Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “technical issues”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 667 records · Page 37

Targeted Health Assessment for Wastes Contained at the Niagara Falls Storage Site to Guide Planning for Remedial Action Alternatives - 13428

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) is evaluating potential remedial alternatives at the 191-acre Niagara Falls Storage Site (NFSS) in Lewiston, New York, under the Formerly Utilized Sites Remedial Action Program (FUSRAP). The Manhattan Engineer District (MED) and Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) brought radioactive wastes to the site during the 1940's and 1950's, and the U.S. Department of Energy (US DOE) consolidated these wastes into a 10-acre interim waste containment structure (IWCS) in the southwest portion of the site during the 1980's. The USACE is evaluating remedial alternatives for radioactive waste contained within the IWCS at the NFSS under the Feasibility Study phase of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) process. A preliminary evaluation of the IWCS has been conducted to assess potential airborne releases associated with uncovered wastes, particularly during waste excavation, as well as direct exposures to uncovered wastes. Key technical issues for this assessment include: (1) limitations in waste characterization data; (2) representative receptors and exposure routes; (3) estimates of contaminant emissions at an early stage of the evaluation process; (4) consideration of candidate meteorological data and air dispersion modeling approaches; and (5) estimates of health effects from potential exposures to both radionuclides and chemicals that account for recent updates of exposure and toxicity factors. Results of this preliminary health risk assessment indicate if the wastes were uncovered and someone stayed at the IWCS for a number of days to weeks, substantial doses and serious health effects could be incurred. Current controls prevent such exposures, and the controls that would be applied to protect onsite workers during remedial action at the IWCS would also effectively protect the public nearby. This evaluation provides framing context for the upcoming development and detailed evaluation of remedial alternatives for the IWCS. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Are We Serious in the US about the Disposal of HLW? - 13561

Since all efforts to date to dispose of HLW in the US have been unsuccessful, the following specific actions need to be taken if we are serious about such disposal: - The requirement in the EPA environmental radiation protection standards to predict the behavior of these unwanted residuals for one million years is meaningless. The Standards must be revisited. - Characterize two sites. There are myriad ways a site can be found to be unacceptable. Additionally, the existing HLW inventory requires a second repository. - Congress should specify incentives to states under consideration for a site. Perhaps 5% of total cost would be appropriate. - An independent technical review group should be established in such states to evaluate a proposed repository similar to the New Mexico Environmental Evaluation Group (EEG) for the WIPP Project because the state's interests are not necessarily the same as DOE's. - Acceptance or rejection of a proposed site should be based on technical issues, not social ones. Professionals in this field should present papers identifying the merits of HLW disposal in their own state. The scarcity of such research suggests Not In My Back Yard (NIMBY) syndrome. - Medical diagnostic ionizing radiation exposure to the US public is now 8,000 times greater than radiation exposure from nuclear energy. People accept this believing the benefits outweigh any risks. A major effort needs to focus on both benefits as well as risks of radioactive waste disposal. - DOE needs to announce preferences of host rock formations, incentives for states, and potential consequences should we fail to act. (author)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Implementing Stakeholders' Access to Expertise: Experimenting on Nuclear Installations' Safety Cases - 12160

In 2009 and 2010, the Institute for Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection (IRSN) led two pilot actions dealing with nuclear installations' safety cases. One concerned the periodical review of the French 900 MWe nuclear reactors, the other concerned the decommissioning of a workshop located on the site of Areva's La Hague fuel-reprocessing plant site in Northwestern France. The purpose of both these programs was to test ways for IRSN and a small number of stakeholders (Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) members, local elected officials, etc.) to engage in technical discussions. The discussions were intended to enable the stakeholders to review future applications and provide valuable input. The test cases confirmed there is a definite challenge in successfully opening a meaningful dialogue to discuss technical issues, in particular the fact that most expertise reports were not public and the conflict that exists between the contrary demands of transparency and confidentiality of information. The test case also confirmed there are ways to further improvement of stakeholders' involvement. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Adapting Dismantling and Decommissioning Strategies to a Variety of Nuclear Fuel Cycle Facilities - 12237

AREVA has accumulated over 20 years of experience in managing and operating fuel cycle facilities Decontamination and Decommissioning (D and D) projects of many different types and a variety of scales, both as facility owner (at La Hague for example) and as prime contractor to external customers such as the French Atomic Energy Commission (at Marcoule). A specific Business Unit was created in 2008 to capitalize on this experience and to concentrate - in one division - the specific skills required to be successful and cost effective in decommissioning projects. Indeed one of the key lessons learned in the past decades is that decommissioning is a significantly different business as compared to normal operations of a nuclear facility. Almost all the functions of a project need to be viewed from a different angle, challenged and adapted consequently in order to optimize costs and schedule. Three examples follow to illustrate the point: Safety management needs to take into account the ever changing configuration of a plant under D and D (a quite new situation for the authorities). Production of waste is significantly different in term of volume, activities, conditioning and disposal path. Technology is important but technical issues are often less critical than good management and planning. Further examples and lessons learned are developed through reviewing the projects experience basis. AREVA has a long and vast experience in the cleanup and dismantling of a number of very large and complex nuclear facilities. This effort focused initially on AREVA's own plants and is expanding now to other customers. The setup of a specific Business Unit in 2008 to takeover this business allowed concentration of the skills and the lessons learned in a dedicated division so as to provide the best means to optimize safety, performance, costs and schedules. Indeed transitioning from operations to D and D of a nuclear facility is a quantum leap. The assistance from specialized teams can bring significant cost savings. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

International Developments on Uncertainties in NPP Decommissioning costs and planned work on Benchmarking at the OECD-NEA - 17074

The ability to decommission NPPs shut down after normal operation has been proven technically. Issues of current concern include the ability to accurately calculate and demonstrate the validity of decommissioning cost estimates, and to control costs during decommissioning. This paper describes recent international developments concerning addressing uncertainties in NPP decommissioning cost estimation, and work currently being planned relating to decommissioning cost benchmarking at the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency. The process of decommissioning cost estimation is evolving, with a general trend towards showing greater levels of detail in the estimate. The International Structure for Decommissioning Costing was published in 2012 and presents a common reporting format for decommissioning costing undertaken on a deterministic basis. However, this does not address probabilistic methods or associated presentation formats for the inclusion of uncertainties in decommissioning estimates. A consistent and comparable treatment of uncertainties in decommissioning cost estimation would further facilitate comparison between different cost estimates and enhance understanding of and confidence in the estimates themselves. There is growing interest in benchmarking decommissioning costs, reflecting a need to better understand the relationships between estimates and actual costs, to give greater confidence that funding will be sufficient, and as a useful tool in project management and enhancing project delivery. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Development and Testing of a High Level Waste Slurry Sampling Technique to Support Hanford Waste Processing - 17164

The Hanford Tank Operations Contractor must demonstrate the capability to adequately sample staged high-level waste feed. The sampler employed must have accuracy and precision performance that allow the Tank Operations Contractor (TOC) to meet the Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant (WTP) Waste Acceptance Criteria Data Quality Objectives (DQO). A full-scale sampling loop was used at a test facility to develop and demonstrate sampler capability. This paper will discuss the modifications to a sampler configuration previously tested - modifications focused on the improvement of the accuracy of test results. This work targets one of the remaining technical issues with the high-level waste treatment mission at Hanford. The sampling method employed must support both Tank Operations and Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant requirements. To facilitate information transfer between the two facilities the mixing and sampling demonstrations are led by the TOC's Chief Technology Office in conjunction with the One System Integrated Project Team. Results of the testing showed that performance of the Isolok{sup R} sampler, chosen for implementation, can be greatly improved by modifying the systems configuration to provide accurate, repeatable results for Hanford's simulated high level waste. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Application of Robotics Technology to D and D - 17249

The Knowledge Management Information Tool (KM-IT) is a web-based system developed to maintain and preserve the deactivation and decommissioning (D and D) knowledge base across the Department of Energy (DOE) complex. The system was developed by the Applied Research Center (ARC) at Florida International University (FIU) with the support of the D and D community, including the DOE Office of Environmental Management (DOE EM), and with the active collaboration and support of the DOE's Energy Facility Contractors Group (EFCOG). The KM-IT system is a D and D community driven system tailored to serve the technical issues faced by the D and D workforce across the DOE Complex. As part of the D and D KM-IT, FIU has developed a robotics database in collaboration with DOE EM and Nuvision/Cogentus which currently contains over 500 robotics technologies along with information about the robotics technology vendors. This information is aggregated in real time and presented as a robotics technology fact sheet to the end user based on the selected technology. FIU is researching these technologies and studying their capabilities and application to D and D. As part of the research, FIU is categorizing each technology into specific application areas: characterization, decontamination, inspection, and demolition. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Full-Scale Vessel Testing of the Standard High-Solids Vessel for the Hanford Waste Treatment Plant Pretreatment Facility - 17282

Concerns over the mixing performance of the planned pulse-jet mixed (PJM) vessels for high solids applications in the Hanford Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant (WTP) Pretreatment (PT) Facility, led to the development of a standard high-solids vessel (SHSV) design and full-scale vessel testing. The SHSV is intended as a potential replacement for several high-level waste feed receipt and lag storage vessels, ultrafiltration feed preparation vessels, and plant wash vessels. The SHSV design concept uses multiple smaller vessels (60 500 to 79 500 liters nominal batch size) to replace larger vessels, providing redundancy, improved mixing (PJM design and spargers), monitoring (multi-level bubblers), reduced material at risk, and improved structural features. The SHSV also requires qualification of a single vessel design for high solids Newtonian and non-Newtonian slurry processing, rather than earlier multiple vessel designs. Qualification of the SHSV design for mixing will be achieved through full-scale vessel testing (FSVT) with a prototypic SHSV under a set of most adverse design conditions in conjunction with additional engineering analyses. An Integrated Technical Team consisting of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), Bechtel National, Inc. (BNI), and independent experts was established to accelerate and provide oversight and direction to the test program and SHSV qualification. This paper will present an overview of the SHSV, full-scale vessel test and qualification program, and the management program to achieve closure of technical issues associated with PJM vessel mixing and control systems. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Searching for science in the past and present discussion on commingling policy in the US - 15083

Since 1985, the policy in the United States for disposing of nuclear waste has included commingling defense and civilian spent nuclear fuel (SNF) and high-level radioactive waste (HLW) in a mined geologic repository. Commingling policy is under discussion again because of developments over the last several years in the nuclear waste management and disposal program. The authors reviewed the extent to which scientific and technical information was involved in considerations of commingling from the 1950's to the present. Evaluations undertaken by the US Department of Energy (US DOE) in 1985 and April 2014 are compared and the technical issues of health and safety, transportation, and national security are addressed in both evaluations. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Knowledge management information tool Web analytics - 15182

The Knowledge Management Information Tool (KM-IT) is a web-based [01] system developed to maintain and preserve the Department of Energy's (DOE's) D and D knowledge base. The system was developed by Florida International University's Applied Research Center (FIU-ARC) with the support of the D and D community including the DOE Office of Environmental Management, and with the active collaboration and support of the DOE's Energy Facility Contractors Group (EFCOG). The KM-IT system is a D and D community driven system tailored to serve the technical issues faced by the D and D workforce across the DOE Complex. The D and D KM-IT is an interactive web-based system operational and available for free access at www.dndkm.org. [02] The D and D KM-IT is currently composed of the following tailored D and D modules: Web Crawler, Hotline, Technology, Document Library (including Hanford's and Savannah River Sites' ALARA Center Reports), Specialist Directory, Lessons Learned, Best Practices, Video/Picture Library, Vendors, Collaboration Tools, Training, and Mobile Systems. The Web Crawler dynamically searches through the D and D KM-IT repository as well as the web and displays search results based on the search criteria. The Hotline allows registered users to post questions/problems related to D and D and to receive solutions from a subject-matter specialist. The Technology module serves as repository of D and D technologies and contains technology/ demonstration fact sheets and vendor information. D and D community members can add Lessons Learned, Best Practices, Documents, and Pictures/Videos to the D and D KM-IT repository, after a formal approval process. The Vendor module provides a directory of commercial vendors who provide D and D related technologies, supplies, and services. D and D KM-IT makes excellent use of the knowledge that exists within the D and D community by allowing D and D project managers around the DOE complex to collaborate by sharing innovative ideas, past experiences, and practices and by maintaining a directory of subject matter specialists. The mobile version of the KM-IT can be accessed from m.dndkm.org [03] and currently has six active modules: Vendor, Technology, Picture/Video Library, Hotline, Lessons Learned and Specialist Directory. Web analytics is a key tool being implemented by the D and D KM-IT project team in an effort to enhance the system to better meet users' needs. The D and D KM-IT project team incorporates web analytics as part of its operational elements to analyze information and key data points on how the system is being used. Web analytics is the measurement, collection, analysis and reporting of internet data for the purposes of understanding and optimizing web usage. The use of web analytics retains or attracts D and D community members to access and share knowledge through virtual collaboration on the KM-IT platform. D and D KM-IT web analytics measures details on the overall usage of the system without tracking personal information or specific user behavior: how many users visited the application, how many of those users were unique visitors, how visitors come to the system (i.e., by following a link to the system or by using the web site URL via bookmark or directly typing the address), what keywords were used to perform searches with the search engine, how long the average user stayed on a given screen or on the entire system and what links were clicked on. This information is used to identify which areas of the system are more popular than the others and provides information that can be used to streamline the application for a better user experience. (authors)

96 KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT AND PRESERVATION↗

The underground research facilities (URF) network - illustrating the IAEA's concept and use of professional networks - 15382

Since 2001, the IAEA has championed the concept and use of professional networks (Communities of Practice) to advance best practices and to provide a platform for cooperation in radioactive waste management, decommissioning and environmental remediation across the globe. The Underground Research Facilities (URF) Network was the first in a series of networks implemented under the auspices of the IAEA to share experiences, elicit best practices, and transfer knowledge on topics relevant to the development and implementation of geological disposal of long lived and high level radioactive waste - i.e. intermediate level waste (ILW), high-level waste (HLW) and/or spent nuclear fuel (SNF). Special emphasis is placed on the role and use of URFs to support such geological disposal developments. In addition to the direct benefits provided to Member States through its programme of work, the URF Network also delivers less tangible, yet equally valuable benefits through the informal exchange of information, the development of peer-to-peer professional networks, and seeding of multi-lateral cooperation between Member States. Network members represent a range of nuclear programme sizes and advancements in their respective repository programmes. After a decade of fruitful cooperation, delivering more than 30 training courses on topics relevant to geological disposal, the URF Network is gradually reassessing its mode of operation and focus of work. Emphasizing selected strategic goals - focused in part on more systematic training of URF Network members human resources and in part on select key technical issues - would benefit all network members, while remaining cautious in the commitment of scarce resources. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Life Cycle Costing in Radioactive Waste Packaging: Reducing Costs Whilst Accelerating Clean-Up - 16131

In recognition of the high up-front costs and potentially long timescales to implement the more traditional methods of encapsulating wastes, in the UK alternative approaches to help accelerate hazard reduction and reduce such costs are being deployed. When considering such the cost of alternative approaches to waste packaging strategies, it is important that the complete waste life cycle is taken into account. This paper will demonstrate that when evaluating waste packaging options, whilst individual elements (e.g. container costs) within an overall waste management programme may appear to offer a cost benefit by comparison with alternatives, the programme as a whole may not necessarily be the most cost effective solution when life cycle costs are taken into account, or when other technical issues are considered. To illustrate this point this paper will present a view of the application of LCC, utilising a number of waste packaging scenarios, to promote discussion and consideration of the benefits of undertaking a holistic assessment of the investment decision as part of an overall waste management strategy. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Public Outreach in FUSRAP - 16201

The U. S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) is the lead federal agency for the Formerly Utilized Sites Remedial Action Program (FUSRAP) which was initiated in 1974 to address contamination remaining from Manhattan Engineer District and early U.S. Atomic Energy Commission activities. As the lead agency, USACE follows the protocols set forth in the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) to address FUSRAP sites. During certain project milestones of the CERCLA process, community outreach initiatives occur to communicate the status and/or findings from site investigations and project decision documents. The style of public interaction is tailored to match the project milestone, technical complexity of a project, the stakeholder involvement level, or type of decision being made on a particular project. Community involvement is one of the most important aspects of environmental work, and proactive and transparent communication can build meaningful relationships with the community and between project stakeholders. The USACE Buffalo District has experience using different stakeholder interaction techniques and providing information on projects through a variety of media. Rather than simply distributing information, the goal of community outreach is to encourage participation in the process and to provide opportunities for the public to fully understand, ask questions about, and provide feedback on the complex technical issues involved in decision-making for each FUSRAP site. The frequency and method of interaction depends on the project, and the USACE Buffalo District has worked to promote openness and transparency and to ensure the community is provided with many opportunities for public participation. Project information has been provided to stakeholders using multiple techniques, such as formal project workshops, poster sessions, site tours, news releases, storybooks, and videos. Aside from project-specific community relations plans, the USACE Buffalo District has participated in Science, Technology, Engineering and Math (STEM) programs established to inspire current and future generations of young people to pursue careers in STEM fields. Each year, the USACE Buffalo District performs outreach in the community to share information on our projects as well as to introduce students to various disciplines associated with environmental careers. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Robotics Technologies on Knowledge Management Information Tool (KM-IT) Platform - 16465

The Knowledge Management Information Tool (KM-IT) is a web-based system developed to maintain and preserve the deactivation and decommissioning (D and D) knowledge base across the Department of Energy (DOE) complex. The system was developed by the Applied Research Center (ARC) at Florida International University (FIU) with the support of the D and D community, including the DOE Office of Environmental Management (DOE EM), and with the active collaboration and support of the DOE's Energy Facility Contractors Group (EFCOG). The KM-IT system is a D and D community driven system tailored to serve the technical issues faced by the D and D workforce across the DOE Complex. New information, including vendors and technologies related to D and D, are researched and added to KM-IT on an ongoing basis. In late 2014, DOE EM provided a database of 471 robotic technologies, originally developed by NuVision Engineering and Cogentus Consulting, with a request to evaluate the potential for integrating the data into the KM-IT framework for ongoing hosting/maintenance of the information. All of the data from the original database as well as photographs, documents, and videos are now available on KM-IT. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Exploiting Knowledge of Technetium in the Subsurface to Develop Remediation Strategies - 18223

Technetium-99 (Tc) contamination remains a major environmental problem at legacy nuclear reprocessing sites, such as the Hanford Site in south-central Washington State, where the total inventory of released Tc is estimated at 700 curies (Ci). The environmental risk associated with Tc is due to its long half-life (213,000 years) and the high mobility of the oxidized anionic pertechnetate species (Tc(VII)O{sub 4}{sup -}). Thus, there is a critical need to resolve scientific and technical issues underpinning the ability to safely, cost-effectively, and efficiently remediate Tc-contaminated vadose zone sediments and groundwater. Developing enhanced attenuation strategies for released Tc that reduce contaminant migration, while mitigating risk to human health and the environment, requires characterization of any retardation processes and Tc mass flux. The current conceptual model for Tc transport in the vadose zone assumes that Tc is predominantly present in its oxidized form as TcO{sub 4}{sup -}, which is highly soluble and mobile. However, under certain conditions, Tc can become entrained in solid phases. Tc-containing mineral phases from sediment cores extracted from various Hanford waste disposal sites were characterized to determine Tc present in vadose zone sediments as (i) TcO{sub 4} - that remains in water films associated with fine-grained sediments; (ii) Tc co-precipitated with other lanthanides in phosphate mineral phases; and (iii) Tc present as TcO{sub 2}.nH{sub 2}O in localized reducing zones. These results will be used to develop improved long-term Tc remediation strategies that are most likely to succeed during field application, through stimulation of conditions that enhance Tc attenuation. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Full-Scale Vessel Testing for the Hanford Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant - 18333

Concerns over the mixing performance of the planned pulse jet mixed (PJM) vessels for high-solids applications in the Hanford Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant (WTP) Pretreatment (PT) Facility, led to the development of a standard high-solids vessel (SHSV) design and full-scale vessel testing program. The SHSV is intended as a potential replacement for several high-level waste feed receipt and lag storage vessels (High-Level Waste Facility lag storage and feed blending process), ultrafiltration feed preparation vessels (ultrafiltration process system), and plant wash vessels (plant wash and disposal system). The SHSV concept uses multiple smaller vessels (60 500 L - 79 500 L nominal batch size) to replace larger vessels, providing redundancy, improved mixing (PJM design and spargers), monitoring (multi-level bubblers), reduced material at risk, and improved structural features. The SHSV also requires qualification of a single vessel design for high solids Newtonian and non-Newtonian slurry processing, rather than having to qualify earlier multiple vessel designs. An Integrated Technical Team consisting of the U.S. Department of Energy, Bechtel National, Inc., and independent experts was established to accelerate and provide oversight and direction of the test program and SHSV qualification. Qualification of the SHSV for mixing has now been achieved through a comprehensive full-scale vessel testing program conducted in 2017 with a prototypic SHSV under a set of most adverse design conditions, in conjunction with additional engineering analyses. This paper will present an overview of the SHSV, results from the three-phase full-scale vessel test and qualification program completed in September 2017, and the management program to achieve resolution of the PJM mixing technical issue. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

TeMoto 2.0: Source Agnostic Command-to-Task Architecture Enabling Increased Autonomy in Remote Systems - 18438

Tele-operated robots provide safe means for executing tasks in hazardous environments such as underground mines, space, disaster and legacy nuclear facility decommissioning sites, etc. The desire to use these systems in increasingly complex and dynamic environments presents a variety of technical and educational challenges including (i) insufficient field knowledge of system developers, (ii) restricted data bandwidth, and (iii) insufficient operator situational awareness. Lack of field knowledge is commonly addressed by actively educating robotics engineers in the perspective areas. The Nuclear Robotics Group (NRG) at the University of Texas at Austin trains students to have the necessary skill and knowledge in both the robotic and nuclear domains. To address the second two deficiencies, the NRG has developed TeMoto: a speech and hand gesture based supervisory teleoperation software. TeMoto addresses several chronic technical issues associated with most teleoperation systems including the operator's situational awareness, communication delays and interface intuitiveness. This paper reviews recent efforts to update and extend the TeMoto architecture (TeMoto 2.0) to support more complex semi-autonomous behaviors and eliminate the unnecessary and confining concept of a human interface as a separate component from the rest of the robot's sensors and actuators. This paper outlines the key architectural changes and demonstrations using a dual-arm mobile manipulator to complete semi-autonomous tasks. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Lessons Learned From Public Outreach: Effective Incorporation of the Stakeholder Voice - 18447

The licensing process for any facility associated with nuclear power or aspects of the nuclear fuel cycle can be expected to encounter intense stakeholder interest, and often significant challenges. Over the last decade, staff of the Center for Nuclear Waste Regulatory Analyses (CNWRA{sup R}) at Southwest Research Institute{sup R} (SwRI{sup R}) provided comprehensive support to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) for public outreach efforts across a wide variety of nuclear activities. Many of these projects included public involvement and consultation activities for compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), including scoping, public meetings, responding to public comments on draft documents, and holding small meetings with affected local, state, and tribal governments. In addition, we have supported NRC public outreach related to nuclear facility licensing activities (including the proposed repository at Yucca Mountain), rulemaking, and regulatory guidance development. This experience has offered us a broad view of the challenges faced by industry, regulators, and stakeholders. In the process, we have observed some best practices that lead to effective stakeholder communication. Communication about complex technical issues is challenging, particularly for societally controversial topics, such as civilian use of nuclear power and management of radioactive waste. Most commonly, we have observed a lack of mutual trust and respect among industry, regulators, and stakeholders that creates an atmosphere ripe for suspicion and misunderstanding. Stakeholders have, in public comments, criticized the lack of appropriate venues to raise concerns in which they feel they can get meaningful responses from the nuclear industry and regulators. Conversely, industry faces difficulty in reaching compromise with stakeholders, who sometimes misinterpret or misrepresent factual information. Within this contentious environment, regulators are constrained by their statutory framework, even as they are challenged to be more responsive, transparent, and fair to both stakeholders and industry. In spite of these obstacles, there are examples where feedback from stakeholders was heard and utilized. Because of successful collection of appropriate feedback, regulators became more adept at understanding the full range of perspectives from both industry and stakeholders, and subsequently did a better job at effectively incorporating feedback and communicating their decisions and findings in a clear and understandable way. Ultimately, the success of these examples was based on a measure of mutual respect, which was reached through effective communication and implementation of some best practices. These best practices include (i) outreach planning that is abundantly mindful of the various stakeholder points of view, site history, regional characteristics, and probable future and related actions, combined with advance identification of key stakeholders; (ii) development and distribution of information that facilitates public participation; and (iii) use of avenues by which stakeholders can provide meaningful and effective comments. Illustrative examples include (i) how concerns raised by stakeholders were heard by an applicant and resulted in a revised project proposal; (ii) use of a variety of interaction formats that incorporated input across a broad spectrum of stakeholders; (iii) utilizing stakeholder feedback received during scoping; and (iv) how a facility underestimated the impact of 'outsider' stakeholder voices that were in contrast to the known local community. By moving past the viewpoint that public outreach is a 'necessary evil' and engaging only to check a procedural box, each participant can benefit from mutually satisfactory and improved outcomes. (author)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗