High-pressure phase transformation of carbonate malachite Cu2(CO3)(OH)2 driven by [CuO6] regularization and [CO3] rotation
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Achieving high product selectivity in electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction (CO 2 RR) remains a critical challenge due to competition between multiple proton-coupled electron-transfer pathways on catalyst surfaces. Meanwhile, chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS), which enables spin-polarized electron transport through chiral interfaces, has recently emerged as a promising strategy to modulate interfacial electrochemical reactions. Although the CISS effect has been shown to enhance selectivity and efficiency in the spin-sensitive oxygen evolution reaction (OER), its role in regulating CO 2 RR pathways and in stabilizing intermediates remains largely unexplored. Here, chiral molecules (R- and S-1,1′-bi-2-naphthyl-2,2′-diyl hydrogen phosphate, BNP) were integrated with SnO 2 to construct chiral-modified catalysts (R-BNP/SnO 2 and S-BNP/SnO 2 ). Compared with bare SnO 2 and racemic BNP-modified SnO 2 (Rac-BNP/SnO 2 ), the chiral catalysts exhibited a pronounced shift in product selectivity from CO toward formate production. Importantly, in-situ attenuated total reflectance surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (ATR-SEIRAS) reveals that the chiral interface selectively stabilizes the O-bound *OCHO intermediate associated with the formate pathway and modulates interfacial water structure and hydrogen-bonding dynamics. These findings demonstrate that spin-polarized interfacial electron transfer can regulate CO 2 RR pathway selectivity by modulating the stabilization of key intermediates. More broadly, this work establishes chiral spin-selective interfaces as a new strategy for regulating competitive electrocatalytic reaction pathways.
Partial oxidation of furanic biomass derivatives such as furfural is of interest for the sustainable production of chemicals including furoic acid, maleic acid, and 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid (FDCA). The oxidative bulk electrolysis of furfural is here investigated on platinum electrodes in acidic media. The effects of potential, concentration, pH, and supporting anion are studied, and selectivity trends are coupled with attenuated total reflectance surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (ATR-SEIRAS) to illuminate adsorbate structures that influence the catalysis. Increasing potential is found to shift selectivity from primarily C 5 products to C 4 products, coincident with oxidation of the Pt surface. Selectivity changes are also observed moving from pH 1 to pH 4, with an increase in C 5 products at higher pH. Furthermore, changing from the weakly adsorbing perchlorate anion to the specifically-adsorbing phosphate anion results in a number of changes that manifest differently depending on potential and pH. Selectivity to furoic acid is found to be highest above the pKa of phosphoric acid due to the strongly adsorbed phosphate ions suppressing flat-lying configurations of furfural that lead to C−C cleavage. These results point toward opportunities to use electrolyte engineering to tune selectivity and optimize surface conditions to disfavor binding of inhibitory products.
Compared to a conventional electrolyte concentration of 1 M HCOOK, the use of a highly concentrated 7.1 M HCOOK electrolyte increases the Faradaic efficiency (FE) ratio of C2H4/CO from 2.2 +- 0.3 to 18.3 +- 4.8 at -1.08 V vs. reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE) on a Cu gas-diffusion electrode. Based on electrochemical analysis and ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulation, the identity and concentration of the cation and anion play more important roles in controlling the CO2R reaction pathway than the bulk CO2 solubility and the bulk pH of electrolytes. In situ attenuated reflectance surface enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (ATR-SEIRAS) suggests that, unlike 1 M HCOOK, the *CO-bridge-binding mode on Cu is dominant in 7.1 M HCOOK electrolyte, which potentially results in less CO release and higher yield of C2H4. This study demonstrates that although we can tailor the electrolyte composition to shift product selectivity, the factors that control the product selectivity are numerous and cannot be distilled down into one correlated property-reactivity relationship.
We investigate the postulate that hydrogen pressure influences the furfural hydrogenation selectivity on palladium to form decarbonylation products at low hydrogen pressures, but 2-methyl furan at higher pressures. This change is caused by co-adsorbed hydrogen changing the orientation of adsorbed furfural; low hydrogen coverages favor flat-lying furfural, higher coverages form tilted species. This was tested for hydrogenation of furfural on a Pd(1 1 1) single crystal. The product distribution agreed with the postulate, with 100% selectivity to furan and tetrahydrofuran for low hydrogen pressures, with 2-methyl furan increasing with hydrogen pressure. The origin of the effect is explored using reflection–absorption infrared spectroscopy. This showed that co-adsorbed hydrogen influenced the orientation in a way predicted by theory. It was also found that other co-adsorbates displayed similar effects implying that a range of molecules in the reaction mixture could have significant effects on the furfural selectivity.
Electrochemical processes that utilize biomass-derived ethanol as a source of electrons and protons offer a sustainable energy strategy, yet their practical implementation is limited by sluggish ethanol oxidation reaction (EOR) kinetics and catalyst poisoning. Here, in this study, we report a modular multi-interface nanocrystal catalyst comprising core/shell Co 2 P/Pd and Pd-Au heterostructured interfaces that exhibit complementary functions for the enhanced EOR catalysis. The Co 2 P/Pd interface boosts Pd atom utilization and lowers the kinetic barriers for ethanol-to-acetate conversion, while the Pd-Au interface effectively alleviates CO poisoning caused by C–C bond cleavage of ethanol. In-depth analyses using in situ attenuated total reflectance-surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy, differential electrochemical mass spectrometry, and density functional theory calculations elucidate the mechanistic roles of these interfaces. The optimized Co 2 P/Pd-Au 0.08 nanorods achieve an excellent mass activity, underscoring the potential of modular, multi-interface nanocrystals for advancing EOR catalysis and offering a generalizable strategy for broader catalytic innovations.
The majority of candidates for simple model molecular-electronic components consist of a conductive π-conjugated hydrocarbon linker attached to at least two anchoring groups, such as thiols or isocyanides. It has been found that select molecules self-assemble on gold surfaces, creating one-dimensional conductive structures that act as “molecular wires”. Furthermore, these oligomers can form molecular bridges between gold nanoparticles, leading to the creation of simple molecular-electronic devices. This raises the question whether other π-conjugated molecular linkers could exhibit similar behavior that might offer a broader range of candidates for fabricating electronic devices. Trithiocyanuric acid (1,3,5-triazine-2,4,6-trithiol, TTCA) provides a possible candidate. TTCA (C3N3(SH)3) can exist as a trithiol or as a trithione in which hydrogens transfer to the sulfurs so that they are present with three C=N groups within the ring. TTCA exists naturally in the trithione form but converts into a trithiol when adsorbed onto an Ag(111) where it is vertically oriented. The structure of TTCA adsorbed on Au(111) is studied here using reflection-absorption infrared spectroscopy (RAIRS) where it is found to remain as the trithione isomer, but changes orientation as the coverage increases. Scanning-tunneling microscopy (STM) reveals that TTCA oligomerizes on Au(111) to form chains and triangular structures. The influence on molecular conductivity due to the differences in the adsorbate's isomeric structure was investigated using devices comprising either silver or gold nanoparticles deposited in the gap between gold nanoelectrodes. Both devices were found to conduct when dosed with TTCA, but the devices fabricated using silver were about 13 time more conductive than those made from gold nanoparticles, consistent with the π-conjugated structure formed on silver but not on gold. This implies that oligomers form both on silver and on gold and potentially increases the range of molecule-metal combinations that might be used to fabricate molecular-electronic devices.
The ubiquity of graphitic materials in electrochemistry makes it highly desirable to probe their interfacial behavior under electrochemical control. Probing the dynamics of molecules at the electrode/electrolyte interface is possible through spectroelectrochemical approaches involving surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (SEIRAS). Usually, this technique can only be done on plasmonic metals such as gold or carbon nanoribbons, but a more convenient substrate for carbon electrochemical studies is needed. Here, we expanded the scope of SEIRAS by introducing a robust hybrid graphene-on-gold substrate, where we monitored electrografting processes occurring at the graphene/electrolyte interface. These electrodes consist of graphene deposited onto a roughened gold-sputtered internal reflection element (IRE) for attenuated total reflectance (ATR) SEIRAS. The capabilities of the graphene-gold IRE were demonstrated by successfully monitoring the electrografting of 4-amino-2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-1-piperidine N -oxyl (4-amino-TEMPO) and 4-nitrobenzene diazonium (4-NBD) in real time. These grafts were characterized using cyclic voltammetry and ATR-SEIRAS, clearly showing the 1520 and 1350 cm –1 NO 2 stretches for 4-NBD and the 1240 cm –1 C–C, C–C–H, and N–Ȯ stretch for 4-amino-TEMPO. Successful grafts on graphene did not show the SEIRAS effect, while grafting on gold was not stable for TEMPO and had poorer resolution than on graphene-gold for 4-NBD, highlighting the uniqueness of our approach. The graphene-gold IRE is proficient at resolving the spectral responses of redox transformations, unambiguously demonstrating the real-time detection of surface processes on a graphitic electrode. This work provides ample future directions for real-time spectroelectrochemical investigations of carbon electrodes used for sensing, energy storage, electrocatalysis, and environmental applications.
Understanding the role of surface structure and hydroxylation in catalytic reactions on metal oxide surfaces is important for developing a mechanistic insight into the complex interface processes. Here, we investigate the reactivity of formic acid on reconstructed Fe 3 O 4 (001) using a combination of X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy, temperature-programmed reaction spectroscopy, low energy electron diffraction, and electronic structure calculations. We find that formic acid initially dissociates at low temperatures (< 80 K) into bidentate formate and a hydroxyl up to an initial dosed coverage of two HCOOH per Fe 3 O 4 (001) unit cell. At higher temperatures (> 450 K), formate largely decomposes along the dehydration pathway, producing CO and H 2 O, with dehydrogenation to CO 2 being a minority side reaction. As a first step, water formation leads to surface oxygen extraction via the Mars-van Krevelen mechanism. Computational studies reveal formate embedded in oxygen vacancies as a key intermediate in the CO formation mechanism. CO formation proceeds via two reaction pathways with desorption that peaks at 530 K on the hydroxyl-rich surface and 560 K on the hydroxyl-deficient surface. Atomic hydrogen coadsorption experiments and ab initio calculations reveal that the presence of surface hydroxyls reduces the CO formation barrier. Furthermore, these results highlight the complex interactions between substrate and intermediate species occurring during reactions on metal oxide surfaces.
Operando electrochemical attenuated total reflection surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (EC ATR-SEIRAS) is a valuable method for a fundamental understanding of electrochemical interfaces under real operating conditions. The applicability of this method depends on the ability to tune the optical and catalytic properties of an electrode film, and it thus requires unique optimization for any given material. Motivated by the growing interest in Sn-based electrocatalysts for selective reduction of CO2 to formate species, we investigate several Sn thin-film synthesis routes for the resulting SEIRA signal response. We compare the SEIRA performance of thermally evaporated metallic Sn to a series of Sn-based films on top of a SEIRA-active Au substrate (metallic Sn, oxide-derived metallic Sn, and metal oxide SnOx). Using alkanethiol self-assembled monolayers as a probe, we find that electrodepositing metallic catalyst films on top of SEIRA-active Au substrates yield higher signal relative to thermal evaporation as well as higher signal than the independent SEIRA-active Au underlayer. These observations come despite the fact that thermally evaporated Sn has a significantly higher surface roughness (and thus higher adsorbate population), suggesting specific SEIRA-magnifying effects for the stacked films. Finally, we applied these films to observe the electrochemical conversion of CO2. Differences are observed in spectral features based on the composition of the electrode being either metallic or oxide-derived metallic Sn, implying differences in their respective reaction pathways.
Metal electrodes with rough surfaces are frequently found to convert CO or CO 2 to hydrocarbons and oxygenates with high selectivity and at high reaction rates in comparison with their smooth counterparts. The atomic-level morphology of a rough electrode is likely one key factor responsible for its comparatively high catalytic selectivity and activity. However, few methods are capable of probing the atomic-level structure of rough metal electrodes under electrocatalytic conditions. As a result, the nuances in the atomic-level surface morphology that control the catalytic characteristics of these electrodes have remained largely unexplored. Because the C≡O stretching frequency of atop-bound CO (CO atop ) depends on the coordination of the underlying metal atom, the IR spectrum of this reaction intermediate on the copper electrode could, in principle, provide structural information about the catalytic surface during electrolysis. However, other effects, such as dynamic dipole coupling, easily obscure the dependence of the frequency on the surface morphology. Further, in the limit of low CO atop coverage, where coupling effects are small, the C≡O stretching frequencies of CO atop on Cu(111) and Cu(100) facets are virtually identical. Therefore, on the basis of the C≡O stretching frequency, it is not straightforward to distinguish between these two ubiquitous surface facets, which exhibit vastly different CO reduction activities. Herein, we show that key features of the atomic-level surface morphology of rough copper electrodes can be inferred from the potential dependence of the line shape of the C≡O stretching band of CO atop . Specifically, we compared two types of rough copper thin-film electrodes that are routinely employed in the context of surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (SEIRAS). We found that copper films that are electrochemically deposited on Si-supported Au films (CuAu–Si) are poor catalysts for the reduction of CO to ethylene in comparison to copper films (Cu–Si) that are electrolessly deposited onto Si crystals. As quantified by differential electrochemical mass spectrometry (DEMS), the onset potential for ethylene is ~200 ± 65 mV more cathodic for CuAu–Si than that for Cu–Si. To reveal the origin of the disparate catalytic properties of Cu–Si and CuAu–Si, we probed the surfaces of the electrodes with cyclic voltammetry (CV) and SEIRAS. The CV characterization suggests that the (111) surface facet predominates on CuAu–Si, whereas the (100) facet is more common on Cu–Si. SEIRAS reveals that the line shape of the C≡O stretching of CO atop is composed of two bands that are attributable to CO atop on terrace and defect sites. The different surface structures manifest themselves in the form of starkly different potential dependences of the line shape of the C≡O stretching mode of CO atop on the two types of electrodes. With a simple Boltzmann model that considers the different adsorption energies of CO atop on terrace and defect sites, and the resulting CO atop populations on terrace and defect sites, we deduced that the observed electrode-specific potential dependence of the line shape is consistent with the presence of different predominant terrace sites on the two types of films. This strategy for assessing the atomic-level morphology is not restricted to SEIRAS but could also be applied to the C≡O stretching bands recorded with surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS), which is suitable for probing a wide range of rough copper electrodes. Therefore, with this work, we establish the potential dependence of the C≡O stretching band of CO atop as a probe of the atomic-level surface structure of rough metal electrodes under electrochemical conditions. When it is coupled with complementary techniques, this methodology provides essential structural information for further improvement in the reaction selectivity of rough metal electrodes.
A thorough comprehension of the mechanism underlying the methanol oxidation reaction (MOR) on Ni-based catalysts is critical for future electrocatalytic design and development. However, the mechanism of MOR on these materials remains a matter of controversy. Herein, we combine in situ surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (SEIRAS) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations to identify the active sites and determine the mechanism of MOR on monometallic Ni-based catalysts in alkaline media. The SEIRAS results show that formate and (bi)carbonate are formed after the commencement of the MOR with potential-dependent relative distributions. These spectroscopic results are in good agreement with the DFT-computed reaction profiles over an oxygen vacancy, suggesting that the MOR mainly proceeds through the formate-involving pathway, in which the early consumption of methanol yields formate as the major product, while increasing potential drives further oxidation of formate to (bi)carbonate. We also find a parallel pathway for the generation of (bi)carbonate at high potentials that bypasses the formation of formate. The two main pathways are thermodynamically more feasible than the one predominantly reported in the literature for MOR on NiOOH that involves CHO and/or CO as key intermediates. These DFT results are supported by spectroscopic evidence showing that no band associated with CHO or CO can be detected by SEIRAS, which is attributed to the nature of the oxygen vacancies as the active sites, suppressing deep dehydrogenation of CH 2 O to CHO. Furthermore, this work thus shows the promising role of defect engineering in promoting the electrocatalytic MOR activity and selectivity.
Iron–sulfur clusters play essential roles in biological systems, and thus synthetic [Fe 4 S 4 ] clusters have been an area of active research. Recent studies have demonstrated that soluble [Fe 4 S 4 ] clusters can serve as net H atom transfer mediators, improving the activity and selectivity of a homogeneous Mn CO 2 reduction catalyst. Here, in this work, we demonstrate that incorporating these [Fe 4 S 4 ] clusters into a coordination polymer enables heterogeneous H atom transfer from an electrode surface to a Mn complex dissolved in solution. A previously reported solution-processable Fe 4 S 4 -based coordination polymer was successfully deposited on the surfaces of different electrodes. The coated electrodes serve as H atom transfer mediators to a soluble Mn CO 2 reduction catalyst displaying good product selectivity for formic acid. Furthermore, these electrodes are recyclable with a minimal decrease in activity after multiple catalytic cycles. The heterogenization of the mediator also enables the characterization of solution-phase and electrode surface species separately. Surface enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (SEIRAS) reveals spectroscopic signatures for an in situ generated active Mn–H species, providing a more complete mechanistic picture for this system. The active species, reaction mechanism, and the protonation sites on the [Fe 4 S 4 ] clusters were further confirmed by density functional theory calculations. The observed H atom transfer reactivity of these coordination polymer-coated electrodes motivates additional applications of this composite material in reductive H atom transfer electrocatalysis.
Electrochemical reduction of CO 2 to CO is a key step in carbon utilization technologies, yet maintaining high CO selectivity under elevated temperatures relevant to industrial membrane-electrode-assembly (MEA) electrolyzers remains challenging due to the competing hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Additionally, the temperature dependence of CO selectivity on Cu-based catalysts has remained largely unexplored. Here, we demonstrate that incorporating atomic In or Sn into Cu fundamentally reshapes the selectivity of Cu catalysts at elevated temperatures. Dilute alloy catalysts, In 1 Cu and Sn 1 Cu, achieve >95% FE of CO over a broad current-density window (0.1−1.1 A cm −2 ) at 60 °C in MEA electrolyzers, far exceeding their performance at ambient temperature. In situ attenuated total reflection surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy suggests that elevating temperature depletes interfacial water activity, which favors a shift in CO 2 activation from a proton-coupled *COOH pathway toward an electron-driven *COO − -associated pathway, while also suppressing HER and CO hydrogenation. In contrast, benchmark CO-selective catalysts such as Ag exhibit minimal temperature-induced changes in CO production at 20−60 °C. These findings identify temperature as an unavoidable yet previously underutilized operating parameter in MEA electrolyzers for high-rate, selective CO production on Cubased catalysts.
Understanding the nature of active sites is central to controlling (electro)catalytic activity. Here we employed surface X-ray scattering coupled with density functional theory and surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy to examine the oxygen evolution reaction on RuO 2 surfaces as a function of voltage. At 1.5 V RHE , our results suggest that there is an –OO group on the coordinatively unsaturated ruthenium (Ru CUS ) site of the (100) surface (and similarly for (110)), but adsorbed oxygen on the Ru CUS site of (101). Density functional theory results indicate that the removal of –OO from the Ru CUS site, which is stabilized by a hydrogen bond to a neighbouring –OH (–OO–H), could be the rate-determining step for (100) (similarly for (110)), where its reduced binding on (100) increased activity. A further reduction in binding energy on the Ru CUS site of (101) resulted in a different rate-determining step (–O + H 2 O – (H + + e - ) → –OO–H) and decreased activity. Our study provides molecular details on the active sites, and the influence of their local coordination environment on activity.
A single atom Ti–Cu(111) surface alloy can be generated by depositing small amounts of Ti onto Cu(111) at slightly elevated surface temperatures (~500 to 600 K). Here, scanning tunneling microscopy shows that small Ti-rich islands covered by a Cu single layer form preferentially on ascending step edges of Cu(111) during Ti deposition below about 400 K but that a Ti–Cu(111) alloy replaces these small islands during deposition between 500 and 600 K, producing an alloy in the brims of the steps. Larger partially Cu-covered Ti-containing islands also form on the Cu(111) terraces at temperatures between 300 and 700 K. After surface exposure to CO at low temperatures, reflection absorption infrared spectroscopy (RAIRS) reveals distinct C–O stretch bands at 2102 and 2050 cm –1 attributed to CO adsorbed on Cu-covered Ti-containing domains vs sites in the Ti–Cu(111) surface alloy. Calculations using density functional theory (DFT) suggest that the lower frequency C–O stretch band originates specifically from CO adsorbed on isolated Ti atoms in the Ti–Cu(111) surface alloy and predicts a higher C–O stretch frequency for CO adsorbed on Cu above subsurface Ti ensembles. DFT further predicts that CO preferentially adsorbs in flat-lying configurations on contiguous Ti surface structures with more than one Ti atom and thus that CO adsorbed on such structures should not be observed with RAIRS. The ability to generate a single atom Ti–Cu(111) alloy will provide future opportunities to investigate the surface chemistry promoted by a representative early transition metal dopant on a Cu(111) host surface.
Plasma-catalytic ammonia synthesis in a ns pulse discharge and a 'hybrid' ns pulse/RF discharge in plane-to-plane geometry is studied by Fourier Transform infrared absorption spectroscopy. The data are taken in a preheated H 2 –N 2 mixture, with and without Ni/γ-Al 2 O 3 or Co/γ-Al 2 O 3 catalyst placed in the discharge section. The measurement results are taken using two different approaches. The first is a 'single-stage' process, where a ns pulse discharge in the H 2 –N 2 mixture is sustained continuously. In this case, the ammonia yield increases slowly, over a period of tens of minutes. The second is a 'two-stage' process, where the catalyst is first activated by the ns pulse discharge sustained in pure nitrogen, and then the activated catalyst is exposed to the H 2 –N 2 flow, with or without the discharge. In this case, a strong overshoot of the NH 3 number density at the reactor exit is detected, by over a factor of two compared to the single-stage process. After the initial overshoot, the ammonia yield gradually decreases to the 'single stage' value (with the discharge on), or to near zero (with the discharge off). The results demonstrate that the ammonia yield in the plasma-catalytic reactor is controlled by the N atom accumulation on the catalyst surface, which reacts with H atoms thermally dissociated on the catalyst or generated in the plasma. The results also show that the plasma-catalytic ammonia yield is significantly higher compared to that in the ns pulse discharge without the catalyst. The accumulation of H atoms on the catalyst, with their subsequent reactions with N atoms generated in the plasma, is of relatively minor importance at the present conditions. An additional series of measurements was made with a sub-breakdown RF waveform overlapped with the ns pulse discharge train, to enhance the vibrational excitation of nitrogen. The ammonia yield measured with the RF waveform added is approximately 20% higher compared to that at the baseline ns pulse discharge conditions, both with and without the catalyst. This effect is weaker compared to that of the catalyst activation by N atoms. Additional data are necessary to isolate the possible effect of the vibrationally excited N 2 molecules on the ammonia synthesis in the plasma catalytic reactions.
Organic photovoltaics incorporating non-fullerene acceptors based on perylenediimide (PDI) now rival fullerene acceptor-based devices in performance, although the mechanisms of charge generation in PDI-based devices are not yet fully understood. Fullerene-based systems are proposed to undergo electron transfer directly from the photoexcited donor into a band of delocalized acceptor states, thus increasing charge generation efficiency. Similarly, anion delocalization has been shown to enhance the rate of electron transfer from a photoexcited donor to two electronically coupled PDI acceptors. Here we investigate how additional electron acceptors may further increase the rate of electron transfer from the donor zinc meso-tetraphenylporphyrin (ZnTPP) to an aggregate of PDI acceptors (PDI[Formula: see text]. Femtosecond transient visible and mid-infrared absorption spectroscopies show that the rate of electron transfer from 1 *ZnTPP to the PDI assembly ZnTPP 2 -PDI 3 is statistically identical to that of the previously examined ZnTPP-PDI 2 . A Marcus theory analysis indicates that the parameters governing electron transfer are nearly identical for the two molecules, suggesting that the maximum electron transfer rate enhancement has been achieved in a cofacial PDI dimer because the ZnTPP directly couples to the first two PDI acceptors whereas the coupling to the third PDI is too weak.