DOE OSTI2010
This document reports on continuation of R&D activities at ORNL directed at investigating the effect of air oxidation of nuclear graphite on development and structure of porosity in the oxidized layer, and on the effect on mechanical properties of oxidized graphite. The material investigated was nuclear-grade graphite (purified PCEA graphite, from GrafTech International). Based on conclusions of previous work (ORNL/TM-2009/192), the method of analysis of the porosity in the oxidized layer based on optical microscopy coupled with automated image analysis was further improved and standardized. In addition, characterization of oxidized specimens by optical microscopy was complemented with measurements of mechanical properties (compressive strength) on a statistically significant number of specimens. A series of cylindrical shape specimens were machined and oxidized in air at two temperatures (600 and 700 o C) and at three levels of burn-off at each temperature (5-6 %; 10-12 % and 15-17%). The procedure used for specimen preparation and oxidation, and the oxidation equipment, were those recommended in ASTM D-7542-09. However, in order to comply with the aspect ratio requirements for specimens employed in compressive strength measurements (ASTM C-695-91) all specimens were machined with a length to diameter ratio of 2 (i.e. 25.4 mm height vs. 12.7 mm diameter) instead of 25.4 mm length and 25.4 mm diameter recommended by ASTM D-7542-09. After oxidation, mechanical properties (compressive strength) were measured on at least three samples obtained at equal oxidation conditions, while another specimen from the same lot was sectioned, mounted in resin and surface polished for optical microscopy analysis. In the latter procedure, mosaic pictures were collected of a rectangular stripe across the diameter of each specimen. These images were analyzed in order to derive the penetration depth and the pore structure in the oxidized layer as a function of oxidation temperature and weight loss level. Automated image analysis was performed using the commercial software Image Pro Plus. The results led to the conclusion that the depth of the oxidation layer is more dependent on the oxidation temperature than on the level of weight-loss. The penetration depth of the oxidized layer is about 6 mm at 600 o C and about 1.5 mm at 700 o C. Consequently, the 12.5 mm diameter specimens oxidized at 600 o C were completely penetrated by oxidation, while those oxidized at 700 o C had the oxidation layer restricted in a narrower band near the exposed surface. This difference was reflected by mechanical properties. A closer analysis of high magnification images in the oxidized layer revealed that oxidation attacks preferentially the binder phase in graphite, where development of fine new pores was observed. The density of new pores was higher near large pores pre-existing in graphite structure. Acute oxidation at low temperatures (e.g. 600 o C) causes more damage on mechanical strength than high temperature oxidation (700 o C). Although the latter is much faster, the oxidized layer is limited to a narrow zone next to the external surface, so that the core is not visibly affected. In contrast, oxidation at lower temperature, although slower, is more damaging because it penetrates deeply beyond the exposed surface.