releases during the 10,000 year regulatory period for the WIPP. Title 40 CFR 194.43 requires a PICs program which contains '... [records] in the international archives that would likely be consulted by individuals in search of unexploited resources'. Due to political, social, and economic motivators for resource exploration and exploitation, the potential future absence of hydrocarbon resources under the WIPP is important in deterring possible human intrusion. To minimize the risk of future human intrusion, it may be necessary to consider actively removing as many of the exploitable hydrocarbon resources under and around a nuclear waste repository as is practicable before the end of the period of AICs (i.e., 100 years after closure of the repository). Additionally, communicating the absence of hydrocarbon resources under a nuclear repository should take a prominent role in any PICs program. Due to its high-cost nature, exploratory drilling of any kind currently involves cost/benefit analysis. If in the future the economic realities of resource exploration remain similar to today, and future oil companies know the resources for a particular area have already been heavily exploited, hypothetically, they would become less motivated to drill in that area. They would instead opt to explore an area with better prospects. It is important then that the remaining hydrocarbon reserves be clearly stated and prominently displayed. In essence we should communicate the message, loud and clear, 'There is nothing here for you'. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

ODI notebook additive_manufacturing_video_2022

Additive Manufacturing, video dataset Two-photon lithography (TPL) is a widely used 3D nanoprinting technique that uses laser light to create objects. Challenges to large-scale adoption of this additive manufacturing method include identifying light dosage parameters and monitoring during fabrication. A research team from LLNL, Iowa State University, and Georgia Tech is applying machine learning models to tackle these challenges-i.e., accelerate the process of identifying optimal light dosage parameters and automate the detection of part quality. Funded by LLNL's Laboratory Directed Research and Development Program, the project team has curated a video dataset of TPL processes for parameters such as light dosages, photo-curable resins, and structures. Both raw and labeled versions of the datasets are available on the links in the Open Data Initiative page. The code uses the labeled dataset. Notebook compiled by Nisha Mulakken (mulakken1@llnl.gov) for LLNL Open Data Initiative, Summer 2022. Original code provided by research team. Publications: X.Y. Lee, S.K. Saha, S. Sarkar, B. Giera. "Automated detection of part quality during two-photon lithography via deep learning." Additive Manufacturing 36, December 2020: doi.org/10.1016/j.addma.2020.101444 X.Y. Lee, S.K. Saha, S. Sarkar, B. Giera. "wo Photon lithography additive manufacturing: Video dataset of parameter sweep of light dosages, photo-curable resins, and structures." Data in Brief 32, October 2020. doi.org/10.1016/j.dib.2020.106119.

Mulakken, NishaJ↗

Hawthorne Nevada Deep Direct-Use Feasibility Study - Temperature and Geochemistry Well Data

The objective of this project is to use a multi-disciplinary, three-tiered approach to assess the geothermal resource and determine the feasibility of implementing a large-scale, direct-use facility for the Hawthorne Army Depot (HAD) and the various town and county facilities in Hawthorne, Nevada. This assessment directly targets a geothermal resource recently characterized by the Navy Geothermal Program Office (GPO) as part of a focused exploration and development campaign. This data batch contains: Zip file containing well and water data from 2002, including reports, isotope analysis, shallow well data, and data by well; Zip folder containing 2009 GPO well data including well logs, geochemistry, and mud logs; Compiled data from 2010 in excel and word format; 2010 Final data from TG, well HAD-1; Zip file containing PDFs and Excel files for wells Haw1, HAD1, HWADD2-3, HWAD4-5; Zip folder containing Word docs and images pertaining to final well reports and discussion.

15 GEOTHERMAL ENERGY↗

International Approaches for Nuclear Waste Disposal in Geological Formations: Report on Fifth Worldwide Review

An important issue for present and future generations is the final disposal of spent nuclear fuel. Over the past over forty years, the development of technologies to isolate both spent nuclear fuel (SNF) and other high-level nuclear waste (HLW) generated at nuclear power plants and from production of defense materials, and low- and intermediate-level nuclear waste (LILW) in underground rock and sediments has been found to be a challenging undertaking. Finding an appropriate solution for the disposal of nuclear waste is an important issue for protection of the environment and public health, and it is a prerequisite for the future of nuclear power. The purpose of a deep geological repository for nuclear waste is to provide to future generations, protection against any harmful release of radioactive material, even after the memory of the repository may have been lost, and regardless of the technical knowledge of future generations. The results of a wide variety of investigations on the development of technology for radioactive waste isolation from 19 countries were published in the First Worldwide Review in 1991 (Witherspoon, 1991). The results of investigations from 26 countries were published in the Second Worldwide Review in 1996 (Witherspoon, 1996). The results from 32 countries were summarized in the Third Worldwide Review in 2001 (Witherspoon and Bodvarsson, 2001). The last compilation had results from 24 countries assembled in the Fourth Worldwide Review (WWR) on radioactive waste isolation (Witherspoon and Bodvarsson, 2006). Since publication of the last report in 2006, radioactive waste disposal approaches have continued to evolve, and there have been major developments in a number of national geological disposal programs. Significant experience has been obtained both in preparing and reviewing cases for the operational and long-term safety of proposed and operating repositories. Disposal of radioactive waste is a complex issue, not only because of the nature of the waste, but also because of the detailed regulatory structure for dealing with radioactive waste, the variety of stakeholders involved, and (in some cases) the number of regulatory entities involved.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Data Compilation for AGC-2 Matrix-only Compact Lot A3-P43

This document is a compilation of fabrication and characterization data for the compact lot A3-P43, which was produced for possible insertion into the second ATR Graphite Creep irradiation test capsule (AGC-2). The compacts were produced by Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) for the Advanced Gas Reactor Fuel Development and Qualification (AGR) program. This compact lot was fabricated using a graphite/resin blend formulated by INL as a candidate matrix precursor for scale-up of overcoating and compacting processes. The matrix precursor powder for compact lot A3-P43 was a jet milled blend of 64 wt% natural graphite (Asbury 3482), 16 wt% synthetic graphite (Graftech GTI-D), and 20 wt% of a standard novolac resin (Plenco 14043).

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Data Compilation for AGC-2 Matrix-only Compact Lot A3-P33

This document is a compilation of fabrication and characterization data for the compact lot A3-P33, which was produced for possible insertion into the second ATR Graphite Creep irradiation test capsule (AGC-2). The compacts were produced by Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) for the Advanced Gas Reactor Fuel Development and Qualification (AGR) program. This compact lot was fabricated using a graphite/resin blend formulated by INL as a candidate matrix precursor for scale-up of overcoating and compacting processes. The matrix precursor powder for compact lot A3-P33 was a jet milled blend of 64 wt% natural graphite (Asbury 3482), 16 wt% synthetic graphite (Graftech GTI-D), and 20 wt% of a developmental novolac resin (Plenco 14433).

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Data Compilation for AGC-2 Matrix-only Compact Lot A3-H08

This document is a compilation of fabrication and characterization data for the compact lot A3-H08, which was produced for possible insertion into the second ATR Graphite Creep irradiation test capsule (AGC-2). The compacts were produced by Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) for the Advanced Gas Reactor Fuel Development and Qualification (AGR) program. This compact lot was fabricated using a graphite/resin blend formulated by INL as a candidate matrix precursor for scale-up of overcoating and compacting processes. The matrix precursor powder for compact lot A3-H08 was a jet milled blend of 64 wt% natural graphite (Asbury 3482), 16 wt% synthetic graphite (Graftech GTI-D), and 20 wt% high purity novolac resin (Hexion D_SD-1708 with 7.5% hexamethylenetetramine added). The “Matrix Compacts for AGC-2 Irradiation” Specification (INL SPC-1285, Rev. 1) provides the requirements necessary for acceptance of the compacts. Sections 2.03 and 2.04 of SPC-1285 provide the property requirements for the heat-treated compacts. There are requirements on the length, diameter, and matrix density. Section 2.02.01.01 further requests impurity analysis on representative samples from the final compact lot, but there are no specified acceptance criteria. The impurity information will be evaluated by INL as part of a final decision on whether to insert the compacts into the AGC-2 experiment. The procedures for characterizing and qualifying the compacts are outlined in ORNL product inspection plan AGR-CHAR-PIP-16. The measurement of compact length, diameter, and matrix density was performed according to data acquisition method AGR-CHAR-DAM-39. The data report forms generated by this procedure document the product acceptance for the property requirements listed in sections 2.03 and 2.04 of SPC-1285. All compacts selected for irradiation conformed to the specified requirements for length, diameter, and density. In addition to the characterization data, this report also contains other records relevant to the product acceptance. A history of the material flow and sample naming is included and the compacting process is summarized. In addition to results of the impurity analysis on representative samples from the final compact lot, impurity analysis results are also provided for samples of the graphite, resin, and the graphite/resin blend. A Certificate of Conformance to SPC-1285, Rev. 1 is attached in Appendix B.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Quantum Computing Strategy 2026

Quantum computing (QC) is a rapidly maturing technology with the potential for revolutionary impacts on stockpile stewardship science and national security. Recent developments in fault-tolerant architectures have compressed vendor roadmaps, and predictions of a production-ready quantum computer by the mid-2030s are becoming increasingly credible. This strategy provides a roadmap for integrating QC into the Advanced Simulation and Computing (ASC) program by investing in four strategic focus areas: 1. Develop Capabilities in Mission-Relevant Quantum Applications: ASC will prioritize developing quantum-ready applications in mission areas that have shown significant promise for quantum advantage, including simulations of materials in extreme environments, nuclear dynamics, solving linear and nonlinear partial differential equations, and uncertainty quantification. These applications directly support stockpile stewardship science and modernization objectives. 2. Conduct R&D in Algorithms, Software, and Hardware: Sustained research into quantum algorithms, robust software tools, and quantum hardware is essential. ASC will develop efficient quantum algorithms; invest in quantum compilers, debuggers, and performance tools; and explore specialized quantum hardware tailored to NNSA’s unique requirements. 3. Engage with Vendors and Partners: Early and active collaboration with commercial quantum hardware vendors and academic partners is critical. Through testbeds, co-design agreements, and quantum demonstration facilities, ASC will influence hardware design, gain early access to emerging technologies, and ensure that quantum platforms evolve to meet mission needs. 4. Build Knowledge, Experience, and Workforce: Expanding and upskilling the quantum-trained workforce is essential to long-term success. This includes hiring, internal training, university outreach, and postdoctoral support to ensure ASC maintains the expertise required to operate, program, and integrate quantum systems as they become available. While quantum computing will never replace classical computing, it has the potential to solve certain problems with speed and accuracy that would be unachievable using any conceivable classical high-performance computing (HPC) system. By investing strategically in QC, ASC will help propel the emergent QC industry, maintain U.S. technological leadership, ensure mission readiness, and position itself to rapidly adopt quantum technologies as they mature.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Assessment of Literature Related to Combustion Appliance Venting Systems

In many residential building retrofit programs, air tightening to increase energy efficiency is often constrained by safety concerns with naturally vented combustion appliances. Tighter residential buildings more readily depressurize when exhaust equipment is operated, making combustion appliances more prone to backdraft or spill combustion exhaust into the living space. Several measures, such as installation guidelines, vent sizing codes, and combustion safety diagnostics, are in place with the intent to prevent backdrafting and combustion spillage, but the diagnostics conflict and the risk mitigation objective is inconsistent. This literature review summarizes the metrics and diagnostics used to assess combustion safety, documents their technical basis, and investigates their risk mitigations. It compiles information from the following: codes for combustion appliance venting and installation; standards and guidelines for combustion safety diagnostics; research evaluating combustion safety diagnostics; research investigating wind effects on building depressurization and venting; and software for simulating vent system performance.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Floating Offshore Wind US Manufacturing and Commercialization: Cooperative Research and Development (Final Report)

NREL assessed the supply chain and workforce considerations for the OCG-Wind floater technology, a floating semi-submersible offshore wind substructure, as well sharing vessel needs to inform their installation strategy. This technical assistance was in support of the FLoating Offshore Wind ReadINess (FLOWIN) Prize Phase 2 submission. NREL provided an assessment of domestic supplier capabilities for the main components of their floating offshore wind platform design and analyzed US regional and national supply chain constraints and gaps. Thirteen interviews with companies including steel distributors, forges, foundries, ports, large component fabricators, subcomponent fabricators, and secondary suppliers provided key insights such as 1) assembly ports are the key infrastructure barrier standing in the way of unlocking the domestic assembly and component fabrication for steel-based FOW platforms, 2) domestic steel producers can supply the types and quantities of steel necessary for FOW platforms, and 3) coordination between stakeholders will be a vital part of successfully developing the supply chain and infrastructure needed to domestically produce FOW platforms. In the workforce assessment, NREL documented a step-by-step approach to conduct a place-based assessment of the foundational workforce consideration for recruiting, upskilling, and retaining a workforce, such as supportive local and state policy, nearby education and training programs, and existing relevant industry. This approach was applied to Tacoma, Washington. Tacoma was indicated to have the potential be a successful location for fabrication and assembly of floating offshore wind energy in terms of workforce development. To share data on vessel requirements to install the OCG-Wind floater, NREL compiled resources that help answer the questions related to anchor handling tug vessels, shared a database of cable laying vessels, and answered questions on complying with the Jones Act.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Data-dependence Profiling to Enable Safe Thread Level Speculation

Data-dependence profling is a technique that enables a com- piler to judiciously decide when the execution of a loop | which the compiler could not prove to be dependence free | should be speculated through the use of Thread Level Spec- ulation (TLS). The data collected by a data-dependence pro- fler can be used to predict if may dependencies reported by a compiler static analysis are likely to materialize at runtime. A cost analysis can then be used to decide that some loops with a lower probability of dependence should be specula- tively parallelized. This paper addresses the question as to whether a loops' dependence behaviour changes when the in- put to the program changes | a study of 57 different bench- marks indicates that it usually does not change. Then the paper describes SpecEval, an automatic speculative paral- lelization framework that uses single-input data-dependence profles to find speculation candidates in the SPEC2006 and PolyBench/C benchmarks. This paper also presents a per- formance evaluation of TLS implementation in IBM's Blue- Gene/Q supercomputer and shows that the performance of TLS is affected by several factors, including the number of speculated loops, the execution-time coverage of speculated loops, the miss-speculation overhead, the L1 cache miss rate and the effect on dynamic instruction path length.

Bhattacharyya, Arnamoy↗

Flowsheet Definition for the Tank Side Cesium Removal Unit and the Importance of Early Communication - 19142

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) tank operations contractor Washington River Protection Solutions, LLC (WRPS) is working toward the start of low-activity waste (LAW) treatment in direct feed mode as soon as 2022. WRPS is responsible for providing the pre-treated feed for this direct feed mode and had originally planned to use the Low Activity Waste Pretreatment System (LAWPS) to supply the initial feed in 2021. In September 2017, in response to a DOE-sponsored LAWPS program review, a new system was proposed to provide the initial feed during direct feed mode until a supplemental pretreatment capability is ready to begin processing feed. This system, known as the Tank Side Cesium Removal (TSCR) system, is based on the Savannah River Tank Closure Cesium Removal (TCCR) system and technology used to separate cesium out of reactor water at Fukushima. A preliminary flowsheet was needed to form the initial basis for future decisions and allow discussions between operations, project management, and the customer. The main goal of the TSCR flowsheet was to form a process flow diagram, process description, and much of the preliminary information to be used to help inform future decisions. When flowsheet development first began, little to no information was readily known and what was known needed to be compiled in one place and digestible by several audiences. The impacts of various parameters on the system also needed a vehicle for clear communication to varying audiences. While a more complicated model was being completed, a model of the process was created using Microsoft Excela which could have several parameters changed while maintaining basic logical requirements (such as treated waste volume cannot exceed the volume of the Interim LAW Storage Tank [ILST], must shutdown for so many days for column changeout, etc.). This program allowed the unit downtime, start dates, treatment rates, and several other variables to be modified and reflect the ILST storage volume as a function of mission progression. The model with several different parameters gathered from the various groups was combined into an early flowsheet of the TSCR process and created one of the first citable documents about TSCR implementation at Hanford. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Innovations in Building Energy Modeling: Research and Development Opportunities for Emerging Technologies

Building energy modeling (BEM) is a multipurpose tool for building energy efficiency (EE). The U.S. Department of Energy Building Technologies Office (BTO) seeks to expand the use and effectiveness of BEM in the design and operation of commercial and residential buildings with the goal of achieving lasting reductions in total and peak energy use. This report identifies gaps and outlines recommended initiatives to achieve this goal, based on a combination of technical analysis and stakeholder input. In addition to BTO, this report can benefit BEM professionals (architects, mechanical engineers, energy consultants, building auditors, equipment manufacturers, and BEM software vendors) and BEM clients (building owners and operators, EE program administrators, EE service providers, policymakers, and policy and code jurisdictions such as states and cities). This report was developed in two phases. In the first, BTO worked with a team from Navigant Consulting (now Guidehouse) to characterize objectives, opportunities, and current activities; identify gaps and barriers; and define initiatives. To collect input, Navigant conducted telephone interviews and workshops with industry experts. The initial phase produced a draft report, which was released for public review in 2016 and yielded over 400 comments. Based on these comments, BTO compiled a second draft report that addressed many of those comments while acknowledging changes that had occurred both at BTO and in the industry. Unlike the first draft report, the second focused much more heavily on BTO’s own role, portfolio, and activities. BTO is a direct player in the BEM field - it funds the development of several significant software packages that are embedded in commercial products - and transparency about its goals and future plans is requisite. BTO recognizes that a great number of other public and private organizations contribute to the BEM enterprise. With the second draft report, BTO did not attempt to produce a blueprint for the industry as a whole, but rather a working document BTO can use to iteratively solicit stakeholder input and synthesize it into a program. BTO released the second draft report for public review in 2019. The second round of review generated 83 pages of feedback and comments - almost exactly the length of the draft report itself - a significant portion of which was collected and synthesized by IBPSA-USA Advocacy Committee. This final report incorporates this feedback. This report does not address the use of BEM in support of building-based grid services, a recent BTO initiative called Grid-interactive Efficient Buildings (GEB). In 2019, BTO published a report that specifically addresses the role of BEM - and other “integration” technologies - in GEB.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗